IN RE C.R. BARD, INC., PELVIC REPAIR SYSTEMS PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION

MDL No. 2187.

IN RE: C.R. BARD, INC., PELVIC REPAIR SYSTEMS PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION. THIS DOCUMENT RELATES TO ALL CASES.

United States District Court, S.D. West Virginia, Charleston Division.

July 25, 2019.

Editors Note
Applicable Law: 28 U.S.C. § 1331
Cause: 28 U.S.C. § 1331 Fed. Question: Personal Injury
Nature of Suit: 365 Personal Inj. Prod. Liability
Source: PACER


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Jacque L. Breitbarth & Joyce E. McCombs, Plaintiffs, represented by Charles H. Johnson , LAW OFFICES OF CHARLES H. JOHNSON & Jonathan R. Mencel , LAW OFFICES OF CHARLES H. JOHNSON.

Mary Henley & Dennis Henley, Plaintiffs, represented by Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice & Steven R. Maher , THE MAHER LAW FIRM.

Mildred Wafford, Plaintiff, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, Carl N. Frankovitch , FRANKOVITCH ANETAKIS COLANTONIO & SIMON, Clayton J. Fitzsimmons , FITZSIMMONS LAW FIRM, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Justin G. Witkin , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Mark A. Colantonio , FRANKOVITCH ANETAKIS COLANTONIO & SIMON, Neil D. Overholtz , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & Robert P. Fitzsimmons , FITZSIMMONS LAW FIRM.

James Youn, Barbara Meacham & Deloye Meacham, Sr., Plaintiffs, represented by Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, James B. Matthews, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, Adam Bryant Land , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Andrew Judson Hill, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, Gary B. Blasingame , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice & Josh B. Wages , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice.

Diana Rice, Renee M. Spencer & Michael J. Spencer, Plaintiffs, represented by Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice & Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM.

Kimberly Kirchner, Plaintiff, represented by Andy Dow Birchfield, Jr. , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Wesley Chadwick Cook , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES & P. Leigh O'Dell , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES.

Jill L. Dewey & Jon C. Dewey, Plaintiffs, represented by Elise A. Waisbren , PHILLIPS LAW OFFICES, pro hac vice, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Stephen D. Phillips , PHILLIPS LAW OFFICES, pro hac vice & Terrence M. Quinn , PHILLIPS LAW OFFICES, pro hac vice.

Charlene Houchins & John Houchins, Plaintiffs, represented by Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Fred Thompson, III , MOTLEY RICE, Harry F. Bell, Jr. , THE BELL LAW FIRM & Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE.

Christine Wheeler, Plaintiff, represented by Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Jacob Plattenberger , TOR HOERMAN LAW, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Jonathan Kieffer , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Raymond Joseph Kramer , TORHOERMAN LAW, Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Tor A. Hoerman , TOR HOERMAN LAW.

Doug Wheeler, Plaintiff, represented by Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Jacob Plattenberger , TOR HOERMAN LAW, Jonathan Kieffer , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Raymond Joseph Kramer , TORHOERMAN LAW & Tor A. Hoerman , TOR HOERMAN LAW.

Teressa Hager, Doris Ann Wilson, deceased, Brandy M. Pauley, Barbara Simon Bierner, Michael Bierner, Angelique L. Herrell & Carol Marie Hadl, Plaintiffs, represented by Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, James B. Matthews, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, Andrew Judson Hill, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, Gary B. Blasingame , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice & Josh B. Wages , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice.

Helen Lee, Betty Barber & Wayne Barber, Plaintiffs, represented by Daniel S. Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Mark P. Robinson, Jr. , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS & Willard J. Moody, Jr. , THE MOODY LAW FIRM.

Lynn Giambrone, deceased, Plaintiff, represented by Brian A. Goldstein , CELLINO & BARNES.

Pamela Goulette & Michael Goulette, Plaintiffs, represented by Alyson Amerson , DOYLE LOWTHER, Christopher W. Cantrell , DOYLE LOWTHER, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice & William J. Doyle, II , DOYLE LOWTHER.

Karen Sherer-Smith & Cindy Dalton, Plaintiffs, represented by Mikal C. Watts , WATTS GUERRA CRAFT, Paige Nicole Boldt , WATTS GUERRA & Ryan L. Thompson , WATTS GUERRA CRAFT.

Kathy Singletary, Charles Singletary & Rene M. Bullard, Plaintiffs, represented by Christopher W. Cantrell , DOYLE LOWTHER, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, John Lowther , DOYLE LOWTHER & William J. Doyle, II , DOYLE LOWTHER.

Ann C. Buoncristiani, Plaintiff, represented by Andrea Solomon Hirsch , HERMAN GEREL, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, James F. Green , ASHCRAFT & GEREL, Joseph A. Kott , HERMAN HERMAN & KATZ, Michelle A. Parfitt , ASHCRAFT & GEREL & Mikalia Miceli Kott , HERMAN HERMAN & KATZ.

Angie Gilliam, Plaintiff, represented by Bruce Cook , BRUCE COOK & ASSOCIATES, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice & Larry D. Helvey , LARRY HELVEY LAW FIRM.

Lois Watkins & William Watkins, Plaintiffs, represented by A. Donald C. Discepolo , DISCEPOLO & Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice.

Janet Nielsen & Michael Nielsen, Plaintiffs, represented by Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Jayne Conroy , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, John J. Foley , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, Paul Hanly , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY & Trent B. Miracle , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY.

Maritza Brackman & Bev Earls, Plaintiffs, represented by Christopher W. Cantrell , DOYLE LOWTHER, John Lowther , DOYLE LOWTHER & William J. Doyle, II , DOYLE LOWTHER.

Annette Fashaw, Plaintiff, represented by Jonathan T. Gilbert , FELDMAN FOX & MORGADO.

Esther Turner, Plaintiff, represented by Andrea Little Gentle , DANIELS & GENTLE, Douglas A. Daniels , DANIELS & GENTLE & Sheri L. Tarr , MARKOFF LEINBERGER.

Larry D. Turner, James Waddick & Royce Pettie, Plaintiffs, represented by Andrea Little Gentle , DANIELS & GENTLE & Douglas A. Daniels , DANIELS & GENTLE.

Martina Wheeler, Plaintiff, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & Nathan C. Bess , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ.

Linda S. Raisor & Humphrey Raisor, Plaintiffs, represented by Elise A. Waisbren , PHILLIPS LAW OFFICES, pro hac vice, Stephen D. Phillips , PHILLIPS LAW OFFICES, pro hac vice & Terrence M. Quinn , PHILLIPS LAW OFFICES, pro hac vice.

Leanne Edwards Hadley, Plaintiff, represented by Catherine T. Heacox , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Dana B. Taschner , pro hac vice, David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Stacy L. Murrow, Sr., Personal Representative of the Estate of Stacy L. Murrow, Sr., Plaintiff, represented by Norwood S. Wilner , THE WILNER FIRM, pro hac vice.

Cynthia Fineburg, Plaintiff, represented by Bret A. Clark , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Hans H. Van Zanten , THE POTTS LAW FIRM & Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM.

Frankie Byrd, & & James L. Byrd, Plaintiffs, represented by Catherine T. Heacox , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Dana B. Taschner , pro hac vice, David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly A. Fitzpatrick , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Richard D. Meadow , THE LANIER LAW FIRM & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Joseph Charles Cornelius, Sr. & Angela Renee Mote-Cornelius, Plaintiffs, represented by Dana B. Taschner , pro hac vice, David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Johnny Sandford, Ricardo Torres, Tina Martin, Mary Edwards, William Edwards, Tony Lee Allison, Anthony Vowell, Cindy Vowell, Kayla Krumnow, Administrator of the Estate of Kayla Krumnow, Sherry Martin, Jane Tamecki & Shelia Bowman, Plaintiffs, represented by Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Laura Armstrong Risech & Diana Cline, Plaintiffs, represented by Robert E. Price , LEVIN PAPANTONIO THOMAS MITCHELL RAFFERTY & PROCTOR.

Donna Chrastecky & Michael Chrastecky, Plaintiffs, represented by J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, John Benjamin Bireley , ARNOLD & ITKIN, John Fabry , MUELLER LAW, Mark R. Mueller , MUELLER LAW, pro hac vice, Mark C. Sparks , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Micajah D. Boatright , ARNOLD & ITKIN, pro hac vice, Noah M. Wexler , ARNOLD & ITKIN & Roland Christensen , ARNOLD & ITKIN.

Pamela Luce & John Morgan, Plaintiffs, represented by Erin K. Copeland , FIBICH LEEBRON COPELAND BRIGGS JOSEPHSON.

Robert Halcomb, Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Halcomb, Sara Halcomb, deceased & Robert Halcomb, Plaintiffs, represented by Merritt E. Cunningham , SMITH STAG, Michael G. Stag , SMITH STAG & Philip Jay Starr , LAWCO USA.

Stephanie Bridgewater, Plaintiff, represented by Bobby Jewell Bell, Jr. , HOLLIS WRIGHT & COUCH.

Franklin Palmer, Jr., Cheryl Newberry, Sherry Barber & Eric Barber, Plaintiffs, represented by C. Andrew Childers , CHILDERS SCHLUETER & SMITH & Michael Brandon Smith , CHILDERS SCHLUETER & SMITH.

Karen Meadows, Plaintiff, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, Carl N. Frankovitch , FRANKOVITCH ANETAKIS COLANTONIO & SIMON, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Erin K. Copeland , FIBICH LEEBRON COPELAND BRIGGS JOSEPHSON & Kevin M. Pearl , FRANKOVITCH ANETAKIS COLANTONIO & SIMON.

Rogerio Leal & Ronald Springman, Plaintiffs, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM & William Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Ida Malay, Sharon Kay Luong, Sharon Lowery, David Lowery, Jill W. Johnson, Bill Johnson, Leigh Ann Kuprowicz, Lois V. Mayberry, Bobby Carl Mayberry, Angela L. Ketelaar, Ellen Simmons LaGamba, Robert LaGamba, Angela Lynch, William Lynch, Naomi Jenkins, Amy L. Fletcher, Denise Jane Martin, Barbara McKinney, Russell McKinney, Nancy L. Johnson, Earnest Johnson, Nellie Johnson, Twila Kingham, Elizabeth Howlett, Mary Jane Horchner, Larry Gene Horchner, Sr., Melissa Malone, Beverly Ferguson, Janis Higginbotham, Abby Joseph-Cabral, Walter Cabral & Eva H. Hess, Plaintiffs, represented by Andy Dow Birchfield, Jr. , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES, P. Leigh O'Dell , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES & Wesley Chadwick Cook , BEASLEY ALLEN CROW METHVIN PORTIS & MILES.

Eunice Arruda, Plaintiff, represented by David L. Lowans , LAWCO USA, Merritt E. Cunningham , SMITH STAG & Michael G. Stag , SMITH STAG.

Leobardo Serrano Garcia, Pamela Anderson Smith, Jimmy Smith, Judy D. Matlock, William T. Matlock, Sr., Susan Lee Young, Jeanne Lynn Welch & George Welch, Plaintiffs, represented by Dana B. Taschner , pro hac vice, David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly A. Fitzpatrick , THE LANIER LAW FIRM & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Edith Wilson Jones, Plaintiff, represented by Brenda S. Fulmer , SEARCY DENNEY SCAROLA BARNHART & SHIPLEY & C. Calvin Warriner, III , SEARCY DENNEY SCAROLA BARNHART & SHIPLEY.

Josephine E. Wingo, Plaintiff, represented by Elizabeth L. Dudley , THE DUDLEY LAW FIRM.

Christina Lynn Ramirez-Nunez & Walter Enrique Ramirez-Nunez, Plaintiffs, represented by James F. Green , ASHCRAFT & GEREL & Michelle A. Parfitt , ASHCRAFT & GEREL.

Cruz Mendoza, Armando Gomez, Stephanie Sparks, Kathryn Czaplicki, Theodore Czaplicki, Reba Sachs, Nathan Sachs, Karen Monteiro & Mavis Herring, Plaintiffs, represented by Robert J. Fenstersheib , ROBERT J. FENSTERSHEIB & ASSOCIATES.

Theresa M. Seely & James Seely, Plaintiffs, represented by David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly A. Fitzpatrick , THE LANIER LAW FIRM & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Barry Williams, Dorothy Phillipy & Quincy Ali, Plaintiffs, represented by Rachel Beth Abrams , LEVIN SIMES, pro hac vice.

Joseph Wislocki, Bernard Derr, Vicky Rainsberger, Dennis Rainsberger, Rebecca Dunlap, David Dunlap, James Barker, Jason Raulston, Jo Ann Richard, Earl Richard & Joseph Waugh, Plaintiffs, represented by Jayne Conroy , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY, John J. Foley , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY & Trent B. Miracle , SIMMONS HANLY CONROY.

Sandra Meeks, Plaintiff, represented by Brian Loncar , LONCAR & ASSOCIATES.

Barbara Heckert Shock, Plaintiff, represented by Andrew Judson Hill, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, Gary B. Blasingame , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice & James B. Matthews, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY.

Allison Y. Ros, Michelle Ray, Mike Hyatt, Cynthia E. Hopper & Ines Silveira, Plaintiffs, represented by Jeremy R. Fietz , ADAMS FIETZ.

Georgettea Schucker, Plaintiff, represented by McDonald S. Worley , MCDONALD WORLEY & Michelle Rene Eddington , MCDONALD WORLEY.

Amy Stewart, Plaintiff, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, William T. Jones, Jr. , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, William W. Lundquist , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & William Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Rebecca L. Lawson & Rick Lawson, Plaintiffs, represented by Doris A. Kim , GRAY & WHITE, Mark K. Gray , GRAY & WHITE & Matthew L. White , GRAY & WHITE.

Elvira Collazo, Roberto Collazo & Wilma Alice Gassett, Plaintiffs, represented by Dana B. Taschner , pro hac vice, David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly A. Fitzpatrick , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Lee A. Cirsch , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, pro hac vice & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Kelly Burnheimer, Plaintiff, pro se.

Daniel Burnheimer, Plaintiff, pro se.

Imelda Guzman, Plaintiff, represented by Jacob Plattenberger , TOR HOERMAN LAW & Tor A. Hoerman , TOR HOERMAN LAW.

Jenny T. Santiago, Plaintiff, represented by Diane K. Watkins , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Norwood S. Wilner , THE WILNER FIRM, , pro hac vice & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Randy Rice, Chapter 7 Trustee, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin A. Bertram , BERTRAM & GRAF, George Robert Wise, Jr. , THE BRAD HENDRICKS LAW FIRM, J. Scott Bertram , BERTRAM & GRAF & James Lamar Porter , THE BRAD HENDRICKS LAW FIRM.

Susan Larsen, Plaintiff, represented by Michael S. Appel , SUGARMAN ROGERS BARSHAK & COHEN & Samuel M. Furgang , SUGARMAN ROGERS BARSHAK & COHEN.

Donna Kay Combs, Anita Fern Herbert, Mary Linda Lamb, Kathleen Pineda Abbatiello, Amie Howlett Goines, Deneen Andrade, Shannon Godfrey Arrington, Diana L. Bayne, Susan E. Perry, Cindy Bock, George Bock & Robert Llewellyn, Plaintiffs, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ.

Marilyn Kidd-Brier, Christopher L. Brier, Michael Boffington, Marguerite Rose Navarro & Jesus Navarro, Plaintiffs, represented by Lee B. Balefsky , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice & Michelle L. Tiger , KLINE & SPECTER, pro hac vice.

Dean Skinner & Tori Abdul-Samad, Plaintiffs, represented by Jim M. Perdue, Jr. , PERDUE KIDD & VICKERY.

Cindy Dunn, David Dunn & Harry Lambert, Jr., Plaintiffs, represented by Harry F. Bell, Jr. , THE BELL LAW FIRM.

Lisa J. Pickett, Jimmy D. Pickett, Janaan Burkhart, (Deceased), Sandra Peters, Willie Peters, Janice Reesor & Angelo Reesor, Plaintiffs, represented by Amy Collignon Gunn , THE SIMON LAW FIRM, pro hac vice & John G. Simon , THE SIMON LAW FIRM.

Jon Thackeray, Plaintiff, represented by Genevieve M. Zimmerman , MESHBESHER & SPENCE, pro hac vice.

Heather Trout & Ron Trout, Plaintiffs, represented by Casey A. Kaufman , THE BRANDI LAW FIRM & Thomas J. Brandi , THE BRANDI LAW FIRM.

Dawn E. Brown, Plaintiff, represented by Dana B. Taschner , pro hac vice, David Kuttles , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Kelly A. Fitzpatrick , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, Lee A. Cirsch , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, pro hac vice, Michael A. Akselrud , THE LANIER LAW FIRM, pro hac vice & W. Mark Lanier , THE LANIER LAW FIRM.

Gladys E. Katsiafas, Plaintiff, represented by Diane K. Watkins , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Norwood S. Wilner , THE WILNER FIRM, , pro hac vice.

Jill Johnson, Plaintiff, represented by Robin M. Myers , MURRAY LAW FIRM, Stephen B. Murray, Jr. , MURRAY LAW FIRM & Stephen B. Murray, Sr. , MURRAY LAW FIRM.

Barbara Branch, Plaintiff, represented by J. Mark Kell , KELL LAMPIN.

Juanita Young, Kenneth Young, W. Douglas White, Thomas Johnston, Richard Greve, Zeb Poindexter, III, Tyron Slaughter, Tom Bricker, Jeanne Cummings, Lynn Cummings, Michael Bowman, Rhonda Littleton & Loucella Solis, Plaintiffs, represented by John T. Boundas , WILLIAMS KHERKHER HART BOUNDAS & Sejal K. Brahmbhatt , WILLIAMS KHERKHER HART BOUNDAS.

Maria Gomez, Plaintiff, represented by Donald S. Edgar , SMITH DOLLAR, Jeremy R. Fietz , ADAMS FIETZ, Rex J. Grady , Fourth Floor, Matthew J. Sill , SILL & MEDLEY & Timothy M. Bunson , SILL LAW GROUP.

Tara Solnoki, Plaintiff, pro se.

Luelda Ruth Carter & Gary D. Carter, Plaintiffs, represented by Gregory L. Laker , COHEN & MALAD, pro hac vice, Irwin B. Levin , COHEN & MALAD, pro hac vice & Jeff S. Gibson , COHEN & MALAD, pro hac vice.

Sallie Kelly, Plaintiff, represented by Ernest W. Boyd, Jr. , THE BUTCH BOYD LAW FIRM & Joseph F. Archer , JOSEPH F. ARCHER.

Elizabeth Jouglard, Plaintiff, represented by James G. Onder , ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON & Mark R. Niemeyer , ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON.

Ann Bostwick, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew John Morrison , HARRISON DAVIS STEAKLEY MORRISON, Preston J. Dugas, III , PARKER MCDONALD, Ryan H. Anderson , PAESANI & KEATON, W. Bradley Parker , PAESANI & KEATON & Zollie C. Steakley , HARRISON DAVIS STEAKLEY MORRISON.

Angie B. Ramirez & Greg Warland, Plaintiffs, represented by Matthew R. McCarley , FEARS NACHAWATI.

Ana Aparicio, Plaintiff, represented by Ryan J. Browne , REYES BROWNE REILLEY & Spencer Paul Browne , REYES BROWNE REILLEY.

Cirila Iris Rojas, Plaintiff, represented by Andrew J. Fink , SOLIS LAW FIRM.

Janet Thomas & Edward Thomas, Plaintiffs, represented by Aaron Clark Johnson , SUMMERS & JOHNSON, David G. Summers , SUMMERS & JOHNSON, Diane K. Watkins , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Nathaniel McGraw Jones , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Mary E. Bradenburg, Thomas H. Bradenburg, Sandra P. Comer, Braxton B. Comer, Rhoda J. Barzak & Israel J. Barzak, Plaintiffs, represented by Jerrold S. Parker , PARKER WAICHMAN, Melanie H. Muhlstock , PARKER WAICHMAN & Raymond C. Silverman , PARKER WAICHMAN.

Veronica Miller & Timothy D. Miller, Plaintiffs, represented by Alyson Oliver , OLIVER LAW GROUP.

Mary Ann Bidwell, Cynthia Trott, John Smith, Lynda Smits-Binns, Greta Schell & Nancy Carolyn Adkins, Plaintiffs, represented by J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Jason A. Itkin , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Kurt B. Arnold , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Mark C. Sparks , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM & Noah M. Wexler , ARNOLD & ITKIN.

Amanda Gray, Plaintiff, pro se.

Frank Jackson, Plaintiff, represented by Bradley D. Honnold , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GOZA, Kirk J. Goza , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GOZA & Anne M. Tarvin , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GOZA.

Margaret Borax, Johanna Baron, Ariel Laureano, Diniece Buchannon, Keith Buchannon, Cordelia D. Miller, Todd S. Miller, Theresia Colleen Nester, Von R. Nester, Donna Lou Ogden, Janice Brown, Lloyd Brown, Patricia Jo Evans, Roger D. Evans, Linda Barbara Sylvestre & Barbara Jean Davison, Plaintiffs, represented by Donald A. Migliori , MOTLEY RICE, Fidelma L. Fitzpatrick , MOTLEY RICE, Fred Thompson, III , MOTLEY RICE & Jonathan D. Orent , MOTLEY RICE.

Bobby LaCrue, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel J. Carr , PEIFFER ROSCA ABDULLAH & CARR, Joseph C. Peiffer , PEIFFER ROSCA ABDULLAH & CARR & Michael Brady Lynch , THE MICHAEL BRADY LYNCH FIRM.

Carolyn Davenport & Darrel Davenport, Plaintiffs, represented by Sean Michael Cleary , LAW OFFICES OF SEAN M. CLEARY.

Ann Frady, Plaintiff, represented by McDonald S. Worley , MCDONALD WORLEY, Michelle Rene Eddington , MCDONALD WORLEY & William H. Barfield , THE POTTS LAW FIRM.

Pastora Cespedes, Plaintiff, represented by Diane K. Watkins , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Aundria Baker, Ricky Baker & Penny Cope, Plaintiffs, represented by Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM & Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM.

Frank Herron, Debra L. Williams & David R. Williams, Plaintiffs, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & Erin K. Copeland , FIBICH LEEBRON COPELAND BRIGGS JOSEPHSON.

Karen Jenkins, Jan McCarthy, Melissa Doyle & Randall Doyle, Plaintiffs, represented by Christopher A. Seeger , SEEGER WEISS & Sindhu S. Daniel , SEEGER WEISS.

Nancy Bennardo, Plaintiff, represented by Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, James Bartimus , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GOZA & Anne M. Tarvin , BARTIMUS FRICKLETON ROBERTSON & GOZA.

Margaret Raybon, Lisa Marie Malone & Michael Thomas Malone, Plaintiffs, represented by Lisa Ann Gorshe , JOHNSON BECKER, Michael K. Johnson , JOHNSON BECKER & Timothy J. Becker , JOHNSON BECKER.

Lonny Evans, Plaintiff, represented by Caroline Maida , MOSTYN LAW, J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM & Noah M. Wexler , ARNOLD & ITKIN.

Sara Evelyn Gary & Donald H. Gary, Jr., Plaintiffs, represented by Joshua David Christian , CHRISTIAN & DAVIS & W. Harold Christian, Jr. , CHRISTIAN & DAVIS.

Marisol Datil, Plaintiff, represented by Charles Bland Patrick , SCHLESINGER LAW OFFICES.

Vernon Dauer, Irma J. Gerrish, Lorena Ayala, Martin J. Ayala, Sr., Taffy Busch, Robert W. Bunch, Wanda Morales, Joann Bates, James Bates, Frances M. Clifford, Ima F. Standridge, Jim H. Standridge, Thomas D. Santacroce, Ernest Jackson, Jr., Perry H. Benton, Guardian Ad Litem for Dora J. Benton, Byron B. Kelley, Ileana Garcia Rojas, Frank S. Owen, Miguel Cruz, Linda K. Ewart, Pamela Will, Dauneen Abel, Heidi L. Hutson, Manuel Martinez, Joanne H. Briggs & Wallace L. Briggs, Plaintiffs, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & William Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Scott D. Hersh, Sharon Dolores Castle, Craig Forte, Executor, Diane Marie Wernet & Paul Wermet, Plaintiffs, represented by Howard L. Nations , THE NATIONS LAW FIRM.

Marilyn Macias, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Karen Barth Menzies , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Mark P. Robinson, Jr. , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS & Shannon Lukei , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS.

Judy K. Vessell, Plaintiff, represented by Everette S. Verhine , VERHINE & VERHINE & Robert Cloar .

Linda Huerta & Jose Huerta, Plaintiffs, represented by Alex Barlow , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK, Bill Robins, III , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK & John M. Black , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK.

Rosa Elia Rodriguez, Steven Rodriguez, Jaelee S. Jones, William Jones, Sherri Lynn Dalton, Darrin Lee Dalton, David Lopez, Carol Jean Gonzales-Crabtree, Max E. Smith, II & Beverly Schreiber-Hester, Plaintiffs, represented by Deborah Kay Levy , BAILEY PERRIN BAILEY, Derek H. Potts , THE POTTS LAW FIRM, Harris Junell , BAILEY PERRIN BAILEY & Timothy L. Sifers , THE POTTS LAW FIRM.

Cathleen A. Carrillo & Paul A. Carrillo, Plaintiffs, represented by Jack T. Hyde , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Norwood S. Wilner , THE WILNER FIRM, , pro hac vice & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Debra Kelley, Pamela S. Peckinpaugh, Mary Ellen Schmitt & Keith J. Schmitt, Plaintiffs, represented by Edward A. Wallace , WEXLER WALLACE & Michael H. Bowman , WEXLER WALLACE.

Deretha Mae Omiotek, Plaintiff, pro se.

Pamela Justice, Plaintiff, represented by David P. Matthews , MATTHEWS & ASSOCIATES, Julie L. Rhoades , MATTHEWS & ASSOCIATES, Kevin L. Edwards , FREESE & GOSS, Matthew J. Sill , SILL & MEDLEY, Peter De La Cerda , EDWARDS & DE LA CERDA, Richard Arthur Freese , FREESE & GOSS, Tamara L. Banno , FREESE & GOSS, Tim K. Goss , FREESE & GOSS & Timothy M. Bunson , SILL LAW GROUP.

Amanda Smith, Cheryl Arrington, Diana Boudreaux & Rebecca McVey, Plaintiffs, represented by Hunter J. Shkolnik , NAPOLI BERN RIPKA SHKOLNIK & ASSOCIATES.

Michel Aranda, Plaintiff, represented by Levi M. Plesset , MILSTEIN JACKSON FAIRCHILD AND WADE.

Wanda Wilson & Jimmy Wilson, Plaintiffs, represented by Benjamin A. Bertram , BERTRAM & GRAF & J. Scott Bertram , BERTRAM & GRAF.

Mary Leos, Plaintiff, represented by Debra J. Humphrey , MARC J. BERN & PARTNERS, Hunter J. Shkolnik , NAPOLI BERN RIPKA SHKOLNIK & ASSOCIATES & Margaret E. Cordner , MARC J. BERN & PARTNERS.

Hayley McClesky & Cornelia Harvey, Plaintiffs, represented by Matthew J. Sill , SILL & MEDLEY, Tim K. Goss , FREESE & GOSS & Timothy M. Bunson , SILL LAW GROUP.

Nereida Cintron, Pamela Adams, Patricia Bennett, Jeneva Jones, Willie Mathews, Frances Medina, Jennifer Alger, Sharon Ambrose, Maggie Anderson, Dorothy F Arnold, Rebecca Baladez, Alberta Barney, Sandra Bellmire, Sharon Bench, Gwen Berrier, Peggy Boss, Cornelia Brantley, Amy Bray, Cheryl Bryant, Lena Bushong, Corita Caldwell, Francine Calvary, Lillie Clay, Mary Ann Cleary, Sandra Clemons, Ola Coffman, Lela Contreras, Judy Cox, Ruth Cupp, Christine Dalton, Alberta Darcy Murray, Betty Degramo, Ouida Di Petrillo, Susan Dombrowski, Beverly Donohoo, Maveline Eaves, Sandra Ebert, Vivian Eccles, Barbara Emmert, Angela Epley, Glaciela Faulkner, Eilene Fincher, Loretta Fraijo, Criselda Garza, Patricia Gesford, Mary Gonzales, Joanne Gray, Judy Hallman, Barbara Hamm, Sharon Hampton, Ruby Harris, Helen Harris, Debbie Heath, Carla Hennies, Doris Hensinger, Shirley Herring, Jeannette Holley, Marlena Horne, Debra Hughes, Nina Humphries, Mary Ingram, Janie H Iven, Joan Jensen, Shelley Johnson, Patricia Keating, Debra Kelly, Kimberly Renea Knight, Laurie Kreeger, Rebecca Lane, Diane Lentz, Freda Lewis, Marinell Lightfoot, Caroline Long, Sherry Long, Nancy Lopez, Ruth Mares, Sylvia McClellan, Victoria McConville, Maria Mendoza, O'Shera Middleton, Sandra Millegan, Billie Moss-McElroy, Karen Moulton, Swadesh Mullick, Lisa Nau, Leone Nelson, Brenda Opperman, Kimberly Phillips, Dianne Pitt, Janine Porter, Connie Quiroga, Sophie Rafidi, Deborah Rawdon-Davies, Linda Rieth & Brenda Rose, Plaintiffs, represented by Matthew J. Sill , SILL & MEDLEY & Timothy M. Bunson , SILL LAW GROUP.

Kathy Weckesser, Louis Weckesser, III, Cheryl Sorrell-Knight, Wade Knight & Timothy Scott, Plaintiffs, represented by J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Jason A. Itkin , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Kurt B. Arnold , ARNOLD & ITKIN & Noah M. Wexler , ARNOLD & ITKIN.

Vickie L. Eldrige & Michael Eldrige, Plaintiffs, represented by Zachary Peter Lowe , LOWE LAW GROUP.

Annamarie Bartolome, Plaintiff, represented by Dylan Franklin Pollard , POLLARD BAILEY & Steven J. Brady , BRADY LAW GROUP.

Scot Sarbacker, Tamara Sarbacker, Vilma Velarde, Michael Velarde & Stephen Fusfeld, Plaintiffs, represented by Aimee H. Wagstaff , ANDRUS & WAGSTAFF, Marc D. Grossman , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN & Randi Kassan , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN.

Rosemary S. Roberts, Plaintiff, represented by Thomas F. Basile , THE LAW OFFICE OF THOMAS F. BASILE.

Jennifer Kay Shelton, Plaintiff, pro se.

Rosaida Alonso, Plaintiff, represented by Bryan F. Aylstock , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, pro hac vice, D. Renee Baggett , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Daniel J. Thornburgh , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Douglass Alan Kreis , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ, Nathan C. Bess , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ & S. Mary Liu , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ.

Leida Faye Seay & Howard Seay, Plaintiffs, represented by Daniel Patrick Barton , BARTON LAW FIRM & Ryan Keith Haun , BARTON LAW FIRM.

Vickie J. Crowe, Plaintiff, represented by Andrea Little Gentle , DANIELS & GENTLE, Douglas A. Daniels , DANIELS & GENTLE & Leslie C. MacLean , WATERS & KRAUS.

Lisa Hughes, Deceased & Cassondra Hughes, Personal Rep, Plaintiffs, represented by Christopher W. Cantrell , DOYLE LOWTHER, J. Gerard Stranch, IV , BRANSTETTER STRANCH & JENNINGS, pro hac vice & William J. Doyle, II , DOYLE LOWTHER.

Yanira Ramos, Miguel Santana & Cathy Whisnant, Plaintiffs, represented by W. James Singleton , THE SINGLETON LAW FIRM.

Lorraine Szczepanik, Plaintiff, represented by John J. Driscoll , THE DRISCOLL FIRM.

Shirley Brown, Plaintiff, represented by Sean Patrick Tracey , TRACEY & FOX LAW FIRM & Shawn P. Fox , TRACEY & FOX LAW FIRM.

Carolyn Allen & James Allen, Plaintiffs, represented by Gregory Neil McEwen , MCEWEN LAW FIRM.

Earlean S. Hill & Edward Hill, Jr., Plaintiffs, represented by Jason J. Thompson , SOMMERS SCHWARTZ.

Catherine I. Taylor, Denice Greiner & David S. Greiner, Plaintiffs, represented by Tamara L. Banno , FREESE & GOSS & Tim K. Goss , FREESE & GOSS.

Ezequiel Ramirez, Plaintiff, represented by Ethan Lee Shaw , SHAW COWART & Justin William Fishback , SHAW COWART.

Billy England, Plaintiff, represented by Charles W. Miller , HEYGOOD ORR & PEARSON & John W. Pate , HEYGOOD ORR & PEARSON.

Katherine Hesson & David Hesson, Plaintiffs, represented by Lauren E. Channell , SIEGFRIED & JENSEN & Mark Rogers Taylor , SIEGFRIED & JENSEN.

Carole A. Gould & Ronald Gould, Plaintiffs, represented by Daniel S. Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Karen Barth Menzies , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Mark P. Robinson, Jr. , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Shannon Lukei , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS & Willard J. Moody, Jr. , THE MOODY LAW FIRM.

Lynda Cozzeus, Plaintiff, represented by Andrew J. Cross , CAREY DANIS & LOWE, pro hac vice, Jeffrey J. Lowe , CAREY DANIS & LOWE & Sarah Shoemake Doles , CARY DANIS & LOWE.

Helen Bradshaw, Linda Johnson, Betty Mcleish & Christina Krikorian, Plaintiffs, represented by Marc D. Grossman , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN & Randi Kassan , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN.

Sylvia Burgess, Plaintiff, pro se.

Tonya Curtis, Plaintiff, pro se.

Gregory Lamm, Plaintiff, represented by J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Jason A. Itkin , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Kurt B. Arnold , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Mark C. Sparks , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Noah M. Wexler , ARNOLD & ITKIN & Richard B. North, Jr. , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH.

Neva Noble & Paul Noble, Plaintiffs, represented by Lee Lawrence Coleman , HUGHES & COLEMAN & Richard B. North, Jr. , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH.

Teresa McCurley & Robert McCurley, Plaintiffs, represented by G. Sean Jez , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ, Merrida P. Coxwell, Jr. , COXWELL & ASSOCIATES & Rand Patrick Nolen , FLEMING NOLEN & JEZ.

Stephanie Wallace, Plaintiff, represented by David A. Cutt , EISENBERG GILCHRIST & CUTT.

Chasity D. Antrim, Plaintiff, represented by Leslie C. MacLean , WATERS & KRAUS.

Pamela Berman, Cleon Clark, Susan Fraser, Julie Hennessy, Frances Labrador, Dana McCoy, Cathleen McGuire, Bryn O'Conner, Dora Perez, Judy Roberts, Julie Scholfield, Ramona Stewart, Guadalupe Tejeda, Sara Vandegrift & Pamela Wright, Plaintiffs, represented by Andrew J. Cross , CAREY DANIS & LOWE, pro hac vice, Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Jeffrey J. Lowe , CAREY DANIS & LOWE, John J. Carey , CAREY DANIS & LOWE, Joseph J. Danis , CAREY DANIS & LOWE, Josh B. Wages , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice, Michael T. Gallagher , THE GALLAGHER LAW FIRM, Sarah Shoemake Doles , CARY DANIS & LOWE, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & William Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Elizabeth Kobata, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Daniel S. Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Karen Barth Menzies , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Mark P. Robinson, Jr. , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Richard B. North, Jr. , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & Shannon Lukei , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS.

Emma Smith, Elizabeth Tompkins & Barbara Bauman, Plaintiffs, represented by Amanda Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Daniel S. Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Karen Barth Menzies , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Mark P. Robinson, Jr. , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS & Shannon Lukei , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS.

Doris Jett, Carol Lovely, Mary Andrews, Lorriane Debray, Carol Nygaard, Kim Mai, Margie Harris, Kathy Carter, Gloria Ronning, Lana Justice, Carrie Tomlinson, Christy Peterson, Margaret Durnan, Jerri Moran, Helga Chrisekos, Beverly Sellers, Margaret Byrd, Nancy Hall, Ramona Lane, Nora Bermejo, Gloria Dominguez, Lauran Stroffolino, Adela Mata, Elda Suarez, Mamie Threet, Lisa Townsend, Martha Jones, Colleen Kahler, Darlene Gutzman, Annette Mueller, Kelly Kirkendall, Mary Pisor, Cynthia Mercede, Trenny McCluskey, Dixie Henrie, Graciela Martinez, Anita Custer, Delores McCormack, Janice Barron, Alberta Murray & Erminie Olah, Plaintiffs, represented by Amanda Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Daniel S. Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Karen Barth Menzies , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Mark P. Robinson, Jr. , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & Shannon Lukei , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS.

Windi Parker, Plaintiff, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Victor Chironos, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Daniel S. Robinson , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Karen Barth Menzies , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Mark P. Robinson, Jr. , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Shannon Lukei , ROBINSON CALCAGNIE ROBINSON SHAPIRO DAVIS & William Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Frimal H. Baker & Beryl A. Baker, Plaintiffs, represented by Michelle A. Parfitt , ASHCRAFT & GEREL & Stephanie Gardner , ASHCRAFT & GEREL.

Kathryn L. Ciotti & Robert Ciotti, Plaintiffs, represented by Robert T. Naumes, Jr. , THE LAW OFFICES OF JEFFREY S. GLASSMAN.

Jo-Ann Henry & Tommy Glen Henry, Plaintiffs, represented by Paulina Do Amaral , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN & Wendy R. Fleishman , LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN.

Judy Nachtigall, Ronnie Nachtigall & Yanet Diaz, Plaintiffs, represented by Alan S. Lazar , MARLIN & SALTZMAN, Christina A. Humphrey , MARLIN & SALTZMAN, Kiley L. Grombacher , MARLIN & SALTZMAN & Marcus J. Bradley , MARLIN & SALTZMAN.

Veronica Rascon, Plaintiff, represented by Caroline Maida , MOSTYN LAW, J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Jason A. Itkin , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Justin R. Kaufman , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK, Kurt B. Arnold , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Mark C. Sparks , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Micajah D. Boatright , ARNOLD & ITKIN, pro hac vice & Noah M. Wexler , ARNOLD & ITKIN.

Evelyn Hill, Robert Hill & Stephanie Le Ann Johnson, Plaintiffs, represented by Caryn Michele Papantonakis , JOHNSON LAW GROUP.

Karen L. Owens, Plaintiff, represented by Douglas Robert Plymale , PLYMALE LAW FIRM & James R. Dugan, II , THE DUGAN LAW FIRM.

Charlotte Swiney, Plaintiff, represented by Brian John Leinbach , ENGSTROM LIPSCOMB & LACK, Gregory P. Waters , ENGSTROM LIPSCOMB & LACK & Walter J. Lack , ENGSTROM LIPSCOMB & LACK.

Andrew Brown & Jacqueline Brown, Plaintiffs, represented by Michael S. Kruse , ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON.

Wilford Thomas Noland, Plaintiff, represented by Andrew J. Cross , CAREY DANIS & LOWE, pro hac vice, Evan Buxner , THE BUXNER LAW FIRM, Jeffrey J. Lowe , CAREY DANIS & LOWE & Sarah Shoemake Doles , CARY DANIS & LOWE.

Wilma Brown, Plaintiff, represented by Douglas Robert Plymale , PLYMALE LAW FIRM, James R. Dugan, II , THE DUGAN LAW FIRM & Richard B. North, Jr. , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH.

Lorena M. Espinoza, Plaintiff, represented by Greg A. Vigna , Larissa Davis , BOSSIER & ASSOCIATES, Leslie W. O'Leary , JOHNSON JOHNSON LUCAS & MIDDLETON, pro hac vice & Sheila M. Bossier , FREESE & GOSS.

Bobby Wright, Plaintiff, represented by Alex Barlow , HEARD ROBINS CLOUD & BLACK.

Rebecca Koch, Plaintiff, represented by Caroline Underwood Hollingsworth , HENINGER GARRISON DAVIS, Christopher B. Hood , HENINGER GARRISON DAVIS, W. Lewis Garrison, Jr. , HENINGER GARRISON DAVIS & William L. Bross , HENINGER GARRISON DAVIS.

Linda Totton, Plaintiff, represented by Michael A. London , DOUGLAS & LONDON.

Marie Henry, Plaintiff, represented by Lisa Ann Gorshe , JOHNSON BECKER, Michael K. Johnson , JOHNSON BECKER, Stacy K. Hauer , JOHNSON BECKER & Timothy J. Becker , JOHNSON BECKER.

Tammie Mecham & Dennie Mecham, Plaintiffs, represented by Alan Tucker , DRIGGS BILLS & DAY, Britt Alicia Birkenbuel , DRIGGS BILLS & DAY & Karolina S. Kulesza , DRIGGS BILLS & DAY.

Judy Meisenheimer, Plaintiff, represented by Richard B. North, Jr. , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH & Scott David McLeod , ELKUS SISSON & ROSENSTEIN.

Angela Reynolds & John Reynolds, Plaintiffs, represented by Jeffrey S. Glassman , THE LAW OFFICES OF JEFFREY S. GLASSMAN, Margaret S. Weiss , LAW OFFICES OF JEFFREY S. GLASSMAN & Robert T. Naumes, Jr. , THE LAW OFFICES OF JEFFREY S. GLASSMAN.

Marta Gardunio, Veronica Madsen & James Madsen, Plaintiffs, represented by Jacob Plattenberger , TOR HOERMAN LAW, Raymond Joseph Kramer , TORHOERMAN LAW & Steven D. Davis , TOR HOERMAN LAW.

Janet S Joseph, Plaintiff, represented by C. Todd Alley , ALLEY CLARK & GREIWE & Katherine Chambers , ALLEY CLARK & GREIWE.

Sallie Booth, David W. Booth, Lynne Diane Wilson, Clarence J. Wilson, Jr., Dorothy Miller, Linda Ulrich, Joseph Ulrich, Sr., Laura Miller, Karen Stocking, David Stocking, Madie Louise Slater & Louie Slater, Plaintiffs, represented by Caroline Maida , MOSTYN LAW, J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Jason A. Itkin , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Kurt B. Arnold , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Mark C. Sparks , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM & Noah M. Wexler , ARNOLD & ITKIN.

Becky Smith, Plaintiff, represented by Danny L. Curtis , DANNY L. CURTIS, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, Lindsey Scarcello , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Donald Mackie, Plaintiff, represented by Danny L. Curtis , DANNY L. CURTIS, Jeffrey M. Kuntz , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL & Thomas P. Cartmell , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Donald Mackie, Plaintiff, pro se.

Susan Heath, Plaintiff, represented by Lindsey Scarcello , WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL.

Pamela G. Jernigan, Plaintiff, represented by Scott David McLeod , ELKUS SISSON & ROSENSTEIN.

Lynn Nabors-McNally & John McNally, Plaintiffs, represented by Richard J. Plezia , RICHARD J. PLEZIA & ASSOCIATES.

Robin Warren, Plaintiff, represented by Anne Vankirk , DRIGGS BILLS & DAY, Britt Alicia Birkenbuel , DRIGGS BILLS & DAY & Karolina S. Kulesza , DRIGGS BILLS & DAY.

Lonny Warren, Plaintiff, represented by Howard Stuart Ross , ROSS LAW OFFICES, Britt Alicia Birkenbuel , DRIGGS BILLS & DAY & Karolina S. Kulesza , DRIGGS BILLS & DAY.

Kathy Bushfield, Plaintiff, represented by Brad Feit , DRIGGS BILLS & DAY, Britt Alicia Birkenbuel , DRIGGS BILLS & DAY & Karolina S. Kulesza , DRIGGS BILLS & DAY.

Tim Bushfield, Plaintiff, represented by Dan Charles Bolton , KELLER FISHBACK & JACKSON, Britt Alicia Birkenbuel , DRIGGS BILLS & DAY & Karolina S. Kulesza , DRIGGS BILLS & DAY.

Sharon McCormick, Plaintiff, represented by Karolina S. Kulesza , DRIGGS BILLS & DAY.

Vicki Lucas & Donnie Lucas, Plaintiffs, represented by Caroline Maida , MOSTYN LAW, J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Jason A. Itkin , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Kurt B. Arnold , ARNOLD & ITKIN, Mark C. Sparks , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM, Noah M. Wexler , ARNOLD & ITKIN & Richard B. North, Jr. , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH.

Beverly D. Brown, Zoila L. Moreno, Marion J. Hughart, Mary Velcich, Brenda Wilson, Terri Mullin, Lora Lee Craton, Tammy Lynn Rogers, Theresa Holloway, Charlotte McGuire, Theresa A. Cassidy, Helene Hoffman, Joyce Jackson, Lucila G. Varela, Jacquelyn Marie Potter, Rebecca Garcia, April Wellington, Mae E. Coffman, Phyllis M. Chase, Thomas S. Chase, Power of Attorney, Rosa E. Herrera, Connie Wagner, Wanda E. Gonzalez, Sandra Kloss, Kimberly Martinez, Betty A. McAllister, Connie Lynn McClain, Lamar Hernandez, Rita A. Smith & Betty S. Daniels, Plaintiffs, represented by J. Steven Mostyn , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM & Mark C. Sparks , THE MOSTYN LAW FIRM.

Kimberly Jo Bohartz, Plaintiff, represented by Lawrence King Holcomb , FLINT LAW FIRM.

Angela Morgan, Plaintiff, represented by Andrew Callahan , FLINT LAW FIRM & Jacob Alex Flint , FLINT LAW FIRM.

Stephanie R. Salzman & Kevin Salzman, Plaintiffs, represented by Clayton A. Clark , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Lauren Schultz , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, Richard B. North, Jr. , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, Scott A. Love , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON & William Michael Moreland , CLARK LOVE & HUTSON.

Deborah Elias, Plaintiff, pro se.

Monica Stansberry, Plaintiff, pro se.

Kay Gnegy, Plaintiff, represented by Derek T. Braslow , POGUST BRASLOW & MILLROOD, Lisa L. Causey , SALIM-BEASLEY, Mark Edward Berns , ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON & Patty Ann Trantham , AYLSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ.

Warren Gnegy, Plaintiff, represented by Derek T. Braslow , POGUST BRASLOW & MILLROOD & Mark Edward Berns , ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON.

Donya Smith, Plaintiff, represented by Derek T. Braslow , POGUST BRASLOW & MILLROOD, Lisa L. Causey , SALIM-BEASLEY, Mark Edward Berns , ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON & Randi Kassan , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN.

Ray R. Smith, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Derek T. Braslow , POGUST BRASLOW & MILLROOD, Mark Edward Berns , ONDER SHELTON O'LEARY & PETERSON & Randi Kassan , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN.

Leigh Sparks, Plaintiff, represented by Maureen Jane Duris , O'HARA & DURIS.

Terrence Sparks, Plaintiff, represented by Sheila M. Bossier , FREESE & GOSS.

C. R. Bard, Inc., Defendant, represented by Aaron A. Clark , MCGRATH NORTH MULLIN & KRATZ, Adonica Starke-Melson , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Alena M. Markley , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Alexander Julian Hall , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Alexandra Joelle Block , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Alexis Anne Rochlin , REED SMITH, Alison Anne Verret , MCAFEE & TAFT, Allison Ng , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Allison Stewart , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Amanda R. McKinzie , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Amanda Naes Shelton , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, Amber L. Duffy , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Amy Elizabeth Dehnel , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Amy Maria T. Vanni , REED SMITH, Andrew Lacy, Jr. , REED SMITH, Andrew Zachery Ryan Smith , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Andrew J. Trevelise , REED SMITH, Angela Ashley Korge , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Anna B. Laakmann , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Annabelle L. Torgman , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Antony B. Klapper , REED SMITH, Ben M. Allen , ALLEN SHEPHERD LEWIS SYRA & CHAPMAN, Bina Palnitkar , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Bradly A. Nankerville , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Brett Linden McClure , REED SMITH, Brian Patrick Cadigan , REED SMITH, Brian D. Straw , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Britt M. Roberts , REED SMITH, Candace Headen Uduebor , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Cassandra Lee Matos , REED SMITH, Chad E. Adams , BROWNING KALECZYC BERRY & HOVEN, Charles Wade Bowden , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Charles H. Crawford, III , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Charles Matthew Smith , THE WEATHINGTON FIRM, Chelsea Emma Koff , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Christine Marie Neuharth , REED SMITH, Christopher M. Butler , REED SMITH, Christopher Anthony Mair , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Christopher Walker , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Christopher P. Winters , ALLEN SHEPHERD LEWIS SYRA & CHAPMAN, Clarence Davis , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Colin E. Seale , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Courtland Carter Chillingworth , REED SMITH, Dale Rose Goldstein , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Daniel C. Kirby , REED SMITH, Daniel M. Rabinovitz , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Daniel I.A. Smulian , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Daniel K. Winters , REED SMITH, Danielle N. Garno , GREENBERG TRAURIG, David Odalis Batista , GREENBERG TRAURIG, David On Chang , REED SMITH, David J. Walz , CARLTON FIELDS, Deborah A. Moeller , SHOOK HARDY BACON, Debra A. Djupman , REED SMITH, Edward W. Gerecke , CARLTON FIELDS, Elizabeth Graham Minerd , REED SMITH, Elizabeth Susan Ralph , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Emily Marie Adams , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Emily Hannigan Bryan , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Eric L. Alexander , REED SMITH, Eric J. Buhr , REED SMITH, Eric F. Gladbach , REED SMITH, Eric Cesar Schnapp , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Eric W. Swanis , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Ernest Paul Gieger, Jr. , GIEGER LABORDE & LAPEROUSE, Ezekiel Rediker , REED SMITH, Felicia V. Manno , GREENBERG TRAURIG, George S. Wang , SIMPSON THACHER & BARTLETT, Gerardo J. Rodriguez-Albizu , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Gregory T. Sturges , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Hayley Easton , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Hiba Kazim , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Ilana Haramati , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Irvin Hernandez , GREENBERG TRAURIG, J. Daniel Hoven , BROWNING KALECZYC BERRY & HOVEN, Jaclyn M. Setili , REED SMITH, Jacqueline E. Tambone , GREENBERG TRAURIG, James Z. Foster , GREENBERG TRAURIG, James Thomas Hewitt , PFEIFFER GLEATON WYATT HEWITT, Jane T. Davis , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, Janis E. Clements , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Janna S. Nugent , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Jason Stephen Allard , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Jason Henry Okleshen , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Jennifer Michelle Gomez , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Jennifer J. Hageman , ULMER & BERNE, Jennifer Marie Little , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Jennifer B. Moore , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Jesse J. Ash , REED SMITH, Jessica L. Gold , REED SMITH, John C. Duane , MOTLEY RICE, John A. LaBoon , SEGAL MCCAMBRIDGE SINGER & MAHONEY, Jonathan Brantley Bass , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Jonathan Michael Young , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Joseph M. McLaughlin , SIMPSON THACHER & BARTLETT, Joshua Benjamin Portnoy , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Juan Martinez , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Julia D. Riedel Emfinger , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Justin Benjamin Aronson , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Karlin Sangdahl , REED SMITH, Karusha Y. Sharpe , GREENBURG TRAURIG, Katherine Lynn Elsbernd , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Kathleen M. Kline , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Katrina M. Kershner , REED SMITH, Kelly H. Hibbert , REED SMITH, Kevin George Lohman , REED SMITH, Kristen A. Bradley , REED SMITH, Kristen Alicia Corpion , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Kristin H. Agnew , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Leah P. Collins , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Lennon B. Haas , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Lindsay DeFrancesco , REED SMITH, Lori G. Cohen , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Lucia Marker-Moore , GREENBERG TRAURIG, M. Antonio Gallegos , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Marcella Coladangelo Ducca , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Marcin S. Kedziora , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Marilyn Ann Moberg , REED SMITH, Mark A. Sentenac , REED SMITH, Maryanne C. Woo , REED SMITH, Matthew E. Brown , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, Matthew D. Jacobson , REED SMITH, Melissa A. Geist , REED SMITH, Melissa J. Oretsky , REED SMITH, Meredith Knudsen , REED SMITH, Michael Thomas Baier , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Michael K. Brown , REED SMITH, Michael C. Hermann , BOYLE BRASHER, Michael L. Johnson , OTJEN VAN ERT & WEIR, Michael Laurence Mandell , REED SMITH, Michael H. Moody , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Michael E. Pastore , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Michelle Lyu Cheng , REED SMITH, Mildred Segura , REED SMITH, Mitchell A. Robinson , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Molly Q. Campbell , REED SMITH, Monica M. Ortiz , REED SMITH, Nabil Anthony Bisharat , REED SMITH, Natassia Kwan , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Nedda Reghabi Gales , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Nicholas Shea Davis , SIMPSON THACHER & BARTLETT, Oliver K. Beiersdorf , REED SMITH, Patrick G. Broderick , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Paul Del Aguila , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Paul Brown Kerlin , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Paul E. Weathington , THE WEATHINGTON FIRM, Peter K. Lacina , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Peter H. Vogel , REED SMITH, Rachel G. Webre , GIEGER LABORDE & LAPEROUSE, Rebekah S. Guyon , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Richard E. Boyle , BOYLE BRASHER, Richard M. Eldridge , ELDRIDGE COOPER STEICHEN & LEACH, Richard Craig Woods , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Ritu Kelotra , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Robert R. Kane, III , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Robin L. Scott , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Ronald Merrell, II , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Roxanne McClure Wilson , REED SMITH, Sara Deskins Tucker , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Sarah Barrows , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Sarah Barr Johansen , REED SMITH, Sarah Marie Mathews , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Sarah Holt Richardson , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Sean P. Jessee , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Sean Allan Newland , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Sebastian Colley , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Spencer D. Wein , REED SMITH, Stephanie Danielle Ahmad , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Stephanie Peral , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Stephen Todd Fowler , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Stephen M. Ullmer , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Steven James Boranian , REED SMITH, Symone Danielle Shinton , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Taryn Walker Harper , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Thomas J. Mazziotti , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Thomas E. Steichen , MCAFEE & TAFT, Tiffany M. Andras , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Todd M. Weir , OTJEN VAN ERT & WEIR, Tsedey A. Bogale , REED SMITH, Vani R. Singhal , MCAFEE & TAFT, Victoria J. Langton , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Brandee Jarski Kowalzyk , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, J. Crisman Palmer , GUNDERSON PALMER GOODSELL & NELSON, John Anderson Camp , CARLTON FIELDS, Marc E. Williams , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, Matthew Brian Lerner , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, Melissa Foster Bird , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, Richard B. North, Jr. , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, pro hac vice & Taylor Tapley Daly , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, pro hac vice.

Covidien Inc., doing business as Sofradim Production, Defendant, represented by David On Chang , REED SMITH, Devin K. Ross , SHOOK HARDY BACON, Holly Stein Sollod , HOLLAND & HART, John Anderson Camp , CARLTON FIELDS, Lindsay Nicole Uhl , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Marc E. Williams , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, Richard B. North, Jr. , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, pro hac vice & Michael D. Moeller , SHOOK HARDY & BACON, pro hac vice.

Covidien plc, Defendant, represented by Charles Wade Bowden , GREENBERG TRAURIG, David On Chang , REED SMITH, M. Paul Reynolds , THE WEATHINGTON FIRM & Paul Del Aguila , GREENBERG TRAURIG.

Covidien International Finance, SA, Floreane Medical Implants SA & Mareane, SA, Defendants, represented by Charles Wade Bowden , GREENBERG TRAURIG, David On Chang , REED SMITH, Holly Stein Sollod , HOLLAND & HART & Paul Del Aguila , GREENBERG TRAURIG.

Sofradim Production SAS, Defendant, represented by Charles Wade Bowden , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Christopher Dean Dusseault , GIBSON DUNN & CRUTCHER, Don R. Sensabaugh, Jr. , FLAHERTY SENSABAUGH & BONASSO, Jennifer Stonecipher Hill , SHOOK HARDY & BACON, John D. Hoblitzell, III , KAY CASTO & CHANEY, Lauren Allyn Eber , GIBSON DUNN & CRUTCHER, John Anderson Camp , CARLTON FIELDS, Matthew Edward DePaz , SHOOK HARDY & BACON, Rebecca A. Betts , KAY CASTO & CHANEY, Brooke Harrison McCarthy , HOLLAND & HART, Ilissa Stacy Samplin , GIBSON DUNN & CRUTCHER & Micah L. Hobbs , SHOOK HARDY & BACON.

Cook Biotech, Inc., is a corporation with its principal place of business in Indiana, Defendant, represented by Douglas B. King , WOODEN & MCLAUGHLIN, James M. Boyers , WOODEN & MCLAUGHLIN & Jere Ann Rosebrock , WOODEN MCLAUGHLIN.

Tissue Science Laboratories Limited, Defendant, represented by Adrienne E. Van Winkle , WILLIAMS & CONNOLLY, Christopher S. McRae , SHOOK HARDY & BACON, Don R. Sensabaugh, Jr. , FLAHERTY SENSABAUGH & BONASSO, Jena Neuscheler , WILLIAMS & CONNOLLY, Andrew J. McElaney, Jr. , NUTTER MCCLENNEN & FISH, Christopher Dean Dusseault , GIBSON DUNN & CRUTCHER, Joseph G. Petrosinelli , WILLIAMS & CONNOLLY, John D. Hoblitzell, III , KAY CASTO & CHANEY, Matthew P. Ritchie , NUTTER MCCLENNEN & FISH, Rebecca M. Gosch , SHOOK HARDY & BACON & Rebecca A. Betts , KAY CASTO & CHANEY.

Covidien LLC, Defendant, represented by David On Chang , REED SMITH.

American Medical Systems, Inc., Defendant, represented by Barbara R. Binis , REED SMITH, Catherine R. Atwood , WOMBLE CARLYLE SANDRIDGE & RICE, Erik W. Legg , FARRELL FARRELL & FARRELL, Michael J. Farrell , FARRELL WHITE & LEGG, Samuel W. Outten , WOMBLE CARLYLE SANDRIDGE & RICE, Sandra L.W. Miller , WOMBLE CARLYLE SANDRIDGE & RICE, Tamela J. White , FARRELL WHITE & LEGG & Tracy G. Weiss , REED SMITH.

Laurens County Health Care System, doing business as Laurens County Hospital, Defendant, represented by Edwin Brown Parkinson, Jr. , DEVLIN & PARKINSON & Jennifer B. Howe , DEVLIN & PARKINSON.

Johnson & Johnson, Defendant, represented by Susan M. Robinson , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, William E. Lawton , DEAN RINGERS MORGAN & LAWTON & William M. Gage , BUTLER SNOW.

Ethicon, Inc., Defendant, represented by Michael B. Hissam , HISSAM FORMAN DONOVAN RITCHIE, David B. Thomas , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN, Laura H. Dixon , BUTLER SNOW & Susan M. Robinson , THOMAS COMBS & SPANN.

Ethicon Women's Health and Urology, Defendant, represented by Laura H. Dixon , BUTLER SNOW.

Boston Scientific Corporation, Defendant, represented by Brannon Jones Arnold , WEINBERG WHEELER HUDGINS GUNN & DIAL, Bryan Pratt , SHOOK HARDY & BACON, Johnathan T. Krawcheck , WEINBERG WHEELER HUDGINS GUNN & DIAL, pro hac vice, Jon A. Strongman , SHOOK HARDY & BACON, Matthew D. Keenan , SHOOK HARDY & BACON, Michael Bonasso , FLAHERTY SENSABAUGH & BONASSO, Robert T. Adams , SHOOK HARDY & BACON & Eric M. Anielak , SHOOK HARDY & BACON.

Mentor Worldwide LLC, Defendant, represented by Dustin B. Rawlin , TUCKER ELLIS & WEST, John Q. Lewis , JONES DAY REAVIS & POGUE & Marcella Coladangelo Ducca , GREENBERG TRAURIG.

Generic Medical Devices, Inc., Defendant, represented by Carolyn Purwin , CIPRIANI & WERNER, Ernest F. Koschineg , CIPRIANI & WERNER & Kelly C. Scheese , KENT & MCBRIDE.

J-Pac, LLC, Defendant, represented by Marcella Coladangelo Ducca , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Carolyn Purwin , CIPRIANI & WERNER, Constantine J. Passodelis , JONESPASSODELIS & Jason A. Rosenberger , JONESPASSODELIS.

Coloplast Corporation, Defendant, represented by Lana K. Varney , KING & SPALDING.

Mentor Corporation, Mentor & Mentor Worldwide, LLC, Defendants, represented by Robert T. Adams , SHOOK HARDY & BACON.

RTI Biologics, Inc., is a corporation with its corporate headquarters in Florida, Defendant, represented by Jace H. Goins , STEPTOE & JOHNSON.

Coloplast Corp., Defendant, represented by Constantine J. Passodelis , JONESPASSODELIS & Ronn B. Kreps , FULBRIGHT & JAWORSKI.

American Medical Systems, Defendant, represented by Joseph G. Petrosinelli , WILLIAMS & CONNOLLY.

C. R. Bard, Defendant, represented by Michael Bonasso , FLAHERTY SENSABAUGH & BONASSO, Matthew E. Brown , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, Meredith Knudsen , REED SMITH & Lennon B. Haas , GREENBERG TRAURIG.

Tissue Science Laboratories, Ltd., Defendant, represented by Don R. Sensabaugh, Jr. , FLAHERTY SENSABAUGH & BONASSO & Andrew J. McElaney, Jr. , NUTTER MCCLENNEN & FISH.

Covidien, Inc., doing business as Sofradim Production, Defendant, represented by Don R. Sensabaugh, Jr. , FLAHERTY SENSABAUGH & BONASSO.

William Elfarr, M.D., Defendant, represented by Samuel A. Houston , SHEPHERD SCOTT CLAWATER & HOUSTON.

Neomedic Inc., Defendant, represented by John Q. Lewis , JONES DAY REAVIS & POGUE & Marcella Coladangelo Ducca , GREENBERG TRAURIG.

Cook Incorporated & Cook Medical, Inc., Defendants, represented by Ilissa Stacy Samplin , GIBSON DUNN & CRUTCHER, Micah L. Hobbs , SHOOK HARDY & BACON & John T. Schlafer , FAEGRE BAKER DANIELS.

Gary Teague, Interested Party, represented by John Anderson Camp , CARLTON FIELDS, Matthew Brian Lerner , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, pro hac vice, Marc E. Williams , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, Richard B. North, Jr. , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, pro hac vice & Michael D. Moeller , SHOOK HARDY & BACON, pro hac vice.

Robert Orr, Laura Bigby, Jonathan Conta & Claire Gloeckner, Interested Partys, represented by John Anderson Camp , CARLTON FIELDS, Michael Warren Johnston , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM, pro hac vice, Marc E. Williams , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, Richard B. North, Jr. , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, pro hac vice & Michael D. Moeller , SHOOK HARDY & BACON, pro hac vice.

Daniel Christensen, Interested Party, represented by Alexander Macia , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, David A. Bosak , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE & James S. Crockett, Jr. , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE.

Injury Victims Assistance Foundation, L.L.C., Interested Party, represented by Ramonda C. Marling , LEWIS GLASSER, Richard L. Gottlieb , LEWIS GLASSER & Webster J. Arceneaux, III , LEWIS GLASSER.

Andrus Wagstaff, PC, Interested Party, represented by Andrew M. Williamson , BLANK ROME.

Plaintiff's Funding Holding, Inc., doing business as LawCash, Interested Party, represented by Edward D. Burbach , FOLEY & LARDNER.

Carolyn Jones, Movant, represented by Henry G. Garrard, III , BLASINGAME BURCH GARRARD & ASHLEY, pro hac vice & Martin Daniel Crump , DAVIS & CRUMP.

MedStar Funding, LC, Movant, represented by Gerald S. Leeseberg , LEESEBERG & VALENTINE, Matthew Brian Lerner , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH & Alexander Macia , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE.

Secant Medical, LLC, Movant, represented by John J. Siciliano , SHUMAKER LOOP & KENDRICK.

Anderson Law Offices, Movant, represented by Paul W. Flowers , PAUL W. FLOWERS CO..

Garretson Resolution Group, Inc., Movant, represented by T. Matthew Lockhart , HUDDLESTON BOLEN.

Tissue Science Laboratories Limited & Sofradim Production SAS, Cross Claimants, represented by Rebecca A. Betts , KAY CASTO & CHANEY.

C. R. Bard, Inc., Cross Defendant, represented by Daniel Vincent Kohls , HANSEN KOHLS SOMMER & JACOB, Alexander Julian Hall , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Alexandra Joelle Block , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Allison Stewart , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Amber L. Duffy , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Amy B. Alderfer , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Andrew Lacy, Jr. , REED SMITH, Anna B. Laakmann , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Annabelle L. Torgman , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Antony B. Klapper , REED SMITH, Bina Palnitkar , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Caroline M. Tinsley , BAKER STERCHI COWDEN & RICE, Casey L. Westover , REED SMITH, Cassandra Lee Matos , REED SMITH, Charles Wade Bowden , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Christopher Anthony Mair , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Christopher Walker , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Christopher P. Winters , ALLEN SHEPHERD LEWIS SYRA & CHAPMAN, Clarence Davis , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Daniel C. Kirby , REED SMITH, Daniel I.A. Smulian , GREENBERG TRAURIG, David Odalis Batista , GREENBERG TRAURIG, David On Chang , REED SMITH, David J. Walz , CARLTON FIELDS, Deborah A. Moeller , SHOOK HARDY BACON, Edward W. Gerecke , CARLTON FIELDS, Emily Hannigan Bryan , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Eric L. Alexander , REED SMITH, Eric F. Gladbach , REED SMITH, Eric Cesar Schnapp , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Ernest Paul Gieger, Jr. , GIEGER LABORDE & LAPEROUSE, Ezekiel Rediker , REED SMITH, Felicia V. Manno , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Ilana Haramati , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Irvin Hernandez , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Jacqueline E. Tambone , GREENBERG TRAURIG, James Z. Foster , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Jane T. Davis , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, Janna S. Nugent , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Jason Henry Okleshen , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Jennifer J. Hageman , ULMER & BERNE, John C. Duane , MOTLEY RICE, Jesse J. Ash , REED SMITH, Jose A. Isasi, II , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Joshua Benjamin Portnoy , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Juan Martinez , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Justin Benjamin Aronson , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Karlin Sangdahl , REED SMITH, Katrina M. Kershner , REED SMITH, Kevin George Lohman , REED SMITH, Lennon B. Haas , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Lindsay DeFrancesco , REED SMITH, Lucia Marker-Moore , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Marcella Coladangelo Ducca , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Marcin S. Kedziora , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Mark A. Sentenac , REED SMITH, Matthew E. Brown , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, Matthew D. Jacobson , REED SMITH, Meredith Knudsen , REED SMITH, Michael Thomas Baier , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Michael K. Brown , REED SMITH, Michael H. Moody , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Nabil Anthony Bisharat , REED SMITH, Natassia Kwan , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Nedda Reghabi Gales , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Paul Del Aguila , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Peter K. Lacina , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Rachel G. Webre , GIEGER LABORDE & LAPEROUSE, Rebekah S. Guyon , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Richard M. Eldridge , ELDRIDGE COOPER STEICHEN & LEACH, Robert R. Kane, III , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Robert Jennings Mollohan, Jr. , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Robin L. Scott , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Sabrina R. Gallo , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Sean P. Jessee , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Sebastian Colley , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Stephanie Peral , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Stephen Todd Fowler , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Symone Danielle Shinton , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Taryn Walker Harper , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Thomas E. Steichen , MCAFEE & TAFT, Todd M. Weir , OTJEN VAN ERT & WEIR, Andrea Roberts Pierson , BAKER & DANIELS, Haroon Anwar , FAEGRE BAKER DANIELS, J. Crisman Palmer , GUNDERSON PALMER GOODSELL & NELSON, John Anderson Camp , CARLTON FIELDS, Lindsay Nicole Uhl , GREENBERG TRAURIG, Marc E. Williams , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, Richard B. North, Jr. , NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH & Michael D. Moeller , SHOOK HARDY & BACON.


PRETRIAL ORDER # 308 MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER (Re: Allocation Order)

I am in receipt of the Fee and Cost Committee's ("FCC") Final Written Recommendation, with the External Review Specialist's Recommended Allocation for distribution of the common benefit fund. [ECF Nos. 7051, 7051-1]. These...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases