IN RE FOSAMAX

MDL No. 2243 (JAP-LHG), Civil Action No. 12-03259.

IN RE: FOSAMAX (ALENDRONATE SODIUM) PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION (NO. II) RELATES TO PATRICK WELSH, et al., Plaintiffs, v. MERCK SHARPE & DOHME CORP., et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, D. New Jersey.

August 8, 2012.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

PHYLLIS MOLNAR, Plaintiff, represented by AMBER RACINE , ANAPOL SCHWARTZ WEISS COHAN FELDMAN & SMALLEY PC, EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DONALD A. ECKLUND , CARELLA, BYRNE, CECCHI, OLSTEIN, BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C. & GREGORY S. SPIZER , ANAPOL, SCHWARTZ, WEISS, COHEN, FELDMAN & SMALLEY, PC.

WILLIAM MOLNAR, Plaintiff, represented by AMBER RACINE , ANAPOL SCHWARTZ WEISS COHAN FELDMAN & SMALLEY PC, EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DONALD A. ECKLUND , CARELLA, BYRNE, CECCHI, OLSTEIN, BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C. & GREGORY S. SPIZER , ANAPOL, SCHWARTZ, WEISS, COHEN, FELDMAN & SMALLEY, PC.

GLORIA HOLBROOK, 11-3248, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, James John Zonas & Jason S. Schwartz , James Zonas.

MARILYN YOUNG, 11-3225, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, CHRISTOPHER A. SEEGER , SEEGER WEISS LLP & JAMES E. CECCHI , CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C..

BETTY MILLER, 11-3174, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC, David A. Nester , Nester & Constance & JEFFREY J. LOWE .

Lucille Collins, 11-3170, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & Melanie Sue Bailey , Burg Simpson Eldredge Hersh Jardine, PC.

Sheila Salvatore, 11-3169, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & ROBERT G. RAFFERTY , RAFFERTY & REDLISKY.

Jeanette S. Chaires, 11-3168, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DAVID P. MATTHEWS , MATTHEWS & ASSOCIATES & Jason C. Webster .

Virginia Lee Germino, 11-3165, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & DAVID B. RHEINGOLD , RHEINGOLD, VALET & RHEINGOLD.

Janet L Boudreaux, 11-3164, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & JACQUES PIERRE SOILEAU , SOILEAU & SOILEAU.

Walter A Boudreaux, 11-3164, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & JACQUES PIERRE SOILEAU , SOILEAU & SOILEAU.

Shirley Homler, 11-3162, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & BRIAN CUMMINGS , LEVINE, ORR & GERACIOTI.

Linette Santos-Meagher, 11-3167, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & RONALD R. BENJAMIN .

PATRICK WELCH, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Marilyn Banderet, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Louis Banderet, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Helga Barna, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Ruth Bennett, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Geertruida Berman, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Wulfred Berman, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Thomas Bianculli, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Betty Bianculli, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Laura Bostick, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Norma Boue, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Angel Boue, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Elizabeth Bradley, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Lana Jean Brownlee, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Richard E. Brownlee, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Natalie Casalino, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Charles A. Casalino, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Kathleen Chase, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Carolyn L. Clark, 11-3045 12-3259, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Phyllis Clark, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

BOB CLARK, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Connie Cline, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Mary Joeann Clutts, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Marcia Crow, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Georgina DeMato, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Bart J. DeMato, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Jean Eseppi, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Cathy Feeler, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Sandra Fram, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Harriet Gasway, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Linda Gentry, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Judith Gervasi-Wiley, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

JAMES WILEY, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Rose Golubik, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Judith Hart, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Kurt Hathaway, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Karen Hathaway, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Johna Hopkins, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Allen N. Hopkins, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Gertrude Irvine, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Karen Jacobs, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

CHARLES KING, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Regina Krebs, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Roland Krebs, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Marlene Lieberman, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Jean Liu, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Been Z. Wang, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Mary Martinez, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Wendy Marino, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Lucille L. McGowan, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

JOHN MCGOWAN, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Mary K. McKinnon, 11-3045 12-3259, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Fred McKinnon, 11-3045 12-3259, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Diane Merrill, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Alan Isaacson, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Glenn David Meyer, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Esther Morton, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Virginia Neumann, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Ann Nielson, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Phil R. Nielson, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Glenda Pace, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Virgeon A. Pace, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Josephine Papale, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Charles Papale, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Jewell Parker, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Wiley Parker, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Marie Paul, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Donna Puisis, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Shirley Reno, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

ELIZABETH RIVERA, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Marlene Romig, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Richard Romig, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Judith Rose, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Sophie Ruiz, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Pearla San Vicente, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Elaine Schaeffer, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Joan Shaller, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Virginia Shanabarger, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Ruth Siedman, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Barbara J. Soukup, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Jerry Soukup, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Mary Sprang, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Elaine Stannard, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

James Allen Stannard, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Peggy Stoklosa, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Phuong Vu, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C., DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Cathy Wallinder, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Richard Wallinder, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

June Weatherley, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Claudia White, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Jim White, 11-3045, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS P. DOWD , DOWD & DOWD PC, JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C. & MICHAEL WARREN JOHNSTON , THE LEVENSTEN LAW FIRM PC.

Beverly Sunshine, 11-3309, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & BRIAN K. MATISE , BURG SIMPSON ELDREDGE HERSH & JARDINE PC.

Lawrence Sunshine, 11-3309, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & BRIAN K. MATISE , BURG SIMPSON ELDREDGE HERSH & JARDINE PC.

BARBARA SUTTON, 11-3310, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & MARK A. TATE , TATE LAW GROUP LLC.

Charles Sutton, Jr., 11-3310, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & MARK A. TATE , TATE LAW GROUP LLC.

JUDITH DAVIS, 11-3313, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, AARON M. LEVINE , AARON M. LEVINE & ASSOCIATES, P.A, BENJAMIN JAY COOPER , AARON M. LEVINE & ASSOCIATES & Brandon J. Levine , AARON M. LEVINE & ASSOCIATES.

MICHAEL MICKALIGER, 11-3313, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, AARON M. LEVINE , AARON M. LEVINE & ASSOCIATES, P.A, BENJAMIN JAY COOPER , AARON M. LEVINE & ASSOCIATES & Brandon J. Levine , AARON M. LEVINE & ASSOCIATES.

PATRICIA ANN JOHNSON, 11-3320, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & BENJAMIN JAY COOPER , AARON M. LEVINE & ASSOCIATES.

JAMES WOLOWICK, 11-3320, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & BENJAMIN JAY COOPER , AARON M. LEVINE & ASSOCIATES.

NANCY ANTOINETTE WOLOWICK, 11-3320, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & BENJAMIN JAY COOPER , AARON M. LEVINE & ASSOCIATES.

MARGARET GOZDZIAK, Plaintiff in 09-5630, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

THOMAS DUKE, Plaintiff in 09-5693, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

DOLORES DUKE, Plaintiff in 09-5693, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP

DOLORES KUCZAJDA, Plaintiff in 10-0679, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

DOLORES KUCZAJDA, Plaintiff in 10-0679, Plaintiff, represented by NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

THOMAS F. KUCZAJDA, Plaintiff in 10-0679, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

RUSS SCHULTZ, Plaintiff in 10-3545, Plaintiff, represented by AMBER RACINE , ANAPOL SCHWARTZ WEISS COHAN FELDMAN & SMALLEY PC, EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

SUSAN S. SCHULTZ, Plaintiff in 10-3545, Plaintiff, represented by AMBER RACINE , ANAPOL SCHWARTZ WEISS COHAN FELDMAN & SMALLEY PC, EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

CYNTHIA H. HINES, Plaintiff in 10-4839, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

ROBERT N. HINES, Plaintiff in 10-4839, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

DENISE LIBKE, Plaintiff in 10-4981, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

ROGER LIBKE, Plaintiff in 10-4981, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

JOAN H. GOODWIN, Plaintiff in 10-5461, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

BARBARA R. MOLINE, Plaintiff in 10-5462, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

RONALD MOLINE, Plaintiff in 10-5462, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

LOUELLA LAMIRANDE, Plaintiff in 10-6049, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

KATHRYN K. WHEELER, Plaintiff in 10-6282, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

ELAYNE DENKER, Plaintiff in 11-0033, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

STEPHEN DENKER, Plaintiff in 11-0033, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

NANCY HEATON, Plaintiff in 11-0570, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH , THE MILLER FIRM LLC.

VIRGINIA BONNE, Plaintiff in 11-0571, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH , THE MILLER FIRM LLC.

ALICE LEFEBVRE, Plaintiff in 11-0586, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH , THE MILLER FIRM LLC.

MARIE HOGAN, Plaintiff in 11-0587, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH , THE MILLER FIRM LLC.

CAROL REIDY, Plaintiff in 11-0588, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH , THE MILLER FIRM LLC.

LILLIE KARCH, Plaintiff in 11-0589, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH , THE MILLER FIRM LLC.

J. THOMAS SULLIVAN, Plaintiff in 11-0869, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

SUSAN WALRAED, Plaintiff in 11-0869, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

THERESA METZ, Plaintiff in 11-1286, Plaintiff, represented by AMBER RACINE , ANAPOL SCHWARTZ WEISS COHAN FELDMAN & SMALLEY PC, EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

LAUREN KOLB, Plaintiff in 11-1498, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

RALPH KOLB, Plaintiff in 11-1498, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

DEBBIE J. PRINCE, Plaintiff in 11-1529, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

JAMES E. PRINCE, Plaintiff in 11-1529, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

Ethelinda Nelson, 11-3367, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, CRAIG DANIEL ROSENBAUM , ROSENBAUM & ROSENBAUM PC & CRAIG DANIEL ROSENBAUM , ROSENBAUM & ROSENBAUM PC.

Irene A. Granato, 11-3369, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & DAVID BRANDON SATISKY , BELLUCK & FOX LLP.

Samuel W. Granato, 11-3169, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & DAVID BRANDON SATISKY , BELLUCK & FOX LLP.

Marilyn Jeffries, 11-3370, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, FRANK E. PISCITELLI , PISCITELLI LAW FIRM & James S. Gemelas , SMITH, ILLNER AND GEMELAS CO LPA.

Barbara Graves, 11-3645, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & RICHARD WILLIAM SCHULTE , BEHNKE MARTIN & SCHULTE LLC.

Mary Swiatowy, 11-3646, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS ROBERT PLYMALE , THE DUGAN LAW FIRM, Frank Jacob D'Amico, Jr. , Law Offices of Frank J. D'Amico, Jr. (New Orleans) & JAMES R DUGAN, II , THE DUGAN LAW FIRM.

ELIZABETH BROWN, 11-3867, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, CALVIN S. TREGRE, JR. , BURG SIMPSON ENDREDGE HERSH & JARDINE PC & JANET G. ABARAY , BURG, SIMPSON, ELDREDGE, HERSH & JARDINE, PC.

ROBERT BROWN, 11-3867, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARY EVELYN VAN, 11-3911, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, ARNOLD B. LEVIN , LEVIN, FISHBEIN, SEDRAN & BERMAN, LPA, CHRISTOPHER A. SEEGER , SEEGER WEISS LLP, FRED S. LONGER , LEVIN FISHBEIN SEDRAN & BERMAN, LAURENCE S. BERMAN & MICHAEL M. WEINKOWITZ , LEVIN, FISHBEIN, SEDRAN & BERMAN, ESQS..

EVELYN LAPAN, 11-3912, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, CHRISTOPHER A. SEEGER , SEEGER WEISS LLP & WESLEY CHADWICK COOK , BEASLEY, ALLEN, CROW, METHVIN PORTIS & MILES, P.C..

CAROL WIRTH, 11-3930, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CHRISTOPHER A. SEEGER , SEEGER WEISS LLP.

Deloris M. Zessin, 11-3918 11-3919, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, Anne M. O'Brien , LAMSON, DUGAN LAW FIRM, William R. Johnson , LAMSON, DUGAN LAW FIRM & William M. Lamson, Jr. , LAMSON, DUGAN LAW FIRM.

Robert F. Zessin, 11-3918 11-3919, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, Anne M. O'Brien , LAMSON, DUGAN LAW FIRM, William R. Johnson , LAMSON, DUGAN LAW FIRM & William M. Lamson, Jr. , LAMSON, DUGAN LAW FIRM.

MARY E. DEMATTO, 11-1886, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NORMAN PERLBERGER , POMERANTZ, PERLBERGER & LEWIS, LLP.

Cheryl Eastwood, 11-5188, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL E. BECNEL , EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, JORDAN LUCAS CHAIKIN , PARKER WAICHMANALONSO LLP & Matthew J. McCauley , Parker Waichman Alonso LLP.

Josephine P. Naccio, 11-4055, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, JOHN R WHALEY , NABLETT, BRAD & ARSENAULT, Mary N. Bennett , Neblett, Beard & Arsenault & RICHARD J. ARSENAULT , NEBLETT, BEARD & ARSENAULT.

Mary Lou Foerschler, 11-4136, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & MARK J. METZGER , GOLDSTEIN & METZGER.

PATRICIA LYMAN, 11-4160, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & JAMES P. GINZKEY .

Peggy Foley, 11-4171, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CALVIN S. TREGRE, JR. , BURG SIMPSON ENDREDGE HERSH & JARDINE PC.

Judith Pew, 11-4172, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & Benjamin H. Anderson , Anderson Law Office.

Lois Takamori, 11-4241, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, Diane T. Ono , Galiher DeRobertis Ono, Gary O. Galiher , Galiher DeRobertis Ono, Ilana Kananipiliokala Waxman , Galiher DeRobertis Ono, L. Richard DeRobertis , Galiher DeRobertis Ono, Michael A. Ragsdale , Galiher DeRobertis Ono, Scott K. Saiki , Galiher DeRobertis Ono & Todd W. Eddins , Galiher DeRobertis Ono.

Neal Takamori, 11-4241, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, Diane T. Ono , Galiher DeRobertis Ono, Gary O. Galiher , Galiher DeRobertis Ono, Ilana Kananipiliokala Waxman , Galiher DeRobertis Ono, L. Richard DeRobertis , Galiher DeRobertis Ono, Michael A. Ragsdale , Galiher DeRobertis Ono, Scott K. Saiki , Galiher DeRobertis Ono & Todd W. Eddins , Galiher DeRobertis Ono.

Molly O'Brien, 11-4242, Plaintiff, represented by BRIAN J. MALLOY , EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & THOMAS J. BRANDI , THE BRANDI LAW FIRM.

LAURA EVANS, 11-4277, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, JONATHAN MICHAEL SEDGH , MICHAEL E. PEDERSON & PERRY WEITZ .

WILLIAM EVANS, 11-4277, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, JONATHAN MICHAEL SEDGH , MICHAEL E. PEDERSON & PERRY WEITZ .

Rachel C Souledier, 11-4284, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & LAURA MCJIMSEY RANDALL , RAMSEY SKILES & STREVA.

Warren Souledier, 11-4284, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & LAURA MCJIMSEY RANDALL , RAMSEY SKILES & STREVA.

Dorene F. Mansfield, 11-4290, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & Michael L. Williams , Williams Love O'Leary & Powers, PC.

Harvey Warner, 11-4955, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, Douglas L. Winston , Berger & Zavesky & Robert J. Zavesky , Berger & Zavesky.

SHARON WARNER, 11-4955, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, Douglas L. Winston , Berger & Zavesky & Robert J. Zavesky , Berger & Zavesky.

Julia A Krieg, 11-4956, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

Larry E Krieg, 11-4956, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

Anna K. Helmly, 11-5003, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, ROBERT CAWOOD & ROY LENARD MASON , MASON AND CAWOOD PA.

NANCY MURPHY, 11-5082, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & FRANK E. PISCITELLI , PISCITELLI LAW FIRM.

SHIRLEY HARDY, 11-5077, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & FRANK E. PISCITELLI , PISCITELLI LAW FIRM.

SHIRLEY GRASSUCCI, 11-5083, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & MICHAEL A. LONDON , DOUGLAS & LONDON, PC.

MARTHA MARKS, 11-5079, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & FRANK E. PISCITELLI , PISCITELLI LAW FIRM.

LORICE CORTEZ, 11-5025, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

Sandra Kahn, 11-5150, Plaintiff, represented by BRIAN J. MALLOY , EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & THOMAS J. BRANDI , THE BRANDI LAW FIRM.

Judith C. Hoholik, 11-5305, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, CHARLES H. JOHNSON & JONATHAN R. MENCEL , LAW OFFICES OF CHARLES H. JOHNSON PA.

MARY PATRICIA CLOUGHTERY, 11 5295, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

REIKO NAKAMURA, 11-5297, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CHRISTOPHER A. SEEGER , SEEGER WEISS LLP.

SYLVIA EDWARDS, 11-5300, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SUSAN JOHNSON, 11-5301, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ELEANOR ONAKA, 11 5302, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SYLVIA SCOTT, 11-5303, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

BERNADETTE GLYNN, 11-5304, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

RICHARD GLYNN, 11-5304, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

BETTY JEAN WHITT, 11 5335, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & FRANK E. PISCITELLI , PISCITELLI LAW FIRM.

BARBARA FRAMPTON, 11-5564, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NEIL DUANE OVERHOLTZ , AYLSTOCK WITKIN & SASSER.

JEAN PENIGIAN, 11-5703, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & DAVID B. KRANGLE , Alonso Krangle LLP.

KATHRYN SQUIRES, 11-5720, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & AARON M. LEVINE , AARON M. LEVINE & ASSOCIATES, P.A.

JoAnn Collins, 11-5826, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, James A Morris, Jr , Morris Law Firm & Kacie LeAnn Starr , Morris Law Firm.

LORETTA BROGNA, 11-5912, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

PETER BROGNA, 11-5912, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

HELEN HODGE, 11-6162, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ELLSWORTH HODGE, 11-6162, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

VIVIAN STARK, 11-6164, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JERRIE WILLIAMS, 11-6244, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

LAURA EVANS, 11-4277, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, JONATHAN MICHAEL SEDGH , WEITZ & LUXENBERG PC, MICHAEL E. PEDERSON & PERRY WEITZ , WEITZ & LUMENBERG PC.

WILLIAM EVANS, 11-4277, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, JONATHAN MICHAEL SEDGH , WEITZ & LUXENBERG PC, MICHAEL E. PEDERSON & PERRY WEITZ , WEITZ & LUMENBERG PC.

VALREE KROPF, 11-6346, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

BETTY VOSS, 11-6347, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

EUGENE VOSS, 11-6347, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JOAN VOLPENHEIN, 11-6345, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

LORI SCHORNICK, 11-6387, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

THERESA PITTMAN, 11-6386, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ANDRONIKI PANOUIS, 11-6411, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & JAMES DOUGLAS BARGER , AULSTOCK WITKIN KREIS & OVERHOLTZ PLLC.

ANGELA GRIBBEN, 11-6452, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH , THE MILLER FIRM LLC.

PAULA CHEE, 11-6451, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH , THE MILLER FIRM LLC.

Roberta Ourecky, 11-6468, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, Gary J. Nedved , KEATING, O'GARA LAW FIRM & Jefferson Downing , KEATING, O'GARA LAW FIRM.

JOSEPHINE PISARZ, 11-6419, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

WALTER PISARZ, 11-6419, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JOAN SCHICK, 11-6421, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JOHN CHARLES SCHICK, 11-6421, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

Carolyn Price, 11-6469, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, Gary L Wilson , Robins Kaplan Miller & Ciresi LLP & KATE E JAYCOX , ROBINS KAPLAN MILLER & CIRESI LLP.

Mary Belle White, 11-6478, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & Michael T Gallagher , The Gallagher Law Firm.

ELAINE F HOWE, 11-6657, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & RANDALL E. SMITH , SMITH ELLIOTT SMITH & GARMEY, PA.

JANE HOOVER, 11-6650, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & DOUGLAS ROBERT PLYMALE , THE DUGAN LAW FIRM.

JESSE JAY HOOVER, 11-6650, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & DOUGLAS ROBERT PLYMALE , THE DUGAN LAW FIRM.

JOHN WALTER CATON, 11-6649, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JOSEPHINE CATON, 11-6649, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CHARLES NELSON, 11-6695, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

GILDA NELSON, 11-6695, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARGARET CARE, 11-6694, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JUDY BREEDEN, 11-6749, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

Dorothy Picone, 11-6906, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & Theresa M. Walsh , Brown Chiari, LLP.

Ellen Marcy, 11-6922, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & Theresa M. Walsh , Brown Chiari, LLP.

ANN M. TORREGROSSA, 11-6874, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CHRISTOPHER A. SEEGER , SEEGER WEISS LLP.

DEBBIE STANDISH, 11-6912, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

KENNETH STANDISH, 11-6912, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

Janet Johnson, 11-6959, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & Nathalie Trepelkova , Rosenbaum & Rosenbaum, P.C..

DAVID WILKINS, 11-6945, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

EDITH WILKINS, 11-6945, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JANET COVEY, 11-6946, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SHIRLEY RADFORD, 11-6947, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

BRUCE RAYMOND POYNOR, 11-6948, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SHERRY POYNOR, 11-6948, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARIAN SONTAG, 11-6893, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARY ROBERTS, 11-6984, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

DON ALAN MAKO, 11-6982, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

RITA MAKO, 11-6982, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

GRETCHEN FLINT-NELSON, 11-7020, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

EDWARD NELSON, 11-7020, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SANDRA GORDON, 11-7022, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & Dennis F O Brien , Dennis F O Brien PA.

BARBARA HAVILAND, 11-7104, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JERRY A. SHACKELFORD, 11-7106, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARGARET SHACKELFORD, 11-7106, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ROSEMARY MATNEY, 11-7145, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

BARBARA MCGILL, 11-7185, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & GORDON BALL , BALL & SCOTT.

CHRISTINE MORGAN, 11-7186, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, ALLEN C. TITTLE , MELLINO ROBENALT LLC & THOMAS D. ROBENALT , MELLINO ROBENALT LLC.

Casey Rose, Power of Attorney for Christine Morgan 11-7186, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, ALLEN C. TITTLE , MELLINO ROBENALT LLC & THOMAS D. ROBENALT , MELLINO ROBENALT LLC.

Linda Schwalbe, 11-7208, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, Robert G Germany , Germany, Roberts & Welsh, L.L.P., Pro Hac Vice & Scot Daniel Warner , Warner and Warner, PL.

ROBERT SCHWALBE, 11-7208, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, Robert G Germany , Germany, Roberts & Welsh, L.L.P., Pro Hac Vice & Scot Daniel Warner , Warner and Warner, PL.

Charlotte Goldklang, 11-7279, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & JOHN C. GALLAGHER , GALLAGHER LAW OFFICES PLLC.

MARGARET CORDELL, 11-7400, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ANITA MISNER, 11-7401, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

LOUISE FINDLEY BURKE, 11-7429, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & WESLEY CHADWICK COOK , BEASLEY, ALLEN, CROW, METHVIN PORTIS & MILES, P.C..

JANICE M. BORRI, 11-7431, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & WESLEY CHADWICK COOK , BEASLEY, ALLEN, CROW, METHVIN PORTIS & MILES, P.C..

PATTY CARTER-MORCOMB, 11-7432, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ELEANOR MCKEE, 11-7493, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

RICHARD F. MCKEE, 11-7493, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

DONNA MESSERLI, 11-7491, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

PATTY CARTER-MORCOMB, 11-7432, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

VIRGINIA LENTZ, 11-7494, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CLAUDICE MAYES, 11-7516, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ROBERT MAYES, 11-7516, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

DONNA MESSERLI, 11-7491, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

PATRICIA DEGEN, 11-7519, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARY HENSLEY, 11-7518, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MICHAEL JOYCE, 11-7517, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CAROLINE MAHAN, 11-7520, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

WILMA MISTRETTA, 11-7521, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

THERESA SORRENTINO, 11-7522, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ASSUNTA TUCKER, 11-7523, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

VIRGINIA DRIVER, 11-7558, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

WILLIAM DRIVER, 11-7558, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

DEWEY GREEN, 11-7524, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARIELLA GREEN, 11-7524, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ANN P. GREENWAY, 11-7525, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & DAVID B. KRANGLE , Alonso Krangle LLP.

RALPH N. GREENWAY, 11-7525, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & DAVID B. KRANGLE , Alonso Krangle LLP.

JANE IVEY, 11-7557, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CATHERINE BUITRON, 11-7614, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

JULES BUITRON, 11-7614, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

BERNARD S. JUTH, 11-7613, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

JOANN M. JUTH, 11-7613, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

JAMES C. MOYERS, 11-7612, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

MARGARET S. MOYERS, 11-7612, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

ROSEANNE M. WALLIS, 11 7619, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

RUSSELL E. WALLIS, 11-7619, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

Sandra Y. Black, 12-33, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & Joe Sam Owen , OWEN, GALLOWAY & MYERS, PLLC.

ANN D. CARTER, 12-12, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

ROBERT E. MCDANIEL, 12 12, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

BETTY MURPHY, 12-14, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARK MURPHY, 12-14, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JOAN DUFFY, 12-16, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CHARLES W. NAGY, 12-18, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

NORMA NAGY, 12-18, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

LANI PINKNEY, 12-17, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CATRINIA SUTTON, Individually and as Proposed Executrix of the Estate of Thelma Neal Deceased 11-15, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

LEE RICHARDSON, 12-19, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARY LOPES, 12-23, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

RICHARD LOPES, 12-23, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

LEONE SKINNER, 12-21, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARVIN SKINNER, 12-21, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JULIE STEINERT, 12-22, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

STEPHEN MICHAEL STEINERT, 12-22, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MADGE SHEPHERD, 12-82, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & NANCY A. MISMASH , ROBERT J DEBRY & ASSOCIATES.

ANTHONY TARDUGNO, 12-118, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

PHYLLIS TARDUGNO, 12-118, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

Juanita Bordelon, 12-161, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, FRANKLIN DAVID BEAHM , BEAHM & GREEN & JACOB KENNETH BEST , BEAHM & GREEN.

Kenneth Bordelon, 12-161, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, FRANKLIN DAVID BEAHM , BEAHM & GREEN & JACOB KENNETH BEST , BEAHM & GREEN.

DIANE PAPPAS, 12-168, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MELINDA COVENTRY, 12-269, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

PATRICIA DAVIS, 12-273, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SUZANE FRANKLIN, 12-272, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CRAIG NESBITT, 12-268, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MILLY YANCU, 12-271, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

BOBBIE FOLAND, Individually and as Proposed Administratrix of the Estate of Judith Foland Deceased 12-278, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CLAUDIA GERARDO, 12-310, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MICHELE MANN, 12-311, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

EILEEN MUELLER, 12-312, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

Betty Burch Hunt, 12-375, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & BOBBY J BELL, JR. , HOLLIS WRIGHT & COUCH PC.

Elaine L. Murphy, 12-376, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & J Ransdell Keene , Law Office of J Ransdell Keene.

ROBERT WEISS, 12-374, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CALVIN S. TREGRE, JR. , BURG SIMPSON ENDREDGE HERSH & JARDINE PC.

Linda Weiss, 12-374, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CALVIN S. TREGRE, JR. , BURG SIMPSON ENDREDGE HERSH & JARDINE PC.

MARION FERGUSON, 12-377, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CHRISTOPHER T. HELLUMS , PITTMAN DUTTON & HELLUMS PC

MARION FERGUSON, 12-377, Plaintiff, represented by JONATHAN S MANN , PITTMAN DUTTON & HELLUMS PC.

Jack C. Ferguson, 12-377, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CHRISTOPHER T. HELLUMS , PITTMAN DUTTON & HELLUMS PC

Jack C. Ferguson, 12-377, Plaintiff, represented by JONATHAN S MANN , PITTMAN DUTTON & HELLUMS PC.

MARY L. HELD, 12-360, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

ROBERT T. HELD, 12-360, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

ELLA EISEN, 12-391, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

HERBERT EISEN, 12-391, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ELVIA RANGEL, 12-392, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CAROLYN SCHENDLE, 12-404, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JACK THOMASSON, 12-403, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

PATSY MAE THOMASSON, 12-403, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JAMES SCHENDLE, 12-404, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

Charlotte Hogan, 12-464, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, AMY LIN HADRA , BIRD LAW GROUP PC, Stephen L. Goldner , Bird Law Group, P.C. & William Q. Bird , Bird Law Group, P.C...

Ronald Hogan, 12-464, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, AMY LIN HADRA , BIRD LAW GROUP PC, Stephen L. Goldner , Bird Law Group, P.C. & William Q. Bird , Bird Law Group, P.C..

CHARLES A. BALDRIDGE, 12-503, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

WILEMINA BALDRIDGE, 12-503, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

DOREEN MCCABE, 12-504, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JOHN P. MCCABE, 12-504, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JUDITH MCCABE, 12-508, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CECIL PAYNE, 12-507, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

TIMOTHY PAYNE, 12-507, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

RUBY BRISCOE, 12-565, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CAROLYN GREGORI, 12-566, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARIE HEINONEN, 12-567, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CATHERINE HUENEFELD, 12-564, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CAROLYN RATH, 12-568, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SHIRLIE ROUSEY, 12-569, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ESTHER SIMPSON, 12-570, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ROBERT L. STOTTS, SR., 12-672, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

WILMA STOTTS, 12-572, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SHARON WILSON, 12-571, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

David A. Rubano, 12-579, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, CHARLES H. JOHNSON & JONATHAN R. MENCEL , LAW OFFICES OF CHARLES H. JOHNSON PA.

Leonarda Salazar, 12-580, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, CHARLES H. JOHNSON & JONATHAN R. MENCEL , LAW OFFICES OF CHARLES H. JOHNSON PA.

GABRIEL ROSENFELD, 12-226, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

LOUISE P. ROSENFELD, 12-226, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

RUBY L. STARCHMAN, 12-225, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

HELEN BEGANY, 12-590, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

EVA COOPER, 12-595, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MYRNA EVERLY, 12-588, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

BARBARA FINN, 12-591, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SHARON GOODMAN, 12-587, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

B. MICHAEL KRAYNICK, 12-589, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JUDITH KRAYNICK, 12-589, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARY MIGATULSKI, 12-593, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ALICE REITZ, 12-594, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

LOIS SCOTT, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

RICHARD SCOTT, 12-592, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARGARET DELAGARZA, 12-622, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MYRTLE FILSHIE, 12-624, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ARTEMIS FRANGOS, 12-625, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ELLEN SHAPIRO, 12-623, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

LEON SHAPIRO, 12-623, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

STEPHANIE FREELIN, 12-626, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SARA GRASSEL, 12-627, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

BEVERLY HALPERN, 12-628, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ROBERT HARVEY, 12-629, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

HENRY HUGO, 12-630, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JUNE HUGO, 12-630, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

RENAE JONES, 12-631, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARY LOU MODLIN, 12-632, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CLARICE OGUNLAVE, 12-636, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

PRISCILLA SINGH, 12-640, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

RICHARD PALMER, 12-644, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

TERRY STEPHENS, 12-641, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

NORMAN WORTHINGTON, 12-643, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

RENEE WORTHINGTON, 12-643, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CLAUDIA JAMES, 12-645, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

KAROL DEAN JAMES, 12-645, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SUSAN DIRKS, 12-650, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARGARET KOZLOSKI, 12-647, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ROXIE MOGLER MATTHEWS, 12-648, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

LULA NEWMAN, 12-649, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JULIA ANN CARPENTER, 12-651, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ROBERTA MADARY, 12-654, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

NELDA RIMSTIDT, 12-655, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ROBERT RIMSTIDT, 12-655, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

BARBARA BALSAM, 12-657, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

THEODORE BALSAM, 12-657, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

DOROTHY MESTER, 12-658, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

WILLIAM MESTER, 12-658, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SHERRI TAYLOR, 12-656, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ARLEEN RAVEN, 12-659, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

NORMAN RAVEN, 12-659, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARION DWYER, 12-663, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARLENE ECK, 12-664, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

RONNIE ECK, 12-664, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

BARBARA GARRETT, 12-660, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

LAVERTA LONGNECKER, 12-661, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

BARBARA SMITH, 12-662, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

DAVID STILL, 12-666, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

NANETTE STILL, 12-666, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

LYNNITA USELTON, 12-665, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JO WHEELER, 12-667, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

Theresa Thomas-Walsh, 12-707, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CALVIN S. TREGRE, JR. , BURG SIMPSON ENDREDGE HERSH & JARDINE PC.

PATRICK WALSH, 12-707, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CALVIN S. TREGRE, JR. , BURG SIMPSON ENDREDGE HERSH & JARDINE PC.

DORIS ERICKSON, 12-715, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, BERNARD DASKAL , LYNCH, DASKAL & EMERY, LLP & SCOTT ANDREW HARFORD , LYNCH DASKAL EMERY LLP.

NANCY SWANSON, 12-714, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

WAYNE SWANSON, 12-714, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

HAROLD PEARSON, 12-750, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

LINDA PEARSON, 12-750, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

VIRGINIA TAYLOR, 12-765, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CHARLES H. JOHNSON .

THOMAS UNDERHILL, 12-762, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, BERNARD DASKAL , LYNCH, DASKAL & EMERY, LLP & SCOTT ANDREW HARFORD , LYNCH DASKAL EMERY LLP.

ALEX BRYANT, 12-790, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

JANE BRYANT, 12-790, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

JOANNA CIRAOLO, 12-791, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

ELAYNE BARBARA NORD, 12-789, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

RONALD V. TRENSE, 12-789, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

HARRY SAVOY, 12-855, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JOSEPHINE SAVOY, 12-855, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JAMES W. MCNEILL, SR., 12-858, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, JR. , SHELLER, PC.

MILDRED B. MCNEILL, 12-858, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & BRIAN J. MCCORMICK, JR. , SHELLER, PC.

Emma Gentile, 12-928, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & MATTHEW JOSEPH MCCAULEY , PARKER WAICHMAN LLP.

Sherry M. Walker, 12-943, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, David Randolph Smith , Law Offices of David Randolph Smith & Associates, Dominick R. Smith , Law Offices of David Randolph Smith & Associates & Raymond T. Throckmorton, III , .

Nancy M. Richmond, 12-946, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & FELIX LEE BOWIE, III , DAVIDSON BOWIE SANDERS, PLLC.

Bobbie Jean Wood-Estes, 12-946, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & FELIX LEE BOWIE, III , DAVIDSON BOWIE SANDERS, PLLC.

Helen Wicher, 12-964, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & Theresa M. Walsh , Brown Chiari, LLP.

Susan Lange, as personal representative of Vera Lange 12-966, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & JOHN J. DRISCOLL , The Driscoll Firm, P.C..

Virginia Meldon, 12-974, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, CALVIN S. TREGRE, JR. , BURG SIMPSON ENDREDGE HERSH & JARDINE PC & JANET G. ABARAY , BURG, SIMPSON, ELDREDGE, HERSH & JARDINE, PC.

ROSALYN RENA FACTOR, 12-936, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

BONNIE L. MCCUNE, 12-950, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

Renee Drouet, 12-1036, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CALVIN S. TREGRE, JR. , BURG SIMPSON ENDREDGE HERSH & JARDINE PC.

Kerry A. Stroh, 12-1038, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CALVIN S. TREGRE, JR. , BURG SIMPSON ENDREDGE HERSH & JARDINE PC.

CAROL GOGGIN, 12-1021, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SUSAN JANE GOODMAN, 12-1035, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

WILLIAM L. GOODMAN, 12-1035, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

JOHN W. HOLTON, 12-1037, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

KAREN LYNN AYSCUE HOLTON, 12-1037, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

DENNIS E. GARMAN, 12-1020, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

ROSE ANN GARMAN, 12-1020, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

Reynold Plato, 12-1051, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CHRISTOPHER T. HELLUMS , PITTMAN DUTTON & HELLUMS PC

Ruth R. Plato, 12-1051, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

Ruth R. Plato, 12-1051, Plaintiff, represented by CHRISTOPHER T. HELLUMS , PITTMAN DUTTON & HELLUMS PC

Shirley DeClue, 12-1052, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

Shirley DeClue, 12-1052, Plaintiff, represented by David G. Bender , ROSENBLUM AND GOLDENHERSH, P.C..

BOBBIE JANE K. ARMSTRONG, 12-1013, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

JOHN V. ARMSTRONG, SR., 12-1013, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

CARLA A. GREENBERG, 12-1009, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

STEPHEN M. GREENBERG, 12-1009, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

VIVIAN B. RIPLEY, 12-1012, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

KAY J. WADE, 12-1018, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

ADELE E. KLEID, 12-1064, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

MARY L. MASSENGALE, 12-1062, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

LAARNI P. MEDINA, 12-1065, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

JAMES A. TEMPLETON, 12-1071, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

MARY F. TEMPLETON, 12-1071, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

AVERY E. VANNOY, SR., 12-1072, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

DORIS A. VANNOY, 12-1072, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

ETHEL WHITMAN, 12-1075, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

GLENN WHITMAN, 12-1075, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

Chester Gill, Individually and on behalf of the estate of his deceased wife Elaine Gill 12-1095, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, John D. Sileo , John D. Sileo, Attorney at Law & Kevin P. Riche , Kevin P. Riche, Attorney at Law.

HENRY F. D'ANGELO, 12-1093, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

KIMIKO D'ANGELO, 12-1093, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

THERESA CASTILLO, Successor in Interest to the Estate of MARIBEL CASTILLO 12-70, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & MARC DAVID GROSSMAN , SANDERS VIENER GROSSMAN, LLP.

CAROL T. HOLLANDER, 12-1107, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

CRAIG HOLLANDER, 12-1107, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

ELLIOT A. FULMER, 12-1108, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

IRENE M. FULMER, 12-1108, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

SOPHIE V. ORR, 12-1110, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

MARTHA L. SANCHEZ, 12-1109, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

RONALD A. HARROW, 12-1111, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

RONNIE M. HARROW, 12-1111, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

JOAN A. RAWSON, 12-1112, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

KEN SADOWSKI, 12-1113, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

PATRICIA A. SADOWSKI, 12-1113, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

LAURA LEE HILL, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

DOROTHY ATKINSON HUDSON, 12-1131, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

JOHN R. HUDSON, JR., 12-1131, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

MILLICENT WITKIN, 11-1142, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

BLOSSOM GITTER, 12-1135, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

YVETTE HARDY, 12-1132, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SHELDON LYNN, 12-1133, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

VIVIAN LYNN, 12-1133, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

EDNA CLOW, 12-1177, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JOHN DOLAN, 12-1178, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARGARET DOLAN, 12-1178, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

LINDA HULIK, 12-1179, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & BRADLEY DEAN HONNOLD .

EDWARD FITZPATRICK, 12-1181, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

NORA FITZPATRICK, 12-1181, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JAMES LYONS, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JANET LYONS, 12-1180, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

LEANNA BROWN, 12-1186, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

LINTON BROWN, 12-1186, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

TOKIA SUEHIRO, 12-1185, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

GARY SEIMS, 12-1187, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARCIE SEIMS, 12-1187, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ANTHONY WARREN, 12-1188, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JOYCE WAYCHOFF, 12-1189, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SALLY EDWARDS, 12-1203, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CLAUDE HILLENBURG, 1201202, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

WILMA HILLENBURG, 12-1202, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

BARBARA HIVELEY, 12-1201, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

DENMAN JONES, 12-1205, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

EDITH KAKAREKA, 12-1204, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

DANIEL MORRIS, 12-1220, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JOYCE MORRIS, 12-1220, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CHERYL MURPHY, 12-1221, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

EVELYN SPIRES, 12-1222, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

Gail Jefferies, 12-1322, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & EVAN D. BUXNER , THE BUXNER LAW FIRM.

JAMES STEVES, 12-1275, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, AMBER RACINE , ANAPOL SCHWARTZ WEISS COHAN FELDMAN & SMALLEY PC, GREGORY S. SPIZER , ANAPOL, SCHWARTZ, WEISS, COHEN, FELDMAN & SMALLEY, PC & TRACY A. FINKEN , ANAPOL, SCHWARTZ, WEISS, COHAN, FELDMAN & SMALLEY, PC.

SUSAN STEVES, 12-1275, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, AMBER RACINE , ANAPOL SCHWARTZ WEISS COHAN FELDMAN & SMALLEY PC, GREGORY S. SPIZER , ANAPOL, SCHWARTZ, WEISS, COHEN, FELDMAN & SMALLEY, PC & TRACY A. FINKEN , ANAPOL, SCHWARTZ, WEISS, COHAN, FELDMAN & SMALLEY, PC.

ANNA M. DAVIS, 12-1277, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

VIKKI L. HULIN, 12-1278, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

WILMA FLYNN, 12-1279, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, ROBERT DENNIS ZATORSKI , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, LLP, BARRY A KNOPF , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, ESQS & PETER S. PEARLMAN , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, LLP.

MARGARET ANN LEBLANC, 12-1280, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

ROY LEBLANC, 12-1280, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

SHARON BRYANT, 12-1329, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

LADONNA FIFER, 12-1327, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & WESLEY CHADWICK COOK , BEASLEY, ALLEN, CROW, METHVIN PORTIS & MILES, P.C..

NORMA M. JEPSON, 12-1326, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & WESLEY CHADWICK COOK , BEASLEY, ALLEN, CROW, METHVIN PORTIS & MILES, P.C..

JOSEPH MOORE, 12-1328, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARLENE MOORE, 12-1328, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

BETTY JO ROSS, 12-1325, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

F. RICHARD BISHOP, 12-1344, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & AARON M. LEVINE , AARON M. LEVINE & ASSOCIATES, P.A.

ROSEMARY BISHOP, 12-1344, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & AARON M. LEVINE , AARON M. LEVINE & ASSOCIATES, P.A.

KANTA MANOJ DHARAMSI, 12-1344, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & AARON M. LEVINE , AARON M. LEVINE & ASSOCIATES, P.A.

MANOJ DHARAMSI, 12-1344, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & AARON M. LEVINE , AARON M. LEVINE & ASSOCIATES, P.A.

JOHN N. HOWE, 12-1344, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & AARON M. LEVINE , AARON M. LEVINE & ASSOCIATES, P.A.

LINDA L. HOWE, 12-1344, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & AARON M. LEVINE , AARON M. LEVINE & ASSOCIATES, P.A.

ELINOR KOHLER, 12-1344, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & AARON M. LEVINE , AARON M. LEVINE & ASSOCIATES, P.A.

PURA GONZALEZ PETERSON, 12-1344, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & AARON M. LEVINE , AARON M. LEVINE & ASSOCIATES, P.A.

ROBERT R. PETERSON, 12-1344, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & AARON M. LEVINE , AARON M. LEVINE & ASSOCIATES, P.A.

JACQUELINE R. BURLESON, 12-1356, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & WESLEY CHADWICK COOK , BEASLEY, ALLEN, CROW, METHVIN PORTIS & MILES, P.C..

CAROLE M. FENTON, 12-1373, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

James Amato, 12-1395, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & LEE JAY HOLLIS , HOLLIS LAW FIRM.

Patricia Richard-Amato, 12-1395, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & LEE JAY HOLLIS , HOLLIS LAW FIRM.

EILENE G. COLLINS-BRIGHT, 12-1380, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

MARY S. COPE, 12-1385, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

BART MIRANDA, 12-1386, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

EDITH MIRANDA, 12-1386, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

BELEN D. NORA, 12-1382, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

MARILYN P. YOST, 12-1387, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, GARY LESTER WILSON , ROBINS KAPLAN MILLER & CIRESI LLP, KATE E JAYCOX , ROBINS KAPLAN MILLER & CIRESI LLP, TARA D. SUTTON , ROBINS KAPLAN MILLER CIRESI LLP & TROY F. TATTING , ROBBINS KAPLAN MILLER & CIRESI LLP.

NANCY JEAN VUICH, 12-1388, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

GAIL A. FLOWER, 12-1399, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

JAMES FLOWER, 12-1399, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

CARL FRANKLIN MARTIN, 12-1396, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

WANDA MARTIN, 12-1396, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

CHAN-HSIUNG WANG, 12-1397, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

SU-MEI WANG, 12-1397, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

BLAINE H. ZIMMERMAN, 12-1398, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

MARTHA FARR ZIMMERMAN, 12-1398, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

KATHERINE CROSS, 12-1410, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ANATALA S. CLIFTON, 12-1408, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

MICHAEL KOZLOV, 12-1406, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

SIMONE A. KOZLOV, 12-1406, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

MICHAELA SHEA MCINNIS, 12-1409, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

Patricia Crook, 12-1468, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & EVAN D. BUXNER , THE BUXNER LAW FIRM.

Maria Fulkerson, 12-1469, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & EVAN D. BUXNER , THE BUXNER LAW FIRM.

Paula R Courville, 12-1476, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & William E. Martin , MARTIN, OLIVEIRA & HAMEL, PC.

TERESITA MEJIA, 12-1449, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARGARET BIELECKY, 12-1484, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & TAYJES MATTHEW SHAH , THE MILLER FIRM LLC.

BARBARA GAYNOR, 12-1492, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ROBERT GAYNOR, 12-1492, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JUDITH WRIGHT, 12-1487, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

BILLIE JEAN BOOTY, 12-1550, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS ROBERT PLYMALE , THE DUGAN LAW FIRM, FRANK JACOB D'AMICO & JAMES R DUGAN, II , THE DUGAN LAW FIRM.

MAVIS HAYES, 12-1549, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

DELBERT STUIVE, 12-1548, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MADELINE STUIVE, 12-1548, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

HELEN ARNOLD, 12-1551, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

NELDA HANSON, 12-1552, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARIE COATS, 12-1553, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS ROBERT PLYMALE , THE DUGAN LAW FIRM, Frank Jacob D'Amico, Jr. , Law Offices of Frank J. D'Amico, Jr. (New Orleans) & JAMES R DUGAN, II , THE DUGAN LAW FIRM.

RUSSELL COATS, 12-1553, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG, DOUGLAS ROBERT PLYMALE , THE DUGAN LAW FIRM, Frank Jacob D'Amico, Jr. , Law Offices of Frank J. D'Amico, Jr. (New Orleans) & JAMES R DUGAN, II , THE DUGAN LAW FIRM.

GORDON LOVELL, individually and as executor of the Estate of Peggy Lovell, deceased 12-1554, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

FLORENCE CRAGO, 12-1561, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

NORMA MATZENBACHER, 12-1565, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARGARET STOCKMAN, 12-1564, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARION COLLIER, 12-1568, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

VERNE COLLIER, 12-1568, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

DAN LOWELL, 12-1567, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SARAH LOWELL, 12-1567, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

PETER STENCLER, 12-1566, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ROXANNA STENCLER, 12-1566, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

FAYE STOREY, 12-1570, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

GEORGE WALDRUP, 12-1569, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ROBERTA WALDRUP, 12-1569, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

PAULA HERBERT, 12-1635, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

Nora Krake, 12-1690, Plaintiff, represented by Myron E. Angstman , Angstman Law Office & William H. Ingaldson , Ingaldson Maassen & Fitzgerald.

Edward Bohn, 12-1715 on behalf of Patricia M. Bohn, Plaintiff, represented by FRANK E. PISCITELLI , PISCITELLI LAW FIRM.

Bernice Lavache, 12-1716, Plaintiff, represented by ERIC K. SCHWARZ , SULLIVAN PAPAIN BLOCK MCGRATH & CANNAVO PC.

Marshall A. Gallop, Jr., 12-1718, Plaintiff, represented by Charles Neal Pope , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood LLP, George W. Walker, III , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood, LLP, Michael Lee McGlamry , POPE MCLGAMRY KILPATRICK MORRISON & NORWOOD PC, N. KIRKLAND POPE , POPE MCGLAMRY KILPATRICK MORRISON & NORWOOD PC & William Usher Norwood , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood.

Martha C. Gallop, 12-1718, Plaintiff, represented by Charles Neal Pope , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood LLP, George W. Walker, III , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood, LLP, Michael Lee McGlamry , POPE MCLGAMRY KILPATRICK MORRISON & NORWOOD PC, N. KIRKLAND POPE , POPE MCGLAMRY KILPATRICK MORRISON & NORWOOD PC & William Usher Norwood , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood.

Mary Jo Gill, 12-1717, Plaintiff, represented by Charles Neal Pope , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood LLP, George W. Walker, III , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood, LLP, Michael Lee McGlamry , POPE MCLGAMRY KILPATRICK MORRISON & NORWOOD PC, N. KIRKLAND POPE , POPE MCGLAMRY KILPATRICK MORRISON & NORWOOD PC & William Usher Norwood , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood.

Farideh Kazemi, 12-1719, Plaintiff, represented by Charles Neal Pope , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood LLP, George W. Walker, III , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood, LLP, Michael Lee McGlamry , POPE MCLGAMRY KILPATRICK MORRISON & NORWOOD PC, N. KIRKLAND POPE , POPE MCGLAMRY KILPATRICK MORRISON & NORWOOD PC & William Usher Norwood , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood.

Reza Kazemi, 12-1719, Plaintiff, represented by Charles Neal Pope , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood LLP, George W. Walker, III , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood, LLP, Michael Lee McGlamry , POPE MCLGAMRY KILPATRICK MORRISON & NORWOOD PC, N. KIRKLAND POPE , POPE MCGLAMRY KILPATRICK MORRISON & NORWOOD PC & William Usher Norwood , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood.

Margie Jackson, 12-1750, Plaintiff, represented by Charles Neal Pope , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood LLP, George W. Walker, III , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood, LLP, Michael Lee McGlamry , POPE MCLGAMRY KILPATRICK MORRISON & NORWOOD PC, N. KIRKLAND POPE , POPE MCGLAMRY KILPATRICK MORRISON & NORWOOD PC & William Usher Norwood , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood.

ONNOLEE FREAY, 12-1754, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

BRENDA CHASE, 12-1786, Plaintiff, represented by KIRK GOZA , GOZA AND HONNOLD.

YVONNE THERESA SHEEHAN, 12-1817, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

ELIZABETH COLLINS, 12-1855, Plaintiff, represented by DOUGLAS ROBERT PLYMALE , THE DUGAN LAW FIRM.

BARBARA KEASER, 12-1850, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

Delia Forkel, 12-1848, Plaintiff, represented by ERIC K. SCHWARZ , SULLIVAN PAPAIN BLOCK MCGRATH & CANNAVO PC.

Raymond Forkel, 12-1848, Plaintiff, represented by ERIC K. SCHWARZ , SULLIVAN PAPAIN BLOCK MCGRATH & CANNAVO PC.

Alice Jones, 12-1846, Plaintiff, represented by NANCY A. MISMASH , ROBERT J DEBRY & ASSOCIATES.

Preston Merrell, 12-1845, Plaintiff, represented by NANCY A. MISMASH , ROBERT J DEBRY & ASSOCIATES.

Fern Lee Fracaro, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES E. SHIPLEY, JR. , TATE LAW GROUP LLC, MARK A. TATE , TATE LAW GROUP LLC & Raymond Carl Steadmon , Lane & Lane, LLC.

Elizabeth McKelvey, 12-1849, Plaintiff, represented by JOHN RAYMOND BEVIS , BARNES LAW GROUP LLC & Roy E. Barnes , The Barnes Law Group, LLC.

Joe McKelvey, 12-1849, Plaintiff, represented by JOHN RAYMOND BEVIS , BARNES LAW GROUP LLC & Roy E. Barnes , The Barnes Law Group, LLC.

BERNICE AZAR, 12-1786, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

LOIS BRENNER, 12-1875, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARY DAWSON, 12-1870, Plaintiff, represented by BRADLEY DEAN HONNOLD .

BERNICE AZAR, 12-1786, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

LOIS BRENNER, 12-1875, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARY DAWSON, 12-1870, Plaintiff, represented by BRADLEY DEAN HONNOLD .

JOHN HUBBARD, 12-1967, Plaintiff, represented by MICHAEL A. LONDON , DOUGLAS & LONDON, PC.

LINDA HUBBARD, 12-1967, Plaintiff, represented by MICHAEL A. LONDON , DOUGLAS & LONDON, PC.

DORIS ARNOLD, 12-1975, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

DEBORAH BESSER, Individually and as proposed executrix of the estate of Margaret Besser, deceased 12-1998, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

EARLENE DANDRIDGE, 12-1999, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

KENNETH TYRONE DANDRIDGE, 12-1999, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MIRYAM FREI, 12-1997, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CARLA HALLIGAN, 12-1996, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

TERESITA MEJIA, 12-2001, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JEAN PUSTILNIK, 12-2048, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

HARRIET STONE, 12-2002, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

KATHRYN WEISSBERGER, 12-2000, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

THEODORE PICKETT, 12-2121, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

GREGORY BOWDEN, 12-2127, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

DONALD LEO KNIFFEN, 12-2150, Plaintiff, represented by HOLLY H. DOLEJSI , ROBINS KAPLAN MILLER & CRESI LLP

DONALD LEO KNIFFEN, 12-2150, Plaintiff, represented by GARY LESTER WILSON , ROBINS KAPLAN MILLER & CIRESI LLP, KATE E JAYCOX , ROBINS KAPLAN MILLER & CIRESI LLP & TARA D. SUTTON , ROBINS KAPLAN MILLER CIRESI LLP.

DONNA LEE KNIFFEN, 12-2150, Plaintiff, represented by HOLLY H. DOLEJSI , ROBINS KAPLAN MILLER & CRESI LLP

DONNA LEE KNIFFEN, 12-2150, Plaintiff, represented by GARY LESTER WILSON , ROBINS KAPLAN MILLER & CIRESI LLP, KATE E JAYCOX , ROBINS KAPLAN MILLER & CIRESI LLP & TARA D. SUTTON , ROBINS KAPLAN MILLER CIRESI LLP.

CHRISTINE G. MAYER, 12-2159, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

Janet Hamman, 12-2189, Plaintiff, represented by Douglas D Small , Foley & Small LLP

LUCILLE DUNN, 12-2211, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

KIERSTEN LYNCH, 12-2210, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

Janet Lindenmeier, 12-2265, Plaintiff, represented by Barry D. Levy , O'Connor, Acciani & Levy, CALVIN S. TREGRE, JR. , BURG SIMPSON ENDREDGE HERSH & JARDINE PC & JANET G. ABARAY , BURG, SIMPSON, ELDREDGE, HERSH & JARDINE, PC.

Lester Lindenmeier, 12-2265, Plaintiff, represented by Barry D. Levy , O'Connor, Acciani & Levy, CALVIN S. TREGRE, JR. , BURG SIMPSON ENDREDGE HERSH & JARDINE PC & JANET G. ABARAY , BURG, SIMPSON, ELDREDGE, HERSH & JARDINE, PC.

Loretta DeStefano, 12-2266, Plaintiff, represented by Brenda S. Fulmer , Searcy Denney Scarola Barnhart & Shipley, P.A. & Clell Calvin Warriner, III , Searcy Denney Scarola Barnhart & Shipley.

Richard DeStefano, 12-2266, Plaintiff, represented by Brenda S. Fulmer , Searcy Denney Scarola Barnhart & Shipley, P.A. & Clell Calvin Warriner, III , Searcy Denney Scarola Barnhart & Shipley.

JAMES NELSON, 12-2258, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SUSAN NELSON, 12-2258, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

BARBARA FRYE, 12-2302, Plaintiff, represented by CALVIN S. TREGRE, JR. , BURG SIMPSON ENDREDGE HERSH & JARDINE PC & WILLIAM E. WININGHAM , WILSON KEHOE & WININGHAM

EDDIE FRYE, 12-2302, Plaintiff, represented by CALVIN S. TREGRE, JR. , BURG SIMPSON ENDREDGE HERSH & JARDINE PC.

EDDIE FRYE, 12-2302, Plaintiff, represented by WILLIAM E. WININGHAM , WILSON KEHOE & WININGHAM

EVELYN SUTHERLAND, 12-2328, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

IRMA SANDFORT, 12-2371, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MELVIN SANDFORT, 12-2371, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

PLAINTIFF STEERING COMMITTEE, Plaintiff, Pro Se.

CONNIE ODUM, 12-2451, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

IRVIN ODUM, 12-2451, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

Barbara Gilbert, 12-2547, Plaintiff, represented by GARY S GRYNKEWICH , SHOWARD LAW FIRM PC

Abolghassem Karimi-Azad, 12-2548, Plaintiff, represented by Charles Neal Pope , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood LLP.

Abolghassem Karimi-Azad, 12-2548, Plaintiff, represented by George W. Walker, III , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood, LLP, Michael Lee McGlamry , POPE MCLGAMRY KILPATRICK MORRISON & NORWOOD PC, N. KIRKLAND POPE , POPE MCGLAMRY KILPATRICK MORRISON & NORWOOD PC & William Usher Norwood , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood.

Talat Karimi-Azad, 12-2548, Plaintiff, represented by Charles Neal Pope , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood LLP, George W. Walker, III , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood, LLP, Michael Lee McGlamry , POPE MCLGAMRY KILPATRICK MORRISON & NORWOOD PC, N. KIRKLAND POPE , POPE MCGLAMRY KILPATRICK MORRISON & NORWOOD PC & William Usher Norwood , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood.

Greg Latta, 12-2549, Plaintiff, represented by Charles Neal Pope , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood LLP, George W. Walker, III , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood, LLP, Michael Lee McGlamry , POPE MCLGAMRY KILPATRICK MORRISON & NORWOOD PC, N. KIRKLAND POPE , POPE MCGLAMRY KILPATRICK MORRISON & NORWOOD PC & William Usher Norwood , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood.

Theresa Latta, 12-2549, Plaintiff, represented by Charles Neal Pope , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood LLP, George W. Walker, III , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood, LLP, Michael Lee McGlamry , POPE MCLGAMRY KILPATRICK MORRISON & NORWOOD PC, N. KIRKLAND POPE , POPE MCGLAMRY KILPATRICK MORRISON & NORWOOD PC & William Usher Norwood , Pope McGlamry Kilpatrick Morrison & Norwood.

CONNIE CANADAY, 12-2560, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

DONNA EDWARDS, 12-2561, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

DANNY LEE KIRKPATRICK, 12-2559, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JUDY KIRKPATRICK, 12-2559, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

TOWANDA BROWN, 12-2598, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

DOLORES COZIAHR, 12-2597, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

DOROTHY EVANS, 12-2596, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SHANTHI HIMALAYA, 12-2599, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

KAREN LACKEY, 12-2594, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ARTHUR MARGULIES, 12-2601, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ROSA LEE NEAL, 12-2595, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

VERA TRESSLER, 12-2600, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MAGUERITE CARTER, 12-2647, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JAMES HELDBERG, 12-2647, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JUDITH HELDBERG, 12-2647, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

GARY L. BROWN, 12-2731, Plaintiff, represented by DOUGLAS ROBERT PLYMALE , THE DUGAN LAW FIRM, Frank Jacob D'Amico, Jr. , Law Offices of Frank J. D'Amico, Jr. (New Orleans) & JAMES R DUGAN, II , THE DUGAN LAW FIRM.

PAULINE KONIECZNY, 12-2735, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SYLVIA MOORE, 12-2734, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CAROLYN BATES, 12-2770, Plaintiff, represented by BARRY A KNOPF , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, ESQS & PETER S. PEARLMAN , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, LLP.

AZUCENA HEN, 12-2771, Plaintiff, represented by BARRY A KNOPF , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, ESQS & PETER S. PEARLMAN , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, LLP.

Clifford J Sias, 12-2388, Plaintiff, represented by GARY S GRYNKEWICH , SHOWARD LAW FIRM PC

Clifford J Sias, 12-2388, Plaintiff, represented by Sarah J Showard , Showard Law Firm PC.

Diana Van Pelt Newel Sias, 12-2833, Plaintiff, represented by GARY S GRYNKEWICH , SHOWARD LAW FIRM PC

Diana Van Pelt Newel Sias, 12-2833, Plaintiff, represented by Sarah J Showard , Showard Law Firm PC.

Donald Otto, 12-2837, Plaintiff, represented by MATTHEW J SCHUMACHER , PEARSON RANDALL & SCHUMACHER PA

Harriet Otto, 12-2837, Plaintiff, represented by MATTHEW J SCHUMACHER , PEARSON RANDALL & SCHUMACHER PA

Bettie J. Best, 12-2838, Plaintiff, represented by Jacob A. Flint , LOWE LAW FIRM.

EVELYN WILSON CARTER, 12-2822, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

KATHLEEN S. CARTIER, 12-2835, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

HARRIET ELIZABETH CIANCI, 12-2859, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

KAREN G. COLLIER, 12-2860, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

MARY LEE UNDERHILL, 12-762, Plaintiff, represented by BERNARD DASKAL , LYNCH, DASKAL & EMERY, LLP, EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG & SCOTT ANDREW HARFORD , LYNCH DASKAL EMERY LLP.

Betty Saki Davis, 12-3017, Plaintiff, represented by GARY S GRYNKEWICH , SHOWARD LAW FIRM PC

Betty Saki Davis, 12-3017, Plaintiff, represented by Sarah J Showard , Showard Law Firm PC.

Joseph Charles Davis, 12-3017, Plaintiff, represented by GARY S GRYNKEWICH , SHOWARD LAW FIRM PC

Joseph Charles Davis, 12-3017, Plaintiff, represented by Sarah J Showard , Showard Law Firm PC.

ANGELITA DORIOTT, 12-3026, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JOHN DORIOTT, 12-3026, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

GERALDINE GOIAS, 12-3022, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MELVIN GOIAS, 12-3022, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

LUCILLE LONA, 12-3023, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

TONY LONA, 12-3023, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

DEBORAH MCMURRAY, 12-3025, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JAMES MCMURRAY, 12-3025, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

TAMARA PERRY, 12-3024, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARGARET ROBERTS, 12-3021, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

DONNA THIEMAN, 12-3027, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

WESLEY THIEMAN, 12-3027, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

BETTY STANLEY, 12-3052, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MAGDA YENICH, 12-3166, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

Stephanie Eshelman, 12-3260, Plaintiff, represented by Jacob A. Flint , LOWE LAW FIRM.

Maria Grillo, 12-3261, Plaintiff, represented by Jacob A. Flint , LOWE LAW FIRM.

Stephanie Eshelman, 12-3260, Plaintiff, represented by Jacob A. Flint , LOWE LAW FIRM.

Maria Grillo, 12-3261, Plaintiff, represented by Jacob A. Flint , LOWE LAW FIRM.

ADOLPH STEFANOWSKI, 12-3286, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

LUCY STEFANOWSKI, 12-3286, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

FRANCES BJORK, 12-3325, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARILYN GERBER, 12-3326, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CLARA NIVER, 12-3327, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ETHEL GOLDBERG, 12-3331, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

LARAINE HUDSON, 12-3335, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CLARA NIVER, 12-3327, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

KAI TONG, 12-3328, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

LUCY TONG, 12-3328, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SHARON USLAN, 12-3330, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

VIDA VENNER, 12-3329, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

Ira D. Indich, 12-3366, Plaintiff, represented by CALVIN S. TREGRE, JR. , BURG SIMPSON ENDREDGE HERSH & JARDINE PC.

Terry E. Indich, 12-3366, Plaintiff, represented by CALVIN S. TREGRE, JR. , BURG SIMPSON ENDREDGE HERSH & JARDINE PC.

RANDAL BUDD, 12-3346, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CARROL DYKES, 12-3348, Plaintiff, Pro Se.

MARSHA DYKES, 12-3348, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

EVA MYERS, 12-3347, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CAROLYN RITTENHOUSE, 12-3345, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ANA DIAZ, 12-3386, Plaintiff, represented by Jonathan Charles Reiter , Law Office Jonathan C. Reiter.

Carl A Travor, 12-3399, Plaintiff, represented by GARY S GRYNKEWICH , SHOWARD LAW FIRM PC

Carl A Travor, 12-3399, Plaintiff, represented by Sarah J Showard , Showard Law Firm PC.

Lois Annette Travor, 12-3399, Plaintiff, represented by GARY S GRYNKEWICH , SHOWARD LAW FIRM PC

Lois Annette Travor, 12-3399, Plaintiff, represented by Sarah J Showard , Showard Law Firm PC.

Judith Leavitt, 12-3400, Plaintiff, represented by Craig K Vernon , JAMES VERNON & WEEKS.

BARBARA STEEN, 12-3429, Plaintiff, represented by STUART LEE GOLDENBERG , GOLDENBERG LAW PLLC

SHIRLEY CHARMS, 12-3511, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

RICHARD D. SCHMITZ, 12-3506, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

JANICE DENHAM, 12-3696, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

GLENDA Y. SWEET, 12-3590, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

LOURDES TANGLAO, 12-3705, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

FRED E. JARRETT, 12-3591, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

JUNE B. JARRETT, 12-3591, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

LINDA DISOSWAY, 12-3730, Plaintiff, represented by JOHN DAVID HART .

Sandra Lare, 12-3769, Plaintiff, represented by LEE JAY HOLLIS , HOLLIS LAW FIRM & Michael W. Patrick , Law Office of Michael W. Patrick.

Arlene Nealen, 12-3770, Plaintiff, represented by Barry D. Levy , O'Connor, Acciani & Levy, CALVIN S. TREGRE, JR. , BURG SIMPSON ENDREDGE HERSH & JARDINE PC & JANET G. ABARAY , BURG, SIMPSON, ELDREDGE, HERSH & JARDINE, PC.

CAROLYN DERHAROOTUNIAN, 12-3789, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JOHN VOCCI, 12-3790, Plaintiff, represented by STEVEN B. BARRETT , HAMBURG RUBIN MULLIN MAXWELL & LUPIN PC

NANCY VOCCI, 12-3790, Plaintiff, represented by STEVEN B. BARRETT , HAMBURG RUBIN MULLIN MAXWELL & LUPIN PC

ALMA BAKER, 12-3878, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

YOSHIE MATEO, 12-3904, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

AGUSTIN PALMA, 12-3879, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

LUCITA PALMA, 12-3879, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CAROLINE YACOUB, 12-3795, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

PATRICIA A. TERRANOVA, 12-3939, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

LARRY HILL, 12-3959, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARY HILL, 12-3959, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MELANIE BRUFFETT, 12-3976, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

RONALD BRUFFETT, 12-3976, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

SELMA N. WILSON, 12-4014, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

FLORENCE BANNON, 12-4082, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

NORMAN R. HUFF, 12-4089, Plaintiff, represented by BERNARD DASKAL , LYNCH, DASKAL & EMERY, LLP & SCOTT ANDREW HARFORD , LYNCH DASKAL EMERY LLP.

BARBARA YOUNG, 12-4089, Plaintiff, represented by BERNARD DASKAL , LYNCH, DASKAL & EMERY, LLP & SCOTT ANDREW HARFORD , LYNCH DASKAL EMERY LLP.

Elizabeth Spitler, 12-4189, Plaintiff, represented by JAMES P. GINZKEY .

Kathleen Toland, 12-4190, Plaintiff, represented by David A Molle , Molle Law Offices.

Diana Russell, 12-4266, Plaintiff, represented by Jacob A. Flint , LOWE LAW FIRM.

MARGARET FILLIPPELLO, 12-4423, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

RALPH FILLIPPELLO, 12-4423, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

RAMONA HARRIS, 12-4424, Plaintiff, represented by ROBERT DENNIS ZATORSKI , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, LLP.

SHARIL CAFFERY, 12-4425, Plaintiff, represented by ROBERT DENNIS ZATORSKI , COHN, LIFLAND, PEARLMAN, HERRMANN & KNOPF, LLP.

CLARK BILES, 12-4439, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SUE GLENN, 12-4454, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SHARON LANE, 12-4426, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

LOUISE WHISENANT, 12-4440, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JOAN E. CARTER, 12-4453, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

CELIA A. GETZBERG, 12-4539, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

ALLYN C. HARRIS, 12-4496, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

MARIE E. HARRIS, 12-4496, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

BETTY J. LEES, 12-4451, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

STEPHANIE JANE ORENT, 12-4540, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

KAREN SWEET, 12-4566, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

Sandra Enfield, 12-4608, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel Adam Osborn , Osborn Law, P.C. & Philip Jeremy Miller , Osborn Law, P.C..

Esther Parker, 12-4611, Plaintiff, represented by MARCUS W. VILES , VILES & BECKMAN LLC

Elizabeth Whiteside, 12-4609, Plaintiff, represented by MATTHEW JOSEPH MCCAULEY , PARKER WAICHMAN LLP.

JUDITH FAVOR, 12-4604, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

TERRY HANKIN, 12-4602, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ANTONIA HERNANDEZ, 12-4601, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

NANCY HUTTON, 12-4599, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SUSAN SIGLIN, 12-4600, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

CHERYL MITCHELL, 12-4638, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

WILLIAM MITCHELL, 12-4638, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

Pamela Paralikis, 12-4656, Plaintiff, represented by Michael Lewis Beckman , Viles and Beckman, LLC.

ANTHONY BOTTARI, JR., 12-4663, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

DONNA BOTTARI, 12-4663, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

BETTY HEDGEPETH, 12-4664, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

Carol A. Piccirilli, 12-4682, Plaintiff, represented by CHARLES H. JOHNSON & REED A. FLATHMANN , LAW OFFICES OF CHARLES H. JOHNSON PA

ELEANOR DEUTSCH, 12-4723, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

BERNICE SPERBER, 12-4721, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MARLENE R. CURRIE, 12-4760, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

RONALD CURRIE, 12-4760, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

CHESTER PATRINA, 12-4773, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

YEN TRAN, 12-4757, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

CHI THANH TRINH, 12-4757, Plaintiff, represented by CARMEN SESSIONS SCOTT , MOTLEY RICE LLC.

GEORGE WORTHINGTON, 12-4762, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

JERRENE WORTHINGTON, 12-4762, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

PATRICIA FALCONE, 12-4802, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ELLEN HURA, 12-4803, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

SHARON WEAVER, 12-4804, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

EVAMAE WILLIAMS, 12-4805, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

ETHEL PATTERSON, 12-4836, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

Laurence Feingold, 12-4941, Plaintiff, represented by Sean Michael Cleary , Sean M. Cleary Law Offices.

Renee Feingold, 12-4941, Plaintiff, represented by Sean Michael Cleary , Sean M. Cleary Law Offices.

Gary Carter, 12-4940, Plaintiff, represented by GARY S GRYNKEWICH , SHOWARD LAW FIRM PC

Gary Carter, 12-4940, Plaintiff, represented by Sarah J Showard , Showard Law Firm PC.

Katherine S Carter, 12-4940, Plaintiff, represented by GARY S GRYNKEWICH , SHOWARD LAW FIRM PC

Katherine S Carter, 12-4940, Plaintiff, represented by Sarah J Showard , Showard Law Firm PC.

CAROLYN HANNAH, 12-4906, Plaintiff, represented by EDWARD BRANIFF , WEITZ & LUXENBERG.

MERCK & CO., INC., Defendant, represented by WILFRED P. CORONATO , HUGHES, HUBBARD & REED LLP, BRETT J. PRESTON , HILL WARD HENDERSON, Ben D. Whitwell , Skadden Arps Slate Meagher & Flom, Brent Roam , Bryan Cave & CHRISTINA LEE GAARDER , VENABLE LLP

MERCK & CO., INC., Defendant, represented by CHRISTOPHER TODD WILLIAMS , VENABLE LLP, DAN H. BALL , BRYAN CAVE, LLP & DAVID L. LUIKART, III , HILL WARD HENDERSON

MERCK & CO., INC., Defendant, represented by David J. Heubeck , Venable LLP (Baltimore), George H. Robinson, Jr. , Liskow & Lewis (LAF) & J. TANNER WATKINS , DINSMORE & SHOHL LLP

MERCK & CO., INC., Defendant, represented by JOHN H. BEISNER , O'MELVENY & MEYERS, LLP, James C. Fraser , Venable LLP (Baltimore), Pro Hac Vice, Jan R McLean Bernier , Nilan Johnson Lewis PA, Jessica Davidson Miller , Skadden, Arps, Slate,Meagher & Flom LLP - DC, KAREN A. CONFOY , STERNS & WEINROTH, PC, Michael L. Hecht , Venable LLP (Baltimore)m, Pro Hac Vice & Nancy M. Erfle , Schwabe Williamson & Wyatt, PC

MERCK & CO., INC., Defendant, represented by Norman Charles Kleinberg , Hughes Hubbard & Reed LLP (NY), PAUL F. STRAIN , VENABLE, BAETJER & HOWARF & RICHARD H.C. CLAY , DINSMORE & SHOHL LLP

MERCK & CO., INC., Defendant, represented by Rebecca A. Lindemann , Schwabe Williamson & Wyatt, PC

MERCK & CO., INC., Defendant, represented by STEVEN G. STRAUSS , BRYAN CAVE, LLP

MERCK & CO., INC., Defendant, represented by Scott A Smith , Nilan Johnson Lewis PA

MERCK & CO., INC., Defendant, represented by Theodore VanHuysen Mayer , Hughes Hubbard & Reed LLP (NY), Vanessa W Anseman , Liskow & Lewis (LAF) & William Joseph Beausoleil, Jr. , Hughes Hubbard & Reed LLP.

MERCK SHARPE & DOHME CORP., 11-3045, Defendant, represented by ERICA SUSAN HELMS , STERNS & WEINROTH, PC, BETTINA J. STRAUSS , BRYAN CAVE & CHRISTINA LEE GAARDER , VENABLE LLP

MERCK SHARPE & DOHME CORP., 11-3045, Defendant, represented by CHRISTOPHER PAUL MIDURA , STERNS & WEINROTH PC, DAN H. BALL , BRYAN CAVE, LLP, David J. Heubeck , Venable LLP (Baltimore), Dino S. Sangiamo , VENABLE LLP, George H. Robinson, Jr. , Liskow & Lewis (LAF) & J. TANNER WATKINS , DINSMORE & SHOHL LLP

MERCK SHARPE & DOHME CORP., 11-3045, Defendant, represented by JOHN H. BEISNER , O'MELVENY & MEYERS, LLP, James M. Doran, Jr. , Waller, Lansden, Dortch & Davis, Jan R McLean Bernier , Nilan Johnson Lewis PA, Jessica Davidson Miller , Skadden, Arps, Slate,Meagher & Flom LLP - DC, John F. McCaffrey , McLaughlin & McCaffrey, KAREN A. CONFOY , STERNS & WEINROTH, PC, M King Hill, III , Venable (MD), PAUL F. STRAIN , PAUL F. STRAIN & RICHARD H.C. CLAY , DINSMORE & SHOHL LLP

MERCK SHARPE & DOHME CORP., 11-3045, Defendant, represented by STEFAN A. MALLEN , BRYAN CAVE LLP, STEPHEN MORGAN LANZA , HUGHES HUBBARD & REED LLP & Scott A Smith , Nilan Johnson Lewis PA

MERCK SHARPE & DOHME CORP., 11-3045, Defendant, represented by Stephen E. Marshall , Pro Hac Vice, Vanessa W Anseman , Liskow & Lewis (LAF) & WILFRED P. CORONATO , HUGHES, HUBBARD & REED LLP.

NOVARTIS PHARMACEUTICALS CORPORATION, 11-3320, Defendant, represented by BETH S. ROSE , SILLS CUMMIS & GROSS P.C., CHARLES J. FALLETTA , SILLS CUMMIS & GROSS & Dana Alan Gausepohl , HOLLINGSWORTH LLP.

COBALT LABORATORIES, INC., Defendant, represented by LAURIE ALBERTS SALITA , BLANK ROME LLP & TERRY M. HENRY , BLANK ROME LLP.

COBALT PHARMACEUTICALS, INC., Defendant, represented by LAURIE ALBERTS SALITA , BLANK ROME LLP.

Northstar Rx LLC, 11-7279, Defendant, represented by JANET LYNN POLETTO , HARDIN, KUNDLA, MCKEON, POLETTO & POLIFRONI, PC & ADAM GRANDIN HUSIK , HARDIN KUNDLA.

GLAXOSMITHKLINE LLC, 11-6650, Defendant, represented by CHARLES F. RYSAVY , K&L Gates LLP.

HOFFMAN LA-ROCHE INC, 11-6650, Defendant, represented by CHARLES F. RYSAVY , K&L Gates LLP.

ROCHE LABORATORIES, INC., 11-6650, Defendant, represented by CHARLES F. RYSAVY , K&L Gates LLP.

GENENTECH, INC., A Delaware Corporation 12-707, Defendant, represented by CHARLES F. RYSAVY , K&L Gates LLP.

Warner-Chilcott Pharmaceuticals, Inc., 12-943, Defendant, represented by Kerry M. Ewald , Dickinson Wright PLLC, LANA K. VARNEY , FULBRIGHT & JAWORSKI LLP, Terry O. Tottenham , Fulbright & Jaworski, LLP & Thomas Marshall Donnell, Jr. , Dickinson Wright PLLC.

Proctor & Gamble Pharmaceuticals, Inc., 12-946, Defendant, represented by Cecil Maison Heidelberg , HEIDELBERG HARMON, PLLC.

WARNER CHILCOTT (US), LLC, Defendant, represented by LANA K. VARNEY , FULBRIGHT & JAWORSKI LLP.

SANOFI-AVENTIS U.S. L.L.C., Defendant, represented by LANA K. VARNEY , FULBRIGHT & JAWORSKI LLP.

SANOFI-AVENTIS U.S., INC., Defendant, represented by LANA K. VARNEY , FULBRIGHT & JAWORSKI LLP.

Sanofi US Services Inc., Defendant, represented by LANA K. VARNEY , FULBRIGHT & JAWORSKI LLP.


OPINION AND ORDER

JOEL A. PISANO, District Judge.

Plaintiffs Patrick Welch; Laura Bostick; Lana Jean Brownlee and Richard E. Brownlee, her husband; Natalie Casalino and Charles Casalino, her husband; Carolyn L. Clark; Phyllis Clark and Bob Clark, her husband; Mary Joeann Clutts; Jean Eseppi; Judith Hart; Lucille L. McGowan and John McGowan, her husband; Mary K. McKinnon and Fred McKinnon, her husband; Glenda Pace and Virgeon A. Pace, her husband; Jewell...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases