IN RE VIVENDI UNIVERSAL, S.A. SECURITIES LITIGATION

No. 02-cv-5571 (SAS).

IN RE VIVENDI UNIVERSAL, S.A. SECURITIES LITIGATION.

United States District Court, S.D. New York.

April 29, 2016.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Special Master, Special Master, represented by Melanie L. Cyganowski , Otterbourg, Steindler, Houston & Rosen.

Miami Group, Plaintiff, represented by Corey D. Holzer , Holzer & Holzer, LLC, pro hac vice, James Stuart Notis , Gardy & Notis, LLP, Sol Schreiber , Milberg LLP, Arthur N. Abbey , Abbey Spanier Rodd Abrams & Paradis, LLP, Brian C. Kerr , Brower Piven, A Professional Corporation, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Pearson-Doniger Family, Plaintiff, represented by Corey D. Holzer , Holzer & Holzer, LLC, pro hac vice, James Stuart Notis , Gardy & Notis, LLP, Sol Schreiber , Milberg LLP, Brian C. Kerr , Brower Piven, A Professional Corporation, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

GAMCO Investors, Inc., Plaintiff, represented by Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Harold F. McGuire, Jr. , D.F. Mcguire & Asscciates, LLC, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Robert N Cappucci , Entwistle & Cappucci LLP, Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA & Vincent Roger Cappucci , Entwistle & Cappucci LLP.

Oppenheim Kapitalanlagegesellschaft mbH, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph F. Rice , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Michael Edward Elsner , Motley Rice LLC, Nathan D. Finch , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, William H. Narwold , Motley Rice LLC, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Leslie Margaret Kelleher , Caplin & Drysdale, Chartered & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Plaintiff KBC Asset Management N.V., Plaintiff, represented by Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

Capitalia Asset Management SGR, S.p.A., Plaintiff, represented by Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Joseph Alberto Fonti , Bleichmar Fonti Tountas & Auld LLP & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

Capitalia Investment Management S.A., Plaintiff, represented by William H. Narwold , Motley Rice LLC, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

Eurizon Capital SGR S.p.A., Plaintiff, represented by Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

Baden-Wurttembergische Investmentgesellschaft mbH, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph F. Rice , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Leslie Margaret Kelleher , Caplin & Drysdale, Chartered, Michael Edward Elsner , Motley Rice LLC, Nathan D. Finch , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, William H. Narwold , Motley Rice LLC, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

Barclays Global Investors (Deutcshland), Plaintiff, represented by Joseph F. Rice , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Leslie Margaret Kelleher , Caplin & Drysdale, Chartered, Michael Edward Elsner , Motley Rice LLC, Nathan D. Finch , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, William H. Narwold , Motley Rice LLC, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

Cominvest Asset Management GMBH, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph F. Rice , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Leslie Margaret Kelleher , Caplin & Drysdale, Chartered, Michael Edward Elsner , Motley Rice LLC, Nathan D. Finch , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, William H. Narwold , Motley Rice LLC, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

Deutsche Asset Management Investmentgesellschaft mbH, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph F. Rice , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Leslie Margaret Kelleher , Caplin & Drysdale, Chartered, Michael Edward Elsner , Motley Rice LLC, Nathan D. Finch , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, William H. Narwold , Motley Rice LLC, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

DWS (Austria) Investmentgesellschaft mbH, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph F. Rice , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Leslie Margaret Kelleher , Caplin & Drysdale, Chartered, Michael Edward Elsner , Motley Rice LLC, Nathan D. Finch , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, William H. Narwold , Motley Rice LLC, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

DWS Investment GmbH, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph F. Rice , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Leslie Margaret Kelleher , Caplin & Drysdale, Chartered, Michael Edward Elsner , Motley Rice LLC, Nathan D. Finch , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, William H. Narwold , Motley Rice LLC, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

Erste-Sparinvest Kapitalanlagegesellschaft m.b.H., Plaintiff, represented by Joseph F. Rice , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Leslie Margaret Kelleher , Caplin & Drysdale, Chartered, Michael Edward Elsner , Motley Rice LLC, Nathan D. Finch , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, William H. Narwold , Motley Rice LLC, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

Forsta AP-fonden, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph F. Rice , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Leslie Margaret Kelleher , Caplin & Drysdale, Chartered, Michael Edward Elsner , Motley Rice LLC, Nathan D. Finch , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, William H. Narwold , Motley Rice LLC, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

Fortis Investment Management SA, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph F. Rice , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Leslie Margaret Kelleher , Caplin & Drysdale, Chartered, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

KBC Asset Management SA, Plaintiff, represented by Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

Landesbank Berlin Investment GmbH, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph F. Rice , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Leslie Margaret Kelleher , Caplin & Drysdale, Chartered, Michael Edward Elsner , Motley Rice LLC, Nathan D. Finch , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, William H. Narwold , Motley Rice LLC, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

LBBW Luxemburg S.A., Plaintiff, represented by Joseph F. Rice , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Leslie Margaret Kelleher , Caplin & Drysdale, Chartered, Michael Edward Elsner , Motley Rice LLC, Nathan D. Finch , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, William H. Narwold , Motley Rice LLC, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

Oppenheim Asset Management Services S.a.r.l., Plaintiff, represented by Joseph F. Rice , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Michael Edward Elsner , Motley Rice LLC, Nathan D. Finch , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

Pioneer Investment Management Ltd., Plaintiff, represented by Joseph F. Rice , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Leslie Margaret Kelleher , Caplin & Drysdale, Chartered, Michael Edward Elsner , Motley Rice LLC, Nathan D. Finch , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, William H. Narwold , Motley Rice LLC, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

Pioneer Investment Management SGRPA, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph F. Rice , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Leslie Margaret Kelleher , Caplin & Drysdale, Chartered, Michael Edward Elsner , Motley Rice LLC, Nathan D. Finch , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, William H. Narwold , Motley Rice LLC, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

Pioneer Investments Austria GmbH, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph F. Rice , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Leslie Margaret Kelleher , Caplin & Drysdale, Chartered, Michael Edward Elsner , Motley Rice LLC, Nathan D. Finch , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, William H. Narwold , Motley Rice LLC, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

Pioneer Investments Kapitalanlagegesellschaft mbH, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph F. Rice , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Leslie Margaret Kelleher , Caplin & Drysdale, Chartered, Michael Edward Elsner , Motley Rice LLC, Nathan D. Finch , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

Raiffeisen Kapitalanlage-Gesellschaft m.b.H., Plaintiff, represented by Joseph F. Rice , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Leslie Margaret Kelleher , Caplin & Drysdale, Chartered, Michael Edward Elsner , Motley Rice LLC, Nathan D. Finch , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, William H. Narwold , Motley Rice LLC, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

SEB Investment Management AB, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph F. Rice , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Michael Edward Elsner , Motley Rice LLC, Nathan D. Finch , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, William H. Narwold , Motley Rice LLC, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

Skandia Insurance Company Ltd., Plaintiff, represented by Joseph F. Rice , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Leslie Margaret Kelleher , Caplin & Drysdale, Chartered, Michael Edward Elsner , Motley Rice LLC, Nathan D. Finch , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, William H. Narwold , Motley Rice LLC, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

Union Asset Mangement Holding AG, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph F. Rice , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Leslie Margaret Kelleher , Caplin & Drysdale, Chartered, Michael Edward Elsner , Motley Rice LLC, Nathan D. Finch , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice & William H. Narwold , Motley Rice LLC.

Universal-Investment-Gesellschaft Mbh, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph F. Rice , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Leslie Margaret Kelleher , Caplin & Drysdale, Chartered, Michael Edward Elsner , Motley Rice LLC, Nathan D. Finch , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, William H. Narwold , Motley Rice LLC, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

SEB Investment GmbH, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph F. Rice , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, Michael Edward Elsner , Motley Rice LLC, Nathan D. Finch , Motley Rice LLC, pro hac vice, William H. Narwold , Motley Rice LLC, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar & Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP.

Andra Ap-Fonden, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Bayern-Invest Kapitalanlagegesellschaft mbH, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Deka Investment, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Deka International (Ireland) Limited, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Deka International S.A. Luxemburg, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Deka Fundmaster Investmentgesellschaft MBH, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Fideuram Investimenti S.G.R., Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Fideuram Gestions S.A., Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Interfund Sica V, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Frankfurt-Trust Investment-Gesellschaft MBH, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Frankfurt-Trust Invest Luxemburg AG, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Helaba Invest Kapitalanlagegesellschaft MBH, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

HSBC Trinkaus & Burkhardt AG, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Internationale Kapitalanlagegesellschaft mbH, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Meag Munich Ergo Kapitalanlagegesellschaft mbH, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Meag Munich Ergo Asset Management GMBH, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Metzler Investment GmbH, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Metzler Ireland LTD, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Nordcon Investment Management AG, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Norges Bank, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Swiss Life Holding AG, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Swiss Life Investment Management Holding AG, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Swiss Life Asset Management AG, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Swiss Life Funds AG, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Swiss Life (Belgium) S.A., Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Swiss Life Asset Management GmbH, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Swiss Life Asset Management (Nederland) B.V., Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Tredje Ap-Fonden, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Westlb Mellon Asset Management Kapitalanlagegesellschaft MBH, Plaintiff, represented by James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Alexander Reus , Diaz Reus & Targ LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Diane Toby Zilka , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Alecta Pensionsforsakring, Omsesidigt, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Javier Bleichmar , John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice.

Sjunde Ap-Fonden, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice.

Varma Mutual Pension Insurance Company, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice.

Danske Invest Administration A/S, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice.

AFA Livforsakringsaktiebolag, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Javier Bleichmar , John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice.

AFA Trygghetsforsakringsaktiebolag, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Javier Bleichmar , John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice.

AFA Sjukforsakringsaktiebolag, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, James Joseph Sabella , Grant & Eisenhofer P.A., Javier Bleichmar , John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice.

AMF Pension Fondforvaltning AB, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice.

Arbetsmarknadsforsakringar, Pensionsforsakringsaktiebolag, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice.

Pensionskassernes Adminstration A/S, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice.

Arbejdsmarkedets Tillaegspension, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice.

Industriens Pensionsforikring A/S, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice.

Arca SGR S.p.A., Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice.

Ilmarinen Mutual Pension Insurance Company, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice.

Prima Societa' di Gestione del Risparmio S.p.A., Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice.

Nordea Invest Fund Management A/S, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice.

Nordea Fonder AB, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice.

Nordea Investment Funds Company I.S.A., Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice.

Nordea Fondene Norge AS, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice.

Nordea Fondbolag Finland AB, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice.

Swedbank Robur Fonder AB, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice.

Fjarde AP-Fonden, Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP & Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice.

Reed S. Clark, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Corey D. Holzer , Holzer & Holzer, LLC, pro hac vice, Brian C. Kerr , Brower Piven, A Professional Corporation, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Sol Schreiber , Milberg LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Daha Davis, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Corey D. Holzer , Holzer & Holzer, LLC, pro hac vice, Brian C. Kerr , Brower Piven, A Professional Corporation, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Sol Schreiber , Milberg LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Collen Dodi, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Corey D. Holzer , Holzer & Holzer, LLC, pro hac vice, Brian C. Kerr , Brower Piven, A Professional Corporation, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Sol Schreiber , Milberg LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Ruth Pearson Trust Pearson Trustee, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Corey D. Holzer , Holzer & Holzer, LLC, pro hac vice, Brian C. Kerr , Brower Piven, A Professional Corporation, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Sol Schreiber , Milberg LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Edward B Brunswick, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Corey D. Holzer , Holzer & Holzer, LLC, pro hac vice, Brian C. Kerr , Brower Piven, A Professional Corporation, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Sol Schreiber , Milberg LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Michael Doniger, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Corey D. Holzer , Holzer & Holzer, LLC, pro hac vice, Brian C. Kerr , Brower Piven, A Professional Corporation, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Sol Schreiber , Milberg LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Alison Doniger, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Corey D. Holzer , Holzer & Holzer, LLC, pro hac vice, Brian C. Kerr , Brower Piven, A Professional Corporation, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Sol Schreiber , Milberg LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Grandchildren's Trust by Bruce Doniger Trustee, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Corey D. Holzer , Holzer & Holzer, LLC, pro hac vice, Brian C. Kerr , Brower Piven, A Professional Corporation, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Sol Schreiber , Milberg LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Bruce Doniger, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Corey D. Holzer , Holzer & Holzer, LLC, pro hac vice, Stephen Thran Rodd , Abbey Spanier Rodd Abrams & Paradis, LLP, Brian C. Kerr , Brower Piven, A Professional Corporation, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Jeffrey A. Lamken , Baker Botts, LLP, Michael Champlin Spencer , Milberg LLP, Sol Schreiber , Milberg LLP, Stephanie Dawn Amin-Giwner , Abbey Spanier Rodd Abrams & Paradis, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Beatrice Doniger, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Corey D. Holzer , Holzer & Holzer, LLC, pro hac vice, Brian C. Kerr , Brower Piven, A Professional Corporation, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Sol Schreiber , Milberg LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Jeffrey Kurtz, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Corey D. Holzer , Holzer & Holzer, LLC, pro hac vice, Brian C. Kerr , Brower Piven, A Professional Corporation, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Sol Schreiber , Milberg LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Hal Price, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Corey D. Holzer , Holzer & Holzer, LLC, pro hac vice, Brian C. Kerr , Brower Piven, A Professional Corporation, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Sol Schreiber , Milberg LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

W. Scott Polland, Jr., Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Corey D. Holzer , Holzer & Holzer, LLC, pro hac vice, Brian C. Kerr , Brower Piven, A Professional Corporation, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Sol Schreiber , Milberg LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Nicholas A. Radosevich, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Corey D. Holzer , Holzer & Holzer, LLC, pro hac vice, Brian C. Kerr , Brower Piven, A Professional Corporation, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Sol Schreiber , Milberg LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Pearson-Doniger Family, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Corey D. Holzer , Holzer & Holzer, LLC, pro hac vice, Brian C. Kerr , Brower Piven, A Professional Corporation, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Sol Schreiber , Milberg LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Miami Group, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Corey D. Holzer , Holzer & Holzer, LLC, pro hac vice, William Beecher Scoville, Jr. , Milberg LLP, Brian C. Kerr , Brower Piven, A Professional Corporation, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Sol Schreiber , Milberg LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Rosenbaum Partners, L.P., Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Corey D. Holzer , Holzer & Holzer, LLC, pro hac vice, Brian C. Kerr , Brower Piven, A Professional Corporation, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Sol Schreiber , Milberg LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Marc Rovner, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Corey D. Holzer , Holzer & Holzer, LLC, pro hac vice, Brian C. Kerr , Brower Piven, A Professional Corporation, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Sol Schreiber , Milberg LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Sheldon Seid, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Corey D. Holzer , Holzer & Holzer, LLC, pro hac vice, Brian C. Kerr , Brower Piven, A Professional Corporation, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Sol Schreiber , Milberg LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Leslie Turbowitz, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Corey D. Holzer , Holzer & Holzer, LLC, pro hac vice, Brian C. Kerr , Brower Piven, A Professional Corporation, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Sol Schreiber , Milberg LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Yong Man Kim, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Corey D. Holzer , Holzer & Holzer, LLC, pro hac vice, Brian C. Kerr , Brower Piven, A Professional Corporation, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Sol Schreiber , Milberg LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Liberty Media Corporation, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Maureen Patricia Reid , Baker Botts L.L.P, Michael Calhoon , Baker Botts L.L.P., R. Stan Mortenson , Baker, Botts, L.L.P., Alexandra M. Walsh , Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison, LLP, pro hac vice, Bryan Anthony Erman , Baker Botts LLP, Bryan Henry Parr , Baker Botts LLP, Paul F. Enzinna , Baker, Botts, L.L.P. & Richard P. Sobiecki , Baker Botts LLP, pro hac vice.

LMC Capital LLC, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Alexandra M. Walsh , Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison, LLP, pro hac vice, Bryan Anthony Erman , Baker Botts LLP, Bryan Henry Parr , Baker Botts LLP, Michael Calhoon , Baker Botts L.L.P. & Richard P. Sobiecki , Baker Botts LLP, pro hac vice.

Liberty Programming Company LLC, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Bryan Anthony Erman , Baker Botts LLP, pro hac vice, Maureen Patricia Reid , Baker Botts L.L.P, Alexandra M. Walsh , Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison, LLP, pro hac vice, Bryan Henry Parr , Baker Botts LLP, Michael Calhoon , Baker Botts L.L.P. & Richard P. Sobiecki , Baker Botts LLP, pro hac vice.

Allianz Global Investors Kapitalanlagegesellschaft MBH, Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, David Kessler , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Jonathan Scott Shapiro , The Shapiro Law Firm, LLP, Jonathen R. Cagan , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, Robert Jason Shapiro , The Shapiro Law Firm, LLP, Steven D. Resnick , Golomb & Honik, P.C., pro hac vice, Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Katharine M. Ryan , Ryan & Maniskas, LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

Allianz Global Investors Luxembourg S.A., Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by Benjamin Jay Hinerfeld , Law Office of Benjamin J. Hinerfeld, David Kessler , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, John J. Gross , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, John Anthony Kehoe , Girard Gibbs LLP, Jonathan Scott Shapiro , The Shapiro Law Firm, LLP, Jonathen R. Cagan , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, Robert Jason Shapiro , The Shapiro Law Firm, LLP, Steven D. Resnick , Golomb & Honik, P.C., pro hac vice, Stuart Berman , Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP, pro hac vice, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

AGF Asset Management, S.A., Consolidated Plaintiff, represented by David J. Goldsmith , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Eric James Belfi , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Javier Bleichmar , Lawrence Alan Sucharow , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Russel Neil Jacobson , Labaton Sucharow, LLP, Christine M. Mackintosh , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA, pro hac vice, Joseph Alberto Fonti , Bleichmar Fonti Tountas & Auld LLP & Stuart M Grant , Grant & Eisenhofer, PA.

A. Hartswell Woodson, Movant, represented by Harold F. McGuire, Jr. , D.F. Mcguire & Asscciates, LLC.

Andrew Rittenbury, Movant, represented by Harold F. McGuire, Jr. , D.F. Mcguire & Asscciates, LLC.

Vivendi Universal, Defendant, represented by Luke Orion Brooks , Coughlin Stoia Geller Rudman & Robbins LLP, Michael J. Malone , King & Spalding LLP, Michael A Paskin , Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP, Michael T Reynolds , Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP, Michael Everett Swartz , Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP, Daniel Slifkin , Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP, James W. Quinn , Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP, Jonathan D Polkes , Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP, Paul C Saunders , Cravath, Swaine & Moore, L.L.P. & Penny Packard Reid , Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP.

Jean-Marie Messier, Defendant, represented by James W. Quinn , Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP, Michael J. Malone , King & Spalding LLP, Michael Everett Swartz , Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP, Paul C Saunders , Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP, Daniel Slifkin , Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP & Paul A. Straus , King & Spalding LLP.

Guillaume Hannezo, Defendant, represented by Martin L. Perschetz , Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

Vivendi Universal S.A., Defendant, represented by Paul C Saunders , Cravath, Swaine & Moore, L.L.P. & Penny Packard Reid , Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP.

Vivendi Universal, S.A., Consolidated Defendant, represented by Luke Orion Brooks , Coughlin Stoia Geller Rudman & Robbins LLP, Michael A Paskin , Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP, Michael T Reynolds , Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP, Daniel Slifkin , Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP, James W. Quinn , Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP, Jonathan D Polkes , Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP, Paul C Saunders , Cravath, Swaine & Moore, L.L.P. & Penny Packard Reid , Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP.

Vivendi, S.A., Consolidated Defendant, represented by James W. Quinn , Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP, Miranda Saskia Schiller , Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP, Paul C Saunders , Cravath, Swaine & Moore, L.L.P., Penny Packard Reid , Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP, Timothy Gray Cameron , Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP, Daniel Slifkin , Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP & Michael T Reynolds , Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP.


MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

This matter having come before the Court on the Plaintiffs' Motion for An Award of Attorneys' Fees And Expenses and Reasonable Costs And Expenses for Lead Plaintiffs, and due and adequate notice having been given to the Class as required in the Court...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases