EON CORP IP HOLDING LLC v. SPRINT SPECTRUM, L.P.

No. C-12-01011 JST (EDL).

EON CORP IP HOLDING LLC, Plaintiff, v. SPRINT SPECTRUM, L.P., et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, N.D. California.

March 13, 2014.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

EON Corp IP Holdings LLC, Plaintiff, represented by John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Aleksandr Korzh, Hopkins & Carley, Cary Ferchill, Reed & Scardino LLP, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Christopher Andrew Hohn, Hopkins and Carley, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, John L. Hendricks, Reed and Scardino LLP, Mark William Halderman, Reed & Scardino LLP, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Nicholas Andrew Wyss, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP & Steven Paul Tepera, Reed & Scardino LLP.

Cisco Systems Inc, Defendant, represented by Matthew Sean Yungwirth, Duane Morris LLP, Richard L. Seabolt, Duane Morris LLP, Alison Marie Haddock, Duane Morris, LLP, David Carl Dotson, Duane Morris LLP, James Patrick Kelley, Ireland Carroll & Kelley, John Robert Gibson, Duane Morris LLP, Joseph Andrew Powers, Duane Morris LLP, Louis Norwood Jameson, Duane Morris LLP, Otis W Carroll, Jr, Ireland Carroll & Kelley, Stephanie Anne Hansen, Duane Morris & Wesley Wei-Ien Yuan, Duane Morris.

HTC America Inc, Defendant, represented by Eric Joseph Klein, Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP, Danielle Christine Crockett, Akin Gump Strauss Hauer Feld LLP, Fred I. Williams, Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP, Jerry Robin Selinger, Patterson & Sheridan, LLP, Jesse Davis Snyder, Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP, Kellie M Johnson, Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP, Matthew Sean Yungwirth, Duane Morris LLP, Teresa Wang Ghali, Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP & Todd Eric Landis, Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP.

United States Cellular Corporation, Defendant, represented by Ashish Nagdev, Sidley Austin LLP, Bryan K. Anderson, Sidley Austin LLP & Richard John O'Brien, Jr., Sidley Austin LLP.

Sprint Spectrum L.P., Defendant, represented by Michael E Zeliger, KL Gates LLP, Andrea B Reed, K&L Gates LLP, Christopher H Centurelli, KL Gates LLP, George S Haight, IV, K&L Gates LLP, John J. Cotter, K&L Gates, LLP & V. Raman Bharatula, KL Gates LLP.

Motorola Solutions, Inc., Defendant, represented by Frederick L. Whitmer, Kilpatrick Townsend and Stockton LLP, Byron Robert Chin, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Carl E Sanders, Kilpatrick Townsend and Stockton LLP, Christopher Schenck, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Dario A. Machleidt, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Eric H Findlay, Findlay Craft, LLP, James Lyle Howard, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Jessica Lea Hannah, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Matthew Sean Yungwirth, Duane Morris LLP, Roger Brian Craft, Findlay Craft & Steven David Moore, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP.

Motorola Mobility LLC, formerly known as Mobility Holdings Inc, Defendant, represented by Frederick L. Whitmer, Kilpatrick Townsend and Stockton LLP.

Motorola Mobility LLC, Defendant, represented by Bonnie Marie Grant, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Byron Robert Chin, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Carl E Sanders, Kilpatrick Townsend and Stockton LLP, Christopher Schenck, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Dario A. Machleidt, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Eric H Findlay, Findlay Craft, LLP, James Lyle Howard, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Jessica Lea Hannah, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Matthew Sean Yungwirth, Duane Morris LLP, Roger Brian Craft, Findlay Craft & Steven David Moore, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP.

Motorola Mobility LLC, Counter-claimant, represented by Frederick L. Whitmer, Kilpatrick Townsend and Stockton LLP, Byron Robert Chin, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Carl E Sanders, Kilpatrick Townsend and Stockton LLP, Eric H Findlay, Findlay Craft, LLP, James Lyle Howard, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Jessica Lea Hannah, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Roger Brian Craft, Findlay Craft, Steven David Moore, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Frederick L. Whitmer, Kilpatrick Townsend and Stockton LLP, Byron Robert Chin, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Carl E Sanders, Kilpatrick Townsend and Stockton LLP, Eric H Findlay, Findlay Craft, LLP, James Lyle Howard, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Jessica Lea Hannah, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Roger Brian Craft, Findlay Craft & Steven David Moore, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP.

Smith Micro Software Inc., Miscellaneous, represented by William J. Brucker, Stetina Brunda Garred & Brucker.

Devicescape, Miscellaneous, represented by Edward V. Anderson, SheppardMullin LLP.

EON Corp IP Holdings LLC, Counter-defendant, represented by John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP & Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP.

HTC America Inc, Counter-claimant, represented by Eric Joseph Klein, Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP, Danielle Christine Crockett, Akin Gump Strauss Hauer Feld LLP, Fred I. Williams, Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP, Jerry Robin Selinger, Patterson & Sheridan, LLP, Kellie M Johnson, Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP & Todd Eric Landis, Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP.

EON Corp IP Holdings LLC, Counter-defendant, represented by John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP & Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP.

Cisco Systems Inc, Counter-claimant, represented by Matthew Sean Yungwirth, Duane Morris LLP, Alison Marie Haddock, Duane Morris, LLP, David Carl Dotson, Duane Morris LLP, James Patrick Kelley, Ireland Carroll & Kelley, Joseph Andrew Powers, Duane Morris LLP, Louis Norwood Jameson, Duane Morris LLP, Otis W Carroll, Jr, Ireland Carroll & Kelley & Wesley Wei-Ien Yuan, Duane Morris.

EON Corp IP Holdings LLC, Counter-defendant, represented by John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP & Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP.

Sprint Spectrum L.P., Counter-claimant, represented by Michael E Zeliger, KL Gates LLP, Andrea B Reed, K&L Gates LLP, George S Haight, IV, K&L Gates LLP, John J. Cotter, K&L Gates, LLP & V. Raman Bharatula, KL Gates LLP.

EON Corp IP Holdings LLC, Counter-defendant, represented by John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP, John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP, John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP, John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP, John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP, John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP, John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP, John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP & Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP.

Motorola Solutions, Inc., Counter-claimant, represented by Eric H Findlay, Findlay Craft, LLP, Jessica Lea Hannah, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Roger Brian Craft, Findlay Craft, Steven David Moore, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP & Byron Robert Chin, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP.

EON Corp IP Holdings LLC, Counter-defendant, represented by John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP, John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP, John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Aleksandr Korzh, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP, John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP, John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP, John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Christopher Andrew Hohn, Hopkins and Carley, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP & Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP.

Sprint Spectrum L.P., Counter-claimant, represented by Michael E Zeliger, KL Gates LLP, Andrea B Reed, K&L Gates LLP, George S Haight, IV, K&L Gates LLP, John J. Cotter, K&L Gates, LLP & V. Raman Bharatula, KL Gates LLP.

Sprint Nextel Corporation, Counter-claimant, represented by Michael E Zeliger, KL Gates LLP, Andrea B Reed, K&L Gates LLP, George S Haight, IV, K&L Gates LLP & John J. Cotter, K&L Gates, LLP.

EON Corp IP Holdings LLC, Counter-defendant, represented by John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP, John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Christopher Andrew Hohn, Hopkins and Carley, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP, John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Christopher Andrew Hohn, Hopkins and Carley, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP & Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP.

HTC America Inc, Counter-claimant, represented by Danielle Christine Crockett, Akin Gump Strauss Hauer Feld LLP, Eric Joseph Klein, Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP, Fred I. Williams, Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP, Jerry Robin Selinger, Patterson & Sheridan, LLP, Kellie M Johnson, Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP, Teresa Wang Ghali, Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP & Todd Eric Landis, Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP.

EON Corp IP Holdings LLC, Counter-defendant, represented by John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Christopher Andrew Hohn, Hopkins and Carley, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP & Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP.

Cisco Systems Inc, Counter-claimant, represented by Matthew Sean Yungwirth, Duane Morris LLP, Richard L. Seabolt, Duane Morris LLP, Alison Marie Haddock, Duane Morris LLP, David Carl Dotson, Duane Morris LLP, James Patrick Kelley, Ireland Carroll & Kelley, Joseph Andrew Powers, Duane Morris LLP, Louis Norwood Jameson, Duane Morris LLP, Otis W Carroll, Jr, Ireland Carroll & Kelley, Stephanie Anne Hansen, Duane Morris & Wesley Wei-Ien Yuan, Duane Morris.

EON Corp IP Holdings LLC, Counter-defendant, represented by John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Christopher Andrew Hohn, Hopkins and Carley, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP, John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Christopher Andrew Hohn, Hopkins and Carley, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP, John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Christopher Andrew Hohn, Hopkins and Carley, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP, John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Christopher Andrew Hohn, Hopkins and Carley, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP, John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Christopher Andrew Hohn, Hopkins and Carley, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP, John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Christopher Andrew Hohn, Hopkins and Carley, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP, John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP, John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP, John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Christopher Andrew Hohn, Hopkins and Carley, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP & Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP.

Motorola Solutions, Inc., Counter-claimant, represented by Frederick L. Whitmer, Kilpatrick Townsend and Stockton LLP, Byron Robert Chin, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Carl E Sanders, Kilpatrick Townsend and Stockton LLP, Eric H Findlay, Findlay Craft, LLP, James Lyle Howard, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Jessica Lea Hannah, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP, Roger Brian Craft, Findlay Craft & Steven David Moore, Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP.

EON Corp IP Holdings LLC, Counter-defendant, represented by John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP, Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP, John V. Picone, III, Hopkins & Carley, Chad Phillip Ennis, Reed & Scardino LLP, Craig Jepson, Reed & Scardino LLP, Daniel R. Scardino, Reed & Scardino LLP, Jennifer S. Coleman, Hopkins & Carley, Matthew Murrell, Reed & Scardino LLP & Raymond William Mort, III, Reed & Scardino LLP.


ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO STRIKE AND DENYING MOTION TO SEAL

ELIZABETH D. LAPORTE, District Judge.

Defendant HTC America, Inc. ("HTC") moves to strike all references in Plaintiff's expert reports relating to HTC devices that Plaintiff did not identify in its infringement contentions. HTC also moves to seal Exhibits A, B, and C to the Klein declaration. For the reasons set forth below, the Court grants HTC's motion to strike and denies its motion to seal.<...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases