MINA v. CHESTER COUNTY

Civil Action No. 14-6261.

ANTHONY STOCKER MINA, TLC DREAMS FOUNDATION, and THE TRUTH TODAY FOR A BETTER TOMORROW POLITICAL COMMITTEE, Plaintiffs, v. CHESTER COUNTY, CHESTER COUNTY COURT OF COMMON PLEAS, PRESIDENT JUDGE JAMES P. MACELREE, JUDGE ANTHONY SARCIONE, JUDGE THOMAS GAVIN, JUDGE JACQUELINE CARROLL CODY, JUDGE KATHERINE B.L. PLATT, JUDGE: MARK L. TUNNELL, JUDGE JOHN L. BRAXTON, CHESTER COUNTY DOMESTIC RELATIONS SECTION (CCDRS), CCDRS DIRECTOR JOSEPH M. WATERS, CCDRS DEPUTY DIRECTOR WILLIAM R. WHITEHEAD, CCDRS DIRECTOR ROBIN KELLY, CCDRS ADMINISTRATIVE SECRETARY CATHY SMITH, CCDRS ENFORCEMENT OFFICER SHAUNA JOHNSON, CCDRS STAFF ATTORNEY MARY JONES, CCDRS HEARING OFFICER RICHARD LOMBARDI, CCDRS HEARING OFFICER ROSE ANDERSON, FAMILY COURT SECRETARY JANET SNYDER, DIRECTOR OF JUVENILE PROBATION ROBERT E. KYLE, CHESTER COUNTY COURT REPORTER CHIEF WILLIAM HANDY, CHESTER COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY (CCDA) THOMAS HOGAN, CCDA PETER HOBART, CCDA JOSEPH CARROLL (FORMER DA), CCDA CRISTIN KUBACKE, CCDA CHARLES GAZA, WEST CHESTER POLICE DEPARTMENT (WCPD), WCPD CHIEF SCOTT BOHN, WCPD DETECTIVE STAN BILLIE, WCPD SGT. LOUIS DESCHULLO, WCPD OFFICER GREG CUGINO, CHESTER COUNTY PROBATION COLLECTION OFFICER DANIELLE CUGINO, CHESTER COUNTY PROBATION OFFICER KEITH LAURER, CHESTER COUNTY PUBLIC DEFENDER JOHN MERRICK, CHESTER COUNTY PUBLIC DEFENDER NATHAN SHENKER, PROTHONOTARY BRYAN WALTERS, DAILY LOCAL NEWS COURTHOUSE, ATTORNEY GENERAL TOM CORBETT, ATTORNEY LEONARD J. RIVERA, ATTORNEY DAWSON RICHARD MUTH, ATTORNEY ERIC TRAJTENBERG, DAILY LOCAL NEWSPAPER, OPTIMA WEB DESIGN/ENET (RON SHUR, NICK POTOPOV), FEDERAL COURT JUDGE LUIS FELIPE RESTREPO, FEDERAL COURT JUDGE MITCHELL S. GOLDBERG, CHESTER COUNTY PROBATION OFFICER CHARLES MAINES, WELLS FARGO BANK, MONTGOMERY COUNTY, MONTGOMERY COUNTY COURT OF COMMON PLEAS, JUDGE BERNARD A. MOORE, JOHN AND/OR JANE DOE SECRETARY OR LAW CLERK OF J. BERNARD A. MOORE, LUMBER LIQUIDATORS, DELAWARE COUNTY, DELAWARE COUNTY JUVENILE DETENTION CENTER, MARK A. MURRAY, DIRECTOR OF DELAWARE COUNTY JUVENILE DETENTION, MEDCENTER 100, DISTRICT JUDGE WILLIAM KRAUT, CHESTER COUNTY HOSPITAL, MICHAEL J. DUNCAN CC HOSP. CEO, WEST GOSHEN TOWNSHIP, WEST GOSHEN POLICE DEPARTMENT, and WEST GOSHEN POLICE OFFICER JOHN J. LISS, Defendants.

United States District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania.

October 29, 2015.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

ANTHONY STOCKER MINA, Plaintiff, Pro Se.

TLC DREAMS FOUNDATION, Plaintiff, represented by TLC DREAMS FOUNDATION .

THE TRUTH TODAY FOR A BETTER TOMORROW POLITICAL COMMITTEE, Plaintiff, represented by THE TRUTH TODAY FOR A BETTER TOMORROW POLITICAL COMMITTEE .

CHESTER COUNTY, Defendant, represented by GUY A. DONATELLI , LAMB & MCERLANE, P.C. & RACHEL E. LUSK , LAMB MCERLANE PC.

CHESTER COUNTY COURT OF COMMON PLEAS, Defendant, represented by COLIN STUART HAVILAND , AOPC & MARTHA GALE , ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE OF PA COURTS.

PRESIDENT JUDGE JAMES P. MACELREE, Defendant, represented by COLIN STUART HAVILAND , AOPC & MARTHA GALE , ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE OF PA COURTS.

JUDGE ANTHONY SARCIONE, Defendant, represented by COLIN STUART HAVILAND , AOPC & MARTHA GALE , ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE OF PA COURTS.

JUDGE THOMAS GAVIN, Defendant, represented by COLIN STUART HAVILAND , AOPC & MARTHA GALE , ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE OF PA COURTS.

JUDGE JACQUELINE CARROLL CODY, Defendant, represented by COLIN STUART HAVILAND , AOPC & MARTHA GALE , ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE OF PA COURTS.

JUDGE KATHERINE B.L. PLATT, Defendant, represented by COLIN STUART HAVILAND , AOPC & MARTHA GALE , ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE OF PA COURTS.

JUDGE MARK L. TUNNELL, Defendant, represented by COLIN STUART HAVILAND , AOPC & MARTHA GALE , ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE OF PA COURTS.

JUDGE JOHN L. BRAXTON, Defendant, represented by COLIN STUART HAVILAND , AOPC & MARTHA GALE , ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE OF PA COURTS.

CHESTER COUNTY DOMESTIC RELATIONS SECTION, Defendant, represented by COLIN STUART HAVILAND , AOPC & MARTHA GALE , ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE OF PA COURTS.

MARY JONES, Defendant, represented by MICHAEL B. PULLANO , WEBER GALLAGHER & THERESA GIAMANCO , WEBER GALLAGHER SIMPSON STAPLETON.

THOMAS HOGAN, Defendant, represented by MICHAEL B. PULLANO , WEBER GALLAGHER & THERESA GIAMANCO , WEBER GALLAGHER SIMPSON STAPLETON.

CCDA PETER HOBART, Defendant, represented by MICHAEL B. PULLANO , WEBER GALLAGHER & THERESA GIAMANCO , WEBER GALLAGHER SIMPSON STAPLETON.

CCDA JOSEPH CARROLL, Defendant, represented by MICHAEL B. PULLANO , WEBER GALLAGHER & THERESA GIAMANCO , WEBER GALLAGHER SIMPSON STAPLETON.

CCDA CRISTIN KUBACKE, Defendant, represented by MICHAEL B. PULLANO , WEBER GALLAGHER & THERESA GIAMANCO , WEBER GALLAGHER SIMPSON STAPLETON.

CCDA CHARLES GAZA, Defendant, represented by MICHAEL B. PULLANO , WEBER GALLAGHER & THERESA GIAMANCO , WEBER GALLAGHER SIMPSON STAPLETON.

JOHN MERRICK, CHESTER COUNTY PUBLIC DEFENDER, Defendant, represented by MICHAEL B. PULLANO , WEBER GALLAGHER.

JOHN MERRICK, Defendant, represented by THERESA GIAMANCO , WEBER GALLAGHER SIMPSON STAPLETON.

NATHAN SHENKER, Defendant, represented by MICHAEL B. PULLANO , WEBER GALLAGHER & THERESA GIAMANCO , WEBER GALLAGHER SIMPSON STAPLETON.

ATTORNEY GENERAL TOM CORBETT, Defendant, represented by BARRY N. KRAMER , PA OFFICE OF ATTY GENERAL.

ATTORNEY LEONARD J. RIVERA, Defendant, represented by JEFFREY P. LEWIS , ECKERT SEAMANS CHERIN & MELLOTT LLC & JOSHUA L. KIRSCH , ECKERT SEAMANS CHERIN & MELLOTT.

ATTORNEY DAWSON RICHARD MUTH, Defendant, represented by DAWSON R. MUTH , GOLDBERG, MEANIX McCALLIN & MUTH.

ATTORNEY ERIC TRAJTENBERG, Defendant, represented by JEFFREY P. LEWIS , ECKERT SEAMANS CHERIN & MELLOTT LLC & JOSHUA L. KIRSCH , ECKERT SEAMANS CHERIN & MELLOTT.

FEDERAL COURT JUDGE LUIS FELIPE RESTREPO, Defendant, represented by ERIC D. GILL , U.S. ATTORNEY'S OFFICE.

FEDERAL COURT JUDGE MITCHELL S. GOLDBERG, Defendant, represented by ERIC D. GILL , U.S. ATTORNEY'S OFFICE.

WELLS FARGO BANK, Defendant, represented by STEVEN B. KANTROWITZ , KANTROWITZ & PHILLIPPI LLC.

JUDGE BERNARD A. MOORE, Defendant, represented by COLIN STUART HAVILAND , AOPC & MARTHA GALE , ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE OF PA COURTS.

LUMBER LIQUIDATORS, Defendant, represented by TIMOTHY P. MULLIN , ZARWIN BAUM DEVITO KAPLAN SCHAER & TODDY PC.

DELAWARE COUNTY, Defendant, represented by SUZANNE MCDONOUGH , HOLSTEN & ASSOCIATES.

DELAWARE COUNTY JUVENILE DETENTION CENTER, Defendant, represented by SUZANNE MCDONOUGH , HOLSTEN & ASSOCIATES.

MARK A MURRAY, Defendant, represented by SUZANNE MCDONOUGH , HOLSTEN & ASSOCIATES.

MEDCENTER 100, Defendant, represented by MARK J. HERMANOVICH , McCumber, Daniels, Buntz, Hartig, & Puig, P.A..

DISTRICT JUDGE WILLIAM KRAUT, Defendant, represented by COLIN STUART HAVILAND , AOPC & MARTHA GALE , ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE OF PA COURTS.

CHESTER COUNTY HOSPITAL, Defendant, represented by JOHN E.D. LARKIN , GAWTHROP GREENWOOD PC.

MICHAEL J. DUNCAN, Defendant, represented by JOHN E.D. LARKIN , GAWTHROP GREENWOOD PC.

WEST GOSHEN TOWNSHIP, Defendant, represented by JOHN PHILIP MORGENSTERN , DEASEY MAHONEY & VALENTINI,LTD. & RUFUS A. JENNINGS , DEASEY, MAHONEY & VALENTINI, LTD.

WEST GOSHEN POLICE DEPARTMENT, Defendant, represented by JOHN PHILIP MORGENSTERN , DEASEY MAHONEY & VALENTINI,LTD. & RUFUS A. JENNINGS , DEASEY, MAHONEY & VALENTINI, LTD.

JOHN J LISS, Defendant, represented by JOHN PHILIP MORGENSTERN , DEASEY MAHONEY & VALENTINI,LTD..

JOHN J LISS, Defendant, represented by RUFUS A. JENNINGS , DEASEY, MAHONEY & VALENTINI, LTD.

MACELREE HARVEY, Movant, represented by JOSHUA L. KIRSCH , ECKERT SEAMANS CHERIN & MELLOTT.


ORDER

AND NOW, this 29th day of October, 2015, after reviewing all documents submitted by the parties; and after two proceedings held before the undersigned; and for the reasons expressed in the accompanying memorandum opinion; accordingly,...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases