BP WEST COAST PRODUCTS, LLC v. SHALABI

Case No. C11-1341 MJP.

BP WEST COAST PRODUCTS, LLC, Plaintiff, v. HATEM SHALABI, et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, W.D. Washington, Seattle.

June 19, 2013.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

BP West Coast Products, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by David M Harris , GREENSFELDER, HEMKER & GALE PC, Daniel J. Oates , GRAHAM & DUNN, Douglas Clayton Berry , GRAHAM & DUNN & Kent Michael Fandel , GRAHAM & DUNN PC.

Hatem Shalabi, Defendant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land, LLC, Defendant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 6031 LLC, Defendant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 6067, LLC, Defendant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5362, LLC, Defendant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 6026, LLC, Defendant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 6530, LLC, Defendant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5490, LLC, Defendant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5816, LLC, Defendant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5854, LLC, Defendant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5911, LLC, Defendant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5568, LLC, Defendant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5660, LLC, Defendant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 4490, LLC, Defendant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5303, LLC, Defendant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5893, LLC, Defendant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Pyramid Gold, Inc., Defendant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Wild Dee, Inc., Defendant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

William Fry, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Douglas Clayton Berry , GRAHAM & DUNN.

Jeff Cary, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Douglas Clayton Berry , GRAHAM & DUNN.

Robert Motley, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Douglas Clayton Berry , GRAHAM & DUNN.

Harbor Olympic Land 6530, LLC, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Pyramid Gold, Inc., ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 6031 LLC, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5660, LLC, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Wild Dee, Inc., ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 4490, LLC, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5568, LLC, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5816, LLC, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land, LLC, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5362, LLC, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5490, LLC, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5854, LLC, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5893, LLC, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5911, LLC, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 6067, LLC, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 6026, LLC, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5303, LLC, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Hatem Shalabi, an individual, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

BP West Coast Products, LLC, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Daniel J. Oates , GRAHAM & DUNN, Douglas Clayton Berry , GRAHAM & DUNN & Kent Michael Fandel , GRAHAM & DUNN PC.

Harbor Olympic Land 6530, LLC, Counter Claimant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Pyramid Gold, Inc., Counter Claimant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 6031 LLC, Counter Claimant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5660, LLC, Counter Claimant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Wild Dee, Inc., Counter Claimant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 4490, LLC, Counter Claimant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5568, LLC, Counter Claimant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5816, LLC, Counter Claimant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land, LLC, Counter Claimant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5362, LLC, Counter Claimant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5490, LLC, Counter Claimant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5854, LLC, Counter Claimant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5893, LLC, Counter Claimant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5911, LLC, Counter Claimant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 6067, LLC, Counter Claimant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 6026, LLC, Counter Claimant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Harbor Olympic Land 5303, LLC, Counter Claimant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

Hatem Shalabi, an individual, Counter Claimant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

BP West Coast Products, LLC, Counter Defendant, represented by Daniel J. Oates , GRAHAM & DUNN, Douglas Clayton Berry , GRAHAM & DUNN & Kent Michael Fandel , GRAHAM & DUNN PC.

Hatem Shalabi, an individual, ThirdParty Plaintiff, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

BP West Coast Products, LLC, ThirdParty Defendant, represented by Daniel J. Oates , GRAHAM & DUNN, Douglas Clayton Berry , GRAHAM & DUNN & Kent Michael Fandel , GRAHAM & DUNN PC.

Hatem Shalabi, an individual, Counter Claimant, represented by Adam T Birnbaum , THE BIRNBAUM LAW OFFICES & David A. Schiller , SCHILLER EXLINE, PLLC.

BP West Coast Products, LLC, Counter Defendant, represented by Daniel J. Oates , GRAHAM & DUNN, Douglas Clayton Berry , GRAHAM & DUNN & Kent Michael Fandel , GRAHAM & DUNN PC.


ORDER GRANTING IN PART AND DENYING IN PART MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION

MARSHA J. PECHMAN, Chief District Judge.

THIS MATTER comes before the Court on Defendants' motion to reconsider the Court's order granting sanctions and dismissing Defendants' counterclaims. (Dkt. No. 132.) The Court issued an order requesting a response from the Plaintiff and ordering pro hac vice Defense Counsel David Schiller to show cause why sanctions should not be shifted to him...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases