URBAN v. FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

Case No. 5:17CV1005.

Laura D. Urban, et al., Plaintiffs, v. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission of the United States of America, et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, N.D. Ohio, Eastern Division.

December 19, 2017.

Editors Note
Applicable Law: 28 U.S.C. § 2201
Cause: 28 U.S.C. § 2201 Declaratory Judgment
Nature of Suit: 899 Other Statutes: Administrative Procedures Act/Review or Appeal of Agency Decision
Source: PACER


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Laura D. Urban, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry.

Laura D. Urban, Plaintiff, represented by Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Jonathan Strong, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Constance Jane Carl, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Susan Wilma Deitrick, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Randy Watt, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Victoria Stefan Watt, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Linda K. Lahr, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Janette J. Henrey, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Dennis W. Plummer, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Patricia A. Plummer, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Victor Giaconia, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Tim Harvey, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Michelle Harvey, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Deborah L. Oakes, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Harlan Oakes, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Connie S. Wasik, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Patrick J. Wasik, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

George J. Pribanich, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Robin S. Pribanich, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Virgil E. Kline, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Wendy J. Kline, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Elaine D. Selzer, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

John G. Selzer, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Joseph E. Bologa, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Amy L. Bologa, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Perry L. Stone, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Donna G. Stone, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Anthony L. Newman, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Gail S. Newman, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Norman A. First, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Carol R. First, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Patrick M. Conahan, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Mary A. Conahan, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Joseph R. Giacomoni, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Ruth A. Giacomoni, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Camelback, Ltd., Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Debra L. Dangelo, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Ricky D. Scholl, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Theresa M. Scholl, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Todd R. Starkey, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Cindi L. Starkey, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Jeffrey L. Aungst, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Denise L. Aungst, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Roy E. Hathaway, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Paul L. Gierosky, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Elizbeth A. Gierosky, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Ted E. Dudra Trust, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

David W. Reese, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Catherine R. Reese, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Greer Kabb-Langkamp, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Ellery J. Langkamp, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Donna J. Noble, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Kevin P. Rodgers, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Darcy R. Rodgers, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Paul F. Fledderjohann, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Debbie M. Fledderjohann, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Joseph F. Marino, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Deborah H. Marino, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Michael F. Hagan, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Coreen Y. Corrigan, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Kevin H. Corrigan, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Anthony D. Fienman, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Debora Christy, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Nicholas S. Pappas, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Melody Pappas, Plaintiff, represented by Aaron A. Ridenbaugh , Gibson & Lowry, Kevin J. Breen & David A. Mucklow .

Federal Energy Regulatory Commission of the United States of America, Defendant, represented by Nicholas M. Gladd , U.S. Department of Energy - Federal Energy Regulatory Commis & Susanna Y. Chu , U.S. Department of Energy - Federal Energy Regulatory Commis.

Acting Chairman Cheryl A. LaFleur, Defendant, represented by Nicholas M. Gladd , U.S. Department of Energy - Federal Energy Regulatory Commis & Susanna Y. Chu , U.S. Department of Energy - Federal Energy Regulatory Commis.

Commissioner Colette D. Honorable, Defendant, represented by Nicholas M. Gladd , U.S. Department of Energy - Federal Energy Regulatory Commis & Susanna Y. Chu , U.S. Department of Energy - Federal Energy Regulatory Commis.

Nexus Gas Transmission, LLC, Defendant, represented by Frank L. Merrill , Bricker & Eckler, James J. Hughes, III , Bricker & Eckler, Kara H. Herrnstein , Bricker & Eckler, Mark R. Wulfe , Bracewell & Giuliani & Michael C. Hefter , Bracewell & Giuliani.


ORDERANDDECISION

(Resolving Docs. 6, 24, 28, 47)

On July 14, 2017, this Court referred the Plaintiffs' motion for a preliminary injunction (Doc. 6) to Magistrate Judge Burke for a report and recommendation. On August 7, 2017, Magistrate Judge Burke issued a Report and Recommendation ("the Report...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases