Michael J. FLAHERTY, Jr., Eugene P. Adams, Joseph A. Agro, Mark D. Arcara, Randy G. Attea, James F. Bargnesi, Christopher J. Belling, Diana M. Boccio, Timothy P. Bridge, Catherine A. Carey, Kenneth F. Case, Melissa M. Chiasera, Peter J. Cosgrove, Peter J. Crotty, Don Dally, John DeFranks, Jorge S. DeRosas, John C. Doscher, G. Michael Drmacich, Daniel DuBois, Susan Etu Eagan, Robert C. Figliola, Thomas M. Fininerty, John J. Flynn, Thomas E. Fowler, Jr., Laurie A. Frank, Anthony L. Fumerelle, Colleen Curtin Gable, Lauren Gauthier, Mario A. Giacobbe, Paul J. Glascott, Amy J. Goldstein, Karen Greenspan, Gary W. Hackbush, Jeffrey J. Hagen, Marcy H. Hagen, Louis A. Haremski, Raymond C. Herman, Jr., Frank T. Roush, Thomas P. Hurley, Wendy R. Irene, Rosanne E. Johnson, Cydney A. Kelly, David S. Kelly, Joseph L. Kilbridge, Daniel M. Killelea, Brian M. Klebba, Thomas D. Kubiniec, J. Patrick Lennon, Sharon M. LoVallo, Jason C. Luna, J. Michael Marion, Latonia D. Gaston Marsh, Joseph J. Marusak, Michael I. McCabe, Michael J. McHale, Brian P. McNamara, Steven Meyer, Donna A. Milling, Marion Miskovski, Joseph M. Mordino, Molly J. Musarra, Joseph A. Muscato, Diane T. O'Gorman, Diane L. Oak, Judith G. Olin, Kelley A. Omel, Brian K. Parker, Glenn Pincus, Paul S. Piotrowski, Frederick J. Platek, Jr., Brandon A. Portis, Lynette M. Reda, Emilia Rodriguez, Lisa M. Rodwin, Walter L. Rooth III, Mark A. Sacha, Robert A. Scharlock, Paul E. Scharmach, John G. Schoemick, Denise M. Schunke, Lawrence M. Schwegler, Frank J. Sedita, Daniel R. Slade, Tina M. Stanford, Douglas P. Stiller, Letizia P. Tagliafierro, Betty Calvo Torres, Thomas D. Trbovich, Holly P. Tucker, Yvonne Vertlieb, Louis P. Violanti, Candace K. Vogel, Pauline C. Will, Paul J. Williams III, Lisa M. Yaeger and Barry A. Zavah, Plaintiffs,
v.
Joel A. GIAMBRA, Erie County Executive, County Legislature of Erie County, Leonard R. Lenihan, Erie County Personnel Commissioner, and County of Erie, Defendants.