IN RE VALSARTAN N-NITROSODIMETHYLAMINE (NDMA), LOSARTAN, AND IRBESARTAN PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION

Master No. 19-2875(RBK/JS), Civil No. 19-14891(RBK/JS)., 19-15043(RBK/JS)

IN RE VALSARTAN N-NITROSODIMETHYLAMINE (NDMA), LOSARTAN, and IRBESARTAN PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION, Marcia Cantrell v. Zhejiang Huahai Pharmaceutical Co., LTD., et al. James Mullins v. Zhejiang Huahai Pharmaceutical Co., LTD., et al.

United States District Court, D. New Jersey, Camden Vicinage.

February 27, 2020.

Editors Note
Applicable Law: 28 U.S.C. § 1332
Cause: 28 U.S.C. § 1332 Diversity - Product Liability
Nature of Suit: 367 Personal Injury: Health Care / Pharmaceutical Personal Injury Product Liability
Source: PACER


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

ERIC ERWIN, Plaintiff, represented by DAVID JOHN STANOCH , GOLOMB & HONIK, P.C.

DOMINIC STIMMA & JYNONA GAIL LEE, Plaintiffs, represented by ANDREW JOSEPH OBERGFELL , BURSOR & FISHER PA & DAVID JOHN STANOCH , GOLOMB & HONIK, P.C.

MARGOTH STRAND, IRA SANDERS, JOSEPH GLENN CUMMINGS, SOLOMON ZELLER, ROSA BURTON, DAMITA OWENS, BRIAN WINEINGER, CHARMAINE WESTRY, MICHAEL JOHNSON, RONALD ANNIS, GLENN RODDEY, HELEN JOHNSON, ALICIA DEGRACIA & WILLIAM KOLACEK, Plaintiffs, represented by ANDREW JOSEPH OBERGFELL , BURSOR & FISHER PA.

RICHARD O'NEILL, Plaintiff, represented by GEORGE ALLEN BARTON , LAW OFFICES OF GEORGE A. BARTON PC, STEFANIE LYNN COLELLA-WALSH , STARK & STARK, STACY ANN BURROWS , LAW OFFICES OF GEORGE A. BARTON PC & DAVID JOHN STANOCH , GOLOMB & HONIK, P.C.

RICHARD GONTESKI, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES C. SHAH , SHEPHERD, FINKELMAN, MILLER & SHAH, LLP.

ELIZABETH DUFFY, Plaintiff, represented by ANDREW JOSEPH OBERGFELL , BURSOR & FISHER PA, JOSEPH I. MARCHESE , BURSOR & FISHER PA & SCOTT A. BURSOR , BURSOR & FISHER PA, pro hac vice.

JOHN JUDSON, Plaintiff, represented by ALLAN KANNER , ALLAN KANNER & ASSOCIATES, PC & JOHN RANDOLPH DAVIS , SLACK & DAVIS LLP.

JO ANN HAMEL, Plaintiff, represented by ALLAN KANNER , ALLAN KANNER & ASSOCIATES, PC, JOHN RANDOLPH DAVIS , SLACK & DAVIS LLP & DAVID JOHN STANOCH , GOLOMB & HONIK, P.C.

JAMES JONES, Plaintiff, represented by LANNY H. DARR , DARR FIRM.

ALPHONSE BORKOWSKI, Plaintiff, represented by DAVID JOHN STANOCH , GOLOMB & HONIK, P.C., JOHN RANDOLPH DAVIS , SLACK & DAVIS LLP, MICHAEL L. SLACK , Slack Davis Sanger, LLP, PAUL G. JOYCE , Colucci & Gallaher, P.C. & RUBEN HONIK , GOLOMB & HONIK, P.C.

LOREN LEWIS, Plaintiff, represented by EDWIN EARL WALLIS , GLASSMAN WYATT TUTTLE & COX PC, pro hac vice & ROBERT A. COX , Glassman, Wyatt, Tuttle & Cox, P.C.

ROBERT KRUK, Plaintiff, represented by JOHN SAWIN , SAWIN LAW LTD., SCOTT ANTHONY MORGAN , Morgan Law Firm, Ltd., MYLES MCGUIRE , MCGUIRE LAW PC, PAUL T. GESKE , MCGUIRE LAW PC & TIMOTHY PATRICK KINGSBURY , MCGUIRE LAW PC.

APRIL HARPER, PAULETTE SILBERMAN, Judy Tasker, Roger Tasker & DAVID KELLEY, Plaintiffs, represented by ADAM M. SLATER , MAZIE SLATER KATZ & FREEMAN.

KEVORK AVEDIKIAN, Plaintiff, represented by BEHRAM V. PAREKH , KIRTLAND & PACKARD LLP & DANIEL A. NIGH , LEVIN PAPANTONIO.

ELIZABETH E GREMILLION, Plaintiff, represented by QUENTIN F. URQUHART, Jr. , IRWIN FRITCHIE URQUHART & MOORE LLC, ADAM R. CREDEUR , LAW OFFICES OF KENNETH W. DEJEAN, KENNETH W. DEJEAN , LAW OFFICES OF KENNETH W. DEJEAN & NATALIE M. DEJEAN , LAW OFFICES OF KENNETH W. DEJEAN.

MSP RECOVERY CLAIMS, SERIES, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by ANDRES RIVERO , RIVERO MESTRE LLP, Alan H. Rolnick , Rivero Mestre LLP, CHRISTOPHER LUKE COFFIN , PENDLEY BAUDIN & COFFIN LLP & DAVID JOHN STANOCH , GOLOMB & HONIK, P.C.

ROBIN ROBERTS, DENNIS KAPLAN & TALSIE NEAL, Plaintiffs, represented by RUBEN HONIK , GOLOMB & HONIK, P.C. & DAVID JOHN STANOCH , GOLOMB & HONIK, P.C.

KAREN POLLOCK, Plaintiff, represented by STEVEN C. BABIN, Jr. , BABIN LAW LLC & DANIEL A. NIGH , LEVIN PAPANTONIO.

EMMANUEL MARTEY, Plaintiff, represented by Michael Brandon Smith , Childers, Schlueter & Smith, LLC & DANIEL A. NIGH , LEVIN PAPANTONIO.

JOSEP CACACCIO, Plaintiff, represented by ANDREW JOSEPH OBERGFELL , BURSOR & FISHER PA & SCOTT A. BURSOR , BURSOR & FISHER PA, pro hac vice.

THOMAS WILLIAMS, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL A. NIGH , LEVIN PAPANTONIO & Jason Ruskin Reese , WAGNER REESE & CROSSEN, LLP.

BETTY SELPH, Plaintiff, represented by ANNESLEY HODGES DEGARIS , DEGARIS & ROGERS LLC.

MAINE AUTOMOBILE DEALERS ASSOCIATION, INC. INSURANCE TRUST, Plaintiff, represented by ANTHONY MICHAEL CHRISTINA , LOWEY DANNENBERG, P.C., EIZABETH FLETCHER QUINBY , PRETFLAHERTY BELIVEAU & PACHIOS LLP, GREGORY PAUL HANSEL , PRETI FLAHERTY BELIVEAU & PACHIOS LLP, PETER D. ST. PHILLIP, Jr. , LOWEY DANNENBERG, P.C., SIGMUND DAVID SCHUTZ , PRETI FLAHERTY BELIVEAU & PACHIOS LLP, URIEL RABINOVITZ , LOWEY DANNENBERG, PC, JOHN JOSEPH CRONAN, III , PRETI FLAHERTY BELIVEAU & PACHIOS LLP & DAVID JOHN STANOCH , GOLOMB & HONIK, P.C.

RANJIT SEN, Plaintiff, represented by CHRISTOPHER T. HELLUMS , PITTMAN DUTTON & HELLUMS PC, JONATHAN S. MANN , PITTMAN DUTTON & HELLUMS PC & DANIEL A. NIGH , LEVIN PAPANTONIO.

SARMISTHA SEN, Plaintiff, represented by CHRISTOPHER T. HELLUMS , PITTMAN DUTTON & HELLUMS PC & DANIEL A. NIGH , LEVIN PAPANTONIO.

SUSAN GUITON, Plaintiff, represented by BEHRAM V. PAREKH , KIRTLAND & PACKARD LLP & MICHAEL L. KELLY , KIRTLAND & PACKARD LLP.

PRISCILLA KLEINMAN, Plaintiff, represented by David V. McLendon , Watts Guerra LLP & PAIGE NICOLE BOLDT , WATTS GUERRA LLP.

DANIEL WINIECKI, GLORIA BARBER, PATRICIA SHEPHERD, 19-12038, WEDAD ABDOU, SARAH ZEHR, REBIA JACKSON, ELIZABETH AXINN, SANDRA MEEKS, JANICE BROWN, BARBARA SMITH, DEBORAH MEALS, SAMUEL HAYDEN, DAVID PHAGAN, MAXINE P. COX, LEAH M. GLEASON, CHARLENE FERRELL, JOHN CROWTHER, JOANNE MURRAY, ELLA POLEDORE, ERIS ROBINSON & STACI KAVE, Plaintiffs, represented by DANIEL A. NIGH , LEVIN PAPANTONIO.

JERRY HOLLAND & KATHRYN HOLLAND, Plaintiffs, represented by Andrea T. McKellar , McKellar Hyde PLC & GEORGE T. WILLIAMSON , FARR LAW FIRM.

RON MOLINARO, Plaintiff, represented by ALLAN KANNER , ALLAN KANNER & ASSOCIATES, PC, BRIAN T. KU , KU & MUSSMAN PA & DAVID JOHN STANOCH , GOLOMB & HONIK, P.C.

GERALD NELSON, JOSEPH CACACCIO & CECIL BYRD, Plaintiffs, represented by ANDREW JOSEPH OBERGFELL , BURSOR & FISHER PA, SCOTT A. BURSOR , BURSOR & FISHER PA, pro hac vice & DAVID JOHN STANOCH , GOLOMB & HONIK, P.C.

VALERIE RODICH-ANNESE, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL AARON RIHN , ROBERT PEIRCE & ASSOCIATES, JASON S. RATHOD , MIGLIACCIO & RATHOD LLP, NICHOLAS A. MIGLIACCIO , MIGLIACCIO & RATHOD LLP, RACHEL GEMAN , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN LLP, DANIEL CALEB LEVIN , LEVIN, FISHBEIN, SEDRAN & BERMAN & KARTIK MADIRAJU , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN LLP.

LARRY TACK, JEANNE TACK, YVONNE KELLY, JOSE VALLES, TIMOTHY FREEMAN, BETTY FREEMAN, RITA CRAWFORD, MARIAN ALLEN, GLENN GEHEFER & MARGARET GEHEFER, Plaintiffs, represented by MARLENE J. GOLDENBERG , GOLDENBERGLAW, PLLC.

VERONICA LONGWELL, Plaintiff, represented by Peter J. Ainsworth , Meehan, Boyle, Black & Bogdanow, P.C. & DAVID JOHN STANOCH , GOLOMB & HONIK, P.C.

CHARLES WILLIAMS, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL A. NIGH , LEVIN PAPANTONIO & Kathleen M. O'Donnell , ODonnell Law Firm.

PEGGY WATTS & KAREN BRACKMAN, Plaintiffs, represented by Andrea T. McKellar , McKellar Hyde PLC & DANIEL A. NIGH , LEVIN PAPANTONIO.

EDWIN CHILDS, RUTHELIA RANSOM, KIMBERLY COUGHENOUR, JEANETTA HOLOWAY, JUAN AVALOS, EUGENE PATE, KATHRYN COLIN, AIRLEAN WILLIAMS, SOPHIA ELWIN, NELLIE DAWSON, GLEN UDELL & DEBORAH DELGADO-RIFFENBURG, Plaintiffs, represented by PAIGE NICOLE BOLDT , WATTS GUERRA LLP.

MAXINE GUILLORY, Plaintiff, represented by CHRISTOPHER LUKE COFFIN , PENDLEY BAUDIN & COFFIN LLP, DANIEL A. NIGH , LEVIN PAPANTONIO, JESSICA A. PEREZ , PENDLEY BAUDIN & COFFIN LLP & NICHOLAS RYAN ROCKFORTE , PENDLEY BAUDIN & COFFIN LLP.

STEVEN BRADSHAW, Plaintiff, represented by CHRISTOPHER BRETT VAUGHN , HOLLIS LAW FIRM & DANIEL A. NIGH , LEVIN PAPANTONIO.

MARGARET RIDLEY, Plaintiff, represented by Michael Brandon Smith , Childers, Schlueter & Smith, LLC.

CELESTINE DARING, MIKE RIVES, ROBERT FIELDS, ANTHONY MARTINEZ, JEFF SOMER, CONNIE HOWARD, DEITRICH BROADNAX, BILL VANHOOSE, TANYA DODSON, EVA CORNELL & DEBORAH ANDERSON, Plaintiffs, represented by STEVEN C. BABIN, Jr. , BABIN LAW LLC.

CURTIS LEBOEUF, CLINTON HERRRIN, NOVA ADAMS, LUCILLE MABIE, LARRY ISBELL, JESSIE HAM, GARY STALLINGS, GARY PALLEN, REED RILEY, ALAN GORDAN, ALBERT STEIGER & VALENCIA B. PUGH, Plaintiffs, represented by JASON CHARLES CHAMBERS , HOLLIS LAW FIRM.

FRANCES BRYANT, SANDRA JOHNSON, SHAMIKA NAIL, JEAN LOLLAR & STACEY THOMAS, Plaintiffs, represented by CALLE M. MENDENHALL , FARRIS RILEY & PITT LLP.

LAWRENCE HERMANN, JEROLD LAMHUT & JAMES LEE, Plaintiffs, represented by MORRIS S. DWECK , Bernstein Liebhard LLP.

JAMES MOSS, Plaintiff, represented by CHRISTOPHER BRETT VAUGHN , HOLLIS LAW FIRM.

BETTY F. HEBERT, RICHARD HEBERT, AMANDA LOU BABIN & CHARLES BABIN, Plaintiffs, represented by DAMON J. BALDONE , DAMON J. BALDONE & ASSOCIATES.

CHERYL CAUDILL, SUSAN MEFFORD, WILLIAM LOVE, ALBERT LEE, TONY JUSTICE, PAUL HOWARD, LUCY HOLCOMB, VIRGIE BUCKLEY, STEVEN BUTCHER, GLENN BAYS, DANIEL L. BAUER, ANTHONY SCOTT BROWNING, SHERRI CLOYD, BOBBY COLE, ELIZABETH CORNETT, CHESTER DAVIDSON, LISA DEBORD & CAROL DUVALL, Plaintiffs, represented by LARACLAY PARKER , GOLDEN LAW OFFICE.

ALBERTA BURNS, Plaintiff, represented by Z LARACLAY PARKER , GOLDEN LAW OFFICE.

ALAN ERNEST, ROGER GIBSON, JUDY GRIFFITT, TALMADGE HALSEY, CLAYBORNE HAYES, JAMES MULLINS, LENNY NEEDY, ROBYN O'DANIEL, DENNIS REBER, WILLIAM REYNOLDS, KIM THOMPSON, DARREN WILKERSON, JOE DURBIN & MARCIA CANTRELL, Plaintiffs, represented by LARACLAY PARKER , GOLDEN LAW OFFICE. .

JAMES BETTINGER, BUDDY LONG, THOMAS AUSTIN, JAMES MAGEE, SR., EVELYN MIMS, GEORGE DOSS, JANET CHESTER, KATTIE TUCKER, HUNTER NEALY, KATHY EDWARDS, ROSA FRANKS, DENIS J. DUELLO & JUNE H. DUELLO, Plaintiffs, represented by JOSEPH D. LANE , THE COCHRAN FIRM - DOTHAN, PC.

KAREN MEADE, Plaintiff, represented by BEHRAM V. PAREKH , KIRTLAND & PACKARD LLP.

RACHAEL HOLLINGSHEAD, Plaintiff, represented by SINDHU SUSAN DANIEL , BARON & BUDD PC.

KEN WISEMAN & JOYCELYN STEVENS, Plaintiffs, represented by LOUIS FRANCIS TUMOLO , THE BEASLEY FIRM LLC & PETER JOSEPH JOHNSEN , THE BEASLEY FIRM, LLC.

JON KING, JAMES HUEY & LANA DUFRENE, Plaintiffs, represented by MATTHEW PALMER LAMBERT , GAINSBURGH BENJAMIN DAVID MEUNIER & WARSHAUER LLC.

CHARLES PITTMAN & LINDA LEWIS, Plaintiffs, represented by JOHN D. SILEO .

JEFFREY A BERRYMAN, 19-15700 & CHITIQUA HOCKER, 19-15700, Plaintiffs, represented by ASHTON R. SMITH , MOORE LAW GROUP PLLC & JENNIFER A. MOORE , MOORE LAW GROUP PLLC.

JOSEPH A. LUCIANO, AMY W LUCIANO, JAMES C. SMITH & CONNIE SMITH, Plaintiffs, represented by ADAM R. CREDEUR , LAW OFFICES OF KENNETH W. DEJEAN, KENNETH W. DEJEAN , LAW OFFICES OF KENNETH W. DEJEAN & NATALIE M. DEJEAN , LAW OFFICES OF KENNETH W. DEJEAN.

DAVID C NUNNALLY, KEITH M. BLAKE & FELICIA C. BLAKE, Plaintiffs, represented by ADAM R. CREDEUR , LAW OFFICES OF KENNETH W. DEJEAN, KENNETH W. DEJEAN , LAW OFFICES OF KENNETH W. DEJEAN, L. Clayton Burgess , Law Office of L Clayton Burgess & NATALIE M. DEJEAN , LAW OFFICES OF KENNETH W. DEJEAN.

BRYANT J BROOKS, Plaintiff, represented by KENNETH W. DEJEAN , LAW OFFICES OF KENNETH W. DEJEAN & NATALIE M. DEJEAN , LAW OFFICES OF KENNETH W. DEJEAN.

RONALD DILBECK, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL V. KOHLS , HANSEN KOHLS SOMMER & JACOB LLP & DANIEL WILLIAM ROBERTSON , HANSEN KOHLS SOMMER & JACOB LLP.

PATRICIA ANN WITTE, TREY WITTE & KERRIE KATHLEEN STEGER, Plaintiffs, represented by MATIAS JOSE ADROGUE , MATIAS J. ADROGUE PLLC.

NATALIE CORTEZ, Plaintiff, represented by JOSE D. ROMAN , POWELL & ROMAN LLC.

THERESE FOUGERE, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Chike Obioha , Law Offices of Pius Obioha and Associates, LLC, Evan J. Godofsky , Larzelere, Picou, Wells, Simpson, Lonero, LLC, Morgan J. Wells, Jr. , Larzelere, Picou, Wells, Simpson, Lonero, LLC & PIUS AKAMDI OBIOHA , LAW OFFICES OF PIUS A. OBIOHA & ASSOCIATES LLC.

BEVERLY PATTON & JEFFREY S. PATTON, Plaintiffs, represented by Jeffrey D. Ries , McGrail & Associates, LLC, Patricia L. McGrail & Weston P. Pesillo , McGrail & Associates, LLC.

DAVID STANO & MYONG HUI KIM-STANO, Plaintiffs, represented by JOSEPH STEVE PIACUN , GENNUSA PIACUN & RULI.

JAMES TOWNSEND, Plaintiff, represented by KENNETH G. GILMAN , GILMAN & PASTOR, LLP.

DOUGLAS V. FARMER, NANCY L. FARMER & WINNIFRED WILSON, Plaintiffs, represented by JENNIFER A. MOORE , MOORE LAW GROUP PLLC.

TRUDY ROBINSON, Plaintiff, represented by JONATHAN S. MANN , PITTMAN DUTTON & HELLUMS PC.

JOSE HERNANDEZ, Plaintiff, represented by CURTIS BRADLEY MINER , COLSON HICKS EDISON PA.

RICKY BELL & SANDY BELL, Plaintiffs, represented by SEAN PATRICK STEINMAN , RON AUSTIN LAW.

CHRISTOPHER BREAUX & SHEILA BREAUX, Plaintiffs, represented by JAMES ALEX WATKINS , CAPITELLI & WICKER.

SVETLANA LEIMBERG & MIKHAIL LEIMBERG, Plaintiffs, represented by PATRICK SHANAN MONTOYA , COLSON HICKS EIDSON.

TERRI STINE, Plaintiff, represented by MICHAEL JOSEPH MODL , AXLEY BRYNELSON LLP.

FRED RICHISSIN, Plaintiff, represented by JESSICA A. PEREZ , PENDLEY BAUDIN & COFFIN LLP, MATTHEW PALMER LAMBERT , GAINSBURGH BENJAMIN DAVID MEUNIER & WARSHAUER LLC & Stanley Paul Baudin , Pendley, Baudin & Coffin, LLP.

ROBERTA CRUZ & JESUS CRUZ, Plaintiffs, represented by MARK R. MUELLER , MUELLER LAW FIRM & STEVE FARIES , MUELLER LAW PLLC.

MICHAEL SVEBEK, Plaintiff, represented by MARTIN DANIEL CRUMP , DAVIS & CRUMP PC.

ROBERT WEYGANDT & TIVIS FIELDS, Plaintiffs, represented by SEJAL K. BRAHMBHATT , WILLIAMS KHERKHER HART BOUNDAS LLP.

ESTATE OF CARL R. CARR, Plaintiff, represented by ASHTON R. SMITH , MOORE LAW GROUP PLLC.

DANIEL TORGHELE & RACHEL TORGHELE, Plaintiffs, represented by ROBERT L. SACHS, Jr. , SHRAGER, SPIVEY, & SACHS.

DAVID LOOSE, Plaintiff, represented by DENNIS M. GEIER , COHEN PLACITELLA & ROTH.

DONALD STEWART, Plaintiff, represented by STEFANIE LYNN COLELLA-WALSH , STARK & STARK.

MARK ALLEN, Plaintiff, represented by ALEX C. DAVIS , JONES WARD PLC.

NORMA BRANHAM, Plaintiff, represented by Andrea T. McKellar , McKellar Hyde PLC & MARLENE J. GOLDENBERG , GOLDENBERGLAW, PLLC.

MYRA BENNETT & JAMES LEE JONGEWAARD, Plaintiffs, represented by DAVID MALCOLM MCMULLAN, Jr. , DON BARRETT PA.

PATRICK FONTENOT & MALCOLM JAMES WALTERS, Plaintiffs, represented by RICHARD LEE ROOT , MORRIS BART & ASSOCIATES.

ARGYRE PATRAS, Plaintiff, represented by ROSALEE B.C. THOMAS , FINKELSTEIN THOMPSON LLP.

ESTATE OF LARRY BROCK, MARVELLA OCHS, NITA LACEY-BYRD, ERMA RODGERS, SELENA WESTER & MELVOLA JASON, Plaintiffs, represented by ALYSON LOUISE OLIVER , Oliver Law Group P.C.

JUDITH HEWITT, Plaintiff, represented by SCOTT ALLEN BENKIE , BENKIE & CRAWFORD.

WORIKEENA RIGHTEOUS & URANIA RIGHTEOUS, Plaintiffs, represented by Donecia Banks Miley , Dean Morris, LLC.

DELIA DE LOS SANTOS, RAMON DORTA, PAULA JONES SURLES & WILLIE SURLES, Plaintiffs, represented by GEORGE T. WILLIAMSON , FARR LAW FIRM.

N ALBERT BACHARACH, JR, Plaintiff, represented by PAUL STUART ROTHSTEIN , PAUL S ROTHSTEIN PA.

LINDA C. BARBOZA & ROBERT P. BARBOZA, Plaintiffs, represented by ROSEMARIE RIDDELL BOGDAN , MARTIN HARDING & MAZZOTTI LLP.

GASTON J. ROBERTS, JR. & JAN ROBERTS, Plaintiffs, represented by DONALD PATRICK MCKENNA, Jr. , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON LLP.

MICHAEL CLEVELAND, MICHELLE HAMMOTHE & LINDA K. SOVINE, Plaintiffs, represented by EMILY JEFFCOTT , Morgan & Morgan Mass Tort Dept.

BELINDA J. WOOD, Plaintiff, represented by DAVID LEE HOBBS , Fleming, Nolen & Jez, L.L.P.

NETTIE DESHIELDS & LEON DESHIELDS, Plaintiffs, represented by MICHAEL A. LONDON , DOUGLAS & LONDON, PC.

JOSEPH GIOIA & SEAN MICHAEL GIOIA, Plaintiffs, represented by THOMAS P. GIUFFRA , RHEINGOLD VALET RHEINGOLD MCCARTNEY & GIUFFRA LLP.

JEANETTE STROZEWSKI, TERENCE STROZEWSKI, KATHY JEAN HUTCHISON, MADELENE ABRANKIAN, CAROL EDWARD, LESTER YOUNG, HILDA YOUNG, CYNTHIA TAYLOR, SHANDA DOWNS-TAYLOR, JOHN DOE, SALVATORE PICCOLO, ANNETTE PICCOLO & DAISY M. BROWN, Plaintiffs, represented by BRIAN A. GOLDSTEIN , CELLINO & BARNES PC.

FRANK TRIMBOLI, Plaintiff, represented by HUNTER J. SHKOLNIK , NAPOLI SHKOLNIK PLLC.

DARREN SNIDER, Plaintiff, represented by PAUL A. HIGDON , HIGDON LAWYERS.

SHEILA ZUCKERMAN & JOSPEH ZUCKERMAN, Plaintiffs, represented by William Morris Bristol , Gary F. Franke CO., L.P.A.

PRINSTON PHARMACEUTICALS INC., doing business as SOLCO HEALTHCARE U.S. LLC & SOLCO HEALTHCARE U.S. LLC, Defendants, represented by ALAN KLEIN , DUANE MORRIS LLP, DAWNN ELAYNE BRIDDELL , DUANE MORRIS LLP, ELINOR HART MURAROVA , Duane Morris LLP, JESSICA ANN PRISELAC , DUANE MORRIS, KEVIN F. HORMUTH , GREENSFELDER & HEMKER, MELISSA S. GELLER , DUANE MORRIS LLP, MEREDITH PROCTOR GRANT , Duane Morris, LLP, PAUL EVANS CHRONIS , Duane Morris LLP & SETH A. GOLDBERG , DUANE MORRIS LLP.

HUAHAI U.S. INC., Defendant, represented by ALAN KLEIN , DUANE MORRIS LLP, DAWNN ELAYNE BRIDDELL , DUANE MORRIS LLP, DREW T. DORNER , Duane Morris, LLP, JESSICA ANN PRISELAC , DUANE MORRIS, KEVIN F. HORMUTH , GREENSFELDER & HEMKER, MELISSA S. GELLER , DUANE MORRIS LLP, MEREDITH PROCTOR GRANT , Duane Morris, LLP & SETH A. GOLDBERG , DUANE MORRIS LLP.

TEVA INDUSTRIES LTD., Defendant, represented by JAMES M. SIMPSON, Jr. , Friday, Eldredge & Clark, LLP.

TEVA BIOPHARMACEUTICALS USA, INC., Defendant, represented by AARON VAN NOSTRAND , GREENBERG TRAURIG LLP & JAMES M. SIMPSON, Jr. , Friday, Eldredge & Clark, LLP.

TORRENT PHARMA INC. & TORRENT PHARMACEUTICALS LIMITED, Defendants, represented by DEVORA WHITMAN ALLON , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP, JAY PHILIP LEFKOWITZ , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP, ALEXIA BRANCATO , KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP & Brittney Nagle , Kirkland & Ellis LLP.

HETERO USA INC., Defendant, represented by JANET LYNN POLETTO , HARDIN, KUNDLA, MCKEON, POLETTO & POLIFRONI, PC & ROBERT ELMORE BLANTON, Jr. , HARDIN KUNDLA MCKEON & POLETTO, P.A.

CAMBER PHARMACEUTICALS INC., KROGER CO., THE & AVKARE, INC., Defendants, represented by MEGAN E. GROSSMAN , Lewis Brisbois Biasgaard & Smith & WALTER H. SWAYZE, III , Lewis Brisbois Biasgaard & Smith LLP.

QUALITY FOOD CENTERS INC., Defendant, represented by BRUCE ANTHONY MCMULLEN , BAKER DONELSON BEARMAN CALDWELL & BERKOWITZ PC, DANIEL C. FLEMING , WONG FLEMING, LINDA WONG , WONG & FLEMING, PC & MARY WU TULLIS , BAKER DONELSON BEARMAN CALDWELL & BERKOWITZ PC.

CVS HEALTH CO., Defendant, represented by ERNEST F. KOSCHINEG, III , CIPRIANI & WERNER PC, JESSICA MARGARET HEINZ , CIPRIANI & WERNER, P.C., KARA KAPKE , BARNES & THORNBURG LLP, KRISTEN LEE RICHER , BARNES & THORNBURG LLP & SARAH ELIZABETH JOHNSTON , BARNES & THORNBURG LLP.

WAL-MART STORES, INC, Defendant, represented by ALAN KLEIN , DUANE MORRIS LLP, DAVID E. SELLINGER , GREENBERG TRAURIG LLP, ELINOR HART MURAROVA , Duane Morris LLP & PAUL EVANS CHRONIS , Duane Morris LLP.

ZHEJIANG HUAHAI PHARMACEUTICAL CO., LTD, Defendant, represented by ALAN KLEIN , DUANE MORRIS LLP, DREW T. DORNER , Duane Morris, LLP, ELINOR HART MURAROVA , Duane Morris LLP, JESSICA ANN PRISELAC , DUANE MORRIS, KEVIN F. HORMUTH , GREENSFELDER & HEMKER, PAUL EVANS CHRONIS , Duane Morris LLP & SETH A. GOLDBERG , DUANE MORRIS LLP.

WALGREEN CO., also known as & THROGGS NECK PHARMACY, Defendants, represented by ALAN KLEIN , DUANE MORRIS LLP & SETH A. GOLDBERG , DUANE MORRIS LLP.

TEVA PHARMACEUTCAL INDUSTRIES, LTD., Defendant, represented by JAMES M. SIMPSON, Jr. , Friday, Eldredge & Clark, LLP & STEVEN M. HARKINS , GREENBERG TRAURIG LLP.

TEVA PHARMACEUTICALS USA, INC., Defendant, represented by BRIAN H. RUBENSTEIN , GREENBERG TRAURIG, JAMES M. SIMPSON, Jr. , Friday, Eldredge & Clark, LLP, LORI G. COHEN , GREENBERG TRAURIG LLP, VICTORIA DAVIS LOCKARD , GREENBERG TRAURIG LLP & STEVEN M. HARKINS , GREENBERG TRAURIG LLP.

HETERO LABS LTD, Defendant, represented by ERIC I. ABRAHAM , HILL WALLACK, LLP.

MYLAN PHARMACEUTICALS INC., Defendant, represented by CLEM C. TRISCHLER , PIETRAGALLO GORDON ALFANO BOSICK & RASPANTI LLP & JASON MICHAEL REEFER , PIETRAGALLO GORDON ALFANO BOSICK & RASPANTI LLP.

MYLAN LABORATORIES LTD., Defendant, represented by CLEM C. TRISCHLER , PIETRAGALLO GORDON ALFANO BOSICK & RASPANTI LLP.

RITE AID CORPORATION, Defendant, represented by ALAN KLEIN , DUANE MORRIS LLP.

AUROBINDO PHARMA USA INC. & AUROLIFE PHARMA, LLC, Defendants, represented by ERNEST F. KOSCHINEG, III , CIPRIANI & WERNER PC & JESSICA MARGARET HEINZ , CIPRIANI & WERNER, P.C.

H J HARKINS CO., INC., Defendant, represented by GEOFFREY MARVIN COAN , HINSHAW & CULBERTSON LLP.

REMEDYREPACK INC., Defendant, represented by HOWARD B. MANKOFF , MARSHALL, DENNAHEY, WARNER, COLEMAN & GOGGEN, PC, MICHELLE NICOLE MICHAEL , MARSHALL DENNEHEY WARNER COLEMAN AND GOGGIN & PAULINE F. TUTELO , MARSHALL DENNEHEY.

NUCARE PHARMACEUTICALS, INC., Defendant, represented by BETH S. ROSE , SILLS CUMMIS & GROSS P.C., BRIAN LUCAS SPADORA , Sills Cummis & Gross & CHARLES J. FALLETTA , SILLS CUMMIS & GROSS.

MAJOR PHARMACEUTICALS, Defendant, represented by ANDREW DAVID KAPLAN , CROWELL & mORING LLP, Kelly T. Currie , Crowell & Moring, LLP, ROBBIE FREYDA ROGART , CROWELL & MORING LLP, HILARY ELIZABETH JOHNSON , CROWELL & MORING LLP & Luke Bresnahan , Crowell & Moring.

A-S MEDICATION SOLUTIONS LLC, Defendant, represented by JULIA KOESTNER WITTMAN , QUARLES & BRADY LLP, LAUREN ELLIOTT STINE , QUARLES & BRADY LLP, MICHAEL S. CATLETT , QUARLES & BRADY LLP & MICHAEL C. SALVO , AHMUTY, DEMERS & MCMANUS, ESQS.

BRYANT RANCH PREPACK, INC., Defendant, represented by BETH S. ROSE , SILLS CUMMIS & GROSS P.C. & NATALIE ROSE COLAO , SILLS CUMMIS & GROSS P.C.

SANDOZ INC., Defendant, represented by AARON VAN NOSTRAND , GREENBERG TRAURIG LLP, ANDREW LANE REISSAUS , HOLLINGSWORTH LLP, DONALD R. MCMINN , HOLLINGSWORTH LLP & HEATHER ANN PIGMAN , HOLLINGSWORTH LLP.

PREFERRED PHARMACEUTICALS, INC., Defendant, represented by KELLY A. WATERS , WOOD SMITH HENNING & BERMAN.

HARRIS TEETER, LLC & HARRIS TEETER SUPERMARKETS, INC., Defendants, represented by DANIEL C. FLEMING , WONG FLEMING & LINDA WONG , WONG & FLEMING, PC.

AUROBINDO PHARMA LTD., Defendant, represented by JESSICA MARGARET HEINZ , CIPRIANI & WERNER, P.C.

HARVARD DRUG GROUP, LLC & CARDINAL HEALTH INC., Defendants, represented by ANDREW DAVID KAPLAN , CROWELL & mORING LLP, HILARY ELIZABETH JOHNSON , CROWELL & MORING LLP, ROBBIE FREYDA ROGART , CROWELL & MORING LLP & Luke Bresnahan , Crowell & Moring.

HUMANA INC. & HUMANA PHARMACY, INC., Defendants, represented by KIRSTIN B. IVES , FALKENBERG IVES LLP, MEGAN A. ZMICK , FALKENBERG IVES LLP & TYLER G. JOHANNES , FLAKENBERG IVES LLP.

ALBERTSONS COMPANIES LLC, Defendant, represented by JASON R. PARISH , BUCHANAN INGERSOLL & rOONEY PC, CHRISTOPHER J. DALTON , BUCHANAN, INGERSOLL & ROONEY, PC & JONATHAN D. JANOW , BUCHANAN INGERSOLL & ROONEY PC.

AMERISOURCEBERGEN CORPORATION, Defendant, represented by JEFFREY DANIEL GEOPPINGER , ULMER & BERNE LLP.

CIGNA CORPORATION, EXPRESS SCRIPTS HOLDING COMPANY & EXPRESS SCRIPTS, INC., Defendants, represented by ABRAHAM JAMES SPUNG , HUSCH BLACKWELL LLP, MATTHEW D. KNEPPER , HUSCH BLACKWELL LLP, MICHAEL CHARLES ZOGBY , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH, LLP & MOLLY E. FLYNN , Faegre Drinker Biddle & Reath LLP.

MCKESSON CORPORATION, Defendant, represented by D'LESLI DAVIS , NORTON ROSE FULBRIGHT US LLP, CARLOS FRANCISCO ORTIZ , Norton Rose Fulbright US LLP & ELIZABETH NORRIS , NORTON ROSS FULBRIGHT US LLP.

OPTUM, INC. & OptumRx, Defendants, represented by SHEVON D.B. ROCKETT , DORSEY & WHITNEY LLP.

LEGACY PHARMACEUTICAL PACKAGING, LLC, Defendant, represented by BRITTON LAURENCE ST. ONGE , POLSINELLI PC & FRANK SPANO , POLSINELLI PC.

GOLDEN STATE MEDICAL SUPPLY INC, Defendant, represented by Graham Caughman Talley , Mitchell, Williams, Selig, Gates & Woodyard, P.L.L.C.


MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

This Order Pertains to:

[C.A. No. 19-14891, Doc. No. 6]

[C.A. No. 19-15043, Doc. No. 8]

This matter is before the Court on identical Motions to Withdraw as Counsel filed by the attorney for two individual personal injury plaintiffs. Oral argument...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases