STATE EX REL. STATE ENGINEER v. ARAGON

Civil No. 69-7941 MV/LFG.

STATE OF NEW MEXICO ex rel. STATE ENGINEER, Plaintiff, v. ROMAN ARAGON, et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, D. New Mexico.

August 2, 2013.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Vickie Gabin, Special Master, represented by Vickie L. Gabin .

State of New Mexico, Plaintiff, represented by Arianne Singer , New Mexico Office of the State Engineer, Edward G. Newville , Gregory C. Ridgley , Office of the State Engineer & Gary B Storm , New Mexico Office of the State Engineer.

USA, Defendant, represented by Bradley S. Bridgewater , U.S. Department of Justice, David W Gehlert , United States Department of Justice & Karla JaNelle Haught , LEAD ATTORNEY.

Santa Fe Archdiocese, Defendant, represented by Tessa T. Davidson .

Presbyterian Church at Ghost Ranch, Defendant, represented by Peter B. Shoenfeld .

El Barranco, LLC, Defendant, represented by Lisa Old-Ferrell .

Mary Ellen Gonzales, Defendant, represented by Frank M Bond , Simons & Slattery, LLP.

San Juan Pueblo, Defendant, represented by David C Mielke , Sonosky, Chambers, Sachse, Mielke & Brownell, LLP, Leander Bergen , Bergen Law Offices, LLC, Timothy A Vollmann , Curtis Berkey , Berkey Williams LLP & Scott Wayne Williams , Berkey Williams LLP.

Norm Vogt, Inc, Defendant, represented by Gary S. Friedman , Cassutt, Hays & Friedman, PA.

Norm Vogt, Defendant, represented by Gary S. Friedman , Cassutt, Hays & Friedman, PA.

Rancho Lobo, Ltd, Defendant, represented by Brett J Olsen , Olsen, Parden & Crow, P.C..

City of Espanola, Defendant, represented by James C. Brockmann , Stein & Brockmann, PA, Jay F Stein , Stein & Brockmann, PA & Kimberly Bannerman , Stein & Brockman PA.

Henry G. Coors, Defendant, represented by Walter L. Reardon, Jr. .

River Bend Ranch LLC, Defendant, represented by Charles T. DuMars , Law & Resource Planning Associates & Tanya L. Scott , Law & Resource Planning Associates.

Associacion de Acequias Nortenas de Rio Arriba, Defendant, represented by David A. Benavides , NM Legal Aid, John W. Utton , Sheehan & Sheehan, P.A. & Ryan Margaret Golten , NM Legal Aid.

Quinlan Ranches New Mexico, LLC, Defendant, represented by Charles T. DuMars , Law & Resource Planning Associates & Tanya L. Scott , Law & Resource Planning Associates.

Juan Hamilton, Defendant, represented by Jeffrey Fornaciari , Hinkle, Hensley, Shanor & Martin, LLP.

T-Bone Ranch Company, Defendant, represented by Jeffrey Fornaciari , Hinkle, Hensley, Shanor & Martin, LLP.

Marion M Lloyd, Defendant, represented by Jeffrey Fornaciari , Hinkle, Hensley, Shanor & Martin, LLP.

John Musser, Defendant, represented by Jeffrey Fornaciari , Hinkle, Hensley, Shanor & Martin, LLP.

Mike Mabry, Defendant, represented by Randolph B. Felker , Felker Ish Ritchie & Geer PA.

Eileen Mabry, Defendant, represented by Randolph B. Felker , Felker Ish Ritchie & Geer PA.

Hap Crawford, Defendant, represented by Randolph B. Felker , Felker Ish Ritchie & Geer PA.

Charlynne Crawford, Defendant, represented by Randolph B. Felker , Felker Ish Ritchie & Geer PA.

Ivan C Corrales, Defendant, represented by Marcus J Rael, Jr , Robles, Rael & Anaya, PC.

Manuel E Corrales, Defendant, represented by Marcus J Rael, Jr , Robles, Rael & Anaya, PC.

Marcella T Corrales, Defendant, represented by Marcus J Rael, Jr , Robles, Rael & Anaya, PC.

Teresita Corrales, Defendant, represented by Marcus J Rael, Jr , Robles, Rael & Anaya, PC.

Various Acequias, Defendant, represented by Mary E. Humphrey , Humphrey & Ode, PC, Daniel A. Sanchez & John W. Utton , Sheehan & Sheehan, P.A..

Dos Rios Ranch, LLC, Defendant, represented by Richard S. Mackenzie .

Chama Investments, Inc., Defendant, represented by Peter B. Shoenfeld .

Dos Rios Development, LLC, Defendant, represented by Peter B. Shoenfeld .

Mr. Charlie Chacon, Defendant, represented by Adan E. Trujillo , Law Offices of Ted J Trujillo & Ted J Trujillo , Law Offices of Ted J Trujillo.

Geralda M Chacon, Defendant, represented by Adan E. Trujillo , Law Offices of Ted J Trujillo & Ted J Trujillo , Law Offices of Ted J Trujillo.

Delfin and Frances Quintana, Defendant, represented by Ted J Trujillo , Law Offices of Ted J Trujillo.

Vista, Ltd., Defendant, represented by Seth Reese Fullerton , Stein & Brockmann, P.A..

Ronald Rundstrom, Defendant, Pro Se.

Charles Russell, Defendant, represented by Catherine R Robinson , Law & Resource Planning Associates, PC & Charles T. DuMars , Law & Resource Planning Associates.

Unser, LLC, Defendant, represented by Catherine R Robinson , Law & Resource Planning Associates, PC & Charles T. DuMars , Law & Resource Planning Associates.

Flavio Gurule, Defendant, represented by Brian F Egolf, Jr , The Egolf Law Firm, LLC.

Chama Valley Independent School District No. 19, Defendant, represented by Rebecca A. Dempsey , Cuddy & McCarthy, LLP.

David Ortiz, Defendant, Pro Se.

Filiberto and Domiti Ulibarri, Defendant, represented by John W. Utton , Sheehan & Sheehan, P.A..

Kenneth Luhcs, Defendant, represented by Peter B. Shoenfeld .

Steve A Padilla, Defendant, represented by Peter B. Shoenfeld .

Dianna Andrews, Defendant, represented by Peter B. Shoenfeld .

Timothy Andrews, Defendant, represented by Peter B. Shoenfeld .

Jose Leandro Martinez, Defendant, represented by David A. Benavides , NM Legal Aid.

Magdalena L Martinez, Defendant, represented by David A. Benavides , NM Legal Aid.

Mrs. Corlinda H. Lujan, Defendant, represented by Elizabeth Newlin Taylor , Taylor & McCaleb & Jolene L McCaleb , Taylor & McCaleb.

Chama Troustalkers LLC, Defendant, represented by Adam G Rankin , Holland & Hart, LLP & Mark F. Sheridan , Holland & Hart, LLP.

Brazos Mutual Domestic Water Consumers Association, Defendant, represented by Jeffrey Albright , Lewis & Roca LLP.

Jicarilla Apache Tribe, Intervenor Defendant, represented by Herbert A. Becker , JA Associates, Shenan Rae Atcitty , Holland & Knight, LLP & Natasha D Cuylear , JA Associates of NM, LLC.

State of New Mexico, Counter Defendant, represented by Barbara A Brill , NM State Engineering Office.


MAGISTRATE JUDGE'S FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDED DISPOSITION1

LORENZO F. GARCIA, Magistrate Judge.

Findings

1. On December 19, 2011, Defendants David M. Ortiz and Cecilia S. Ortiz filed a one-page objection to the priority date proposed for their water right. [Doc. 10672]. On January 11, 2012, David Ortiz filed a second objection discussing the basis for his objection...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases