1. Home
  2. Browse Decisions
  3. GRONIK v. BALTHASAR
 

GRONIK v. BALTHASAR

Case Nos. 10-cv-0954, 11-cv-0697

DAVID S. GRONIK, JR., et al., Plaintiffs, v. SUSAN BALTHASAR, et al., Defendants, and SHOREWEST REALTORS, INC., CONTINENTAL CASUALTY COMPANY, and ANNE SCHWARTZ, Third-Party Defendants, and OPIO BOAT MOON, LLC, et al., Plaintiffs, v. CHUBB INDEMNITY INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant.

United States District Court, E.D. Wisconsin.

March 3, 2015.

Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

David S Gronik, Jr, Plaintiff, represented by Charles D Schmidt , Halloin & Murdock SC, James J Irvine , Halloin & Murdock SC, Anthony K Murdock , Halloin & Murdock SC & Scott R Halloin , Halloin & Murdock SC.

Mary K Gronik, Plaintiff, represented by Charles D Schmidt , Halloin & Murdock SC, James J Irvine , Halloin & Murdock SC, Anthony K Murdock , Halloin & Murdock SC & Scott R Halloin , Halloin & Murdock SC.

S C G, Plaintiff, represented by Charles D Schmidt , Halloin & Murdock SC, James J Irvine , Halloin & Murdock SC, Anthony K Murdock , Halloin & Murdock SC & Scott R Halloin , Halloin & Murdock SC.

M A G, a minor child by her Guardian ad Litem, Plaintiff, represented by Charles D Schmidt , Halloin & Murdock SC, James J Irvine , Halloin & Murdock SC, Anthony K Murdock , Halloin & Murdock SC & Scott R Halloin , Halloin & Murdock SC.

David S Gronik Jr Living Trust, Plaintiff, represented by Charles D Schmidt , Halloin & Murdock SC, James J Irvine , Halloin & Murdock SC, Anthony K Murdock , Halloin & Murdock SC & Scott R Halloin , Halloin & Murdock SC.

Opio Boat Moon LLC, Plaintiff, represented by Charles D Schmidt , Halloin & Murdock SC, James J Irvine , Halloin & Murdock SC, Anthony K Murdock , Halloin & Murdock SC & Scott R Halloin , Halloin & Murdock SC.

Susan Balthasar, Defendant, represented by Valerie R Jonas , Bascom Budish & Ceman SC, Jaclyn Clair Kallie , Bascom Budish & Ceman SC, Jacob A Sosnay , Bascom Budish & Ceman SC, Ralph A Weber , Gass Weber Mullins LLC, Timothy Andrew Bascom , Bascom Budish & Ceman SC & Wendy G Gunderson , Smith Gunderson & Rowen SC.

Estate of Norman J Balthasar, Defendant, represented by Valerie R Jonas , Bascom Budish & Ceman SC, Jaclyn Clair Kallie , Bascom Budish & Ceman SC, Jacob A Sosnay , Bascom Budish & Ceman SC, Timothy Andrew Bascom , Bascom Budish & Ceman SC & Wendy G Gunderson , Smith Gunderson & Rowen SC.

Thomas J. Branigan, Defendant, represented by Donald A Allen , Mawicke & Goisman SC.

Federal Insurance Company, Defendant, represented by David A Westrup , von Briesen & Roper SC.

Chubb Indemnity Insurance Company, Defendant, represented by David A Westrup , von Briesen & Roper SC.

Chubb Indemnity Insurance Company, Consolidated Defendant, represented by Frederick J Strampe , Borgelt Powell Peterson & Frauen SC, Nicolas C Mesco , Tressler LLP, Todd S Schenk , Tressler LLP, Ann E O'Connor , Tressler LLP & David A Westrup , von Briesen & Roper SC.

Estate of Norman J Balthasar, Third Party Plaintiff, represented by Valerie R Jonas , Bascom Budish & Ceman SC, Jaclyn Clair Kallie , Bascom Budish & Ceman SC, Jacob A Sosnay , Bascom Budish & Ceman SC, Timothy Andrew Bascom , Bascom Budish & Ceman SC & Wendy G Gunderson , Smith Gunderson & Rowen SC.

Shorewest Realtors Inc, Third Party Defendant, represented by Daniel A Manna , Foley & Lardner LLP, Edward A Hannan , Hannan & Associates LLC, Heather K Gatewood , Davis & Kuelthau SC, Michael J Aprahamian , Foley & Lardner LLP & Susan G Schellinger , Davis & Kuelthau SC.

Continental Casualty Company, Third Party Defendant, represented by Jennifer AB Kreil , Meissner Tierney Fisher & Nichols SC & Michael J Cohen , Meissner Tierney Fisher & Nichols SC.

West Bend Mutual Insurance Company, Intervenor, represented by Kristopher J Bartos , Jeffrey Leavell SC & Jeffrey L Leavell , Jeffrey Leavell SC.

LiquiTec Industries Inc, Movant, represented by Anthony K Murdock , Halloin & Murdock SC, Joshua J Roever , Halloin & Murdock SC & Scott R Halloin , Halloin & Murdock SC.

AccuVal Associates Inc, Movant, represented by Anthony K Murdock , Halloin & Murdock SC, Joshua J Roever , Halloin & Murdock SC & Scott R Halloin , Halloin & Murdock SC.

Branigan Communications Inc, Movant, represented by Donald A Allen , Mawicke & Goisman SC.

Susan Balthasar, Third Party Plaintiff, represented by Valerie R Jonas , Bascom Budish & Ceman SC, Jaclyn Clair Kallie , Bascom Budish & Ceman SC, Jacob A Sosnay , Bascom Budish & Ceman SC, Ralph A Weber , Gass Weber Mullins LLC, Timothy Andrew Bascom , Bascom Budish & Ceman SC & Wendy G Gunderson , Smith Gunderson & Rowen SC.

Anne Schwartz, Third Party Defendant, represented by Daniel A Manna , Foley & Lardner LLP, Edward A Hannan , Hannan & Associates LLC, Heather K Gatewood , Davis & Kuelthau SC & Michael J Aprahamian , Foley & Lardner LLP.

DECISION AND ORDER

Plaintiffs, the Groniks, brought this diversity case against defendant Chubb Indemnity Insurance Company ("Chubb") for damages to their home resulting from several storms. On June 17, 2014 after a lengthy appraisal process, I confirmed the appraisal award. Subsequently...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases