IN RE ETHICON, INC., PELVIC REPAIR SYSTEMS PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION

No. MDL 2327, Civil Action No. 2:12-cv-03797.

IN RE: ETHICON, INC., PELVIC REPAIR SYSTEMS PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION. THIS DOCUMENT RELATES TO PHYLLISS OGG Plaintiff, v. ETHICON, INC., BOSTON SCIENTIFIC CORPORATION, and JOHNSON & JOHNSON, Defendants.

United States District Court, S.D. West Virginia, Charleston Division.

January 22, 2020.

Editors Note
Applicable Law: 28 U.S.C. § 1331
Cause: 28 U.S.C. § 1331 Fed. Question: Personal Injury
Nature of Suit: 365 Personal Inj. Prod. Liability
Source: PACER


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Larry A. Cutter, member case assigned to Judge Robert C. Chambers, Plaintiff, represented by Charles C. Adams, Jr. , HERREN & ADAMS.

Michael Clements, individually, and on behalf of the estate of Brenda Clements & Brenda Clements, decedent, Plaintiffs, represented by Seth S. Webb , BROWN & CROUPPEN.

Patricia Copelin, Larry Copelin, Bethany May, &, Jimmy May, Joyce Snow, & & Christopher Snow, Plaintiffs, represented by Lee J. Hollis , HOLLIS LAW FIRM.

Romona Greer, Administratrix of the Estate of Romona Greer, Plaintiff, represented by Adam Matthew Evans , HOLLIS LAW FIRM & Lee J. Hollis , HOLLIS LAW FIRM.

Barbara Lucas, Plaintiff, represented by Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, John Fabry , MUELLER LAW, Mark R. Mueller , MUELLER LAW, pro hac vice & Susie Lin Hahn , LEESEBERG & VALENTINE.

Elsie Pierce, Laritza Messina, John Messina, Tina Harris & Darla Ray, Plaintiffs, represented by Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Fred Thompson, III , MOTLEY RICE, Harry F. Bell, Jr. , THE BELL LAW FIRM, Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE & Michael G. Rousseau , MOTLEY RICE.

Patricia Ruiz, Plaintiff, represented by Bobby J. Bradford , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Joseph A. Osborne, Jr. , BABBITT JOHNSON OSBORNE & LE CLAINCHE, Larry E. Coben , ANAPOL WEISS, Lydia Lucius , S. Mary Liu , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Samantha Margaret Katen , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & Thomas Richard Anapol , ANAPOL WEISS.

Monica Freitas & Kenneth Freitas, Plaintiffs, represented by Breanne Vandermeer Cope , MUELLER LAW, pro hac vice, Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Fred Thompson, III , MOTLEY RICE, Harry F. Bell, Jr. , THE BELL LAW FIRM, Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE & Michael G. Rousseau , MOTLEY RICE.

Diane Kropf, Plaintiff, represented by Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM.

Joseph Kropf, Darleen Kidd, Alice Scordo, Charles Scordo, Holly Benningfield, Donald Benningfield, Patricia Ballerino, Laurie Shannon Devine, William Eugene Devine, Sharon Arnold, Donald Lee Arnold, Virginia Alequin, Carlos Alequin, Jr., Ketrenia Hare, David Hare, Alania Keymel, Kathryn Stratton, Nancy Allocca, Kenneth Alden Allocca, Mary A. Wicke, Thomas Wicke, Betty Sue Quick, Johnny Quick, Camilla T. Herron, Amy Peterson, Virginia Duty, Jesse H. Duty, Amelia Luque, Lynn Holmes, Stacy Johnson Holmes, Kathy Kellams, Steven Kellams, Shelley Snyder, Robert E. Snyder, Beverly D. Dehart, Mary Mays, Tammie Jackson, Michael Jackson, Carrie Heckman & Shaunna Gill, Plaintiffs, represented by Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM & Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM.

Cynthia Nix, Plaintiff, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, Donald Douglas Grubbs , LEE MURPHY LAW FIRM, Douglas C. Monsour , THE MONSOUR LAW FIRM, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Jay H. Henderson , FIBICH LEEBRON COPELAND BRIGGS JOSEPHSON & Lisa L. Causey , SALIM-BEASLEY.

Sandra Cyrus, Gregory Cyrus, Martha Martinez & Frank S. Martinez, Plaintiffs, represented by A. Donald C. Discepolo , DISCEPOLO.

Elizabeth M. McGathey, Plaintiff, represented by Brenda S. Fulmer , SEARCY DENNEY SCAROLA BARNHART & SHIPLEY, C. Calvin Warriner, III , SEARCY DENNEY SCAROLA BARNHART & SHIPLEY & Thomas M. Creech, Jr. , LAW OFFICES OF THOMAS M. CREECH, JR.

Tamara Carter & David Carter, Plaintiffs, represented by Danny L. Curtis , DANNY L. CURTIS & Gregory Neil McEwen , MCEWEN LAW FIRM.

Alice A. Williams, Debbra K. Warden, Ruth Ellen Walenta, Madge M. Nichols, Doris A. Matney, Deretha Mae Omiotek, Kristine R. Sullivan, Loretta Ann Reyna, Mary Ann O'Hara, Judy Ann Goodman, Kimberly D. Frakes, Rhondena S. Brown, Robert Leo Fish, as Personal Representative of, The Estate of Wilma D. Fish, Eileen Mae Sills & Susan E. Perry, Plaintiffs, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ.

Dorothy Minix, Rebecca Levrets, Nina Majzel & Scott Majzel, Plaintiffs, represented by Andrea Solomon Hirsch , HERMAN GEREL, James F. Green , ASHCRAFT & GEREL, Joseph A. Kott , HERMAN HERMAN & KATZ & Michelle A. Parfitt , ASHCRAFT & GEREL.

Michelle Klinker & David Klinker, Plaintiffs, represented by Debra J. Humphrey , MARC J. BERN & PARTNERS, Hunter J. Shkolnik , NAPOLI BERN RIPKA SHKOLNIK & ASSOCIATES & Wilson Sikes , NAPOLI SHKOLNIK.

Cheryl Poole & Kenneth Poole, Plaintiffs, represented by Charles R. Houssiere, III , HOUSSIERE DURANT & HOUSSIERE & Randal A. Kauffman , HOUSSIERE DURANT & HOUSSIERE.

Brenda Gullett & Carl Gullett, Plaintiffs, represented by Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Fred Thompson, III , MOTLEY RICE, Harry F. Bell, Jr. , THE BELL LAW FIRM, Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE, Michael J. Pendell , MOTLEY RICE & Michael G. Rousseau , MOTLEY RICE.

Marion Chrysler, Plaintiff, represented by Danny L. Curtis , DANNY L. CURTIS, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Janice Green, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Mason Lee Boling , KEITH MILLER BUTLER SCHNEIDER & PAWLIK, Sean T. Keith , KEITH MILLER BUTLER SCHNEIDER & PAWLIK & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Yvonne Semere, Plaintiff, represented by Jay H. Henderson , FIBICH LEEBRON COPELAND BRIGGS JOSEPHSON, Lisa L. Causey , SALIM-BEASLEY & Richard T. Haik, Jr. , MORROW MORROW RYAN & BASSETT.

Mary E. McCarthy, Teresa M. Bailey & Gary David Bailey, Plaintiffs, represented by G. Sean Jez , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ & Rand Patrick Nolen , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ.

Tammy Jackson, member case assigned to Judge Robert C. Chambers & Bryon Jacksohn, member case assigned to Judge Robert C. Chambers, Plaintiffs, represented by Matthew J. Skikos , SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, Steven S. Skikos , LOPEZ HODES RESTAINO MILMAN & SKIKOS & Melissa Erin Mielke , SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH.

Nancy Rivers & Darryl Rivers, Plaintiffs, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Elizabeth M. Wilkins , SCHLICHTER BOGARD & DENTON, Kristine K. Kraft , SCHLICHTER BOGARD & DENTON & Roger C. Denton , SCHLICHTER BOGARD & DENTON.

Gayle King, Plaintiff, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Elizabeth M. Wilkins , SCHLICHTER BOGARD & DENTON, Kristine K. Kraft , SCHLICHTER BOGARD & DENTON, Lydia Lucius , Roger C. Denton , SCHLICHTER BOGARD & DENTON & Samantha Margaret Katen , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ.

Mikkii Edmonds, Cody Lee Edmonds, Lydia Correa & Jose Correa, Plaintiffs, represented by Andy Dow Birchfield, Jr. , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES, P. Leigh O'Dell , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES & Wesley Chadwick Cook , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES.

Audrey Smallridge, Plaintiff, represented by James Crosland , LAWCO USA, Merritt E. Cunningham , STAG LIUZZA, Michael G. Stag , SMITH STAG & Philip Jay Starr , LAWCO USA.

Theron Smallridge, Plaintiff, represented by Merritt E. Cunningham , STAG LIUZZA, Michael G. Stag , SMITH STAG & Philip Jay Starr , LAWCO USA.

Jamie Rutherford & Steven Rutherford, Plaintiffs, represented by Anne M. Tarvin , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GOZA & James Bartimus , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GOZA.

Janice Fields & Don Fields, Plaintiffs, represented by Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Fred Thompson, III , MOTLEY RICE, Harry F. Bell, Jr. , THE BELL LAW FIRM, John David O'Neill , MOTLEY RICE, Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE & Michael G. Rousseau , MOTLEY RICE.

Susan Grizzle & Simon Thomas Grizzle, Plaintiffs, represented by Andrea Little Gentle , DANIELS & GENTLE, Douglas A. Daniels , DANIELS & GENTLE & Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice.

Madenna K. Dorgan & Richard Dorgan, Plaintiffs, represented by Brian J. Madden , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Sherrill West, Plaintiff, represented by Alyson Oliver , OLIVER LAW GROUP & Matthew Caldwell Barsenas , OLIVER LAW GROUP.

Donna Williams, Rex Williams, Rebecca Roberts, Dianne Getter, Kesha Taylor, Elizabeth Humes, Jeanette Montijo & Margaret Wolf, Plaintiffs, represented by Hunter J. Shkolnik , NAPOLI BERN RIPKA SHKOLNIK & ASSOCIATES.

Emma White, Plaintiff, represented by Hunter J. Shkolnik , NAPOLI BERN RIPKA SHKOLNIK & ASSOCIATES & Mahesh Nair , MARC J. BERN & PARTNERS.

Norma Patterson & Randall Patterson, Plaintiffs, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM & William Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Mary Sither, Plaintiff, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Lezzlie Elizabeth Hornsby , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Shelley Van Natter Hutson , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & William Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Anna M. Jucha, Plaintiff, represented by Casey A. Kaufman , THE BRANDI LAW FIRM & Thomas J. Brandi , THE BRANDI LAW FIRM.

Toni Staton, Plaintiff, represented by Bobby J. Bradford , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Leslie D. Roussell , Patty Ann Trantham , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & S. Mary Liu , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ.

Cindy Orr & Allen Orr, Plaintiffs, represented by Christopher W. Cantrell , DOYLE LOWTHER, J. Gerard Stranch, IV , BRANSTETTER STRANCH & JENNINGS, pro hac vice & John Lowther , DOYLE LOWTHER.

Mary A. Jelks, Plaintiff, represented by David Hobbs , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ, George M. Fleming , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ, Jon C. Conlin , CORY WATSON, G. Sean Jez , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ & Rand Patrick Nolen , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ.

Donna Carver, Janis M. Cooper, Tina Graves, Horace E. Graves, Linda Nelson, Bobby Nelson, Janet Drake, Kyle Drake, Connie Martin, Marie Daugherty, Kelly J. Webb, Jennifer L. Jude, Evelyn Lambert, John D. Lambert, Cynthia D. Hines, James Hines, Seba Luckett-Epps, Sandra J. Pelham, Deborah Kinard, John Kinard, Cathy Lynn Bond, Margaret Stratton, Wanda Brown, Doreta S. Norris, Mark Norris, Aimee Slusser, Evelyn Barrera, Valdemar Barrera, Linda Munsterman, Ardell Munsterman, Wanda Duhon, Jerry Duhon, Deborah J. Coleman, Rebecca Heuerman, Timothy Heuerman, Doris Alford, Charlotte Rondot, Linda Heidelberg, Ronald Espey, Cherita Smith, Wanda Gutierrez, Ramiro Gutierrez, Belinda Vargas, Joseph Vargas, Brenda Tucker, Kimberly Schmitz, Kevin Schmitz, Cynthia Amelong, John Amelong, Barbara D. Smith, Tony M. Smith, Sherri Hughes, Donald Hughes, Frances D. Burger, Adrea Bettis, Robert Bettis, Tabitha Smith, Nickolas Smith, Nettie Schultz, Gordon Schultz, Janice McClurg, David McClurg, Larry Martin, Teresa Martin, Frances M. Fielder, Joseph Fielder, Debbie Prasuhn, Jill Wolfert, Mike Wolfert, Susan Heindl, Edward Heindl, Rayne Perrywinkle, Anneliese Boland, Jeanette McCall, Natalie Crow, Judy Cuttrell, Darleen Nugnes, Alicia Malcolm, David Trout, Julie Trout, Carolyn Nowland, Rick Nowland, Mary Coker, Brandi May-Weirauch, Betty Banda, Katie Bentley, Clara Coleen Bryant, Patricia Gilstrap, Sherry Kirby & Clifford S. Kirby, Plaintiffs, represented by Amy Collignon Gunn , THE SIMON LAW FIRM, pro hac vice & John G. Simon , THE SIMON LAW FIRM.

Edna M. Spoon & William S. Spoon, Plaintiffs, represented by George M. Fleming , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ, James R. Omer, Sr. , OMER & ASSOCIATES, G. Sean Jez , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ & Rand Patrick Nolen , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ.

Ediany Carbon & Albert Carbon, Plaintiffs, represented by Ami Rebecca Romanelli , BABBITT JOHNSON OSBORNE & LECLAINCHE & Joseph A. Osborne, Jr. , BABBITT JOHNSON OSBORNE & LE CLAINCHE.

Rita Mattingly, Plaintiff, represented by Charles S. Zimmerman , ZIMMERMAN REED, Genevieve M. Zimmerman , MESHBESHER & SPENCE, pro hac vice, Jacqueline Anne Olson , ZIMMERMAN REED & Jason P. Johnston , ZIMMERMAN REED.

Tamika Griffin, Plaintiff, represented by Carolyn Glass Anderson , ZIMMERMAN REED, Charles S. Zimmerman , ZIMMERMAN REED, Genevieve M. Zimmerman , MESHBESHER & SPENCE, pro hac vice, Jacqueline Anne Olson , ZIMMERMAN REED & Jason P. Johnston , ZIMMERMAN REED.

Shannon Pulliam & Kenneth Pulliam, Plaintiffs, represented by Mark R. Mueller , MUELLER LAW, pro hac vice & W. Todd Harvey , BURKE HARVEY.

Lynda S. Nicholson, Sarah R. Jenkins & Billy Ray Jenkins, Plaintiffs, represented by Andrea Little Gentle , DANIELS & GENTLE & Douglas A. Daniels , DANIELS & GENTLE.

Jeannae M. Thomson-Roy & Mary Elizabeth Dowling, Plaintiffs, represented by Brenda S. Fulmer , SEARCY DENNEY SCAROLA BARNHART & SHIPLEY & C. Calvin Warriner, III , SEARCY DENNEY SCAROLA BARNHART & SHIPLEY.

Pamela Sobie & Raymond Sobie, Plaintiffs, represented by William J. Doyle, II , DOYLE LOWTHER.

Sarah Reeves, Barbara Smith, Gary Smith & Marilyn Seal, Plaintiffs, represented by John Lowther , DOYLE LOWTHER & William J. Doyle, II , DOYLE LOWTHER.

Adelheid Pirlien, Plaintiff, represented by Bobby J. Bradford , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Joseph A. Osborne, Jr. , BABBITT JOHNSON OSBORNE & LE CLAINCHE, Lydia Lucius , Nathan C. Bess , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Neil D. Overholtz , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & Patty Ann Trantham , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ.

Kristen Lee Sluis & Greg Sluis, Plaintiffs, represented by Andrew Judson Hill, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, Gary B. Blasingame , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, James B. Matthews, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY & Josh B. Wages , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice.

Teresa Smith, deceased, James C. McCann, Personal Representative of the Estate of & Dwaine Smith, Plaintiffs, represented by Christine V. Clarke , KLINE & SPECTER, Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice.

Elaine G. Geraty, Georgia Hervey, deceased, Susan Hervey, Personal Representative of the Estate of, Vivian Hogge, Randy Hogge, Victoria Postil, Judy Baker, Teresa Bush, Nina Garcia, Ismel Garcia, Edwin Britt, Judy Britt, Delia Morreira, Klaudia Gurrola, Frank Gurrola, Nohemi Martinez, Maria Bertha Chavez, Fausto Chavez, Paula Boomhower, Richard Boomhower, Kristine Mattox, Circe Dealba, Penney Hagler, Richard Hagler, Diana Buchholz, Richard Stricklin, Successor in Interest for the Estate of, Tona Stricklin, deceased, Richard Stricklin, Shirley Greenwell, Patricia Hughes Siefkas & Jon Siefkas, Plaintiffs, represented by Alan S. Lazar , MARLIN & SALTZMAN, Christina A. Humphrey , MARLIN & SALTZMAN, Craig S. Pynes , MARLIN & SALTZMAN, Kiley L. Grombacher , MARLIN & SALTZMAN & Marcus J. Bradley , MARLIN & SALTZMAN.

Lenda Sugg & Ernest Sugg, Plaintiffs, represented by Darren Ray Wolf , LAW OFFICES OF DARREN WOLF.

Larri Donner, Plaintiff, pro se.

Tammy Graham, Plaintiff, represented by Lisa Ann Gorshe , JOHNSON BECKER & Michael K. Johnson , JOHNSON BECKER.

Blake Cox, Tammy Welch, Edward Welch, Jr., Melissa Triche, Lucia Contreras, Conrado Contreras, Juanita Johnston, Pleazant Johnston, Rebecca Langlois, Mary Almaraz & Linda Vardaman, Plaintiffs, represented by Adam J. Blake , PERDUE & KIDD, Donald H. Kidd , PERDUE & KIDD & Jim M. Perdue, Jr. , PERDUE KIDD & VICKERY.

Mary Toole, Daylon Toole, Clarice Sterba, William Sterba, Marianne Jefford, Garry Jefford, Julie Waldon, Letha Brantley, Charles Brantley, Esther Markes & Rob Markes, Plaintiffs, represented by John Fabry , MUELLER LAW & Mark R. Mueller , MUELLER LAW, pro hac vice.

Tammie Labiche & Mitchell Labiche, Plaintiffs, represented by Julie L. Rhoades , MATTHEWS & ASSOCIATES & Tim K. Goss , FREESE & GOSS.

Helen Higgins, Plaintiff, represented by Leslie C. MacLean , WATERS & KRAUS.

Patricia Gail Arnold & Gary Lynn Arnold, Plaintiffs, represented by Dana B. Taschner , pro hac vice, David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly A. Fitzpatrick , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Lee A. Cirsch , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, pro hac vice & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Deborah Barone, Plaintiff, represented by Alex Barlow , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK, Bill Robins, III , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK, Justin R. Kaufman , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK & Rebecca Lynn Phillips , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD.

Paula Carole Clowe & Audie L. Pope, Plaintiffs, represented by Kip Allan Petroff , LAW OFFICE OF KIP PETROFF.

Virda Holland, member case assigned to Judge Robert C. Chambers & Benjamin Holland, member case assigned to Judge Robert C. Chambers, Plaintiffs, represented by Joseph Lyon , THOMAS & LYON.

Hallie Hawkins & Jerry Hawkins, Plaintiffs, represented by Daniel S. Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Mark P. Robinson, Jr. , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Shannon Lukei , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS & Willard J. Moody, Jr. , THE MOODY LAW FIRM.

Patricia Hosbrook, Plaintiff, represented by David Silverman , SCHLESINGER LAW OFFICES, Jeffrey L. Haberman , SCHLESINGER LAW OFFICES & Valerie Ann Conzo , SHELDON J. SCHLESINGER.

Brenda Harvey, Plaintiff, pro se.

Paula M. Houck & Gary G. Houck, Plaintiffs, represented by James F. Green , ASHCRAFT & GEREL, Michelle A. Parfitt , ASHCRAFT & GEREL, T. Matthew Leckman , LECKMAN LAW & Zoe Littlepage , LITTLEPAGE BOOTH LECKMAN, pro hac vice.

Cynthia Zember & Donald C. Zember, Plaintiffs, represented by David Silverman , SCHLESINGER LAW OFFICES & Valerie Ann Conzo , SHELDON J. SCHLESINGER.

Bobbie Strickland, Plaintiff, represented by Douglas Robert Plymale , PLYMALE LAW FIRM, Frank Jacob D'Amico, Jr. , LAW OFFICES OF FRANK J. D'AMICO, JR., James R. Dugan, II , THE DUGAN LAW FIRM, Jeffrey A. Mitchell , THE MITCHELL FIRM & Mark W. Davis , DAVIS & CRUMP.

Linda Locklear, Dell Locklear, Eda Torres & Alberto Torres, Plaintiffs, represented by Michael Gallant , KELLEY BERNHEIM & DOLINKSY.

Carolyn M. Kieffaber, Plaintiff, represented by Diane K. Watkins , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Elizabeth L. Dudley , THE DUDLEY LAW FIRM, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Thomas M. Kieffaber, Plaintiff, represented by Elizabeth L. Dudley , THE DUDLEY LAW FIRM, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Roi L. Gilsdorf, Plaintiff, represented by Holly Nighbert , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, Jayne Conroy , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, John J. Foley , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, Paul Hanly , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY & Trent B. Miracle , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY.

Eddie Garcia, Joy J. Miller, Haley M. Smith, Lucas Smith, Darlene Champion, Jon Champion & Ramona Tolman, Plaintiffs, represented by Jayne Conroy , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, John J. Foley , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, Paul Hanly , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY & Trent B. Miracle , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY.

Margo Ellis, Beau Ellis, Christine Heatherman, Terry Weaver & Elizabeth Jones, Plaintiffs, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Marc K. Erickson , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Amanda Ann Baldwin, Janet Pickell, John Pickell, Amanda Nicole Eskew, Randy Eskew, Anne-Marie Dubois, Scott Pemberton, Barbara Garcia, Paul Garcia, Dana Meade, Glen Meade, Elizabeth McCormack, Mark McCormack, Susanna B. Garver, Phyllis Trulove, Larry Trulove, Tinamarie Hamilton, William Roy, Donna Sims, Donna J. Harris, Kathryn L. Rasa, Anthony S. Rasa, Debra A. Buchman, Robert C. Buchman, Deborah Johnson, Michael A. Johnson, Mary Weast, Phyllis S. Simmons, Diana Hochstetler, Juanita Jenkins, Christopher Jenkins, Willene Carrigg, Sue Ellen Fleckner, Emma McCoy, Steve McCoy, Michelle McGown, Mike McGown, Tina Comouche, Douglas Comouche, Lydia M. Arnold, Deborah Dockery, Trey Dockery & Herminia Ornelas, Plaintiffs, represented by Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Fred Thompson, III , MOTLEY RICE & Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE.

Kerry Dudas & Deborah S. Snyder, Plaintiffs, represented by Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Donna Young & Walter Young, Plaintiffs, represented by Adam J. Blake , PERDUE & KIDD, Donald H. Kidd , PERDUE & KIDD, Jim M. Perdue, Jr. , PERDUE KIDD & VICKERY & Katie A. Fillmore , BUTLER SNOW.

Diane Cayer, Plaintiff, represented by Jacob Plattenberger , TOR HOERMAN LAW, Raymond Joseph Kramer , TORHOERMAN LAW, Steven D. Davis , TOR HOERMAN LAW & Tor A. Hoerman , TOR HOERMAN LAW.

Paul Cayer, Plaintiff, represented by Jacob Plattenberger , TOR HOERMAN LAW & Raymond Joseph Kramer , TORHOERMAN LAW.

Judy L. Tedder, Plaintiff, represented by Elizabeth L. Dudley , THE DUDLEY LAW FIRM, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Sarah S. Ruane , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Delores Longoria, Lorenzo D. Longoria, Nadina J. Price, Jason Price, Mandy L. Thompson, Ricardo J. Aguirre, Dawn Duffy & Darren Duffy, Plaintiffs, represented by Joseph H. Saunders , SAUNDERS & WALKER.

Tammy Pizzitola, Plaintiff, represented by Greg A. Vigna , Laura J. Baughman , BARON & BUDD, Paige Nicole Boldt , WATTS GUERRA & Ryan L. Thompson , WATTS GUERRA CRAFT.

Aleli M. Blank & Leonard Blank, Plaintiffs, represented by Dana B. Taschner , pro hac vice, David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly A. Fitzpatrick , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Lisa Baron Blue , BARON & BLUE & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Roger D. Tyler, Independent Administrator of the Estate of Peggy J. Knight, Deceased, Plaintiff, represented by Andrew J. Cross , CAREY DANIS & LOWE, pro hac vice, Jeffrey J. Lowe , CAREY DANIS & LOWE, Sarah Shoemake Doles , CARY DANIS & LOWE & Amy E. Garrett , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY.

Shirley Rouse, Claudia Hagood, Kenneth Hagood, Imogene Mecaskey, Charles B. Mecaskey, Doris M. Pilger, Edwin Pilger, Autumn Ruth Ater & Scott Ater, Plaintiffs, represented by Matthew John Morrison , HARRISON DAVIS STEAKLEY MORRISON, Preston J. Dugas, III , PARKER MCDONALD, Ryan H. Anderson , PARKER MCDONALD, W. Bradley Parker , PARKER MCDONALD & Zollie C. Steakley , HARRISON DAVIS STEAKLEY MORRISON.

LaWanda Blackmon & Thomas O. Blackmon, Plaintiffs, represented by Michael Cory Bradley , PITTMAN DUTTON & HELLUMS.

Mary Thorne, Plaintiff, represented by Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER.

Linda Romero, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Luke F. Callahan , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Andrea Crissman, Plaintiff, represented by Amy Eskin , LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS, pro hac vice, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Lindsey Scarcello , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Mark E. Burton, Jr. , HERSH & HERSH, pro hac vice & William M. Audet , AUDET & PARTNERS.

Randall Crissman, Plaintiff, represented by Amy Eskin , LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS, pro hac vice, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Mark E. Burton, Jr. , HERSH & HERSH, pro hac vice & William M. Audet , AUDET & PARTNERS.

Debra Ruberti, Plaintiff, represented by McDonald S. Worley , MCDONALD WORLEY & Michelle Rene Eddington , MCDONALD WORLEY.

Linda F. Hooper, Plaintiff, represented by Elizabeth L. Dudley , THE DUDLEY LAW FIRM, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Jonathan Kieffer , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Kevin Kauffman , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Victoria Lyn Mortimer, Plaintiff, represented by David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Ian Stern Millican , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, John Edward Charland , Charland Law Firm, Kelly A. Fitzpatrick , THE LANIER LAW FIRM & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Phyllis Pearson, Denese Dice, Terry Dice, Stephanie Green, Eric Griffin, Kathleen Minton, Jennifer Clark & James K. Clark, Plaintiffs, represented by Jacob Plattenberger , TOR HOERMAN LAW & Tor A. Hoerman , TOR HOERMAN LAW.

Janna Dickey, Archie Dickey & Harolyn Kent, Plaintiffs, represented by Aimee H. Wagstaff , ANDRUS & WAGSTAFF, Marc D. Grossman , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN & Randi Kassan , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN.

Carol Gomez, Plaintiff, represented by John Fabry , MUELLER LAW, Mark R. Mueller , MUELLER LAW, pro hac vice & W. Todd Harvey , BURKE HARVEY.

Irene Fortuna, Plaintiff, represented by Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice, Thomas R. Kline , KLINE & SPECTER & Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER.

Patricia Bernice Martinez, Plaintiff, represented by Mark Alan Milstein , MILSTEIN ADELMAN.

Lauri Bell, Plaintiff, represented by Erin K. Copeland , FIBICH LEEBRON COPELAND BRIGGS JOSEPHSON & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Terrill Bell & Theresa A. Connolly, Plaintiffs, represented by Erin K. Copeland , FIBICH LEEBRON COPELAND BRIGGS JOSEPHSON.

Sherry Moore, Moira Hawk, Sandra M. Thorpe, Walter Thorpe, Cynthia Newman, Sheri Mingus, Florence Bernhardt, Brenda J. Miller, Betty Jones, Marjorie Mann, Peggy McCormick, Norma Pugh, Cheryl Trobough & Sarah Starbuck, Plaintiffs, represented by Sean Patrick Tracey , TRACEY & FOX LAW FIRM & Shawn P. Fox , TRACEY & FOX LAW FIRM.

Carol Olsen, Plaintiff, represented by Marilyn T. McGoldrick , THORNTON LAW FIRM.

William Smith, Plaintiff, represented by Ross H. Ehlinger , EHLINGER & DEADERICK.

Gwen L. Buntgen & Wayne Buntgen, Plaintiffs, represented by David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly A. Fitzpatrick , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Lee A. Cirsch , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, pro hac vice & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Nancy Fine & Mlrzeta Hirkich, Plaintiffs, represented by Michael Leslie Hodges , HODGES LAW FIRM.

Patricia H. Walker, Personal Representative of the Estate of Patricia H. Walker, Plaintiff, represented by Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice, Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Priscilla E. Jimenez , KLINE & SPECTER.

Elaine Hyatt, Plaintiff, pro se.

Vicki C. Woods & Tim Woods, Sr., Plaintiffs, represented by Rebecca M. Langston , LANGSTON & LANGSTON & Shane F. Langston , LANGSTON & LANGSTON.

Deserie Lim, Plaintiff, represented by Christopher Justin Broome , LANGSTON & LANGSTON, Kevin J. White , LANGSTON & LANGSTON, Rebecca M. Langston , LANGSTON & LANGSTON & Shane F. Langston , LANGSTON & LANGSTON.

Lisa Mason, Plaintiff, represented by Geoffrey T. Moore , MAHER LAW FIRM & Rebecca Lynn Phillips , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD.

Maria Robinson, Plaintiff, represented by Greg A. Vigna , Larissa Davis , BOSSIER & ASSOCIATES, Laura J. Baughman , BARON & BUDD, Paige Nicole Boldt , WATTS GUERRA & Sheila M. Bossier , BOSSIER & ASSOCIATES.

Hilda Jones, Johnny D Jones, Emily Burlingame, Elaine Lawson, Sherrilene Cunningham, Dora Estrada, Joel Estrada, Diane Hamlett Lalumiere, Gill Lalumiere, Barbara Leder, LaDonna Haviland, Elisabeth Harris, Robert Harris, Alta Joy Loague, Robert W. Loague, Crystal Morrow, Thomas Morrow, Laura Roundine, Robin Weaver, Frank Weaver, Darlene Wildfong, Harry Clayton Wildfong, Bessie Walters, deceased, Debra Bishop, as Independent Co-Executor of the Estate of, Barbara Hull, Sheila Melton, Bobby Melton, Carol Young, Joseph Young, Carol Bayer, Richard Bayer, Joyce McCoy, Deborah Baca, Geraldine Wheeler, George Wheeler, Linda Harhart, Naomi Jacobson, Carol Vitale, William Vitale, Kathleen Grimme, James Grimme, Leonor Castro, Anselmo Castro, Gail Cannon, John Cannon, Celia O'Fallon, Dennis O'Fallon, Kelley Gulley, John Gulley, W/H, Jyoti Bathija, Jagdish T. Bathija, Girma Negash, Sandra Ann Smith, Rebecca Sharp, Daniel Beckett, Shelley Guyette, Raymond Guyette, Kathryn Erwin, Charles Erwin, Sue Bell, James Bell, Tia LaFlesh, Scott LaFlesh, Brenda Sinkovich, Aaron Sinkovich, Susan Long, Lee Long, Carolyn Foley, Charles Foley, Stefanie Rutherford, Jean M. Yetter, Terrill Cagle, Richard Heffelfinger, Kristne Elizabeth Minor, Calvin Thomas Minor, Sarah Lampron, Walter Lampron, Cynthia E. Thompson, John E. Thompson, Jr., Debra Clemons, Karry Clemons, Dana Endicott, Charles Endicott, Mariquita Santistevan, Dennis Santistevan, Betty Carter, Rita Christie, Deanna Cuckler, Ronald Cuckler, Melody Poore, Ronald Poore, Maxine Edith Parker, Cathy A. Russell, Barbara Haizlip, William C. Haizlip, Wendy Jung, John Jung, Bobbie Jean Saxton, Gloria Grubbs, Glenn D. Grubbs, Delphia Plott, Carter Plott, Janet Bell, Diane L. Scaife, Robert Scaife, Lydia Fancil, Todd Fancil, Peggy Bryant, Dean Bryant, Kimberley Poe, Angela Abt, Jeanette Dozier, Charles Dozier, Theresa Walz, John J. Walz, III, Mary Glaze, Jessica Gillespie, Damien Sandifer, Sharon Segrist, John Segrist, Phyllis Cessna, William Cessna, Lisa Faye Regino, Carvel Priest, Steven Jens, Linda Gordon, Jeff Gordon, Lori Illjes, Robert Illjes, Heyda Rosa, Eddie Rosa, Sharon Saez, Nancy Bailey, Chari Hoover, George Robert Hoover, Carol Elliott, Randy Elliott, Denise Post, Kenneth Post, Patti Scott, Matthew Scott, Nanette Ward, John J. Ward, Patricia Fox, Elaine Maloney, Dennis Maloney, Debra Berube, Robert Berube, Clara Mae Rutledge, Donald Rutledge, Danny Brown, Linda Finley, Brianne Marshall, Nora Mitchell, Arthur Mitchell, Susan Cannon, William Cannon, Deborah Miller, Debra Kimble, Allan Kimble, Vanessa Dates, Jeanette Joss, Russell Joss, Joan Brown, Carrie Vaughn, Rita Carey, Sharyne Anderson, Alan Anderson, Corliss Fowler, Nancy Bauer, Stanlee Bauer, Tiffany K. Wilson, Nathan Arnhamn, Marta Fernandez, Farah Massoudi, Cyrus Massoudi, Gay Brown, Rhonda Hall, Greg Hall, Dale Hall, Catherine Forlines, Charles B. Forlines, Gloria Ward, Thomas K. Ward, Marlene Linnon, Richard Linnon, Pilar ElQuesny, Mongy ElQuesny, Lilia Valadez Izguerra, Jean Clarkson, Victoria Altman, Nicola Ferla, Paul T. Ferla, Mary Farrell, Paul Vincent Farrell, Hazel Barnes, Mary Ellen Stigen, Merritt Stigen, Linda Moore, Linda Danoff, Marilyn Bourque, John P. Bourque, Sharon Murphy, John G. Murphy, Jr., Patricia Boreni, Alan Boreni, Sheryl Gaughan, Philip Gaughan, Nicole D. Williams, Michael V. Williams, Susan L. Moser, Doreen Villandry, Doris Mitchell, Katrina Nixon, Sandra Stiffler, William Stiffler, Debra Bargiol & Jason Bargiol, Plaintiffs, represented by Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice.

Gloria F. Wilson, Plaintiff, represented by Sheila M. Bossier , BOSSIER & ASSOCIATES, Mark K. Gray , GRAY & WHITE & Doris A. Kim , GRAY & WHITE.

Enid Hutchings, Sylvester Hutchings, Gloria Jean Taylor & Barbara Jean Lotz, Plaintiffs, represented by David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly A. Fitzpatrick , THE LANIER LAW FIRM & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Marla M. Cabell, Rebecca Dale, Michael Dale, Raymond Bruce, Renee Bruce, Doris Chelala & Tony Chelala, Plaintiffs, represented by Robert J. Fenstersheib , ROBERT J. FENSTERSHEIB & ASSOCIATES.

Ruth Mushrush & Ramona Smith, Plaintiffs, represented by Brent William Bailey , LAW OFFICES OF BILL BAILEY, Daniel S. Gruber , GRUBER & GRUBER & Howard A. Snyder , LAW OFFICES OF HOWARD A. SNYDER.

Alexandra Perciballi, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Nigh , LEVIN PAPANTONIO THOMAS MITCHELL RAFFERTY & PROCTOR, Robert E. Price , LEVIN PAPANTONIO THOMAS MITCHELL RAFFERTY & PROCTOR & Rochelle Rottenstein , ROTTENSTEIN LAW GROUP.

Lewis Perciballi, Plaintiff, represented by Roger Heath , FOSTER & SEAR, Robert E. Price , LEVIN PAPANTONIO THOMAS MITCHELL RAFFERTY & PROCTOR & Rochelle Rottenstein , ROTTENSTEIN LAW GROUP.

Hedy Miller, Robert Miller, Carol A. Martziaris, Kayleen Martin & Rosa Martin, Plaintiffs, represented by Erin M. Wood , WATERS & KRAUS & Leslie C. MacLean , WATERS & KRAUS.

Karren A. Shilson, Plaintiff, represented by Dennis A. Costigan , MOTLEY RICE, Kimberly Wilson White , WILSON LAW & William J. Blakemore , WILSON LAW.

Cynthia Donall & David Donall, Plaintiffs, represented by Ryan Keith Haun , BARTON LAW FIRM, Kimberly Wilson White , WILSON LAW & William J. Blakemore , WILSON LAW.

Kimberly Raney, Plaintiff, represented by Aoife-Roisin Nora Bourke , MARK J. BERN & PARTNERS, Debra J. Humphrey , MARC J. BERN & PARTNERS & Hunter J. Shkolnik , NAPOLI BERN RIPKA SHKOLNIK & ASSOCIATES.

Patricia Foley, George Foley, Vera Bloomfield, Robert Bloomfield, Michelle Caughill, Brian Caughill, Susan Casperson, Robert Casperson, Wanda L. Evans, Rosalie Fincher, Patricia A. Green, James Green, Marquetta Hales, Christine R. Hoffman, James R. Hoffman, Jill Johnson, Keith Johnson, Margaret Kingsbury, John Joseph Kingsbury, Sue Ellen May, Gerald G. May, Janice Long, Rosemary Lopez, Leann O'Malley, Terence O'Malley, Rena Faye Norby, John Norby, Jane E. Ream, Williams J. Ream, Carolann Silvia, DeeAnne Silva, David Holland, Mary Ann Sirko, Janeen Smith, Randall Smith, Joanna Thompson, Joyce Wessel, Philip Wessel, Merel Walker, Emily Whitson, Glenda Emerick, Phillip Emerick, Lana Holt, John Holt, Angela Dent, Rebie Dixon & Steve Dixon, Plaintiffs, represented by Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice, Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Thomas R. Kline , KLINE & SPECTER.

Iretta Lynn Ashbrook, Plaintiff, represented by Kris Douglas Mullins , MORGAN & MORGAN, Robert K. Finnell , THE FINNELL FIRM, Shea W. Conley , MORGAN & MORGAN & Timothy Michael Morgan , MORGAN & MORGAN.

Suzanne Yarbrough, Plaintiff, represented by Karen Beyea-Schroeder , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & Riley L. Burnett, Jr. , BURNETT LAW FIRM.

Maxine Jo Domorod, Lawrence A. Domorod, Kristyne L. Behymer & Donald A. Behymer, Plaintiffs, represented by Gregory L. Laker , COHEN & MALAD, pro hac vice, Irwin B. Levin , COHEN & MALAD, pro hac vice & Jeff S. Gibson , COHEN & MALAD, pro hac vice.

Ignacia G. Sandoval & Terry L. Taylor, Plaintiffs, represented by Alexandra V. Boone , MILLER WEISBROD, Les Weisbrod , MILLER WEISBROD & Luke Harrison Metzler , MILLER WEISBROD.

Mary L. Brown, Savitaben Patel & Vinod Patel, Plaintiffs, represented by Andy Dow Birchfield, Jr. , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES, Marianne C. LeBlanc , SUGARMAN & SUGARMAN, P. Leigh O'Dell , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES & Wesley Chadwick Cook , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES.

Marlene Lenze, Plaintiff, represented by Alexander Grier Dwyer , KIRKENDALL DWYER & Andrew F. Kirkendall , KIRKENDALL DWYER.

Teresa Autrey, Plaintiff, represented by Michael S. Wilson , CURTIS LAW GROUP & William B. Curtis , CURTIS LAW GROUP, pro hac vice.

Leverett Autrey, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Donald S. Edgar , SMITH DOLLAR & Rex J. Grady , Fourth Floor, pro hac vice.

Susan Rusciano, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Nathaniel McGraw Jones , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Tammy Stephens, Joyce Wishart, Michael Wishart, Evelyn Racca, Pete Racca, Sherrie Smith, Maribeth Fuller, James Fuller, Clara Rounds, Anna Temple, Lisa Ann Gilbert, Nancy S. Davidson, Michael A. Davidson, Evon Norris, Karen Johnson, Richard A. Johnson, Brenda Elkey, Sina Billingsley, Donald Billingsley, Donna Neil, Jose Munoz & Heather Lyons, Plaintiffs, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Ruth M. Barrymore & Roxanne Lee Huish, Plaintiffs, represented by David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly A. Fitzpatrick , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Lee A. Cirsch , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, pro hac vice, Michael A. Akselrud , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, pro hac vice & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Maria Anaya, Wendy Wilson & Richard Wilson, Plaintiffs, represented by Sean Michael Cleary , LAW OFFICES OF SEAN M. CLEARY.

Lori J. Jack, Plaintiff, represented by Nabil Majed Nachawati, II , FEARS NACHAWATI LAW FIRM.

Michelle Lee Morris & Scottie J. Morris, Plaintiffs, represented by David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly A. Fitzpatrick , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Rebecca Lynn Phillips , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Tammy Edwards, Plaintiff, represented by Megan M. McBride , LEVIN PAPANTONIO THOMAS MITCHELL RAFFERTY & PROCTOR & Nabil Majed Nachawati, II , FEARS NACHAWATI LAW FIRM.

Brandie Clanton, Leslie Lee Gomez, Ignacio Gomez Vasquez, Olivia Belmann, Jose Guillermo Martinez, Sherry Lynn Zehr, Linda J. Pagan, Maria Ayala & Elizabeth Zona, Plaintiffs, represented by Stephen Charles Swain , SHUTTLEWORTH RULOFF SWAIN HADDAD & MORECOCK.

Toni Genone, Plaintiff, represented by J. Mark Kell , KELL LAMPIN.

Kelly Ann Markham & Joseph Markham, Plaintiffs, represented by Dennis A. Costigan , MOTLEY RICE.

Tricia Rodman & Michael Rodman, Plaintiffs, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & Jeffrey A. Bowersox , BOWERSOX LAW FIRM.

Traci Haynes, Dina M. Sellers, Leon Sellers, Emily H. Bowers, Albert B. Bowers, Jr., Sandra R. Rosenfeld & Robert M. Rosenfeld, Plaintiffs, represented by Brady Ryan Thomas , RICHARDSON PATRICK WESTBROOK & BRICKMAN & Daniel S. Haltiwanger , RICHARDSON PATRICK WESTBROOK & BRICKMAN.

Jimmie Jones, Robert Jones, Eleanor Root, Joseph Root, Michelle M. Casey & Silvia Munoz, Plaintiffs, represented by Diane K. Watkins , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Leah R. Shostrom, Plaintiff, represented by Gregory D. Bentley , ZONIES LAW, Joseph J. Zonies , ZONIES LAW & Richard J. Plezia , RICHARD J. PLEZIA & ASSOCIATES.

Irma Lopez & Porfirio Lopez, Plaintiffs, represented by Carolyn Glass Anderson , ZIMMERMAN REED, Genevieve M. Zimmerman , MESHBESHER & SPENCE, pro hac vice & Jacqueline Anne Olson , ZIMMERMAN REED.

Cassandra Sutton, Robert Sutton, Naomi Larson, Mark Larson, JoAnn Syverson & Lori Murray, Plaintiffs, represented by Marc E. Lipton , LIPTON LAW CENTER, Andrew N. Faes , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, John M. Black , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Mark Tucker, Plaintiff, represented by Amy Collignon Gunn , THE SIMON LAW FIRM, pro hac vice, John G. Simon , THE SIMON LAW FIRM, Bobby J. Bradford , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Lydia Lucius , S. Mary Liu , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & Seth S. Webb , BROWN & CROUPPEN.

Maria Benestad, Plaintiff, represented by Charles Bland Patrick , SCHLESINGER LAW OFFICES.

John T. Benestad, Plaintiff, represented by Carasusana B. Wall , ZOLL & KRANZ.

Judith A. Shears, Gary F. Shears, Jr. & Bradley Howard, Plaintiffs, represented by Carasusana B. Wall , ZOLL & KRANZ & Jeffrey L. Haberman , SCHLESINGER LAW OFFICES.

Yolanda Wielgopolski & Ken Wielgopolski, Plaintiffs, represented by Bobby J. Bradford , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Daniel N. Gallucci , NASTLAW, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Dianne M. Nast , NASTLAW, Lydia Lucius & Michele S. Burkholder , NASTLAW.

Kristi Lynne Bowman, Svetlana Victor, Daniel J. Victor & Julie Rodriguez, Plaintiffs, represented by Paulina Do Amaral , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN & Wendy R. Fleishman , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN.

Loretta J. Cornutt, Plaintiff, represented by Paul Kiesel , KIESEL & LARSON.

Jennifer Leclaire & Janet White, Plaintiffs, represented by Paige Nicole Boldt , WATTS GUERRA & Ryan L. Thompson , WATTS GUERRA CRAFT.

Terri Enborg, Christopher Enborg, Jacinta Leavitt, Paul Leavitt, Dayna A. Stimers, Valerie Campbell & Jon K. Campbell, Sr., Plaintiffs, represented by Michael A. Cavaliere , KLINE & SPECTER.

Cecilia A. Edson & Steven Edson, Plaintiffs, represented by Anne M. Tarvin , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GOZA, Bradley D. Honnold , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GOZA & Kirk J. Goza , GOZA & HONNOLD.

Sharon Pottier, Plaintiff, represented by Lennie F. Bollinger , WORMINGTON LAW GROUP.

Melissa Bart, Plaintiff, pro se.

Adele Stukas, Plaintiff, pro se.

Richard Martinez, Plaintiff, pro se.

Janna Garvin, Plaintiff, represented by Elizabeth Booth , LITTLEPAGE BOOTH, Natasha Ardoin , LITTLEPAGE BOOTH, Rainey Booth , LITTLEPAGE BOOTH, pro hac vice, T. Matthew Leckman , LECKMAN LAW & Zoe Littlepage , LITTLEPAGE BOOTH LECKMAN, pro hac vice.

Michael David Garvin, Plaintiff, pro se.

Michael David Garvin, Plaintiff, represented by Elizabeth Booth , LITTLEPAGE BOOTH, pro hac vice, T. Matthew Leckman , LECKMAN LAW & Zoe Littlepage , LITTLEPAGE BOOTH LECKMAN, pro hac vice.

Katherine Bowen-North & Lillian M. Hayes, Plaintiffs, represented by Suzanne Heald Kaplan , SLACK & DAVIS.

Laura E. Martin, Plaintiff, pro se.

Mitchell L. Martin, Plaintiff, pro se.

Norma Viola, Evangelina Jimenez, Thomas Jimenez, Peggy J. Gipson, Kathleen Krause, Roland Krause, Mary E. Akins, Kenneth Akins & Linda V. Gibson, Plaintiffs, represented by Erin M. Wood , WATERS & KRAUS, Leslie C. MacLean , WATERS & KRAUS & Rachel A. Gross , WATERS & KRAUS.

Susan Hoss, Neal Hoss, Crystal S. Vincent, Randy J. Vincent, Cheryl M. Heide, Carrie Ellen Deforest, Dwight Deforest & Cathy Pelican, Plaintiffs, represented by Daniel J. Carr , PEIFFER ROSCA ABDULLAH & CARR.

Camille Smith, Plaintiff, represented by Adam Daniel Peavy , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, pro hac vice, Deborah Kay Levy , BAILEY PERRIN BAILEY, Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Harris Junell , BAILEY PERRIN BAILEY, Michael A. Stratton , STRATTON FAXON TRIAL LAWYERS & Adam Daniel Peavy , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

James Smith, Plaintiff, represented by Corrie James Schuler , MERKEL & COCKE, pro hac vice, Deborah Kay Levy , BAILEY PERRIN BAILEY, Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Harris Junell , BAILEY PERRIN BAILEY, Michael A. Stratton , STRATTON FAXON TRIAL LAWYERS & Adam Daniel Peavy , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Juanita Barton, Plaintiff, represented by Annie McAdams , ANNIE MCADAMS, Charles E. Soechting, Jr. , SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER, Jay Eric Stuemke , SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER & Matthew Scott Parmet , PARMET.

James Scott Dean, Robin Mason & James Mason, Plaintiffs, represented by Jennifer L. Lawrence , THE LAWRENCE FIRM, Adam Daniel Peavy , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Annie McAdams , ANNIE MCADAMS & Charles E. Soechting, Jr. , SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER.

Brenda Peabody, Juanita Wells, Norma Motley, Herbert Hudson, Roseann Morris, Cheryl Lindenmuth & Henry Lindenmuth, Plaintiffs, represented by John W. Pate , HEYGOOD ORR & PEARSON & John T. Boundas , WILLIAMS KHERKHER HART BOUNDAS.

Bonnie Marie Maschler, Plaintiff, represented by Paul L. Sadler , CARABIN & SHAW.

Charles Maschler, Debbie Kay Mitchell, Laurie M. Imhoff, Robert Imhoff, Rita Jackson, Nelda Christine Stebbins, Debra Gutierrez, Raymond Gutierrez, Terri D. Swavely & Rafaela Davila, Plaintiffs, represented by Thom E. Smith , AUDET & PARTNERS.

Elizabeth Burgin, member case assigned to Judge Robert C. Chambers, Plaintiff, represented by Bruce Garrett Anderson , ANDERSON & VAUGHN.

Lewis Burgin, member case assigned to Judge Robert C. Chambers, Plaintiff, represented by Lance M. Sears , SEARS & SWANSON.

Mary Schillachi, Plaintiff, represented by Brian A. Goldstein , CELLINO & BARNES.

Gwen Jackson, Eloise Martinez, Tina Marie Blake, Dorothy Gevers, Viola Cavazos, Renae Huntsinger, Mary Ann Ward, Rosalia Aveni, Sharon Bunch, Joanne Hockenbroch, Billie R. Milam, Vicki Jennings, Allison Godin & Jennifer Call, Plaintiffs, represented by Tamara L. Banno , FREESE & GOSS & Tim K. Goss , FREESE & GOSS.

Carmen A. Vaughan, Plaintiff, represented by Larry D. Helvey , LARRY HELVEY LAW FIRM.

Dawn Henderson, Plaintiff, pro se.

Dawn Henderson, Charles Gordon Henderson, Victoria King, Greg King, Angela Baisden, Carlos Baisden, Christine K. Diaz & Melissa Nava, Plaintiffs, represented by Robert Binstock , REICH & BINSTOCK.

Charles Gordon Henderson, Plaintiff, pro se.

Ashlea DeMasi, Betty Ann Price & Vincent Price, Plaintiffs, represented by Marc E. Lipton , LIPTON LAW CENTER & John M. Black , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK.

Tracy Placido, Plaintiff, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Jeffrey A. Bowersox , BOWERSOX LAW FIRM & Patty Ann Trantham , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ.

Arlena Haynie, Plaintiff, represented by Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Patricia L. Campbell , THE POTTS LAW FIRM & Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM.

Karen Hightower-Duffy, Plaintiff, represented by Sarah R. London , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN, Tamara L. Banno , FREESE & GOSS, Tim K. Goss , FREESE & GOSS & Wendy R. Fleishman , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN.

Angela M. Cameron, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph John Perez , SHUTTLEWORTH RULOFF SWAIN HADDAD & MORECOCK & Cecilia Han , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN.

Keith Cameron, Plaintiff, represented by David W. Stewart , STEWART & STEWART & Cecilia Han , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN.

Amy Nystrom, Sharon Grundel, Alan Grundel, Cheryl Martin, Tami Vasquez, Paula Brown, James Brown, Hortencia Vigil, Pablo Vigil, Linda Epstein-Clark, Joseph Peter Clark, Kathy Reyna, Victor Reyna, Jr., Dennis Solano, Josie Solano, Karen Henderson, Willie Henderson, Jennifer Haymart, Jess Haymart, Dorothy Pauline Tidler, Max Tidler, Madelien Miller, George Miller, Nadine Frietze & Lyndon Frietze, Plaintiffs, represented by Alan S. Lazar , MARLIN & SALTZMAN, Christina A. Humphrey , MARLIN & SALTZMAN, Kiley L. Grombacher , MARLIN & SALTZMAN & Marcus J. Bradley , MARLIN & SALTZMAN.

Kelly Wingard & Kenneth Wingard, Plaintiffs, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Amy Eskin , LEVIN SIMES ABRAMS.

Victoria King, Plaintiff, pro se.

Greg King, Plaintiff, pro se.

Angela Baisden, Plaintiff, pro se.

Carlos Baisden, Plaintiff, pro se.

Amber Bowman, Christopher Michaels, Administrator and Personal Representative of the Estate of, Lori Gibson, William Lee Gibson & Yvette Petty, Plaintiffs, represented by John J. Driscoll , THE DRISCOLL FIRM.

Crystal Nixon, Derek Nixon & Carol Rowley, Plaintiffs, represented by Donald H. Kidd , PERDUE & KIDD & Jim M. Perdue, Jr. , PERDUE KIDD & VICKERY.

Jeanne Meindertsma & Bruce Meindertsma, Plaintiffs, represented by Andrew N. Faes , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Jason R. Fraxedas , THE MAHER LAW FIRM, Mark E. Burton, Jr. , HERSH & HERSH, pro hac vice, Rachel Beth Abrams , LEVIN SIMES, pro hac vice, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & William M. Audet , AUDET & PARTNERS.

Freda Millette & Robert Millette, Sr., Plaintiffs, represented by Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE & Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE.

Linda Moustapha, Mohamed Moustapha, Jennifer S. Coleman & Jerry Coleman, Plaintiffs, represented by Rachel Beth Abrams , LEVIN SIMES, pro hac vice.

Serap Shorter, Jerry Shorter, Deborah Satterfield & Theodore Satterfield, Plaintiffs, represented by Amanda Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Karen Barth Menzies , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Mark P. Robinson, Jr. , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Shannon Lukei , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS & Willard J. Moody, Jr. , THE MOODY LAW FIRM.

Mary Therese Melsheimer, Steve Melsheimer, Carolyn Beach & Wayne Beach, Plaintiffs, represented by James G. Onder , ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON & Mark R. Niemeyer , ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON.

Cassandra Akins, Carol Taylor, Brenda Gill, Gloria Stauber & Stephanie Steelman, Plaintiffs, represented by Andrew J. Cross , CAREY DANIS & LOWE, pro hac vice, Jeffrey J. Lowe , CAREY DANIS & LOWE & Sarah Shoemake Doles , CARY DANIS & LOWE.

Terri Freeman & Earl Freeman, Plaintiffs, represented by Alex Barlow , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK, Bill Robins, III , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK & Fred A. Truglio , FRED A. TRUGLIO & ASSOCIATES.

Susan Wasik, Plaintiff, represented by James V. Sabatini , SABATINI & ASSOCIATES.

Henry Wasik, Plaintiff, represented by Michael A. D'Isola , THE LAW OFFICES OF JEFFREY S. GLASSMAN.

Kari Poole, Plaintiff, represented by Andrew J. Feldman , FLINT LAW FIRM, Jacob Alex Flint , FLINT LAW FIRM & Sara E. Coopwood , FLINT LAW FIRM.

Ted Poole, Carolyn Wagers, Susan Kelly, Timothy Kelly, Doris Ullendorff, Barbara Weinkam, Catherine Middleton & Nancy Zemanovic, Plaintiffs, represented by Erin C. Murphy , LEE MURPHY LAW FIRM, Jacob Alex Flint , FLINT LAW FIRM & Sara E. Coopwood , FLINT LAW FIRM.

Brenda Pitts, Plaintiff, represented by Jon B. Burmeister , MOORE & LANDREY.

Mary Smith, Plaintiff, represented by Rachel Beth Abrams , LEVIN SIMES, Laura J. Baughman , BARON & BUDD, Jimmy W. Bilbo , BILBO LAW OFFICE, John A. Corr , CORDISCO CORR, Martin Paul Schrama , STARK & STARK, Stefanie Colella-Walsh , STARK & STARK & Joseph A. Ermeti , OFFICE OF JOSEPH A. ERMETI.

J. Harold Smith, Reggenia Ashley & Michael Ashley, Plaintiffs, represented by Rachel Beth Abrams , LEVIN SIMES, Laura J. Baughman , BARON & BUDD & Jimmy W. Bilbo , BILBO LAW OFFICE.

Nancy Haines, Plaintiff, represented by Richard W. Schulte , WRIGHT & SCHULTE & Stephen Dennis Behnke , WRIGHT & SCHULTE.

Bridgette Marie Fitzgerald, Grace M. Flora-Stinnett, Mae Bell Storey, Juanita June Hattenstein, Becky Marie Shih, Janette A. Bruns, Linda D. Gilbert, Linda L. Brady, Juanita R. Rogers, Deborah Kay Watts, Paula H. Peeler & Josephine M. Deatherage, Plaintiffs, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Erin K. Copeland , FIBICH LEEBRON COPELAND BRIGGS JOSEPHSON, J. Mark Kell , KELL LAMPIN, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Joseph J. Zonies , ZONIES LAW, Kenneth T. Fibich , FIBICH LEEBRON COPELAND BRIGGS JOSEPHSON, Lisa L. Causey , SALIM-BEASLEY, Patty Ann Trantham , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Robert L. Salim , LAW OFFICES OF ROBERT L. SALIM & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Debra Moe & Gregory Moe, Plaintiffs, represented by Nathan C. VanDerVeer , FARRIS RILEY & PITT, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Lucinda S. Septer, Dwayne Field, Ella Field, Barbara Lemonds, Raquel Lopez, Sammy Arenas, Earnestine Beasley, Shirley Charles, Jack J. Charles, Beatriz Adams, Oliver B. Adams, Kerry McKeever, Jarrod McKeever, Scheryl Barman, Martha G. Plascencia, Ramiro Plascencia, Shirley Rackley & Carl Edward Rackley, Plaintiffs, represented by Deborah Kay Levy , BAILEY PERRIN BAILEY, Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Harris Junell , BAILEY PERRIN BAILEY & Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM.

Tamara J. Townsend, Plaintiff, represented by Bobby J. Bradford , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & S. Mary Liu , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ.

Lanell Munsee & Blain Munsee, Plaintiffs, represented by James Robert Hail , DOYLE LOWTHER & William J. Doyle, II , DOYLE LOWTHER.

Sandra Howerton, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Karen Barth Menzies , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS & Mark P. Robinson, Jr. , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS.

Pamela Bohannon, Plaintiff, pro se.

James Bohannon, Plaintiff, pro se.

Judith Ross, Lewis Ross, Deborah G. Batson, Debra Westerfield, Donna Parks & Delbert Parks, Plaintiffs, represented by Christopher W. Cantrell , DOYLE LOWTHER & William J. Doyle, II , DOYLE LOWTHER.

Pamela Lynch, Plaintiff, represented by Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Paul Keisel , KEISEL & LARSON.

Melissa Roberts, Plaintiff, represented by Erin C. Murphy , LEE MURPHY LAW FIRM, Jacob Alex Flint , FLINT LAW FIRM & Lawrence King Holcomb , FLINT LAW FIRM.

Debbie Dee Leinen-Cruz, Ignacio L. Cruz & Pamela Maddox, Plaintiffs, represented by A. Craig Eiland , THE LAW OFFICES OF A. CRAIG EILAND & Bret Daniel Stanley , THE LAW OFFICES OF A. CRAIG EILAND.

Claudia Medlock, Plaintiff, represented by Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE & Fred Thompson, III , MOTLEY RICE.

Tamella L. Dukek & Wade Dukek, Plaintiffs, represented by Kenneth L. Sales , BUBALO GOODE SALES & CRONEN.

Eula Jane Clark Oxendine, Plaintiff, represented by Jessica Locklear , LOCKLEAR & CLARK.

Michael Kenneth Oxendine, Plaintiff, pro se.

Elizabeth Louise Damato & Michael Damato, Plaintiffs, represented by Matthew J. Skikos , SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, Melissa Erin Mielke , SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, Philip Bohrer , BOHRER LAW FIRM & Steven James Skikos , SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH.

LaDonna Joanne Hansen, Plaintiff, represented by Clinton Casperson , TRACEY & FOX, Sean Patrick Tracey , TRACEY & FOX LAW FIRM & Shawn P. Fox , TRACEY & FOX LAW FIRM.

Barbara Heinrich, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew R. Vannah , VANNAH & VANNAH, Tamara L. Banno , FREESE & GOSS & Tim K. Goss , FREESE & GOSS.

Gregory Heinrich, Plaintiff, represented by John J. Driscoll , THE DRISCOLL FIRM, Tamara L. Banno , FREESE & GOSS & Tim K. Goss , FREESE & GOSS.

Tanya M. Galloway, Plaintiff, pro se.

Maricela Mendoza, Receiver, pro se.

Arnoldo Mendoza, Jr., Plaintiff, pro se.

Laura Jepperson, Plaintiff, represented by Justin William Fishback , SHAW COWART & Richard L. Fewell, Jr. , Office Location for Richard L. Fewell, Jr., APLC.

Linda Cheek, Barbara Carrier, Michelle Zamora, Hilda Campbell & John Campbell, Plaintiffs, represented by Michael J. Miller , THE MILLER FIRM.

Tiffany Diane Cartner & Joshua Harold Cartner, Plaintiffs, represented by Paulina Do Amaral , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN, Wendy R. Fleishman , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN & Jeffrey G. Blackwell , BLACKWELL LAW FIRM.

Kimberly Howard, Plaintiff, represented by Carasusana B. Wall , ZOLL & KRANZ, Jeffrey L. Haberman , SCHLESINGER LAW OFFICES & Peter Mullenix , FRIEDMAN RUBIN.

Kathleen McGee, Plaintiff, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & Denise A. Vinet .

Frank Gipson, Plaintiff, represented by Leslie C. MacLean , WATERS & KRAUS & Rachel A. Gross , WATERS & KRAUS.

Jena M. Delk & Michael L. Delk, Plaintiffs, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Patty Ann Trantham , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & S. Mary Liu , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ.

Debra L. Williams & David R. Williams, Plaintiffs, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & Erin K. Copeland , FIBICH LEEBRON COPELAND BRIGGS JOSEPHSON.

Diana Roberts, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin A. Bertram , BERTRAM & GRAFF, Jennifer J. Lajoie , BARR & ASSOCIATES, J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Avram Josef Blair , MEYER BLAIR, Mark C. Sparks , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Amanda Heather Kent , GIRARDI KEESE, pro hac vice & Noah M. Wexler , ARNOLD & ITKIN.

Maureen Lyons, Judy Rodriguez, Jennifer Taylor & Cleo Zyph, Plaintiffs, represented by Lina B. Melidonian , KABATECK BROWN KELLNER & Mark Alan Milstein , MILSTEIN ADELMAN.

Patricia England, Royce England, Kathryn Quashnock, James Quashnock, Julie Letourneau, Sandra Lord, Jimmy Lord, Mariellen Dewald, Karina Mares, Jose Vega, Maria Zapata, Lorenza Gutierrez, Blanca Marmolejo, Alfredo Marmolejo, Cynthia McBride, Theresa McGuffie, Joseph McGuffie, Rebecca Vera, Laura Montero, Rita Macknis, Michael Macknis, Esperanza Cobos, Elijeo Cobos, Stacey Dempsey, Alicia Cisneros & Herberto Cisneros, Plaintiffs, represented by Paul Elliott Bueker , LAW OFFICES OF FRED TROMBERG.

Roxane Klinefelter & Zeda Rebecca Champ, Plaintiffs, represented by Jennifer J. Lajoie , BARR & ASSOCIATES, J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Avram Josef Blair , MEYER BLAIR, Mark C. Sparks , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM & Noah M. Wexler , ARNOLD & ITKIN.

Nebra Simpson, Dana Thibodeaux-Billodeaux, Criag Billodeaux, Crystal Thomas & Joan Tily, Plaintiffs, represented by Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice, Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Michael L. Armitage , WATERS KRAUS & PAUL.

Jane Shrive, Plaintiff, represented by Kila Briget Baldwin , KLINE & SPECTER, Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice, Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Thomas R. Kline , KLINE & SPECTER.

Dennis Shrive, Plaintiff, represented by Thomas V. Girardi , GIRARDI KEESE, Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice, Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Thomas R. Kline , KLINE & SPECTER.

Tamara Searl, Plaintiff, represented by Braden R. Lepisto , KLINE & SPECTER, Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice, Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Thomas R. Kline , KLINE & SPECTER.

Jane Walton & Patricia Murphy, Plaintiffs, represented by Benjamin A. Bertram , BERTRAM & GRAFF, James J. Waldenberger , KLINE & SPECTER, J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Avram Josef Blair , MEYER BLAIR, Mark C. Sparks , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Amanda Heather Kent , GIRARDI KEESE, pro hac vice & Noah M. Wexler , ARNOLD & ITKIN.

Annamarie Bartolome, Plaintiff, represented by Dylan Franklin Pollard , POLLARD BAILEY & David Andrew List , CLARK PERDUE & LIST.

Cheryl Annette Bacon, Jamie Michelle Howard, Lisa Ann Franklin, Lina Reiss & Martin Reiss, Plaintiffs, represented by Howard L. Nations , THE NATIONS LAW FIRM & Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice.

Annette Sutphin, Plaintiff, represented by Micajah D. Boatright , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Ross D. Plont , GRUEL MILLS NIMS & PYLMAN, Colin Burke , KLINE & SPECTER, Elia A. Robertson , KLINE & SPECTER, Thomas V. Girardi , GIRARDI KEESE, Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice, Maura E. Scanlon , THE SCANLON GROUP CO. & Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice.

Kimberly Fromm Foster & Keith Foster, Plaintiffs, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Vanessa H. Gross , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Diane Michelle Bailey, Plaintiff, represented by Jack T. Hyde , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Gary S. Grynkewich , GRYNKEWICH LAW OFFICES & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Billie Jo Aschmeller, Plaintiff, represented by J. Gerard Stranch, IV , BRANSTETTER STRANCH & JENNINGS, pro hac vice & William J. Doyle, II , DOYLE LOWTHER.

Collette Theresa LoCoco, Plaintiff, represented by Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Howard L. Nations , THE NATIONS LAW FIRM, Lauren Kaplan , WEXLER WALLACE & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Michael J. LoCoco, Plaintiff, represented by Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Howard L. Nations , THE NATIONS LAW FIRM & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Gail Jilek, Jacqueline Young, Margaret Reeves & Billie Winstead, Plaintiffs, represented by Daryl J. Douglas , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & McDonald S. Worley , MCDONALD WORLEY.

Jill S. Brand, Plaintiff, pro se.

Danna A. Bauer & Gregory Thomas Bauer, Plaintiffs, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Kathryn Grace Hooten , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Lezzlie Elizabeth Hornsby , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & William Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Michelle A. Geery, Plaintiff, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & Patty Ann Trantham , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ.

Sheryl Rodriguez, Plaintiff, pro se.

Kim Rodriguez, Plaintiff, pro se.

Teresa Miller, Plaintiff, represented by Douglas Robert Plymale , PLYMALE LAW FIRM & James R. Dugan, II , THE DUGAN LAW FIRM.

Yvonne Coca, Plaintiff, pro se.

Melynda Fitt, Plaintiff, represented by Robert E. Price , LEVIN PAPANTONIO THOMAS MITCHELL RAFFERTY & PROCTOR.

Virginia Green & Bruce Green, Plaintiffs, represented by C. Andrew Childers , CHILDERS SCHLUETER & SMITH & Michael Brandon Smith , CHILDERS SCHLUETER & SMITH.

Linda Powers, Plaintiff, represented by Justinian Lane , JUSTINIAN.

Pollyanna Montgomery, Plaintiff, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & S. Mary Liu , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ.

Wilma Collins, Plaintiff, represented by Dan Charles Bolton , KELLER FISHBACK & JACKSON & Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice.

Dora Sloan, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew John Morrison , HARRISON DAVIS STEAKLEY MORRISON, Preston J. Dugas, III , PARKER MCDONALD & Zollie C. Steakley , HARRISON DAVIS STEAKLEY MORRISON.

Alize Rocha, Plaintiff, represented by Alan S. Lazar , MARLIN & SALTZMAN, Christina A. Humphrey , MARLIN & SALTZMAN, Karen I. Gold , MARLIN & SALTZMAN, Kiley L. Grombacher , MARLIN & SALTZMAN & Marcus J. Bradley , MARLIN & SALTZMAN.

Theresa J. Hough, Gwendolyn Cartier & Richard Cartier, Plaintiffs, represented by Jason J. Thompson , SOMMERS SCHWARTZ.

Nancy E. Lewis, Leroy Lewis & Deborah Ann Frisbie, Plaintiffs, represented by Maricela Cavazos , PHIPPS CAVAZOS & Martin J. Phipps , PHIPPS CAVAZOS.

Brenda J. Davis, Plaintiff, represented by Andrew Welker , WEXLER WALLACE, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Anna Natalie Rol , BARON & BUDD, Michelle Perkovic , WEXLER WALLACE, Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE & William P. Ronan, III , THE RONAN LAW FIRM.

Tonya Redden, Donald Redden, Sandra A. Partee, Heather N. Poole & Kevin B. Poole, Sr., Plaintiffs, represented by George Tharin Williamson , FARR FARR EMERICH HACKETT & CARR & Steven Anthony Martino , TAYLOR MARTINO.

Rebecca Burton, Plaintiff, represented by David C. DeGreeff , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Jeffrey Burton, Plaintiff, represented by Andrew Welker , WEXLER WALLACE, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Kimberly Borbely & Brian Borbely, Plaintiffs, represented by Norwood S. Wilner , THE WILNER FIRM, pro hac vice & Wesley Chadwick Cook , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES.

Carol S. Shook & Darrell L. Shook, Plaintiffs, represented by Amy E. Garrett , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY.

Joyce Mayton Cramer, Plaintiff, represented by Anne M. Tarvin , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GOZA & Kirk J. Goza , GOZA & HONNOLD.

Kandy Sue Parkinson, Plaintiff, represented by Tobin Dean Ellis , AGNEW BRUSAVICH.

Rosemary Gordon, Kimberly Moore, Kerri Meyers, Eric Meyers, Martha Bailey, Donald Bailey, Margie Hurley, Mark Hurley, Karen Grieninger & Terry Grieninger, Plaintiffs, represented by Laura J. Baughman , BARON & BUDD & John B. Noble , MICHAEL HINGLE & ASSOCIATES.

Terressa Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Jeremy S. McKenzie , KARSMAN MCKENZIE & HART & Ronald Paul Hart, III , KARSMAN MCKENZIE & HART.

Russell Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Charles Anthony Frankovic , PRIBANIC & PRIBANIC & Kevin P. O'Connor, Jr. , SWARTZ & SWARTZ.

Clara Cotton, Zack Cotton, Jeanine Porogi, John Porogi, Phyllis K. Hall & Patrick Hall, Plaintiffs, represented by Douglas D. Small , FOLEY & SMALL.

Elizabeth Cooper, Plaintiff, represented by Gregory J. Pals , THE DRISCOLL FIRM & Daniel J. McGlynn , MCGLYNN GLISSON & MOUTON.

Roberta V. Iversen, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Norwood S. Wilner , THE WILNER FIRM, pro hac vice & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Kimberly C. Aldridge & Larry T. Aldridge, Plaintiffs, represented by Lauren Kaplan , WEXLER WALLACE.

Rebecca D. Wenger, Plaintiff, represented by Kevin P. Sullivan , SALSBURY SULLIVAN & Stuart Marshall Salsbury , SALSBURY SULLIVAN.

Eric Wenger & Paula M. Donalds, Plaintiffs, represented by Cathryn Jaime Schexnaider , MOSTYN LAW & Justin David Burrow , MOSTYN LAW.

Lesley Cooper, Plaintiff, represented by James G. Onder , ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON & Michael Joseph Quillin , ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON.

Jean Warner, Plaintiff, represented by Jason W. Whitley , NOVITZKE GUST SEMPF WHITLEY & BERGMANIS.

Steven Warner, Plaintiff, represented by David Michael Langevin , MCSWEENEY LANGEVIN.

Eileen Kress, Plaintiff, represented by Rachel Beth Abrams , LEVIN SIMES, Laura J. Baughman , BARON & BUDD & Jimmy W. Bilbo , BILBO LAW OFFICE.

Mary L. Lawler & James Lawler, Plaintiffs, represented by Jennifer Ann Moore , GROSSMAN & MOORE.

Yvonne Roman & Daniel Roman, Plaintiffs, represented by Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice, Matthew J. Skikos , SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, Melissa Erin Mielke , SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH, Philip Bohrer , BOHRER LAW FIRM & Steven James Skikos , SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH.

Wanda L. Injasoulian, Plaintiff, represented by John C. Thornton, III , ANDREWS & THORNTON & Karren Schaeffer , ANDREWS & THORNTON.

Diana St. Laurent, Robin Maring, Phillip Maring, Angelika Streck & Thomas Streck, Plaintiffs, represented by Mark S. Gervelis , GERVELIS LAW FIRM.

Laura Curtin, Plaintiff, represented by Jennifer J. Lajoie , BARR & ASSOCIATES, J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, John Benjamin Bireley , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Avram Josef Blair , MEYER BLAIR, Noah M. Wexler , ARNOLD & ITKIN & Roland Christensen , ARNOLD & ITKIN.

Charles Curtin, Plaintiff, represented by Jennifer J. Lajoie , BARR & ASSOCIATES, J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Rayna Elizabeth Kessler , LOPEZ MCHUGH, Avram Josef Blair , MEYER BLAIR, Noah M. Wexler , ARNOLD & ITKIN & Margaret S. Weiss , LAW OFFICES OF JEFFREY S. GLASSMAN.

Cheryl Berden & Mark Berden, Plaintiffs, represented by James Robert Hail , DOYLE LOWTHER, John Lowther , DOYLE LOWTHER & William J. Doyle, II , DOYLE LOWTHER.

Kimberley Anne Davis, Plaintiff, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & Matthew D. Powell , MATT LAW.

Irene M. Ferguson, Plaintiff, represented by Gail A. Balser , PI LAW GROUP.

Ward A. Ferguson, Plaintiff, pro se.

Cheryl Sorrell-Knight, Plaintiff, represented by Jennifer J. Lajoie , BARR & ASSOCIATES, J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Avram Josef Blair , MEYER BLAIR & Noah M. Wexler , ARNOLD & ITKIN.

Tina Burris, Plaintiff, represented by Greg A. Vigna , Laura J. Baughman , BARON & BUDD & Sarah Holt Sublett , FOSTER & SEAR.

Cynthia Melhado, Donna Hester, Maria Cavileer, Olga Romero, Rhonda Grimstead, Darlene McQueen, Angela Rodriguez, Carlos Rodriguez, Mike Taylor, Taylor Taylor, Velma G. Thompson-Hampton, Sharon Clark, Davis Clark & Henrietta Phillips, Plaintiffs, represented by Brian David Cook , BAHE COOK CANTLEY & NEFZGER.

Nada Louise Ciriello & Amy Schulz, Plaintiffs, represented by Brett L. Rosenthal , MCNULTY LAW FIRM.

Carla Poling, Plaintiff, represented by David Andrew List , CLARK PERDUE & LIST.

Suzanne Nies & Shellie Anne Nies, Plaintiffs, represented by Jacob Alex Flint , FLINT LAW FIRM.

Marbeth Wilder, Plaintiff, represented by Diane K. Watkins , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Joan D. Toomey , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Barbara J. Hejduk, Plaintiff, represented by Brett Ashley Hastings , LAW OFFICES OF BRETT HASTINGS & Zakariah Johnson .

Charles A. Hejduk, Plaintiff, represented by John Arthur Bahe, Jr. , BAHE COOK CANTLEY & NEFZGER & Brooke F. Cohen , REYES BROWNE REILLEY.

Amanda C. Grady, Plaintiff, represented by James F. Green , ASHCRAFT & GEREL, Michelle A. Parfitt , ASHCRAFT & GEREL & Stephanie Gardner , ASHCRAFT & GEREL.

James M. Grady, Plaintiff, represented by James F. Green , ASHCRAFT & GEREL, Michelle A. Parfitt , ASHCRAFT & GEREL & Zakariah Johnson .

Lois D. Mullins, Plaintiff, pro se.

Debra Pickett, John F. Pickett, Jr., Dammae Dawn Williams, Kenneth Williams, Sally Virginia Baldwin & Laura Rodriguez, Plaintiffs, represented by Richard J. Plezia , RICHARD J. PLEZIA & ASSOCIATES.

Joyce Spencer, Donna Long, Ernest Long, Dana D. Mills & Rocky Mills, Plaintiffs, represented by Joseph J. Zonies , ZONIES LAW.

Tami L. Fauth, Plaintiff, represented by B. T. Dunken, Jr. , DUNKEN LAW GROUP.

Anne Wegmann, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron K. Dickey , FLINT LAW FIRM, Erin C. Murphy , LEE MURPHY LAW FIRM, Jacob Alex Flint , FLINT LAW FIRM & Lisa Gentleman Hogg , FLINT LAW FIRM.

Deborah M. Stephen, Bret E. Stephen, Pearle Larsen, Evelyn Jeannette Poff, Ethel Marrufo & Barbara Paris, Plaintiffs, represented by David Paul Matthews , MATTHEWS & ASSOCIATES, Julie L. Rhoades , MATTHEWS & ASSOCIATES, Kevin L. Edwards , FREESE & GOSS, Peter De La Cerda , EDWARDS & DE LA CERDA, Kumar S. Raja , PHILLIPS ERAKAT, Tamara L. Banno , FREESE & GOSS & Tim K. Goss , FREESE & GOSS.

Mary Sparks, Plaintiff, represented by Kumar S. Raja , PHILLIPS ERAKAT & Tim K. Goss , FREESE & GOSS.

Michelle Grover, Robert Grover, Barbara Manes, Richard Manes, Joan Campbell, Richard T. Campbell, Tamara Schulte, Timothy Schulte, Cynthia Russell, Jeffery Russell, Debra Metcalf, Laurie Gerbino, Robert Gerbino, Marlene Staigmiller, Cynthia Dicomo-Wilson, John Kelly Wilson, Alisha (Perez) Lauzon Suarez, Carlos Suarez, Valera Washburn, Carlton Washburn, Charlene Hunt, Kenneth Hunt, W/H, Shirley McLaughlin, Kristine Pearson, Brad Pearson, Crystal Cable, James Cable, W/H, Peggy Dunn, Patricia Wallin, Crystal Shannon, Robin Buttino, Luigi Buttino, Peggy A. Davis, Norma Kelley, Dennis Kelley, w/h, Pamela Peterson, David Peterson, W/H, Mary Elayne Eldreth, Bobby Eldreth, Donna Lee Spadafore, Ray Spadafore & Rosemary Toliver, Plaintiffs, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice.

Janet Burgoyne & Danny Burgoyne, Plaintiffs, represented by Gregory Neil McEwen , MCEWEN LAW FIRM, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Victoria Slaikeu & Kevin Slaikeu, Plaintiffs, represented by Yvonne M. Flaherty , LOCKRIDGE GRINDAL NAUEN.

Norma C. Smith, Joni Hass, Steven Hass, Evelyn Renee Sadler, Samuel Sadler, Patricia Hebert, Carol Lynn Pike, Darrell Pike, Sara Campos, Laurent Degrakovac & Ronna Moore, Plaintiffs, represented by Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice.

Ann Clark, Sondra Hardie, Trina Hoelscher, Lola Korzinski, Sharon Mershon & Elynda Valle, Plaintiffs, represented by Andrew J. Cross , CAREY DANIS & LOWE, pro hac vice, Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Jeffrey J. Lowe , CAREY DANIS & LOWE, John J. Carey , CAREY DANIS & LOWE, David J. Lumber , GUERRA LAW GROUP, Sarah Shoemake Doles , CARY DANIS & LOWE, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & William Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Jennifer Sellers, Plaintiff, pro se.

Jennifer Sellers, Jason Sellers & Cheryl Dombroski, Plaintiffs, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice, Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice, Michael L. Armitage , WATERS KRAUS & PAUL & Thomas R. Kline , KLINE & SPECTER.

Jason Sellers, Plaintiff, pro se.

Evelyn Bunch, Plaintiff, represented by Joshua Rubenstein , SCHEUERMANN & JONES & Roger Alan Johnson , JOHNSON VORHEES & MARTUCCI.

Denise Pitlyk, Plaintiff, represented by Brandon D. Henry , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

William Pitlyk & Barbara Hunt, Plaintiffs, represented by Theresa M. Walsh , BROWN CHIARI, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Teena Henson, Plaintiff, pro se.

Sally Gueret-Negash & Cynthia M. Heffelfinger, Plaintiffs, represented by Elia A. Robertson , KLINE & SPECTER, Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice.

Sheila Mongeon, Cynthia Meltsch & John Meltsch, Plaintiffs, represented by Micajah D. Boatright , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice.

Juanita Ratliff, Plaintiff, represented by Andrew N. Faes , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Sofia Bruera , BLIZZARD & NABERS, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Evelyn Jones, Plaintiff, represented by Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice, Maura E. Scanlon , THE SCANLON GROUP CO. & Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice.

Connie Harms, Plaintiff, represented by James Edward Fitzgerald , THE FITZGERALD LAW FIRM & Vance Tyler Countryman , VANCE T. COUNTRYMAN.

Robert Harms, Plaintiff, represented by Timothy W. Allen & Lindsay A. Lawrence , THE LAWRENCE FIRM.

Stacey Butler & Della Brown, Plaintiffs, represented by R. Brent Cueria , CUERIA LAW FIRM & Anna Blizzard Greenberg , BLIZZARD LAW.

Jeanette Armentor Sanford & Wilmer L. Sanford, Plaintiffs, represented by Bob F. Wright , DOMENGEAUX WRIGHT ROY & EDWARDS, Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Elwood C. Stevens, Jr. , DOMENGEAUX WRIGHT ROY & EDWARDS, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Fred Thompson, III , MOTLEY RICE, James H. Domengeaux , DOMENGEAUX WRIGHT ROY & EDWARDS & Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE.

Nadine Small, Plaintiff, represented by Martin Paul Schrama , STARK & STARK & Stefanie Colella-Walsh , STARK & STARK.

Dana Baldwin, Debra Schrimsher & Lewis Schrimsher, Plaintiffs, represented by Bobby Dale McCallister , BAXTER LAW FIRM & Michael L. Sensor , LUNDY LAW.

Jeanne Sutter & Marilyn B. Meyer, Plaintiffs, represented by Tim K. Goss , FREESE & GOSS.

Mary Dickson, Personal Respresentative of the Estate of Mary Dickson, Plaintiff, pro se.

Amanda McBroom, Robin Battiste & Julie Ann Holm, Plaintiffs, represented by Jacob Plattenberger , TOR HOERMAN LAW.

Elizabeth Julie Mayse & Michael Mayse, Plaintiffs, represented by Virginia Anello , DOUGLAS & LONDON & Adrienne Worsham Kim , ADRIENNE W. KIM.

Kimberly Joan Ellis, Plaintiff, represented by Adam A. Edwards , GREG COLEMAN LAW, Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Troy R. Keller , Troy R. Keller Attorney at Law, Elliott J. Schuchardt , SCHUCHARDT LAW FIRM & Anna Natalie Rol , BARON & BUDD.

William Ray Ellis, Plaintiff, pro se.

William Ray Ellis, Plaintiff, represented by Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Troy R. Keller , Troy R. Keller Attorney at Law, Elliott J. Schuchardt , SCHUCHARDT LAW FIRM & Anna Natalie Rol , BARON & BUDD.

Marlene Ocasio, Plaintiff, represented by Edward Perry Bertram , BARON & BUDD, Laura J. Baughman , BARON & BUDD & John B. Noble , MICHAEL HINGLE & ASSOCIATES.

Marcos Ocasio, Plaintiff, represented by John Patrick Connor , STOBIERSKI & STOBIERSKI, Laura J. Baughman , BARON & BUDD & John B. Noble , MICHAEL HINGLE & ASSOCIATES.

Lisa D. Hudspeth, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel William Clanton , BILBO LAW OFFICE, pro hac vice, Erin M. Wood , WATERS & KRAUS, Gregory A. Anderson , ANDERSON GLENN, James G.T. Nealis, IV , ANDERSON GLENN, Leslie C. MacLean , WATERS & KRAUS & Rachel A. Gross , WATERS & KRAUS.

Marjorie Spradley, Greg Spradley & Elizabeth Woodward, Plaintiffs, represented by Michael S. Kruse , ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON.

Marguerite Rose Navarro & Jesus Navarro, Plaintiffs, represented by Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice, Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Tracie L. Palmer , KLINE & SPECTER.

Frances Jens, Plaintiff, represented by Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice, Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Stephen A. Sheller , SHELLER.

Miranda Ratcliff, Plaintiff, represented by Gail O. Matthews , MATTHEWS SANDERS & SAYES.

Mary Katherine Rambeau, Plaintiff, represented by Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice.

Violet Rappuchi, Mary Albecker, Amparo Libreros, Gloria Ramirez, Martha Lopez, Dorothy Breytenbach, Debbie Brock, Angela Howard, Georgia Rich, Connie Arnette, Linda Kuenzli, Jo Ann Pugh, Bonnie Crawford, Rosa Graciani, Maria Morales, Gwendolyn Knox, Janice Simons, Charlotte Storms, Irene Mikula, Sharon Mullay, Andrea Cogley, Carol Ranson, Amy Moreira, Daria Worley, Cheryl Murphy, Linda Davis, Beatriz Sandoval, Kandyce Singletary, Martha Serres, Debbie Horton, Andrea Robin, Debra Galbraith, Patricia De La Fuentte, Maria White, Tina Samaniego, Cathy Wilson, Gina McSweeney, Joanne Nichols, Kimberly Schuler, Peggy Clawson, Deline Boyse, Janet Meacham, Susann Thrasher, Lorna Marple, Carolanne Potts, Sheree Sweetland, Peggy Dosch, Susan Murzycki, Nancy Esidor, Malissa Brown, Josephine Karstetter, Beryl Velguth, Faith Meyer, Katherine Carnahan, Michelle Marini, Nicole Bettin, Lisa Ramirez, Sally Bissell, Ottie Turnmyre, Tammy Cook, Donna Clark, Alice Revells, Terri Leith, Llewelly Edwards, Mamie Stanga, Betty Jean Hall, Karin Boyer, Rose Ellen Pepsin, Glenda Griffin, Patricia Edenborg-Gorman, Paula Davis, Rosemary Flores, Fran Banach, Rose Maria Dorantes, Patti Della Vecchia, Helen Cannon, Tabatha Treadway, Sarah Haselden & Ella Kiser, Plaintiffs, represented by Amanda Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Daniel S. Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Jeffrey Ray Vaughan , VAUGHAN LAW FIRM, Karen Barth Menzies , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Mark P. Robinson, Jr. , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & Shannon Lukei , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS.

TaQuita Jones, Plaintiff, represented by Andrew David Tharp , BUTLER SNOW, Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Kathryn Grace Hooten , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Lauren Schultz , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Lezzlie Elizabeth Hornsby , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & William Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Robyn Warhol, Plaintiff, represented by Catherine E. Clark , CLARK WERNER & FLYNN.

Marcus Syverson, Plaintiff, represented by Marc E. Lipton , LIPTON LAW CENTER, Andrew N. Faes , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, John M. Black , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Teresa England, Plaintiff, represented by Joshua Dustin Moore , MORGAN & MORGAN, Laura V. Yaeger , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ, Michael Goetz , MORGAN & MORGAN, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Dorothy L. Watts , NICKERSON WATTS.

Kathy Sexton, Garry Sexton, Patricia Mejia & Barbara Reynolds, Plaintiffs, represented by Alan S. Lazar , MARLIN & SALTZMAN & Kiley L. Grombacher , MARLIN & SALTZMAN.

Loretta Brown & Lilyan Hoy, Plaintiffs, represented by Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice, Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & David A. Pearlman , HELMSDALE LAW.

Robyn Freiberger, Plaintiff, pro se.

Robyn Freiberger, Dave Freiberger, Michelle Kuhns, Sheila Schollmeier & Mark Schollmeier, Plaintiffs, represented by Genevieve M. Zimmerman , MESHBESHER & SPENCE, pro hac vice.

Dave Freiberger, Plaintiff, pro se.

Brenda Diane Skinner, Plaintiff, represented by Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Haytham Faraj , THE LAW OFFICES OF HAYTHAM FARAJ & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Chad Skinner, Plaintiff, represented by Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Vincent J. Moccio , BENNEROTTE & ASSOCIATES & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Terry Ann Jones, Plaintiff, pro se.

Laurie Briggs, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel S. Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Karen Barth Menzies , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Mark P. Robinson, Jr. , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Shannon Lukei , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS & Willard J. Moody, Jr. , THE MOODY LAW FIRM.

Carol L. Wherry, Plaintiff, represented by Bradford Ryan Kvinta , LAW OFFICES OF BRADFORD KVINTA & Stephen Neil Foster , FOSTER LAW FIRM.

Jerome Wherry, Plaintiff, represented by Haytham Faraj , THE LAW OFFICES OF HAYTHAM FARAJ & Laura Greene Lumaghi , DOWD & DOWD.

Patty Hunter, Joann Vazquez, Cynthia Kiel, Brandy Wilson, Corena M. McCurry, Suzanne Rickerson, William Rickerson, Mary A. Griffis, Dalena Jimenez, Carolyn Phillips & Marsha A. Woodtke, Plaintiffs, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & William Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Ovis Ellerbee, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Laura V. Yaeger , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ, Michael Goetz , MORGAN & MORGAN, Sarah S. Ruane , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

James Ellerbee, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Laura V. Yaeger , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ, Michael Goetz , MORGAN & MORGAN & Sarah S. Ruane , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Michelle Kuhns, Plaintiff, pro se.

Sheila Schollmeier, Plaintiff, pro se.

Mark Schollmeier, Plaintiff, pro se.

Debra Higginbotham, Plaintiff, represented by Marc D. Grossman , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN & Randi Kassan , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN.

Sarah W. Martz, Plaintiff, represented by Richard Walter Langerman , LAW OFFICE OF RICHARD LANGERMAN.

Sandra Lynette Murrah, Plaintiff, pro se.

Susan Holman, Plaintiff, represented by Brock P. Alvarado , ALVAREZ LAW OFFICE.

Chastity Sexton, Plaintiff, represented by Eric D. Barton , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Joni Hass, Plaintiff, pro se.

Steven Hass, Plaintiff, pro se.

Ann L. Green, Plaintiff, pro se.

Ann L. Green & Mark S. Green, Plaintiffs, represented by Joseph C. Peiffer , PEIFFER ROSCA ABDULLAH & CARR.

Mark S. Green, Plaintiff, pro se.

Mary Ellen Schmitt & Keith J. Schmitt, Plaintiffs, represented by Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE.

Lisa Franklin, Plaintiff, represented by Sarah Holt Sublett , FOSTER & SEAR & Pamela R. McLemore , THE GALLAGHER LAW FIRM.

Deborah Cloutier, Plaintiff, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Kathryn Grace Hooten , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Lezzlie Elizabeth Hornsby , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Shelley Van Natter Hutson , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & William Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Marsha Foster & Alvin A. Jensen, Plaintiffs, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Kathryn Grace Hooten , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & William Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Priscilla Cruz, Marlene Grieff, Lisa M. Sa'u, Bradlee M. Sa'u, Nell Christine Higgs & Michael Higgs, Plaintiffs, represented by Paul J. Molinaro , FRANSEN & MOLINARO.

Gina White, Marian J. Tomich & Rudy Tomich, Plaintiffs, represented by Joseph A. Osborne, Jr. , BABBITT JOHNSON OSBORNE & LE CLAINCHE.

Diane Roberts-Miller & Don Miller, Plaintiffs, represented by Anne M. Tarvin , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GOZA.

Ann Durham & Shelley Layton, Plaintiffs, represented by Edward F. Blizzard , BLIZZARD LAW & Katherine Lindsey Cornell , PULASKI KHERKHER.

Lora Burke, Tricia Hansen & Mitzi Juarez, Plaintiffs, represented by Heather H. Wong , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN.

Barbara Sue Hodge, Plaintiff, represented by Cathy Honaker Morton , KIZER & BLACK.

Edward J. Hodge, Plaintiff, represented by Robert R. Waters , WATERS LAW OFFICE.

Rowena K. Crowe & Robert H. Crowe, Plaintiffs, represented by Andy Dow Birchfield, Jr. , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES, W. Harold Christian, Jr. , CHRISTIAN & DAVIS, P. Leigh O'Dell , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES & Wesley Chadwick Cook , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES.

George Chedick, Plaintiff, represented by Anna Blizzard Greenberg , BLIZZARD LAW.

Aurora Cole, Jaime Reagin & James Richard Reagin, Plaintiffs, represented by Sarah Holt Sublett , FOSTER & SEAR.

Katy Rose, member case assigned to Judge Robert C. Chambers, Plaintiff, pro se.

Katy Rose, member case assigned to Judge Robert C. Chambers & Ronald Rose, member case assigned to Judge Robert C. Chambers, Plaintiffs, represented by Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE & Troy R. Keller , Troy R. Keller Attorney at Law.

Ronald Rose, member case assigned to Judge Robert C. Chambers, Plaintiff, pro se.

Tasha Mobley, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Laura V. Yaeger , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ, Michael Goetz , MORGAN & MORGAN, Kenneth H. Baker , KENNETH H. BAKER & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Douglass Daniels, Plaintiff, represented by Laura V. Yaeger , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ, Michael Goetz , MORGAN & MORGAN, Kenneth H. Baker , KENNETH H. BAKER & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Paulette Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Christopher Jake Balser , ARNOLD & ITKIN, D. Douglas Mena, II , HAUN MENA, Jennifer J. Lajoie , BARR & ASSOCIATES, J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Avram Josef Blair , MEYER BLAIR, Mark C. Sparks , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM & Noah M. Wexler , ARNOLD & ITKIN.

Jeanette Fields, Plaintiff, represented by Katherine Lindsey Cornell , PULASKI KHERKHER & Jeffrey A. Lake , Lake, P.C.

Wendy Lowery & Mary Muniz, Plaintiffs, represented by Alyson Oliver , OLIVER LAW GROUP.

Jayne Aceto & Joseph Aceto, Plaintiffs, represented by Christine V. Clarke , KLINE & SPECTER, Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice, Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Thomas R. Kline , KLINE & SPECTER.

Janice Burchyett, Plaintiff, represented by James G. Onder , ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON & Molly Kathleen Bowen , MOSTYN LAW.

Alisa M. Mathis & Gregg Mathis, Plaintiffs, represented by Jayne Conroy , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, John J. Foley , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY & Trent B. Miracle , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY.

Elda Fitzsimmons, Plaintiff, represented by Marc R. Stanley , STANLEY LAW GROUP & Scott Kitner , STANLEY LAW GROUP.

Donald Fitzsimmons, Plaintiff, represented by Alicia S. Curran , Cheong Denove Rowell & Bennett & John F. Denove , Cheong Denove Rowell and Bennett ALPC.

Brenda Parker & Chris Parker, Plaintiffs, represented by K. Camp Bailey , BAILEY PERRIN BAILEY & T. Scott Allen, Jr. , BAILEY PERRIN BAILEY.

Leslie White, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey L. Haberman , SCHLESINGER LAW OFFICES & Larry P. Boyd , FISHER BOYD BROWN & HUGUENARD.

Marilyn D. Clark & James Lee Clark, Plaintiffs, represented by Ross D. Plont , GRUEL MILLS NIMS & PYLMAN & Howard L. Nations , THE NATIONS LAW FIRM.

Gema Maria Garcia, Plaintiff, represented by Howard L. Nations , THE NATIONS LAW FIRM, Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice, Matthew J. Skikos , SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH & Steven James Skikos , SKIKOS CRAWFORD SKIKOS & JOSEPH.

Sandra Sue Chavis Deese, Plaintiff, represented by Jessica Lynn Norton , LAW OFFICE OF JESSICA NORTON.

Ricky Deese, Plaintiff, represented by Derek T. Braslow , POGUST BRASLOW & MILLROOD.

Heather McFarland, Plaintiff, represented by David Silverman , SCHLESINGER LAW OFFICES & Jeffrey L. Haberman , SCHLESINGER LAW OFFICES.

Mellissia Russell & Greg Russell, Plaintiffs, represented by Erin C. Murphy , LEE MURPHY LAW FIRM, Jacob Alex Flint , FLINT LAW FIRM, Laura V. Yaeger , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ & Sara E. Coopwood , FLINT LAW FIRM.

Rebecca Payne, Plaintiff, represented by Erin C. Murphy , LEE MURPHY LAW FIRM, Arthur A. Hogg , FLINT LAW FIRM, Jacob Alex Flint , FLINT LAW FIRM & Dan Charles Bolton , KELLER FISHBACK & JACKSON.

Diane Ranae Bordewyk & Bruce Bordewyk, Plaintiffs, represented by Michael Lewis Beckman , VILES & BECKMAN.

Elouise Phillips, Peggy White & Kathryn Watts, Plaintiffs, represented by Chad Cameron Lucas , KUHLMAN & LUCAS.

Doris Austin, Plaintiff, represented by Erin C. Murphy , LEE MURPHY LAW FIRM & Jacob Alex Flint , FLINT LAW FIRM.

Karmen Thornton, Plaintiff, represented by Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE, Anna Natalie Rol , BARON & BUDD, Gary S. Grynkewich , GRYNKEWICH LAW OFFICES & Timothy E. Jackson , WEXLER WALLACE.

Julie Hanifl, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Sarah S. Ruane , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

William Hanifl, Plaintiff, represented by Diane K. Watkins , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Sarah S. Ruane , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Dawn M. Albrecht, Plaintiff, represented by Gregory Charles Ward , THE WARD LAW GROUP.

Bonnie Chockley & Jeff Chockley, Plaintiffs, represented by Peyton P. Murphy , MURPHY LAW FIRM.

Vicki Lucas & Donnie Lucas, Plaintiffs, represented by James J. Waldenberger , KLINE & SPECTER, Jennifer J. Lajoie , BARR & ASSOCIATES, J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Avram Josef Blair , MEYER BLAIR, Mark C. Sparks , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM & Noah M. Wexler , ARNOLD & ITKIN.

Cynthia Pineda, Plaintiff, pro se.

Linda Bryce & William J. Bryce, Plaintiffs, represented by Timothy P. Pothin , FAXON LAW GROUP, Erin C. Murphy , LEE MURPHY LAW FIRM & Jacob Alex Flint , FLINT LAW FIRM.

Rebecca Henderson & Winford Henderson, Plaintiffs, represented by Timothy P. Pothin , FAXON LAW GROUP & Jacob Alex Flint , FLINT LAW FIRM.

Donna J. Brum-Wright, Tonya Holland & Janet L. Mann, Plaintiffs, represented by Jennifer J. Lajoie , BARR & ASSOCIATES & Mark C. Sparks , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM.

Peggy Ann Shreve, Plaintiff, pro se.

Lisa Burkhart, Plaintiff, pro se.

Grace Beck & Karen R. Hughes, Plaintiffs, represented by Mike Guajardo , GUAJARDO & MARKS.

Katherine DuBose & Myron DuBose, Plaintiffs, represented by Kirk J. Goza , GOZA & HONNOLD.

Tosha Coffman, Plaintiff, represented by Buffy K. Martines , LAMINACK PIRTLE & MARTINES, Richard N. Laminack , LAMINACK PIRTLE & MARTINES & Thomas W. Pirtle , LAMINACK PIRTLE & MARTINES.

Roberta Fischer, Plaintiff, pro se.

Dawna Mallow, Plaintiff, represented by Laura J. Baughman , BARON & BUDD & Jimmy W. Bilbo , BILBO LAW OFFICE.

Rose Marie Bushway & Charles Bushway, Plaintiffs, represented by Timothy P. Pothin , FAXON LAW GROUP, Jacob Alex Flint , FLINT LAW FIRM & Dan Charles Bolton , KELLER FISHBACK & JACKSON.

Velma Louise Luellen, Plaintiff, pro se.

Katrina Brown, Plaintiff, pro se.

Christal Fisher, Plaintiff, pro se.

Jeremy Fisher, Plaintiff, pro se.

Julie A. Parsons, Plaintiff, pro se.

Terrie Walker, Plaintiff, pro se.

Dawn Tucker, Plaintiff, represented by Bobby J. Bradford , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Lydia Lucius , S. Mary Liu , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & Seth S. Webb , BROWN & CROUPPEN.

Marie Smith, Plaintiff, pro se.

Sonia Kosakowski, Plaintiff, represented by James Kendall Clark , Clark Robb Mason Coulombe & Buschman, Leah Fahey Charbonnet , CLARK ROBB MASON COULOMBE BUSCHMAN & CHARBONNET & Michael Austin Robb , CLARK ROBB MASON COULOMBE BUSCHMAN & CHARBONNET.

Gary Kosakowski, Plaintiff, represented by Nicholas Rocco Farnolo , NAPOLI SHKOLNIK, Cristina Yadira Hernandez , FITTS LAW FIRM & Mary Elizabeth Graham , GRANT & EISENHOFER.

Cheryl Arrington, Plaintiff, represented by Christopher R. LoPalo , NAPOLI SHKOLNIK, Hunter J. Shkolnik , NAPOLI BERN RIPKA SHKOLNIK & ASSOCIATES & Michael Jay Hart , SHER CORWIN WINTERS.

Evelyn Adler, Kristin Lynn Jacobson & Eric Christopher Jacobson, Plaintiffs, represented by Paulina Do Amaral , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN, Sarah R. London , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN & Wendy R. Fleishman , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN.

Deborah Hubbard & Darren Hubbard, Plaintiffs, represented by Ross D. Plont , GRUEL MILLS NIMS & PYLMAN & Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice.

Karen Rockafellow, Plaintiff, represented by Timothy P. Pothin , FAXON LAW GROUP, Erin C. Murphy , LEE MURPHY LAW FIRM, Jacob Alex Flint , FLINT LAW FIRM & Dan Charles Bolton , KELLER FISHBACK & JACKSON.

Ramona Copeland, Plaintiff, pro se.

Judy A Harris, Plaintiff, pro se.

Elizabeth Radun, Plaintiff, pro se.

Velma Butler, Plaintiff, pro se.

Mary McKimmy, Plaintiff, pro se.

Robyn Laughlin, Plaintiff, pro se.

Pauletta Modesitt, Leiann Rothenberger, Teresa Penn, Michelle R. Duncan, Gulfinaz Ekici & Nancy S. Francis, Plaintiffs, represented by John Zgourides , JOHN ZGOURIDES, ATTORNEY AT LAW, Gregory A. Anderson , ANDERSON GLENN & Robert Binstock , REICH & BINSTOCK.

Eneida Lopez, Plaintiff, represented by Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Shawn P. Fox , TRACEY & FOX LAW FIRM.

Tami Kelley, Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth A. Murphy , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH, Melissa A. Merk , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH & Robert Binstock , REICH & BINSTOCK.

Tami Kelley, Plaintiff, pro se.

Patricia Luna, Plaintiff, represented by John Patrick Connor , STOBIERSKI & STOBIERSKI & Robert Binstock , REICH & BINSTOCK.

Karen Kowalik, Plaintiff, pro se.

Patricia Phillips, Wendy D. Blake, Samantha D. Doddato, Sharon B. Gale, Angela L. Hunt & Susan Hicks, Plaintiffs, represented by John Patrick Connor , STOBIERSKI & STOBIERSKI, John Zgourides , JOHN ZGOURIDES, ATTORNEY AT LAW & Robert Binstock , REICH & BINSTOCK.

Jennifer L. Granda, Plaintiff, represented by John Patrick Connor , STOBIERSKI & STOBIERSKI, John Zgourides , JOHN ZGOURIDES, ATTORNEY AT LAW, Laura J. Baughman , BARON & BUDD & Robert Binstock , REICH & BINSTOCK.

Lynne Bloom & Richard Bloom, Plaintiffs, represented by Khaldoun A. Baghdadi , WALKUP MELODIA KELLY & SCHOENBERGER & Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice.

Stacy Westmoreland & Adam Westmoreland, Plaintiffs, represented by Raymond Joseph Kramer , TORHOERMAN LAW & Steven D. Davis , TOR HOERMAN LAW.

Kathleen Crouchet, Plaintiff, pro se.

Courhand A. Crouchet, Plaintiff, pro se.

Maranda Johnson, Plaintiff, pro se.

Brian Johnson, Plaintiff, pro se.

Karen Kight, Plaintiff, pro se.

Deborah Kim, Plaintiff, pro se.

John Kim, Plaintiff, pro se.

Kathryn King, Plaintiff, pro se.

Marjorie Moore, Plaintiff, pro se.

Carolina Ponton, Plaintiff, pro se.

Pamela Sherman, Plaintiff, pro se.

Frank Sherman, Plaintiff, pro se.

Kimberly Schubert, Plaintiff, represented by Raymond Joseph Kramer , TORHOERMAN LAW.

Kitty Kellar, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS & Steven K. Beckett .

Albert Kellar, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS & Aaron G. Durden , DURDEN LAW.

Barbara Bearb, Plaintiff, pro se.

Misty Dawn Long & John Costa, Plaintiffs, represented by Craig L. Cook , THE LAW OFFICES OF CRAIG L. COOK & Keith Michael Kannett , THE LAW OFFICES OF CRAIG L. COOK.

Darren Wayne Long, Plaintiff, represented by Jonathan M. Ashton , GALLON TAKACS BOISSONEAULT& SCHAFFER & Kevin J. Boissoneault , GALLON TAKACS BOISSONEAULT & SCHAFFER.

Margaret Acosta & Rudolph Acosta, Plaintiffs, represented by Andrew N. Faes , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Stephanie Janes, Plaintiff, represented by James J. Waldenberger , KLINE & SPECTER, Jennifer J. Lajoie , BARR & ASSOCIATES & Mark C. Sparks , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM.

Carol Messina, Plaintiff, represented by Andrew Parker Felix , MORGAN & MORGAN, Michael Goetz , MORGAN & MORGAN & Dorothy L. Watts , NICKERSON WATTS.

James Messina, Plaintiff, represented by Michael D. Bell , GALLON TAKACS BOISSONEAULT & SCHAFFER & Michael Goetz , MORGAN & MORGAN.

Betty Wyatt, Plaintiff, represented by Ryan H. Anderson , PARKER MCDONALD & W. Bradley Parker , PARKER MCDONALD.

Lisa M. Robles & Joe Robles, Plaintiffs, represented by Steven Anthony Martino , TAYLOR MARTINO.

Nancy Yelinek, Plaintiff, represented by Jesse A. Drumm , FRIDAY & COX.

Bianca Costa, Plaintiff, represented by Howard S. Grossman , GROSSMAN ATTORNEYS AT LAW & Thomas Anthony Tarro, III , TARRO & MAROTTI LAW FIRM.

Christine Vigneau, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Jason R. Fraxedas , THE MAHER LAW FIRM, Jonathan Kieffer , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Lucinda Cepeda, Plaintiff, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Lezzlie Elizabeth Hornsby , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & William Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Yolanda Rey Sotolongo, Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey L. Haberman , SCHLESINGER LAW OFFICES.

Sandra Thibodeau Zelmat & Jamal Zelmat, Plaintiffs, represented by Lisa Gentleman Hogg , FLINT LAW FIRM.

Valerie Dunagan, Plaintiff, represented by Andrew Parker Felix , MORGAN & MORGAN & T. Scott Allen, Jr. , BAILEY PERRIN BAILEY.

Laura Lambaren, Plaintiff, represented by Kyle D. Kaiman , KAIMAN & CRAHAN & Sarah Beth Hackman .

Laura Lambaren, Plaintiff, pro se.

Raul Lambaren, Plaintiff, represented by Thomas Anthony Tarro, III , TARRO & MAROTTI LAW FIRM & Beth A. Klein , KLEIN FRANK.

Raul Lambaren, Plaintiff, pro se.

Geraldine Bunt, Plaintiff, represented by Troy R. Keller , Troy R. Keller Attorney at Law.

Renee Oliveira, Plaintiff, pro se.

Antonio Oliveira, Plaintiff, pro se.

Ana Dowling, Paul Markham, Alishia Pinon & Michael Pinon, Plaintiffs, represented by Dale Bernardo Ratner , MARC J. BERN & PARTNERS.

Maria E. Diaz, Plaintiff, represented by Richard J. Rosenblum , RUBIN MACHADO & ROSENBLUM.

Sacramento Diaz, Plaintiff, represented by Sarah Beth Hackman .

Ken Gorfinkle, Plaintiff, represented by Jacob Alex Flint , FLINT LAW FIRM & Sara E. Coopwood , FLINT LAW FIRM.

Jean Oliver & Richard Oliver, Plaintiffs, represented by Erin C. Murphy , LEE MURPHY LAW FIRM, Jacob Alex Flint , FLINT LAW FIRM & Laura V. Yaeger , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ.

Susan Breen, Plaintiff, pro se.

Diana Gonzalez & Robert Gonzalez, Plaintiffs, represented by Sean Patrick Tracey , TRACEY & FOX LAW FIRM.

Marie Renteria, Plaintiff, pro se.

Christie Turner, Plaintiff, pro se.

Susan Robertson, M.D., Defendant, represented by Andolyn R. Johnson , O'BRYAN BROWN & TONER, Andrew D. Pellino , O'BRYAN BROWN & TONER & Donald K. Brown, Jr. , O'BRYAN BROWN & TONER.

Broward Outpatient Medical Center, Interested Party, represented by Gerald M. Titus, III , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Mitchell J. Rhein , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE & Neva G. Lusk , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE.

Beth Israel Outpatient Surgery Center, Interested Party, represented by John Phillip Fischer , FISCHER REDAVID & Richard J. Rosenblum , RUBIN MACHADO & ROSENBLUM.

Beth Israel Outpatient Surgery Center, Interested Party, pro se.

D. Todd Heniford, M.D., Interested Party, represented by Matthew Scott Parmet , PARMET.

Gregory Neil McEwen, Movant, pro se.

Anderson Law Offices, Movant, represented by Paul W. Flowers , PAUL W. FLOWERS CO.

Ethicon, Inc., doing business as, Defendant, represented by A. La'Verne Edney , BUTLER SNOW, Aaron N. Arthur , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Adam Porter , BUTLER SNOW, Adam J. Spicer , BUTLER SNOW O'MARA STEVENS & CANNADA, Alex C. Walker , MODRALL SPERLING ROEHL HARRIS & SISK, Alexandra Spear Peurach , TROUTMAN SANDERS, Allyson Miller Julien , GOLDMAN ISMAIL TOMASELLI BRENNAN & BAUM, Alyssa Jordan Broyles , FRIDAY ELDREDGE & CLARK, Alyssa Brittany McDaniel , BECK REDDEN, Amy Sherry Fischer , FOLIART HUFF OTTAWAY & BOTTOM, Amy M. Pepke , BUTLER SNOW, Andrew L. Goldman , GOLDMAN ISMAIL TOMASELLI BRENNAN & BAUM, Andrew R. Kruppa , SQUIRE PATTON BOGGS, Stacey A. Adamski , ELLIS BOXER & BLAKE, Anita Modak-Truran , BUTLER SNOW, Asher Griffin , SCOTT DOUGLASS & MCCONNICO, Ashley Kemper Corkery , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH, Ashley Nader Stubbs , BUTLER SNOW, Barry J. Koopmann , BOWMAN & BROOKE, Beatriz E. Jaramillo , SQUIRE PATTON BOGGS, Benjamin M. Watson , BUTLER SNOW, Bettina Joist Strauss , BRYAN CAVE, Bradley J. Johnston , THE CAVANAGH LAW FIRM, Brett Wesley Taylor , FRIDAY ELDREDGE & CLARK, Camala E. Capodice , IRWIN FRITCHIE URQUHART & MOORE, Carly W. Stephani , BOWMAN AND BROOKE, Caroline Dye Walker , BUTLER SNOW, Catherine A. Faught Pollard , QUARLES & BRADY, Chad R. Hutchinson , BUTLER SNOW, Charles Clark Harrell , BUTLER SNOW, Charles Martin Pritchett , FROST BROWN TODD, Christian Elizabeth Piccolo , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH, Christopher S. Berdy , BUTLER SNOW, Christopher Cowan , BUTLER SNOW, Christopher R. Drury , SHIPMAN & GOODWIN, Christopher D. Morris , BUTLER SNOW, Claire A. Noonan , IRWIN FRITCHIE URQUHART & MOORE, Cynthia L. Saiter , SCOTT DOUGLASS & MCCONNICO, Dan H. Ball , BRYAN CAVE, Dana M. Lenahan , NILAN JOHNSON LEWIS, Daniel R. Higginbotham , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Daniel W. Van Horn , BUTLER SNOW O'MARA STEVENS & CANNADA, Darleene Darensbourg Peters , IRWIN FRITCHIE URQUHART & MOORE, David B. Bartel , QUARLES & BRADY, David Michael Cohen , BUTLER SNOW, David J. Duke , BOWMAN & BROOKE, David Frederic Norden , TROUTMAN SANDERS, David R. Noteware , THOMPSON & KNIGHT, David Wayne O'Quinn , IRWIN FRITCHIE URQUHART & MOORE, David George Oliveira , ROERIG OLIVEIRA & FISHER, Diana Katz Gerstel , RIKER DANZIG SCHERER HYLAND PERRETTI, Dimple Desai Shah , BOWMAN AND BROOKE, E. Righton J. Lewis , BUTLER SNOW, Eden M. Darrell , BOWMAN & BROOKE, Edie M. Cagnolatti , IRWIN FRITCHIE URQUHART & MOORE, Edwin F. Chociey, Jr. , RIKER DANZIG SCHERER HYLAND & PERRETTI, Eileen Marie Somers , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH, Eric M. Anielak , SHOOK HARDY & BACON, Erica M. James , TUCKER ELLIS, Gordon Lee Mowen, II , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Gretchen A. Colter , BOWMAN & BROOKE, Halli D. Cohn , TROUTMAN SANDERS, Helen Kathryn Downs , BUTLER SNOW, J. Adam Wells , FRIDAY ELDREDGE & CLARK, James C. Barton, Jr. , BUTLER SNOW, James M. Campbell , CAMPBELL CAMPBELL EDWARDS & CONROY, James B. Irwin , IRWIN FRITCHIE URQUHART & MOORE, Jan R. McLean Bernier , NILAN JOHNSON LEWIS, Janelle L. Davis , THOMPSON & KNIGHT, Jeffrey Royal Johnson , SCHEER LAW GROUP, Jennifer L. Greenblatt , GOLDMAN ISMAIL TOMASELLI BRENNAN & BAUM, Jennifer Lynn Steinmetz , TUCKER ELLIS, Jenny A. Covington , BOWMAN & BROOKE, pro hac vice, Jill Kuhn , TROUTMAN SANDERS, Joe W. Tomaselli, Jr. , GOLDMAN ISMAIL TOMASELLI BRENNAN & BAUM, John A. Anderson , STOEL RIVES, John William Ellis , SCOTT DOUGLASS & MCCONNICO, John J. O'Donnell , CAMPBELL CONROY & O'NEIL, P.C., Joni A. Jamison , KAEMPFER CROWELL, Jordan N. Walker , BUTLER SNOW, Jordyn Leigh Cartmell , FOLIART HUFF OTTAWAY & BOTTOM, Joseph Kendall Merical , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Joseph E. O'Neil , CAMPBELL CONROY & O'NEIL, P.C., Joshua C. Carpenter , SQUIRE PATTON BOGGS, Joshua J. Wes , TUCKER ELLIS, Judith A. Wahrenberger , RUPRECHT HART WEEKS & RICCIARDULLI, Julia M. Rafferty , CAMPBELL CONROY & O'NEIL, Julie A. Callsen , TUCKER ELLIS, Kari L. Sutherland , BUTLER SNOW, pro hac vice, Kasey Mitchell Adams , BUTLER SNOW, Kathleen Gallagher , BECK REDDEN, Kathleen M. Guilfoyle , CAMPBELL CAMPBELL EDWARDS & CONROY, Kathryn June Skagerberg , BECK REDDEN, Kathryn E. Warihay , TROUTMAN SANDERS, Katie A. Fillmore , BUTLER SNOW, Kaylan Michelle Meaza , TROUTMAN SANDERS, Kelly S. Crawford , RIKER DANZIG SCHERER HYLAND & PERRETTI, Kelly Juneau Rookard , IRWIN FRITCHIE URQUHART & MOORE, Kenneth Paul Conour , BUTLER SNOW, Kim E. Moore , IRWIN FRITCHIE URQUHART & MOORE, Kim M. Schmid , BOWMAN & BROOKE, Kimberly Gustafson Bueno , SCOTT DOUGLAS & MCCONNICO, Kimberly C. Metzger , ICE MILLER, pro hac vice, Kimberly Dickerson Young , FRIDAY ELDREDGE & CLARK, Larry D. Ottaway , FOLIART HUFF OTTAWAY & BOTTOM, Laura H. Smith , FRIDAY ELDREDGE & CLARK, Lauren Patten , BUTLER SNOW, Lee Adair Floyd , BUTLER SNOW, Lyn Peeples Pruitt , MITCHELL WILLIAMS SELIG GATES & WOODYARD, Maha M. Kabbash , RIKER DANZIG SCHERER HYLAND & PERRETTI, Margaret H. Loveman , BUTLER SNOW, Martin Aaron Kasten , FRIDAY ELDREDGE & CLARK, Mary Nold Larimore , ICE MILLER, Mary Elen Scalera , RIKER DANZIG SCHERER HYLAND & PERRETTI, Matthew P. Moriarty , TUCKER ELLIS, Matthew P. Smith , BUTLER SNOW, Meta Cooper Danzey , BUTLER SNOW, Michael L. Brown , BUTLER SNOW O'MARA STEVENS & CANNADA, pro hac vice, Michael B. Hewes , BUTLER SNOW, Michael P. O'Mullan , RIKER DANZIG SCHERER HYLAND & PERRETTI, Michael Andrew Snowden , BUTLER SNOW, Michael C. Zellers , TUCKER ELLIS, Molly E. Flynn , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH, Molly J.G. Given Nietfeld , BOWMAN & BROOKE, Nancy Karen Deming , TROUTMAN SANDERS, Nathan D. Cardozo , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH, Nikita Sherrell McMillian , BUTLER SNOW, Nils Burton Snell , BUTLER SNOW, Paige Arnette Amstutz , SCOTT DOUGLASS & MCCONNICO, Pamela Lawrence , BUTLER SNOW, Patrice B. Childress , BECK REDDEN, Patricia Elaine Lowry , SQUIRE PATTON BOGGS, Paul Stokely Rosenblatt , BUTLER SNOW, Philip J. Combs , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Rachelle A. Velgersdyk , BOWMAN AND BROOKE, Rebecca L. Trela , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH, Rebecca Lee Wiggs , BUTLER SNOW, Rita A. Maimbourg , TUCKER ELLIS, pro hac vice, Robert R. McCoy , KAEMPFER CROWELL, pro hac vice, Robert Reginald Simpson , SHIPMAN & GOODWIN, Rockney Taveau , BUTLER SNOW, Ryan Sellars Squires , SCOTT DOUGLASS & McCONNICO, S. Eric Rumanek , TROUTMAN SANDERS, Sanford E. Watson, II , TUCKER ELLIS, Sara Wilder Clark , SCOTT DOUGLASS & MCCONNICO, Sarah A. Leonard , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Sarah A. Martin , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Sarah Smyth O'Brien , BUTLER SNOW, Sarah Ann Westby , SHIPMAN & GOODWIN, Scholastica N.S. Baker , BOWMAN & BROOKE, Shari M. Goodstein , SHIPMAN & GOODWIN, Shayna S. Cook , GOLDMAN ISMAIL TOMASELLI BRENNAN & BAUM, Sherrie A. Armstrong , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Sherry A. Knutson , TUCKER ELLIS, Sheryl A. Bjork , BOWMAN & BROOKE, Stephanie Lottinger Irwin , IRWIN FRITCHIE URQUHART & MOORE, Stephen E. McConnico , SCOTT DOUGLASS & McCONNICO, Steven James Wingard , SCOTT DOUGLASS & MCCONNICO, Su-Lyn Combs , TUCKER ELLIS, Susan J. Pope , FROST BROWN TODD, Matthew Scott Parmet , PARMET, Susanna Moore Moldoveanu , BUTLER SNOW, T. Michelle Ator , FRIDAY ELDREDGE & CLARK, Tarek Ismail , GOLDMAN ISMAIL TOMASELLI BRENNAN & BAUM, Taylor B. Mayes , BUTLER SNOW, Thomas Bailey , TROUTMAN SANDERS, Tiffany L. Roach Martin , MODRALL SPERLING ROEHL HARRIS & SISK, Timothy M. Considine , STOEL RIVES, Timothy C. Holm , MODRALL SPERLING ROEHL HARRIS & SISK, Tracy J. Van Steenburgh , NILAN JOHNSON LEWIS, William M. Gage , BUTLER SNOW, William E. Lawton , DEAN RINGERS MORGAN & LAWTON, Alexandria J. Reyes , TROUTMAN SANDERS, Andrea Cox , ARNSTEIN & LEHR, Jeffrey B. Shapiro , ARNSTEIN & LEHR, Matthew Jacob Adler , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH, Michelle Ann Childers , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH & Theresa L. F. Levings , BADGER & LEVINGS.

Ethicon, Inc., doing business as, Defendant, pro se.

Johnson & Johnson, Defendant, represented by Brent William Bailey , LAW OFFICES OF BILL BAILEY, Gerald M. Titus, III , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Mitchell J. Rhein , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Neva G. Lusk , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Allen M. Gardner , LATHAM & WATKINS, Andrew J. Robinson , LATHAM & WATKINS, T. Michelle Ator , FRIDAY ELDREDGE & CLARK, Tarek Ismail , GOLDMAN ISMAIL TOMASELLI BRENNAN & BAUM, Paul W. Flowers , PAUL W. FLOWERS CO., Gerald Lawrence , Lowey Dannenberg, P.C., Amy Pepke , BUTLER SNOW, Aaron N. Arthur , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Adam J. Spicer , BUTLER SNOW O'MARA STEVENS & CANNADA, Alex C. Walker , MODRALL SPERLING ROEHL HARRIS & SISK, Alexandra Spear Peurach , TROUTMAN SANDERS, Allyson Miller Julien , GOLDMAN ISMAIL TOMASELLI BRENNAN & BAUM, Alyssa Jordan Broyles , FRIDAY ELDREDGE & CLARK, Amy Sherry Fischer , FOLIART HUFF OTTAWAY & BOTTOM, Amy M. Pepke , BUTLER SNOW, Andrew L. Goldman , GOLDMAN ISMAIL TOMASELLI BRENNAN & BAUM, Andrew R. Kruppa , SQUIRE PATTON BOGGS, Anita Modak-Truran , BUTLER SNOW, Ashley Kemper Corkery , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH, Barry J. Koopmann , BOWMAN & BROOKE, Beatriz E. Jaramillo , SQUIRE PATTON BOGGS, Benjamin M. Watson , BUTLER SNOW, Brett Wesley Taylor , FRIDAY ELDREDGE & CLARK, Camala E. Capodice , IRWIN FRITCHIE URQUHART & MOORE, Carly W. Stephani , BOWMAN AND BROOKE, Chad R. Hutchinson , BUTLER SNOW, Charles Martin Pritchett , FROST BROWN TODD, Christian Elizabeth Piccolo , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH, Christopher S. Berdy , BUTLER SNOW, Christopher Cowan , BUTLER SNOW, Christopher D. Morris , BUTLER SNOW, Christy D. Jones , BUTLER SNOW, David Frederic Norden , TROUTMAN SANDERS, Claire A. Noonan , IRWIN FRITCHIE URQUHART & MOORE, Cynthia L. Saiter , SCOTT DOUGLASS & MCCONNICO, Dan H. Ball , BRYAN CAVE, Daniel R. Higginbotham , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Daniel W. Van Horn , BUTLER SNOW O'MARA STEVENS & CANNADA, Darleene Darensbourg Peters , IRWIN FRITCHIE URQUHART & MOORE, David Michael Cohen , BUTLER SNOW, David J. Duke , BOWMAN & BROOKE, David Wayne O'Quinn , IRWIN FRITCHIE URQUHART & MOORE, Dimple Desai Shah , BOWMAN AND BROOKE, E. Righton J. Lewis , BUTLER SNOW, Eden M. Darrell , BOWMAN & BROOKE, Edwin F. Chociey, Jr. , RIKER DANZIG SCHERER HYLAND & PERRETTI, James P. Emanuel, Jr. , BRYAN CAVE, Eileen Marie Somers , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH, Eric M. Anielak , SHOOK HARDY & BACON, Gretchen A. Colter , BOWMAN & BROOKE, Halli D. Cohn , TROUTMAN SANDERS, Helen Kathryn Downs , BUTLER SNOW, pro hac vice, J. Adam Wells , FRIDAY ELDREDGE & CLARK, James C. Barton, Jr. , BUTLER SNOW, James M. Campbell , CAMPBELL CAMPBELL EDWARDS & CONROY, James B. Irwin , IRWIN FRITCHIE URQUHART & MOORE, Janelle L. Davis , THOMPSON & KNIGHT, Jennifer Lynn Steinmetz , TUCKER ELLIS, Jill Kuhn , TROUTMAN SANDERS, Joe W. Tomaselli, Jr. , GOLDMAN ISMAIL TOMASELLI BRENNAN & BAUM, John A. Anderson , STOEL RIVES, John J. O'Donnell , CAMPBELL CONROY & O'NEIL, P.C., Joni A. Jamison , KAEMPFER CROWELL, pro hac vice, Jordyn Leigh Cartmell , FOLIART HUFF OTTAWAY & BOTTOM, Joseph Kendall Merical , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Joseph E. O'Neil , CAMPBELL CONROY & O'NEIL, P.C., Joshua C. Carpenter , SQUIRE PATTON BOGGS, Katie A. Fillmore , BUTLER SNOW, Joshua J. Wes , TUCKER ELLIS, Judith A. Wahrenberger , RUPRECHT HART WEEKS & RICCIARDULLI, Julie A. Callsen , TUCKER ELLIS, Kari L. Sutherland , BUTLER SNOW, Kasey Mitchell Adams , BUTLER SNOW, Kathleen Gallagher , BECK REDDEN, Kathleen M. Guilfoyle , CAMPBELL CAMPBELL EDWARDS & CONROY, pro hac vice, Kathryn June Skagerberg , BECK REDDEN, Kelly S. Crawford , RIKER DANZIG SCHERER HYLAND & PERRETTI, Kelly Juneau Rookard , IRWIN FRITCHIE URQUHART & MOORE, Kenneth Paul Conour , BUTLER SNOW, Kim E. Moore , IRWIN FRITCHIE URQUHART & MOORE, Margaret H. Loveman , BUTLER SNOW, Kimberly C. Metzger , ICE MILLER, Larry D. Ottaway , FOLIART HUFF OTTAWAY & BOTTOM, Laura H. Dixon , BUTLER SNOW, Laura H. Smith , FRIDAY ELDREDGE & CLARK, Lauren Patten , BUTLER SNOW, Lee Adair Floyd , BUTLER SNOW, pro hac vice, Lyn Peeples Pruitt , MITCHELL WILLIAMS SELIG GATES & WOODYARD, Martin Aaron Kasten , FRIDAY ELDREDGE & CLARK, Mary Nold Larimore , ICE MILLER, Molly J.G. Given Nietfeld , BOWMAN & BROOKE, Mary Elen Scalera , RIKER DANZIG SCHERER HYLAND & PERRETTI, Matthew P. Moriarty , TUCKER ELLIS, Matthew P. Smith , BUTLER SNOW, Meta Cooper Danzey , BUTLER SNOW, Michael L. Brown , BUTLER SNOW O'MARA STEVENS & CANNADA, Michael B. Hewes , BUTLER SNOW, Michael Andrew Snowden , BUTLER SNOW, Michael C. Zellers , TUCKER ELLIS, Philip J. Combs , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Nancy Karen Deming , TROUTMAN SANDERS, Randy J. Soriano , BRYAN CAVE, Nikita Sherrell McMillian , BUTLER SNOW, Nils Burton Snell , BUTLER SNOW, pro hac vice, Paige Arnette Amstutz , SCOTT DOUGLASS & MCCONNICO, pro hac vice, Pamela Lawrence , BUTLER SNOW, Patrice B. Childress , BECK REDDEN, Paul Stokely Rosenblatt , BUTLER SNOW, Rachelle A. Velgersdyk , BOWMAN AND BROOKE, Rebecca L. Trela , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH, Rebecca Lee Wiggs , BUTLER SNOW, Rita A. Maimbourg , TUCKER ELLIS, Robert R. McCoy , KAEMPFER CROWELL, Rockney Taveau , BUTLER SNOW, S. Eric Rumanek , TROUTMAN SANDERS, Sanford E. Watson, II , TUCKER ELLIS, Sara Wilder Clark , SCOTT DOUGLASS & MCCONNICO, Stefan A. Mallen , BRYAN CAVE LLP, Sarah A. Leonard , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Sarah A. Martin , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Sarah Ann Westby , SHIPMAN & GOODWIN, Scholastica N.S. Baker , BOWMAN & BROOKE, Matthew Scott Parmet , PARMET, Shari M. Goodstein , SHIPMAN & GOODWIN, Shayna S. Cook , GOLDMAN ISMAIL TOMASELLI BRENNAN & BAUM, Sherrie A. Armstrong , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Sherry A. Knutson , TUCKER ELLIS, Stephen E. McConnico , SCOTT DOUGLASS & McCONNICO, Steven James Wingard , SCOTT DOUGLASS & MCCONNICO, Su-Lyn Combs , TUCKER ELLIS, William M. Gage , BUTLER SNOW, Susan J. Pope , FROST BROWN TODD, Taylor B. Mayes , BUTLER SNOW, Timothy M. Considine , STOEL RIVES, Allyson D. Miller , GOLDMAN ISMAIL TOMASELLI BRENNAN & BAUM, Andrea Cox , ARNSTEIN & LEHR & Jeffrey B. Shapiro , ARNSTEIN & LEHR.

Johnson & Johnson, Defendant, pro se.

American Medical Systems, Inc., Defendant, represented by Barbara R. Binis , REED SMITH, Camille N. Johnson , SNOW CHRISTENSEN & MARTINEAU, David Rodman Cooper , MARSHALL & MELHORN, Erik W. Legg , FARRELL WHITE & LEGG, Graeme Hancock , FENNEMORE CRAIG, Lori G. Cohen , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Michael J. Farrell , FARRELL WHITE & LEGG, R. Scott Campbell , GREENBERG TAURIG, Suzanne Lorraine Diaz , FENNEMORE CRAIG, Tracy G. Weiss , REED SMITH & Meghan Anderson Roth , COOPER & KOWALSKI.

Boston Scientific, LLC, Defendant, represented by Brannon Jones Arnold , WEINBERG WHEELER HUDGINS GUNN & DIAL, Bryan Pratt , SHOOK HARDY & BACON, Craig A. Marvinney , WALTER HAVERFIELD, Johnathan T. Krawcheck , WEINBERG WHEELER HUDGINS GUNN & DIAL, pro hac vice, Jon A. Strongman , SHOOK HARDY & BACON, pro hac vice & Robert T. Adams , SHOOK HARDY & BACON.

Ethicon Women's Health and Urology, Defendant, represented by Neva G. Lusk , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Amy M. Pepke , BUTLER SNOW, Charles Martin Pritchett , FROST BROWN TODD, Christopher S. Berdy , BUTLER SNOW, David Frederic Norden , TROUTMAN SANDERS, David Wayne O'Quinn , IRWIN FRITCHIE URQUHART & MOORE, Eileen Marie Somers , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH, Eric M. Anielak , SHOOK HARDY & BACON, James M. Campbell , CAMPBELL CAMPBELL EDWARDS & CONROY, Nils Burton Snell , BUTLER SNOW, pro hac vice, Paul Stokely Rosenblatt , BUTLER SNOW, Matthew Jacob Adler , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH, Sarah A. Leonard , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Scholastica N.S. Baker , BOWMAN & BROOKE, Stephen E. McConnico , SCOTT DOUGLASS & McCONNICO, Su-Lyn Combs , TUCKER ELLIS, William M. Gage , BUTLER SNOW & Susan J. Pope , FROST BROWN TODD.

Gynecare, Inc., doing business as, Defendant, represented by Neva G. Lusk , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Ashley Nader Stubbs , BUTLER SNOW, Christopher R. Drury , SHIPMAN & GOODWIN, Eric M. Anielak , SHOOK HARDY & BACON, Scholastica N.S. Baker , BOWMAN & BROOKE, Su-Lyn Combs , TUCKER ELLIS, William M. Gage , BUTLER SNOW & Susan J. Pope , FROST BROWN TODD.

Ethicon, L.L.C., Defendant, represented by Adam J. Spicer , BUTLER SNOW O'MARA STEVENS & CANNADA, Cynthia L. Saiter , SCOTT DOUGLASS & MCCONNICO, Eileen Marie Somers , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH, Joni A. Jamison , KAEMPFER CROWELL, pro hac vice, Lee Adair Floyd , BUTLER SNOW, pro hac vice, Paul Stokely Rosenblatt , BUTLER SNOW, Sarah A. Leonard , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN & William M. Gage , BUTLER SNOW.

Johnson & Johnson International, a New Jersey corporation & Johnson & Johnson Services, Inc., Defendants, represented by James M. Campbell , CAMPBELL CAMPBELL EDWARDS & CONROY, Paul Stokely Rosenblatt , BUTLER SNOW, Stephen E. McConnico , SCOTT DOUGLASS & McCONNICO & William M. Gage , BUTLER SNOW.

Herniamesh S.R.L., Defendant, represented by Frederick O. Ferrand , SWIFT CURRIE MCGHEE & HIERS & S. DeAnn Bomar , SWIFT CURRIE MCGHEE & HIERS.

Caldera Medical, Inc., Defendant, represented by Beth S. Rose , SILLS CUMMIS & GROSS, Stephen E. Matasich , DAY KETTERER & William R. Stuart, III , SILLS CUMMIS & GROSS.

Duc B. Lee, M. D., Defendant, represented by Samuel A. Houston , SHEPHERD SCOTT CLAWATER & HOUSTON.

Niraj Patel, M. D., Fort Bend OB-GYN, LLP, a Texas limited liability partnership, Alejandro Tey, M.D. & Alejandro A. Tey, M.D. P.A, also known as, Defendants, represented by Bryan Pratt , SHOOK HARDY & BACON.

Coloplast Corporation, Defendant, represented by Lana K. Varney , KING & SPALDING.

Coloplast Corp., Defendant, represented by Craig A. Marvinney , WALTER HAVERFIELD & Nancy Ledy-Gurren , LEDY-GURREN BASS D'AVANZO & SIFF.

Mentor Corporation, Defendant, represented by Dustin Bradley Rawlin , TUCKER ELLIS & WEST.

Gynecare, Defendant, represented by Amy M. Pepke , BUTLER SNOW, Dana M. Lenahan , NILAN JOHNSON LEWIS, Kelly S. Crawford , RIKER DANZIG SCHERER HYLAND & PERRETTI, Maha M. Kabbash , RIKER DANZIG SCHERER HYLAND & PERRETTI & William M. Gage , BUTLER SNOW.

Gynecare, Defendant, pro se.

Cook Biotech, Inc., an Indiana corporation, Defendant, represented by Douglas B. King , WOODEN & MCLAUGHLIN, James M. Boyers , WOODEN & MCLAUGHLIN & Jere Ann Rosebrock , WOODEN MCLAUGHLIN.

Cook Medical, Inc., an Indiana corporation, Cook, Inc., an Indiana corporation & Cook Incorporated, Defendants, represented by William R. Stuart, III , SILLS CUMMIS & GROSS, Samuel A. Houston , SHEPHERD SCOTT CLAWATER & HOUSTON & Ronn B. Kreps , FULBRIGHT & JAWORSKI.

Johnson & Johnson Sales and Logistics Company, LLC, Defendant, represented by Andrew Love , WRIGHT & CLOSE, Paul Stokely Rosenblatt , BUTLER SNOW, William M. Gage , BUTLER SNOW & Tiffany L. Roach Martin , MODRALL SPERLING ROEHL HARRIS & SISK.

Dr. Todd A. Richards, Defendant, represented by Andrew J. Donelan , HYDE LOVE & OVERBY, David E. Overby , HYDE LOVE & OVERBY & Kent O. Hyde , HYDE LOVE & OVERBY.

Freeman Health System, doing business as, Defendant, represented by Dustin Bradley Rawlin , TUCKER ELLIS & WEST, Kelly S. Crawford , RIKER DANZIG SCHERER HYLAND & PERRETTI, Lisa D. Schrock , HYDE LOVE & OVERBY & Maha M. Kabbash , RIKER DANZIG SCHERER HYLAND & PERRETTI.

Freeman Health Systems, Defendant, represented by Dustin Bradley Rawlin , TUCKER ELLIS & WEST, Kelly S. Crawford , RIKER DANZIG SCHERER HYLAND & PERRETTI & Maha M. Kabbash , RIKER DANZIG SCHERER HYLAND & PERRETTI.

Boston Scientific Corporation, Defendant, represented by Adrienne L. Hernandez , SHOOK HARDY & BACON, David R. Noteware , THOMPSON & KNIGHT, Lori G. Cohen , GREENBERG TRAURIG, pro hac vice, Matthew D. Keenan , SHOOK HARDY & BACON, Michael Bonasso , FLAHERTY SENSABAUGH & BONASSO, Michael B. Brennan , GASS WEBER MULLINS & Michael J. Farrell , FARRELL WHITE & LEGG.

Cardinal Health, Inc. & Cardinal Health 200, Inc., Defendants, represented by David Wayne O'Quinn , IRWIN FRITCHIE URQUHART & MOORE & Matthew Scott Parmet , PARMET.

Ethicon, Incorporated, (previously named John Doe Manufacturer), Defendant, represented by David Wayne O'Quinn , IRWIN FRITCHIE URQUHART & MOORE, Nils Burton Snell , BUTLER SNOW, pro hac vice, Paul Stokely Rosenblatt , BUTLER SNOW & William M. Gage , BUTLER SNOW.

St. Mary Medical Center, Defendant, represented by John C. Kelly , CARROLL KELLY TROTTER FRANZEN & MCKENNA & Sandra Jeane Carlson , CARROLL KELLY TROTER FRANZEN & MCKENNA.

Dignity Health, Defendant, represented by John T. Schlafer , FAEGRE BAKER DANIELS & Andrew Love , WRIGHT & CLOSE.

Johnson & Johnson Medical S.A., Inc., a New Jersey corporation, Defendant, represented by William F. Bottoms , VANANTWERP MONGE JONES & EDWARDS, Paul Stokely Rosenblatt , BUTLER SNOW, William M. Gage , BUTLER SNOW & Tiffany L. Roach Martin , MODRALL SPERLING ROEHL HARRIS & SISK.

American Medical Systems, Defendant, represented by Michelle Ann Childers , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH & Theresa L. F. Levings , BADGER & LEVINGS.

Ethicon, Defendant, represented by Neva G. Lusk , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, David R. Noteware , THOMPSON & KNIGHT, Joni A. Jamison , KAEMPFER CROWELL, pro hac vice, Michael B. Hewes , BUTLER SNOW, Paul Stokely Rosenblatt , BUTLER SNOW, Matthew Scott Parmet , PARMET, Sherry A. Knutson , TUCKER ELLIS & William M. Gage , BUTLER SNOW.

Mentor Worldwide, LLC, Defendant, represented by Heleina Lorraine Formoso , KING & SPALDING & S. DeAnn Bomar , SWIFT CURRIE MCGHEE & HIERS.

Ethicon SARL, a Swiss Corporation, Ethicon SAS, a French Company, Johnson & Johnson Medical, LTD, a Scottish Company, Johnson & Johnson Medical GmbH, a German Company, Johnson & Johnson Health Care Systems, Inc., Ethicon Sarl, Ethicon Women's Health & Urology, A Div of Johnson & Johnson Medical, Ethicon LTD & Johnson & Johnson Neuchatel, Defendants, represented by Paul Stokely Rosenblatt , BUTLER SNOW & William M. Gage , BUTLER SNOW.

Ethicon, LLC, a Puerto Rican Company, Defendant, represented by Mitchell J. Rhein , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Aaron N. Arthur , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Adam J. Spicer , BUTLER SNOW O'MARA STEVENS & CANNADA, Allyson Miller Julien , GOLDMAN ISMAIL TOMASELLI BRENNAN & BAUM, Halli D. Cohn , TROUTMAN SANDERS, Katie A. Fillmore , BUTLER SNOW, Kenneth Paul Conour , BUTLER SNOW, Mary Nold Larimore , ICE MILLER, Michael B. Hewes , BUTLER SNOW, Michael Andrew Snowden , BUTLER SNOW, Nikita Sherrell McMillian , BUTLER SNOW, Nils Burton Snell , BUTLER SNOW, pro hac vice, Paul Stokely Rosenblatt , BUTLER SNOW, Matthew Scott Parmet , PARMET & William M. Gage , BUTLER SNOW.

Ethicon, LLC, a Puerto Rican Company, Defendant, pro se.

C. R. Bard, Inc., Defendant, represented by Mildred Segura , REED SMITH, Richard B. North, Jr. , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, pro hac vice & James P. Emanuel, Jr. , BRYAN CAVE.

Tissue Science Laboratories Limited, Defendant, represented by Deborah A. Moeller , SHOOK HARDY BACON.

Johnson & Johnson, Inc., Defendant, represented by Claire A. Noonan , IRWIN FRITCHIE URQUHART & MOORE, Cynthia L. Saiter , SCOTT DOUGLASS & MCCONNICO, Eileen Marie Somers , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH, Erica M. James , TUCKER ELLIS, Joni A. Jamison , KAEMPFER CROWELL, pro hac vice, Manuel A. Moreda-Toledo , MCCONNELL VALDES, Molly E. Flynn , DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH, Paul Stokely Rosenblatt , BUTLER SNOW, Sarah A. Leonard , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Matthew Scott Parmet , PARMET & William M. Gage , BUTLER SNOW.

Tissue Science Laboratories Ltd., Defendant, represented by Kent O. Hyde , HYDE LOVE & OVERBY.

Prakash Ranka, M.D., Defendant, represented by Rebecca S. Kenny , MADISON MROZ STEINMANT & DEKLEVA.

Ethicon, LLC, Defendant, represented by Mitchell J. Rhein , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Allyson Miller Julien , GOLDMAN ISMAIL TOMASELLI BRENNAN & BAUM, Carly W. Stephani , BOWMAN AND BROOKE, Michael B. Hewes , BUTLER SNOW, Paul Stokely Rosenblatt , BUTLER SNOW, Matthew Scott Parmet , PARMET & William M. Gage , BUTLER SNOW.

Prodesco, Inc., Defendant, represented by Joe H. Tucker, Jr. , TUCKER LAW GROUP & Venyckles Amanda Witts , TUCKER LAW GROUP.

Secant Medical Inc. & Secant Medical LLC, Defendants, represented by Matthew D. Keenan , SHOOK HARDY & BACON & Michael Bonasso , FLAHERTY SENSABAUGH & BONASSO.

W. L. Gore & Associates, Inc., Defendant, represented by James P. Emanuel, Jr. , BRYAN CAVE.

Desarrollo e Investigacion Medica Aragonesa, S.L., Defendant, represented by Carolyn Purwin , CIPRIANI & WERNER.

Neomedic International, S.L. & Neomedic, Inc., Defendants, represented by Michael B. Brennan , GASS WEBER MULLINS.

Gynecare Worldwide, Defendant, represented by David Frederic Norden , TROUTMAN SANDERS & William M. Gage , BUTLER SNOW.

Dr. Lee A. Hutton, Defendant, represented by Frank N. Luccia , LUCCIA & EVANS & Bryan Pratt , SHOOK HARDY & BACON.

Lifecell Corporation, Defendant, represented by David W. Field , LOWENSTEIN SANDLER & Michael Andrew Kaplan , LOWENSTEIN SANDLER.

Christopher H. Roberts, M.D., Defendant, represented by Douglas B. King , WOODEN & MCLAUGHLIN.

Ryan P. McKeon, Defendant, represented by Janna S. Nugent , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Justin Benjamin Aronson , GREENBERG TRAURIG, James P. Emanuel, Jr. , BRYAN CAVE & Richard B. North, Jr. , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, pro hac vice.

Selena M. Mitseas, also known as, Gregory L. Prine & David Montgomery Jackson, Defendants, represented by Adam Porter , BUTLER SNOW & Michael Andrew Snowden , BUTLER SNOW.

Garretson Resolution Group, Inc., Movant, represented by T. Matthew Lockhart , HUDDLESTON BOLEN.

MedStar Funding, LC, Movant, represented by Alexander Macia , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, David A. Bosak , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE & James S. Crockett, Jr. , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE.

Daniel Christensen, Movant, represented by Joe H. Tucker, Jr. , TUCKER LAW GROUP, Venyckles Amanda Witts , TUCKER LAW GROUP & Carolyn Purwin , CIPRIANI & WERNER.


MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

On November 15, 2018, a Suggestion of Death was filed by plaintiff's counsel suggesting the death of plaintiff Phyllis Ogg during the pendency of this civil action. [ECF No. 30].

Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 25(a) and Pretrial...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases