GREENBRIER HOTEL CORPORATION v. UNITE HERE HEALTH

Civil Action No. 5:13-11644.

GREENBRIER HOTEL CORPORATION, et al., Plaintiffs, v. UNITE HERE HEALTH, et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, S.D. West Virginia, Beckley Division.

April 13, 2015.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Greenbrier Hotel Corporation, Plaintiff, represented by David A. Bosak , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Grant P.H. Shuman , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Kimberly K. Parmer , THE MASTERS LAW FIRM & Samuel M. Brock, III , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE.

Thelma R. Adkins, Plaintiff, represented by David A. Bosak , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Grant P.H. Shuman , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Kimberly K. Parmer , THE MASTERS LAW FIRM & Samuel M. Brock, III , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE.

William Arnold, Plaintiff, represented by David A. Bosak , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Grant P.H. Shuman , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Kimberly K. Parmer , THE MASTERS LAW FIRM & Samuel M. Brock, III , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE.

Dennis Austin, Plaintiff, represented by David A. Bosak , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Grant P.H. Shuman , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Kimberly K. Parmer , THE MASTERS LAW FIRM & Samuel M. Brock, III , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE.

Greg Scott, and, Plaintiff, represented by David A. Bosak , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Grant P.H. Shuman , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Kimberly K. Parmer , THE MASTERS LAW FIRM & Samuel M. Brock, III , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE.

Eric Tygrett, Plaintiff, represented by David A. Bosak , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Grant P.H. Shuman , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE, Kimberly K. Parmer , THE MASTERS LAW FIRM & Samuel M. Brock, III , SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE.

Unite Here Health, a trust, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

H.E.R.E.I.U. Welfare Fund -- Plan Unit 155, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

John W. Wilhelm, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

Geoconda Arguello-Kline, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

William Biggerstaff, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

Donna DeCaprio, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

Maya DeHart, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

Bill Granfield, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

Terry Greenwald, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

Constance M. Holt, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

Karen Kent, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

Clete Kiley, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

C. Robert McDevitt, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

Leonard O'Neill, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

Henry Tamarin, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

Donald Taylor, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

Thomas Walsh, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

Paul Ades, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

James M. Anderson, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

Richard M. Betty, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

Albert I. Church, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

James L. Claus, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

Richard Ellis, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

George Greene, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

Arnold F. Karr, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

Cynthia Kiser Murphy, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

Russ Melaragni, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

Frank Muscolina, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

William Noonan, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

Jack M. Penman, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

John Socha, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

Harold Taegel, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

Gary Wang, and, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.

George Wright, Defendant, represented by Charles M. Love, III , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE, Ian H. Morrison , SEYFARTH SHAW, Jill E. Hall , BOWLES RICE MCDAVID GRAFF & LOVE & Samuel M. Schwartz-Fenwick , SEYFARTH SHAW.


MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

Pending before the Court is Plaintiffs' Motion to Compel (Document No. 54.), filed on March 24, 2014. Defendants filed their Response to Plaintiffs' Motion to Compel on April 17, 2014 (Document No. 62.), to which Plaintiffs filed their Reply on...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases