HOWELL v. McAULIFFE

Record No. 160784.

788 S.E.2d 706 (2016)

William J. HOWELL, et al. v. Terence R. McAULIFFE, et al.

Supreme Court of Virginia.

July 22, 2016.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Charles J. Cooper ( Michael W. Kirk , Arlington; David H. Thompson ; William C. Marra ; Haley N. Proctor ; Cooper & Kirk, on brief), for appellant.

Stuart A. Raphael , Solicitor General ( Mark R. Herring , Attorney General; Trevor S. Cox , Deputy Solicitor General; Matthew R. McGuire , Assistant Attorney General; Anna T. Birkenheier , Assistant Attorney General, on brief), for appellee.

Amici Curiae: Robert N. Tracci ; Edward Stein , Norfolk; W. Lyle Carver ; Darrel W. Puckett , Appomattox; Theophani K. Stamos , Arlington; Joel R. Branscom ; Paul A. McAndrews ; William W. Davenport , Chesterfield; Paul Walther , Culpeper; Ann Cabell Baskervill ; Raymond F. Morrogh , Fairfax; James P. Fisher ; Eric Branscom ; Jeff Haislip ; Allen `A.J.' W. Dudley, Jr. , Rocky Mount ; Ross P. Spicer ; Tracy Quackenbush Martin ; R.E. `Trip' Chalkley, III ; M. Andrew Nester ; James E. Plowman , Leesburg; Rusty E. McGuire ; Theresa J. `Terry' Royall ; Diana Wheeler O'Connell ; Stephanie Brinegar Vipperman ; Robert Bryan Haskins ; Paul B. Ebert , Manassas; Christopher Billias ; Marsha L. Garst , Harrisonburg; Marcus McClung ; Travis D. Bird ; Derek A. Davis ; Julia H. Sichol ; C.H. `Chuck' Slemp, III ; Benjamin M. Hahn , Poquoson; Christopher B. Russell ; Nancy G. Parr , Chesapeake; William B. Bray ; LaBravia J. Jenkins , Fredericksburg; H. Clay Gravely, IV , Danville; Donald Caldwell , Roanoke; Thomas E. Bowers ; Colin D. Stolle , Virginia Beach; David L. Ledbetter ( James E. Plowman , Leesburg, on brief), in support of petitioners.

Amici Curiae: Andrew P. Miller ; James S. Gilmore, III ; Kenneth T. `Ken' Cuccinelli, II , Richmond, ( William S. Consovoy ; Bryan K. Weir ; Consovoy McArthur Park, on brief), in support of petitioners.

Amicus Curiae: Virginia State Conference of the NAACP ( David O. Prince ; Allison J. Riggs , on brief), in support of respondents.

Amici Curiae: ACLU and ACLU of Virginia ( Hope R. Amezquita ; Dale E. Ho ; Julie A. Ebenstein , on brief), in support of respondents.

Amici Curiae: David Green and Bridging the Gap in Virginia, Inc. ( Rodney F. Page ; Kristen Clarke ; Ezra D. Rosenberg ; Bryan Cave, on brief), in support of respondents.

Amicus Curiae: Fair Elections Legal Network ( Jon Sherman ; Jan A. Larson ; Jessica Ring Amunson ; Mark P. Gaber ; Jenner & Block, on brief), in support of respondents.

Amici Curiae: A.E. Dick Howard, Charlottesville; Daniel R. Ortiz ; Carl W. Tobias ; John Paul Jones ( Alexander B. Bowerman ; N. Thomas Connally III ; Hogan Lovells, McLean, on brief), in support of respondents.

Amici Curiae: Anton A. Bell , Portsmouth; Michael N. Herring , Shannon L. Taylor , Richmond; Stephanie N. Morales ; Gergory D. Underwood ; Bryan L. Porter ( Frank K. Friedman ; Erin B. Ashwell ; Woods Rogers, Roanoke, on brief), in support of respondents.

PRESENT: All the Justices.


The dominant role in articulation of public policy in the Commonwealth of Virginia rests with the elected branches. The role of the judiciary is a restrained one. Ours is not to judge the advisability or wisdom of policy choices. The Executive and Legislative...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases