DONAHOE v. ARPAIO

Consolidated With No. CV 10-02756-PHX-NVW, No. CV 10-02758-PHX-NVW., CV 11-00116-PHX-NVW, CV 11-00473-PHX-NVW, CV 11-00902-PHX-NVW

Gary Donahoe and Cherie Donahoe, husband and wife, Plaintiffs, v. Sheriff Joseph Arpaio and Ava Arpaio, husband and wife; Andrew Thomas and Anne Thomas, husband and wife; Lisa Aubuchon and Peter R. Pestalozzi, wife and husband; Deputy Chief David Hendershott and Anna Hendershott, husband and wife; Peter Spaw and Jane Doe Spaw, husband and wife; Maricopa County, a municipal entity; Jon Does I-X; Jane Does I-X; Black Corporations I-V; and White Partnerships I-V, Defendants. Sandra Wilson and Paul Wilson, husband and wife, Plaintiffs, v. Sheriff Joseph Arpaio and Ava Arpaio, husband and wife; et al., Defendants. Conley D. Wolfswinkel, a single man; Brandon D. Wolswinkel, a single man; Ashton A. Wolfswinkel, a single man; Vanderbilt Farms, LLC, an Arizona limited liability company; ABCDW, LLC, an Arizona limited liability company; Stone Canyon, LLC, an Arizona limited liability company; Vistoso Partners, LLC, an Arizona limited liability company; and W Harquahala, LLC, an Arizona limited liability company; Plaintiffs, v. Sheriff Joseph Arpaio and Ava Arpaio, husband and wife; et al., Defendants. Mary Rose Wilcox and Earl Wilcox, wife and husband, Plaintiffs, v. Sheriff Joseph Arpaio and Ava Arpaio, husband and wife; et al., Defendants. Donald T. Stapley, Jr. and Kathleen Stapley, husband and wife, Plaintiffs, v. Sheriff Joseph Arpaio and Ava Arpaio, husband and wife; et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, D. Arizona.

May 31, 2012.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Gary Donahoe, husband, Plaintiff, represented by Lawrence J Wulkan , Stinson Morrison Hecker LLP — Phoenix, AZ, M Elizabeth Nillen , Stinson Morrison Hecker LLP — Phoenix, AZ, Michael C Manning , Stinson Morrison Hecker LLP & Stefan Mark Palys , Stinson Morrison Hecker LLP.

Cherie Donahoe, wife, Plaintiff, represented by Lawrence J Wulkan , Stinson Morrison Hecker LLP — Phoenix, AZ, M Elizabeth Nillen , Stinson Morrison Hecker LLP — Phoenix, AZ, Michael C Manning , Stinson Morrison Hecker LLP & Stefan Mark Palys , Stinson Morrison Hecker LLP.

Lisa Randall, Plaintiff, represented by Richard Monte Gerry , Aiken Schenk Hawkins & Ricciardi PC.

Mary Rose Wilcox, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Christina Claire Rubalcava , Osborn Maledon PA, Colin F Campbell , Osborn Maledon PA, Kathleen Erin Brody OMeara , Osborn Maledon PA & Sharad H Desai , Osborn Maledon PA.

Earl Wilcox, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Christina Claire Rubalcava , Osborn Maledon PA, Colin F Campbell , Osborn Maledon PA, Kathleen Erin Brody OMeara , Osborn Maledon PA & Sharad H Desai , Osborn Maledon PA.

Conley D Wolfswinkel, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M Kaban , Cooley LLP — Palo Alto, CA, Lawrence C Wright , Wright & Associates, Shannon Marie Eagan , Cooley LLP & Stephen C Neal , Cooley LLP.

Brandon D Wolfswinkel, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M Kaban , Cooley LLP — Palo Alto, CA, Lawrence C Wright , Wright & Associates, Shannon Marie Eagan , Cooley LLP & Stephen C Neal , Cooley LLP.

Ashton A Wolfswinkel, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M Kaban , Cooley LLP — Palo Alto, CA, Lawrence C Wright , Wright & Associates, Shannon Marie Eagan , Cooley LLP & Stephen C Neal , Cooley LLP.

Vanderbilt Farms LLC, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M Kaban , Cooley LLP — Palo Alto, CA, Lawrence C Wright , Wright & Associates, Shannon Marie Eagan , Cooley LLP & Stephen C Neal , Cooley LLP.

ABCDW LLC, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M Kaban , Cooley LLP — Palo Alto, CA, Lawrence C Wright , Wright & Associates, Shannon Marie Eagan , Cooley LLP & Stephen C Neal , Cooley LLP.

Stone Canyon LLC, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M Kaban , Cooley LLP — Palo Alto, CA, Lawrence C Wright , Wright & Associates, Shannon Marie Eagan , Cooley LLP & Stephen C Neal , Cooley LLP.

Vistoso Partners LLC, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M Kaban , Cooley LLP — Palo Alto, CA, Lawrence C Wright , Wright & Associates, Shannon Marie Eagan , Cooley LLP & Stephen C Neal , Cooley LLP.

W Harquahala LLC, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Jeffrey M Kaban , Cooley LLP — Palo Alto, CA, Lawrence C Wright , Wright & Associates, Shannon Marie Eagan , Cooley LLP & Stephen C Neal , Cooley LLP.

Sandra Wilson, wife, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Lawrence J Wulkan , Stinson Morrison Hecker LLP — Phoenix, AZ, M Elizabeth Nillen , Stinson Morrison Hecker LLP, Michael C Manning , Stinson Morrison Hecker LLP & Stefan Mark Palys , Stinson Morrison Hecker LLP.

Paul Wilson, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Lawrence J Wulkan , Stinson Morrison Hecker LLP — Phoenix, AZ, M Elizabeth Nillen , Stinson Morrison Hecker LLP — Phoenix, AZ, Michael C Manning , Stinson Morrison Hecker LLP & Stefan Mark Palys , Stinson Morrison Hecker LLP.

Donald T Stapley, Jr., husband, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth B Vaughn , Grant & Vaughn PC & Merwin D Grant , Grant & Vaughn PC.

Kathleen Stapley, wife, Consol Plaintiff, represented by Kenneth B Vaughn , Grant & Vaughn PC & Merwin D Grant , Grant & Vaughn PC.

Anna Baca, Judge, Intervenor Plaintiff, represented by Jose de Jesus Rivera , Haralson Miller Pitt Feldman & McAnally PLC, Nathan Ballard Webb , Haralson Miller Pitt Feldman & McAnally PLC, Peter T Limperis , Haralson Miller Pitt Feldman & McAnally PLC & Stephen Thomas Portell , Haralson Miller Pitt Feldman & McAnally PLC.

Charles Hoskins, Intervenor Plaintiff, represented by Gregory Stephen Como , Lewis Brisbois Bisgaard & Smith LLP — Phoenix, AZ & Carl F Mariano , Lewis Brisbois Bisgaard & Smith LLP — Phoenix, AZ.

Joseph M Arpaio, named as: Sheriff Joseph Arpaio/ husband, Defendant, represented by John James Kastner, Jr. , Audilett Kastner PC, Roger W Perry, Jr. , Audilett Kastner PC & Daryl A Audilett , Audilett Kastner PC.

Ava Arpaio, wife, Defendant, represented by John James Kastner, Jr. , Audilett Kastner PC, Roger W Perry, Jr. , Audilett Kastner PC & Daryl A Audilett , Audilett Kastner PC.

Andrew Thomas, husband, Defendant, represented by Donald Wilson, Jr. , Broening Oberg Woods & Wilson PC — Phoenix, AZ, Richard E Chambliss , Broening Oberg Woods & Wilson PC & Sarah Lynn Barnes , Broening Oberg Woods & Wilson PC.

Anne Thomas, wife, Defendant, represented by Donald Wilson, Jr. , Broening Oberg Woods & Wilson PC — Phoenix, AZ, Richard E Chambliss , Broening Oberg Woods & Wilson PC & Sarah Lynn Barnes , Broening Oberg Woods & Wilson PC.

Lisa Aubuchon, wife, Defendant, represented by Bradley L Booke , Moriarity Badaruddin & Booke, Douglas V Drury , Mueller & Drury PLLC, Edward P Moriarity , Moriarity Badaruddin & Booke & James Paul Mueller , Mueller & Drury PLLC.

Peter R Pestalozzi, husband, Defendant, represented by Bradley L Booke , Moriarity Badaruddin & Booke, Douglas V Drury , Mueller & Drury PLLC, Edward P Moriarity , Moriarity Badaruddin & Booke & James Paul Mueller , Mueller & Drury PLLC.

David Hendershott, Deputy Chief/ husband, Defendant, represented by Bradley L Booke , Moriarity Badaruddin & Booke, Barry Matthew Markson , Thomas Thomas & Markson PC, Caleb Saul Lihn , Thomas Thomas & Markson PC & Edward P Moriarity , Moriarity Badaruddin & Booke.

Anna Hendershott, wife, Defendant, represented by Bradley L Booke , Moriarity Badaruddin & Booke, Barry Matthew Markson , Thomas Thomas & Markson PC, Caleb Saul Lihn , Thomas Thomas & Markson PC & Edward P Moriarity , Moriarity Badaruddin & Booke.

Maricopa, County of, a municipal entity, Defendant, represented by Daniel Baca Mestaz , Sacks Tierney PA, Helen Rubenstein Holden , Sacks Tierney PA, Jeffrey S Leonard , Sacks Tierney PA & Sharon Brook Shively , Sacks Tierney PA.

Peter Spaw, Defendant, represented by Erica June Shoaf , Christian Dichter & Sluga PC, Stephen M Dichter , Christian Dichter & Sluga PC & Charles Michael Callahan , Christian Dichter & Sluga PC.

Unknown Spaw, Defendant, represented by Erica June Shoaf , Christian Dichter & Sluga PC, Stephen M Dichter , Christian Dichter & Sluga PC & Charles Michael Callahan , Christian Dichter & Sluga PC.

Jonathan Halverson, Husband, Consol Defendant, represented by Daryl A Audilett , Kimble Nelson Audilett & Kastner PC.

Unknown Halverson, wife, named as Jane Doe, Consol Defendant, represented by Daryl A Audilett , Audilett Kastner PC.

Patrick Roshetko, husband, Consol Defendant, represented by Daryl A Audilett , Audilett Kastner PC.

Unknown Roshetko, wife, name as Jane Doe, Consol Defendant, represented by Daryl A Audilett , Audilett Kastner PC.

Paul R Babeu, names as: Paul Babeu, Movant, represented by Wendy Ann Petersen , Pinal County Attorneys Office.


ORDER

(Applicable only in CV 11-00116)

NEIL V. WAKE, District Judge.

Before the Court is Plaintiff Conley Wolfswinkel and Defendant Maricopa County's Joint Summary of Discovery Dispute (Doc. 459), which will be treated as a motion to compel discovery by Plaintiff Wolfswinkel.

The County is the proper defendant liable for various claims alleged regarding the conduct of the Sheriff and members of his office and the former County Attorney...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases