FEDERICO v. MID-ATLANTIC MILITARY FAMILY COMMUNITIES, LLC

Civil Action No. 2:12cv80, No. 2:14cv596., 2:14cv178

SHELLEY FEDERICO, et al., Plaintiffs, v. MID-ATLANTIC MILITARY FAMILY COMMUNITIES, LLC, et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, E.D. Virginia, Norfolk Division.

August 23, 2016.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Joe Federico, Plaintiff, represented by David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Hilton Wise , Wise & Donahue PLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD, James Plummer Lukes , Wise & Donahue PLC, Stephen C. Swain , Shuttleworth Ruloff Swain Haddad & Morecock PC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

Shelley Federico, Plaintiff, represented by David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Hilton Wise , Wise & Donahue PLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD, James Plummer Lukes , Wise & Donahue PLC, Stephen C. Swain , Shuttleworth Ruloff Swain Haddad & Morecock PC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

Mid-Atlantic Military Family Communities LLC, Defendant, represented by Andrew Edward Goldsmith , Kellogg Huber Hansen Todd Evans & Figel PLLC, pro hac vice, Connie Nora Bertram , Proskauer Rose LLP, David Steve Mordkoff , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Guy Brenner , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Amy Blackwood , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Brendan S. Cox , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Daniel Jerome Davis , Proskauer Rose LLP, David Charles Frederick , Kellogg Huber Hansen Todd Evans & Figel PLLC, pro hac vice, Gourdin W. Sirles , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Lary Alan Rappaport , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice & Michael Firestein , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice.

LPC Property Management, Inc., Defendant, represented by Andrew Edward Goldsmith , Kellogg Huber Hansen Todd Evans & Figel PLLC, pro hac vice, Connie Nora Bertram , Proskauer Rose LLP, David Steve Mordkoff , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Guy Brenner , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Amy Blackwood , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Brendan S. Cox , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Daniel Jerome Davis , Proskauer Rose LLP, David Charles Frederick , Kellogg Huber Hansen Todd Evans & Figel PLLC, pro hac vice, Gourdin W. Sirles , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Lary Alan Rappaport , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice & Michael Firestein , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice.

Mid-Atlantic Military Family Communities, LLC, Consolidated Defendant, represented by Andrew Edward Goldsmith , Kellogg Huber Hansen Todd Evans & Figel PLLC, pro hac vice, Connie Nora Bertram , Proskauer Rose LLP, David Steve Mordkoff , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Guy Brenner , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Amy Blackwood , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Brendan S. Cox , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Daniel Jerome Davis , Proskauer Rose LLP, David Charles Frederick , Kellogg Huber Hansen Todd Evans & Figel PLLC, pro hac vice, Gourdin W. Sirles , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Lary Alan Rappaport , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice & Michael Firestein , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice.

LPC Property Management, Inc., Consolidated Defendant, represented by Andrew Edward Goldsmith , Kellogg Huber Hansen Todd Evans & Figel PLLC, pro hac vice, Connie Nora Bertram , Proskauer Rose LLP, David Steve Mordkoff , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Guy Brenner , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Amy Blackwood , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Brendan S. Cox , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Daniel Jerome Davis , Proskauer Rose LLP, David Charles Frederick , Kellogg Huber Hansen Todd Evans & Figel PLLC, pro hac vice, Gourdin W. Sirles , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Lary Alan Rappaport , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice & Michael Firestein , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice.

Stephanie Dozier, Consolidated Defendant, represented by Andrew Edward Goldsmith , Kellogg Huber Hansen Todd Evans & Figel PLLC, pro hac vice, Connie Nora Bertram , Proskauer Rose LLP, David Steve Mordkoff , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Guy Brenner , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Amy Blackwood , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Brendan S. Cox , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Daniel Jerome Davis , Proskauer Rose LLP & Gourdin W. Sirles , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice.

Troy Wayne Farrar, II, Consolidated Defendant, represented by Andrew Edward Goldsmith , Kellogg Huber Hansen Todd Evans & Figel PLLC, pro hac vice, David Steve Mordkoff , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Guy Brenner , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Amy Blackwood , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Brendan S. Cox , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice, Connie Nora Bertram , Proskauer Rose LLP, Daniel Jerome Davis , Proskauer Rose LLP & Gourdin W. Sirles , Proskauer Rose LLP, pro hac vice.

Redi-Carpet Sales of Virginia, Inc., Consolidated Defendant, represented by Benjamin Thomas Owings, II , Hanover Law Office.

Christopher Chan, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Hilton Wise , Wise & Donahue PLC, David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD, Stephen Mark Smith , Brain Injury Law Center, Stephen C. Swain , Shuttleworth Ruloff Swain Haddad & Morecock PC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

Monica Chan, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Hilton Wise , Wise & Donahue PLC, David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD, Stephen Mark Smith , Brain Injury Law Center, Stephen C. Swain , Shuttleworth Ruloff Swain Haddad & Morecock PC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

John Brandsema, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Hilton Wise , Wise & Donahue PLC, David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD, Stephen Mark Smith , Brain Injury Law Center, Stephen C. Swain , Shuttleworth Ruloff Swain Haddad & Morecock PC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

Abbee Brandsema, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Hilton Wise , Wise & Donahue PLC, David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD, Stephen Mark Smith , Brain Injury Law Center, Stephen C. Swain , Shuttleworth Ruloff Swain Haddad & Morecock PC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

Joe R. Federico, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Hilton Wise , Wise & Donahue PLC, David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD, James Plummer Lukes , Wise & Donahue PLC, Stephen Mark Smith , Brain Injury Law Center, Stephen C. Swain , Shuttleworth Ruloff Swain Haddad & Morecock PC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

Nichole Spivey Harding, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Hilton Wise , Wise & Donahue PLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

George Joseph Sulligan, IV, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Hilton Wise , Wise & Donahue PLC, David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD, Stephen Mark Smith , Brain Injury Law Center, Stephen C. Swain , Shuttleworth Ruloff Swain Haddad & Morecock PC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

Meagan Walker Sulligan, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Hilton Wise , Wise & Donahue PLC, David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD, Stephen Mark Smith , Brain Injury Law Center, Stephen C. Swain , Shuttleworth Ruloff Swain Haddad & Morecock PC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

Meagan Sulligan, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Hilton Wise , Wise & Donahue PLC, David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD, Stephen Mark Smith , Brain Injury Law Center, Stephen C. Swain , Shuttleworth Ruloff Swain Haddad & Morecock PC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

Theo J. Delorey, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Hilton Wise , Wise & Donahue PLC, David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD, Stephen Mark Smith , Brain Injury Law Center, Stephen C. Swain , Shuttleworth Ruloff Swain Haddad & Morecock PC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

Rachael M. Delorey, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Hilton Wise , Wise & Donahue PLC, David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD, Stephen Mark Smith , Brain Injury Law Center, Stephen C. Swain , Shuttleworth Ruloff Swain Haddad & Morecock PC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

Joe Federico, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Hilton Wise , Wise & Donahue PLC, David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD, James Plummer Lukes , Wise & Donahue PLC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

Anthony M. Harding, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Hilton Wise , Wise & Donahue PLC, David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

Shawna Nicole Sheriff, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Hilton Wise , Wise & Donahue PLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

Odonavoah (Don) D. Dixon, II, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

Laura C. Dixon, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

John Clelland, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD, Stephen Mark Smith , Brain Injury Law Center, Stephen C. Swain , Shuttleworth Ruloff Swain Haddad & Morecock PC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

Hope Clelland, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD, Stephen Mark Smith , Brain Injury Law Center, Stephen C. Swain , Shuttleworth Ruloff Swain Haddad & Morecock PC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

Amanda Bell, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Hilton Wise , Wise & Donahue PLC, David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, Stephen Mark Smith , Brain Injury Law Center, Stephen C. Swain , Shuttleworth Ruloff Swain Haddad & Morecock PC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

Jodie Evans, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Hilton Wise , Wise & Donahue PLC, David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD, James Plummer Lukes , Wise & Donahue PLC, Stephen Mark Smith , Brain Injury Law Center, Stephen C. Swain , Shuttleworth Ruloff Swain Haddad & Morecock PC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

Anthony Evans, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Hilton Wise , Wise & Donahue PLC, David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD, James Plummer Lukes , Wise & Donahue PLC, Stephen Mark Smith , Brain Injury Law Center, Stephen C. Swain , Shuttleworth Ruloff Swain Haddad & Morecock PC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

Ross and Dawna Stowers, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Hilton Wise , Wise & Donahue PLC, David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD, James Plummer Lukes , Wise & Donahue PLC, Stephen Mark Smith , Brain Injury Law Center, Stephen C. Swain , Shuttleworth Ruloff Swain Haddad & Morecock PC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

Ross Stowers, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Hilton Wise , Wise & Donahue PLC, David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD, James Plummer Lukes , Wise & Donahue PLC, Stephen Mark Smith , Brain Injury Law Center, Stephen C. Swain , Shuttleworth Ruloff Swain Haddad & Morecock PC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

Dawna Stowers, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Hilton Wise , Wise & Donahue PLC, David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD, James Plummer Lukes , Wise & Donahue PLC, Stephen Mark Smith , Brain Injury Law Center, Stephen C. Swain , Shuttleworth Ruloff Swain Haddad & Morecock PC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

JF, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David Hilton Wise , Wise & Donahue PLC, David Sanburg Bailey , The Environmental Law Group PLLC, David Barnes Holt , Joseph Smith LTD, Stephen Mark Smith , Brain Injury Law Center, Stephen C. Swain , Shuttleworth Ruloff Swain Haddad & Morecock PC & Tammy L. Belinsky , The Environmental Law Group PLLC.

Harry Hindmarsh, Interested Party, represented by Kellam Thomas Parks , Law Office of Kellam T. Parks PLLC.

Harbor Publishing Group, Inc., Interested Party, represented by Kellam Thomas Parks , Law Office of Kellam T. Parks PLLC.

Hindmarsh Industries, Inc., Interested Party, represented by Kellam Thomas Parks , Law Office of Kellam T. Parks PLLC.


MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

Before the Court is Plaintiffs' Motion for a New Trial and Renewed Motion for Judgment as to Liability, or In the Alternative, for Judgment Notwithstanding the Verdict pursuant to Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 50(b) and 59. ECF No. 994. Having reviewed the Parties...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases