1. Home
  2. Browse Decisions
  3. TOBAR v. U.S.
 

TOBAR v. U.S.

Case No. 07cv817-WQH-JLB.

OSWALDO ENRIQUE TOBAR, et al., Plaintiff, v. UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, Defendant.

United States District Court, S.D. California.

April 5, 2016.

Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Oswaldo Enrique Tobar, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Heriberto Ramos, Heriberto Ramos & Associates, P.C., pro hac vice, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Rosa Carmelina Zambrano Lucas, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Junior Ivan Pico Alava, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Heriberto Ramos, Heriberto Ramos & Associates, P.C., pro hac vice, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Segundo Matias Zambrano Alonzo, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Francisco Gabriel Yole Arteago, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Fausto Lupercio Arias Castaneda, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Heriberto Ramos, Heriberto Ramos & Associates, P.C., pro hac vice, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Frabricio Bayron Cedeno, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Heriberto Ramos, Heriberto Ramos & Associates, P.C., pro hac vice, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Joffre Johnny Cedeno Cedeno, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Heriberto Ramos, Heriberto Ramos & Associates, P.C., pro hac vice, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Lindon Cleofe Cedeno Cedeno, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Heriberto Ramos, Heriberto Ramos & Associates, P.C., pro hac vice, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Ramon Eliades Ramon Velez Cedeno, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Daniel David Quimi Chalen, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Heriberto Ramos, Heriberto Ramos & Associates, P.C., pro hac vice, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Pablo Eduardo Lucas Conforme, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Heriberto Ramos, Heriberto Ramos & Associates, P.C., pro hac vice, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Ramon Eduardo Pilligua Conforme, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Heriberto Ramos, Heriberto Ramos & Associates, P.C., pro hac vice, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Ciro Mariano Lopez Mero, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Heriberto Ramos, Heriberto Ramos & Associates, P.C., pro hac vice, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Pedro Manuel Lopez Mero, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Heriberto Ramos, Heriberto Ramos & Associates, P.C., pro hac vice, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Jose Eduardo Lucas Mero, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Heriberto Ramos, Heriberto Ramos & Associates, P.C., pro hac vice, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Luis Antonio Penafiel Mero, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Heriberto Ramos, Heriberto Ramos & Associates, P.C., pro hac vice, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Pedro Jose Reyes Mero, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Heriberto Ramos, Heriberto Ramos & Associates, P.C., pro hac vice, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Telmo Arcadio Chica Obando, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Heriberto Ramos, Heriberto Ramos & Associates, P.C., pro hac vice, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Luis Miguel Cedeno Pico, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Heriberto Ramos, Heriberto Ramos & Associates, P.C., pro hac vice, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Jaime Gustavo Palma Pinargote, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Heriberto Ramos, Heriberto Ramos & Associates, P.C., pro hac vice, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Yardy Klever Flores Segovia, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Heriberto Ramos, Heriberto Ramos & Associates, P.C., pro hac vice, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Pacho Hernandez Solorzano, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Heriberto Ramos, Heriberto Ramos & Associates, P.C., pro hac vice, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Carlos Wilfrido Veliz Velez, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Jose Luis Zambrano Zambrano, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

Carlos Orlando Velez Zambrano, Plaintiff, represented by Albert W Morris, Law Offices of Albert W. Morris, Ruben P. Hernandez, Law Office of Ruben P. Hernandez, pro hac vice & Walter L Boyaki, Miranda & Boyaki.

United States of America, Defendant, represented by R Scott Blaze, US Department of Justice, R Michael Underhill, Torts Division Civil Division & Vickey L. Quinn, US Department of Justice.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

The matter before the Court is the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law pursuant to Rule 52(a) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, and Plaintiffs' Emergency Rule 37 and Rule 26(b) Motion or in the Alternative Plaintiffs' Motion for a Continuance (ECF No....

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases