BERNAL v. FedEX GROUND PACKAGE SYSTEM INC.

Case No. CV 15-01448 DDP (PLAx).

JOSE L. BERNAL, on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated, Plaintiff, v. FEDEX GROUND PACKAGE SYSTEM INC., a Delaware corporation; FEDEX CORPORATION, a Delaware corporation; and FLAT RATE TRUCK REPAIR, INC., a California corporation, Defendants.

United States District Court, C.D. California.

July 14, 2015.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Jose L. Bernal, on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Ana Frech, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Jose Ayala, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Juan Cambara, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Jose Cruz, Plaintiff, represented by David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP.

Luis Eslavo, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Samuel McGrew, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Jesus Medina, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Jorge Obeso, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Luis Palacios, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Juan Rios Orozco, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Carlos Chavez, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Ruben Sanchez, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Rafael Sosa, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Francisco Aguilar, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Victor Azcona Fuentes, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Jorge Campos, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Luis Bravo Castellon, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Luis Manuel Segura, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Juan Espinoza, -, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Alberto Flores, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Daniel Hernandez, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Alfonso Marquz, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Lorenzo Molina, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Terrazas, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Francisco Morales, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Olber Osorio Ramirez, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Alejandro Quintanta, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Jose Rivera, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Arturo Higarera, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Augustin Sanchez, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

German Aguila, Plaintiff, represented by David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP.

Jorge Martinez, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Lawrence McGirr, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Loudes Vasconcelos, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Luis Prada, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Manuel Oritz, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Marco Ramirez, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

MarcoI Samagiego, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Olga Delmuro Mijraes, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Omar Montes, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Omar Velazquez, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Rafael Huerta, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Ramon Gonzalez, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Ramon Sura, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Rodolfo Amequita, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Salvador Arellano, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Santos Vasquz, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Saul Mejia, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Victor Escheverria, Plaintiff, represented by David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP.

William Sarratt, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Yudi Castaneda, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Eduardo Vasquez, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Candelario Quezada, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Jorge Ramirez, Plaintiff, represented by David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP.

Solomon D Ramirez, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Eduerdo Vazquez, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Emilo Hernandez, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Ebed Delgado, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Ruben Flores, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Axsel Lima, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Miguel Lima, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Isaias Gonzalez, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Olga Boya, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Gustaro Mondragon, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Anibal Aldara, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Orette Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Luis Angel Diaz, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Roberto Cortes, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Alex Barrcamp, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Felipe Morales, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Willie Marquez, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

Francisco Garcia, Plaintiff, represented by Ashton Ryan Watkins, Lee Han and Paciocco, LLP, David J Lee, Lee Han and Paciocco LLP & Keon H Han, Lee Han & Paciocco LLP.

FedEx Ground Package System, Inc., a Delaware corporation, Defendant, represented by Brandy Thompson Cody, Fisher and Phillips LLP, Shaun J Voigt, Fisher & Phillips LLP, Andrew Hoag, Fisher and Phillips LLP, James C Fessenden, Fisher and Phillips & Peter C Flanderka, Fisher & Phillips LLP.


ORDER GRANTING IN PART AND DENYING IN PART DEFENDANT FEDEX GROUND PACKAGE SYSTEM INC.'S MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFFS' FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION FOR FRAUD AND/OR STRIKE PORTIONS OF PLAINTIFFS' FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT PURSUANT TO FRCP RULES 12(b)(6) and 12(f)

[Dkt. No. 23]

Presently before the Court...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases